Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page:

From The Socialist newspaper, 3 November 2010

Defend the right to asylum

THE RIGHT to asylum is under political attack across Europe. In Britain, one of the Con-Dem coalition's first acts was to close the charity, Refugee and Migrant Justice, leaving thousands of asylum seekers without legal advice and representation.

Eric Segal

The media often portray asylum seekers as part of Britain's economic crisis. As if a few thousand desperate, vulnerable people could have caused this massive economic chaos rather than the City spivs and racketeers!

Socialists defend the right to asylum in Britain and internationally. Most asylum seekers are asking for refuge because capitalism, in Britain and internationally, pursues profits relentlessly while creating poverty, building up the power of dictatorial rulers and stirring up ethnic and other divisions in their own countries.

Before 1905 the UK had no legal immigration controls or right to asylum. The 1905 Aliens Act aimed to exclude Jews fleeing pogroms in Russia. It excluded the poor and the sick, but for the first time a limited legal concession was granted for those seeking asylum. In 1906, despite the obstacles, 500 refugees managed to enter the UK under the 1905 Act.

After the 1917 Russian revolution, which saw the working class, led by the Bolshevik Party, take power, the British ruling class's fear of socialist revolution gave it an excuse to clamp down on the right of asylum. By 1919 no trace of legal protection for refugees remained on the statute book other than Home Office 'discretion' which allowed the myth of Britain's tradition of granting refuge to survive.

Many UK agencies including the security service were given responsibility for immigration. "The British security authorities saw Bolshevism as the key external threat and saw exclusion of Bolshevik agents as one of the chief functions of the post-war system of passport controls," author Louise London writes in Whitehall and the Jews.

Leon Trotsky, a leader of the Russian revolution, applied for asylum in Britain in 1929. This forced home secretary JR Clynes (a former union leader) to tell parliament: "In regard to... 'the right of asylum', this country has the right to grant asylum to any person whom it thinks fit to admit as a political refugee... no alien has the right to claim admission to this country if it would be contrary to the interests of this country to receive him." In other words - "You have no right to claim asylum - we decide who is a refugee!"

Trotsky wrote in My Life: "Clynes's definition by a single blow destroys the very foundations of so-called democracy... Neither in its historical origin, nor in its legal nature, does [the right of asylum] differ from the right of freedom of speech, of assembly, etc."

Mass movement

Britain's unyielding immigration controls blocked a mass movement of refugees from Nazi Germany and surrounding countries in the late 1930s. Only a tiny minority of people fleeing a brutal regime, hell-bent on genocide, were allowed entry into Britain. Others fled to the USA (if they could afford it) or remained behind to face the death camps.

After World War Two, working class anger at Britain's failure to provide refuge to millions of socialists, trade unionists, Jews, Gypsies and other minorities forced the allies, through the UNHCR refugee convention, to classify a refugee as a person who "owing to a well-founded fear of being persecuted for reasons of race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group, or political opinion, is outside the country of his nationality, and is unable to or, owing to such fear, is unwilling to avail himself of the protection of that country..."

This paragraph excludes many categories such as environmental refugees. But many people escaping persecution found refuge in Britain through the refugee convention and the Human Rights Act even though, as Clynes said in 1929, the state rather than the person seeking asylum decides who can claim asylum or receive refugee status. Successive governments rigorously maintained this principle particularly when the issue is seen as lacking popular support.

Recently under home secretary Alan Johnson, the previous Labour government aimed to win votes by resisting asylum applications from Iranian and Ghanaian gay men. The Home Office told the applicants to avoid persecution in Iran and Ghana through "hiding their sexuality, by behaving discreetly".

Even the UK Supreme Court said: "To compel a homosexual person to pretend his sexuality does not exist or suppress the behaviour... is to deny his fundamental right to be who he is. Homosexuals are as entitled to freedom of association with others of the same sexual orientation as people who are straight."

In the current world economic crisis, there has been a dramatic worldwide increase in violent struggles that has greatly expanded the number of refugees. However Home Office figures show a 48% reduction in the number of asylum applications in the UK in the first three months of 2010 compared to last year (see box below) although the fall is mainly due to fewer applications from Zimbabwe.

The future for UK asylum seekers is grim. Immigration Minister Damian Green has opened a new wing of the notorious Harmondsworth immigration removals centre. Two wings that were burnt down in disturbances there in 2006 have been rebuilt, making it the UK Border Agency's largest removal centre with over 600 bed spaces. Already, under the new government, over 1,900 failed asylum seekers and over 990 foreign national prisoners have been removed from the UK.

Big business sees detention and removal of asylum seekers as another profit-making opportunity. The horrendous results were seen recently in the death of Jimmy Mubenga, an Angolan who was restrained by G4S guards on a plane.

In July even the High Court declared a Home Office policy denying some refugees a last-minute appeal against deportation "unlawful". Most people are given 72 hours' notice of deportation from the country so they can launch a final legal challenge to their removal. But the previous government introduced a fast-track policy to remove some refugees, including children deemed likely to abscond and those in fragile mental health and at risk of becoming suicidal.

Many families get less than 45 minutes to pack all their belongings, including clothes, medication and children's toys, before removal. Even John Vine, the UK Border Agency's Independent Chief Inspector, questioned the treatment of refugee children removed from Britain - particularly over early morning raids. Vine says there is a danger that 30 minutes is becoming the "default position" to allow a family to pack.

Socialists must fight to defend the right to asylum and build links with those seeking asylum. The leadership of the trade union movement should head a mass campaign to stop the government forcing asylum seekers into destitution and to halt the forcible removal of asylum seekers.

Inhuman treatment of vulnerable people

ASYLUM APPLICATIONS to the UK fell steadily from over 80,000 in 2002 to 24,250 last year but not due to falling numbers of asylum seekers internationally. Guy Gordon-Gill, Oxford professor of international refugee law, calculates that only 0.3% of global refugees get anywhere near the EU. Britain ranks only 14th amongst EU countries in asylum seekers per head of population.

The drop from last year is mainly due to sorting out backlogs in the system rather than a change of heart in the Home Office. 15% of appellants were granted asylum compared with 29% in 2009. 68% of appeals were dismissed in 2010, whilst 27% were allowed.

3,730 people applied for asylum support in the first three months of 2010, 23% lower than 2009. 27,455 asylum seekers received asylum support in the first quarter of 2010, 17% lower than a year earlier.

Section 4 of the Immigration and Asylum Act 1999 provides support in the form of accommodation and 35 a week in vouchers or 'azure cards', effectively 5 a day. This disgraceful sum is little more than half income support. Despite this, many people who reach the end of the initial 21-day period do not even apply for Section 4 support because they are frightened of what will happen to them if they return home.

Failed asylum seekers are generally eligible for Section 4 support if they are destitute. However parliament's Joint Committee on Human Rights says the government had "a deliberate policy of destitution of this highly vulnerable group.

"We believe all deliberate use of inhumane treatment is unacceptable. We have seen instances where government treatment of asylum seekers and refused asylum seekers falls below the requirements of the common law of humanity and international human rights law."

Immigration legislation provides powers of detention. 6,895 people entered detention, held solely under Immigration Act powers in the first quarter of 2010, 2% higher than a year previously. A disproportionate number, 3,485 (51%) were asylum detainees.

Statistics of grants of settlement - ie people allowed to remain in Britain indefinitely - are the main available measure of long-term immigration of people subject to immigration control.

Comparing the last 12 months with the previous year, the number of persons granted settlement in the UK rose by 40% from 153,020 to 214,345. Of these only a tiny number were of asylum-related cases, up from 2,695 to 2,720.

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.

In The Socialist 3 November 2010:

Anti-cuts campaign

Con-Dems' cuts can be stopped

Anti-cuts movement continues to grow

Model motion for a national demonstration in 2010

Firefighters' strike

Pickets injured: Solidarity with London firefighters

Solidarity with London firefighters


We need jobs, homes and services - not racism

Defend the right to asylum

Socialist Party editorial

Con-Dem shock therapy - midwife to a double dip?

Socialism 2010

Socialism 2010

Fund the fight for socialism

Socialist Party news and analysis

Housing: Rent caps, not benefit caps

India - no voice for Kashmiri struggle

Graduate unemployment: We will not be a lost generation!

News in brief

Cable is a coward!

Don't destroy our sickness benefits

Socialist Party youth and students

100 students march against cuts and fees in Leeds

Students challenge Willetts

Birmingham youth protest

Socialist Party workplace news

Nottingham school staff force council retreat over pay cuts

Tube workers take more action for safety

BBC strike over pensions

UCU: No education cuts, no fees!

National Shop Stewards Network: Anti-cuts conference

International socialist news and analysis

USA elections: What the Tea Party really represents


Home   |   The Socialist 3 November 2010   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate  

Related links:


triangleRoyal wedding exposes them-and-us visa system

triangleInterview: Refugee Rights Campaign

triangle40% of England's psychiatric wards are 'unsafe'

triangleSupport for Socialist Party campaigns at biggest ever Leeds Pride

triangleDerby Socialist Party: Solidarity with refugees - defend the right to asylum


triangleMobilise to stop bigoted billionaire Donald Trump's state visit to Britain

triangleEast London & Tower Hamlets Socialist Party: 2017 - From Trump to Paradise Papers; a year in review

triangleWestminster sexual harassment scandal: symptom of a rotten system

triangleCan you donate to the Socialism 2017 appeal?


triangleThem & Us

triangleMay's lies about foreign students exposed

triangleReject Starmer's Single Market u-turn


triangleHundreds of torture victims wrongly detained

triangleManchester Socialist Party: The Rohingya refugee crisis


triangleGerman elections: rise of the far right and right-wing government will provoke resistance

Reports and campaigns

Reports and campaigns



Anti-DOO lobby of Liverpool's transport committee



Unite protest against blacklisting


Donald Trump

Mobilise to stop bigoted billionaire Donald Trump's state visit to Britain



Arriva bus strikers stand firm



BT pensions review - oppose the attacks on the pension schemes



Driving examiners walkout hits first day of new test



School staff strike against privatisation



Brutal rail privateer Abellio takes over Midlands rail services



PCS Left Unity celebrates 40th anniversary at annual conference


North Yorkshire

Court maintains injunction against fracking protesters


Waltham Forest

Waltham Forest Universal Credit protest



Coventry Socialist sales hit 1,000



TUSC conference to debate 2018 elections



Liverpool John Moores Uni landslide for Socialist Students



Plans to launch no-cuts campaign at Kirklees College

triangleMore Reports and campaigns articles...

Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party

triangle8 Dec Local government pay: fight for the full 5% claim

triangle6 Dec Strikers rally in Liverpool

triangle6 Dec Corbyn's Labour can defeat Tories with socialist programme

triangle5 Dec Victory at Glenfield shows people power can save our NHS

triangle5 Dec Labour council Blairites deselected

triangle30 Nov Victory: Glenfield Children's Heart Centre saved!

triangle30 Nov Dramatic retelling of Grunwick strike

More ...

triangle11 Dec Leeds Socialist Party: Campaigning workshop

triangle11 Dec Bristol North Socialist Party: Christmas Quiz

triangle12 Dec Birmingham South East Socialist Party: Can the Labour Party be changed?

triangle12 Dec Liverpool Socialist Party: Fighting council cuts

More ...

Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube



December 2017

November 2017

October 2017

September 2017

August 2017

July 2017

June 2017

May 2017

April 2017

March 2017

February 2017

January 2017





















Platform setting: = No platform choice