Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page:

From The Socialist newspaper, 14 December 2011

Unacceptable! Draconian sentences for Dundee 'Facebook riot' teenagers

Matt Dobson, Socialist Party Scotland, Dundee
Bankers are the real looters: placard on Hackney - Tottenham demo after the riots , photo Paul Mattsson

Bankers are the real looters: placard on Hackney - Tottenham demo after the riots , photo Paul Mattsson   (Click to enlarge)

There is anger and disbelief in Dundee at the jailing of teenagers who were involved in joke Facebook pages 'organising riots'. Four youth, the youngest being 14, were arrested by Tayside police in August as riots swept across cities in England.

A cursory glance at these web pages would have informed anyone sensible and without a preconceived agenda that they had no intention of organising a riot. Joking about the riots at a time when people were being burnt out of their homes was insensitive but these outrageous sentences have to be understood in the context that in Dundee and the rest of Scotland, no riots took place.

These young people are victims of a politically motivated miscarriage of justice, they are being punished for events they did not cause that occurred hundreds of miles away.

Politically punished

The four were kept in police custody for the maximum duration and were initially refused bail. Two have been banned from any form of internet use. Shawn Diven, 16, and Jordan McGinley, 18, who did not set up a group but were added by others as administrators, were jailed on 12 December after pleading guilty, expressing regret at what they had done, and having been incarcerated on remand for months awaiting trial.

It is clear from the sheriff's remarks on sentencing that Shawn and Jordan, like others jailed for being caught up in the rioting and the recent cases of the student protesters, are being politically punished in an attempt to obscure the real causes of the riots.

Sheriff Elizabeth Munro called the riot that didn't take place "the most serious breach of the peace, I have ever come across". The justification for the severe sentences was based on the fact that the Facebook groups were set up at a time of "widespread disturbance and civil unrest".

But as the Guardian's Reading the Riots report shows, social networking sites were not widely used by people who actually rioted.

A local trade unionist made the point in a Facebook discussion after the sentencing that the authorities are out of touch: "Jeremy Clarkson can joke about shooting public sector workers in front of their families and nothing happens, these lads make a silly joke on Facebook and they get three years in prison." A school student activist expressed the sentiments of young people and the wider community: "It's not okay to ruin their lives to make an example."

During the riots in England politicians, both Scottish National Party (SNP) government ministers and Labour in opposition, boasted that they were responsible for creating a different society in Scotland. The Scottish Sun carried an article claiming the main cause of a lack of unrest in Scotland was that the police were more polite - the students and young people attacked on protests at Glasgow universities recently would beg to differ!

Social conditions

The reality is that brutal social conditions similar to those behind the riots in England exist in cities like Dundee and across Scotland and young people face just as bleak prospects for a future.

Students still receive EMA payments, but hundreds of places have been cut and courses slashed at both local colleges. The SNP government is embarking on a programme of merging colleges and universities across regions that will shut the door on thousands hoping to go into education.

A recent survey by Citizens Advice Scotland found that the majority of Dundee's young people are trapped in poverty and, in many cases, in unemployment. There are 1,000 NEETS (not in education, employment or training) who are under 19 in Dundee.

The Youth Fight for Jobs and Education campaign demands Shawn and Jordan are immediately released and internet sanctions on young people are immediately lifted. The widespread anger in the community at these sentences shows that the criminalisation of young people in the city will not be accepted.

Recently Dundee's streets have been filled with young people organising and protesting, not rioting. School students walked out in April against the setting up of a city campus and cuts. Young people had a visible presence on the 10,000 strong demonstration on 30 November.

Young people are enraged by the conditions they face but they also want to organise and fight back. Youth Fight for Jobs and Education fights against education cuts, unemployment and for democratic rights.

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.

In The Socialist 14 December 2011:

Socialist Party feature

Tories speak for the rich - not for us

Socialist Party news and analysis

Hands off our NHS!

Unacceptable! Draconian sentences for Dundee 'Facebook riot' teenagers

Striking to defend pensions

No progress at climate conference

Them & Us

Why I joined the Socialist Party

Socialist Party editorial

Stand up to the Con-Dem government

Socialist Party reviews

Inside Job: Capitalism is a failed system: support the socialist fightback

TV review: Britain's great housing scandal exposed

Socialist Party workplace news

All out now to stop the sites!

Pensioners and workers - united fight needed

Occupy London tours Canary Wharf

Action after N30

Langdon school strike

Public sector pensions - where now?

Tax workers on strike

Workplace news in brief

International socialist news and analysis

"Putin is a thief", "Putin is a thief"

Kazakhstan - 20 years of authoritarianism!

Readers' Comments

Cameron's drugs problems

Attacks on Tupe rights hit hard

Building bosses and their blacklist


Home   |   The Socialist 14 December 2011   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate  

Related links:


triangleScotland: Towards a second indyref?

triangleScottish elections: strong mood for anti-cuts strategy continues

triangleScotland: battle heats up against council cuts

triangleWest Dunbartonshire teachers' strike

triangleQuiz of the year


triangleWhat we saw: May on Facebook

triangleWhat we saw

triangleHyperNormalisation: Arbitrary selection of ideas to confirm feelings of powerlessness

triangleWhat we saw

Young people:

triangleTunisia: explosion of protests against government austerity

triangleSweden: School strike against deportations

triangleMovement challenges Iranian regime


triangleChesterfield Socialist Party: Race riots in the US 50 years ago

triangleThe Socialist inbox


triangleUndercover policing legal challenge

News and socialist analysis

News and socialist analysis



Corbyn's Labour needs 100% anti-cuts strategy and fight for democracy



Victory! Trump's UK visit cancelled by fear of protests



NHS crisis: under pressure from all angles - end cuts and sell-offs!



Carillion crisis: demand action to save jobs and services



Cabinet chaos as shambolic reshuffle underlines Theresa May's impotence



Sustained mass movement needed to stop Tories wrecking our NHS



Bigot Toby Young quits - now scrap the new uni regulator driving privatisation


Them & Us

Them & Us



Teacher recruitment falls by a third - cut workload, not funding


Fire service

Fire service victory



Rail: fares up, bosses' pay up - delays and cancellations up


Higher Education

Mobilise against rip-off executive pay



NHS in winter crisis as Branson creams off 1bn



Thousands live in tents and sheds - seize empty homes


Fat cats

Widening wealth gap, increase in poverty...make the fat cats pay

triangleMore News and socialist analysis articles...

Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party

triangle22 Jan Women rally defiantly

triangle22 Jan Red Mary - a Force of Nature

triangle17 Jan Corbyn's Labour needs 100% anti-cuts strategy and fight for democracy

triangle17 Jan NHS crisis: under pressure from all angles - end cuts and sell-offs!

triangle17 Jan We must fight all council cuts!

triangle16 Jan Home care workers to strike

triangle15 Jan Carillion crisis: Demand action to save jobs and services

More ...

triangle23 Jan Bristol North Socialist Party: 'You can't have capitalism without racism' - was Malcolm X correct?

triangle23 Jan Cardiff West Socialist Party: How the Poll Tax was beaten

triangle24 Jan Caerphilly Socialist Party: The Carillion scandal

triangle24 Jan Cardiff Central Socialist Party: Carillion collapse - Watershed moment for public services

More ...

Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube



January 2018






















Platform setting: = No platform choice