Link to this page:

Posted on 28 October 2011 at 12:25 GMT

'Virgin' on the outrageous

Cleaners working on trains on the Virgin West Coast Mainline struck for 24 hours from this morning (28 October) in a row over poverty pay and union rights between the 'Carlisle Cleaning and Support Services' contractor, and the RMT union.

Carlisle's owner, Impellam Group, part of the business empire of top Tory Lord Ashcroft, has increased its profits by almost 30% to 16.2 million in the past year off the backs of its low paid workforce.

Yet it is telling cleaners they need to take a real-terms pay cut for it to keep the contract with Virgin.

The entire rail industry should be renationalised and employ all workers directly, putting an end to this maze of contractors and sub-contractors grubbing their profits at the expense of workers and the travelling public.

Pickets at the rail depot in east Manchester told me about "sweatshop" conditions for cleaners paid a flat rate of 6.54 an hour, even when on permanent night shifts, even when working in sub-zero winter temperatures.

RMT official Andy Warnock-Smith said:

"These cleaners are on appalling wages and conditions, and they're being treated with absolute contempt by the company.

"Something else about this dispute is how Virgin Trains are just sitting back. Branson has this image as a 'great entrepreneur', but what's he doing to resolve this?"

Carlisle had offered a miserable 1% pay 'rise' this year, 'worth' 6p an hour. As one picket pointed out, that's 2.40 a week: a pint of milk and a loaf of bread! Carlisle also offered 1% next year, 'worth' 7p.

When inflation is officially around 5% and in reality far higher for workers, this is a big pay cut.

Under pressure, Carlisle made a new offer, described by pickets as so "miniscule" that the union rejected it out of hand. RMT general secretary Bob Crow said:

"Carlisle should understand that our members are not prepared to tolerate low pay and poor conditions any longer from a company that makes millions on the backs of their work.

"Virgin should also recognise that it has a moral obligation not to allow poverty wages to be paid to people who play a key role in providing services to its 20 million passengers.

"Instead of planning to derecognise the union and threatening our members, Carlisle should get around the table and negotiate a sensible, fair deal that reflects the true worth of the hard work that creates Carlisle's profits."

RMT membership at Carlisle has doubled to represent the overwhelming majority of the workers, 94% of whom voted to take strike action.

RMT members on the contract will also refuse to empty train effluent tanks or refill fresh water tanks for 24 hours from 6pm on Friday 4th November.

Longsight pickets told me that Carlisle threatened to bus in agency workers to do the work of strikers.

This is probably illegal. All supporters of this strike should show their support this evening, from 8.30pm at the Longsight depot just off Kirkmanshulme Lane in Longsight.

Hugh Caffrey

Additional report:

Reports during the day confirmed an overwhelmingly solid strike. In Crewe the great majority of workers went on strike, and in Stoke 100%.

Meanwhile, if Carlisle's boasts are to be believed then they shipped the small handful of their employees not on strike from one end of the country to the other!

Reports suggested the illegal use of scab agency labour to do the work of strikers. The RMT will be investigating the legal facts of the matter.

Strikers said that agency workers were being paid 12 an hour, almost double the rate Carlisle normally pays its own workforce! The cleaners are determined to win a fair settlement, taking further strike action if necessary.

The union will now discuss this on the basis of this solid strike which has hammered home to Carlisle that these workers will not be bullied and the company has a real fight on its hands.


Around 25 Carlisle Contact Cleaners and support staff were on strike on 27 October at the Liverpool Edgehill depot.

These cleaners work on the West Coast main line, mostly on permanent nights cleaning Virgin Trains.

They have been offered a paltry 1% pay increase for this year and the Carlisle group are attempting to derecognise the RMT union. The action was supported by Liverpool trades council and Liverpool Against the Cuts.

John Marston

This version of this article was first posted on the Socialist Party website on 28 October 2011 and may vary slightly from the version subsequently printed in The Socialist.

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.

Facebook   Twitter

Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Related links:


triangleHypocritical attacks on tube control room strike

triangleTUSC: Central in the battle for a working class anti-austerity voice

triangleRMT motion on anti-union laws carried at TUC

triangleMost important TUC Congress for decades

triangleJoin the NSSN lobby of TUC Congress


triangleGovernment reneges on rail modernisation pledge

triangleBosses take tax liberties

triangleVirgin Media and the unions


triangleCarlisle TUSC: What future now for Labour?

triangleThem & Us

triangleBurns' Night a blazing success


triangleGive us the resources to defeat the Tories

triangleWorkplace news in brief

Reports and campaigns

Reports and campaigns



Come to Socialism 2015


The Socialist

Subscribe to a paper by workers, for workers


Socialist Party

Give us the resources to defeat the Tories


Socialist Party

Why you should join the socialists



Kazakhstan: workers solidarity action


Fire service

Anger and protest against fire service cuts in Leicestershire



Campaign Kazakhstan protest: Kaz Minerals



Labour cuts school crossings


Waltham Forest

Tower block residents defend homes


Mental health

Notts NHS trust closing more mental health units



TUC debates action to defeat anti-trade union bill


Socialist Students

Organise the student fightback!



Workplace news in brief



Traffic wardens strike for better pay



London protesters demand affordable housing

triangleMore Reports and campaigns articles...

triangle30 Sep EU ministers squabble while refugees drown

triangle30 Sep Socialism is back!

triangle30 Sep Junior doctors fight government attacks

triangle30 Sep How can we bring down the Tories?

Protesting against school crossing cuts by Derbyshire County Council, photo E Evans

triangle29 Sep Labour cuts school crossings

triangle28 Sep TUSC: Central in the battle for a working class anti-austerity voice

triangle23 Sep Greece: Widespread abstention in election

More ...

triangle4 Oct TUC demonstration against the government's austerity agenda

triangle5 Oct Wirral Socialist Party: History of the Socialist Party

triangle5 Oct Chesterfield Socialist Party: When Liverpool council defeated a Tory government

triangle5 Oct Birmingham Central Socialist Party: Class struggle, feminism and socialism

More ...

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube

Find us on Facebook






October 2015

September 2015

August 2015

July 2015

June 2015

May 2015

April 2015

March 2015

February 2015

January 2015



















Platform setting: = No platform choice