Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page: http://www.socialistparty.org.uk/issue/701/13523

From The Socialist newspaper, 18 January 2012

Breast implant scandal exposes private healthcare

Keep private vultures out of our NHS!

March to save the NHS 17 May 2011, photo Paul Mattsson

March to save the NHS 17 May 2011, photo Paul Mattsson   (Click to enlarge)

The Health and Social Care Bill, currently working its way through Parliament, is a huge threat to our NHS. The government is trying to sneak through privatisation under the guise of 'reform'. All the big business parties agree that 'the market' can help run our public services efficiently. But we've seen countless examples of the devastating effect of handing these services over to private companies who only care about making profit. The latest is the scandal over PIP breast implants.

Sue Powell

One blog on the PIP breast implant scandal read: "How many people realise, when you entrust your health to a private clinic you have less consumer protection than if you bought a used car?"

Some people think women should pay for their 'bad lifestyle choice' but the NHS should not discriminate - this is how private medical insurance works - denying help to alcoholics, smokers, drug addicts, the obese, people who engage in 'dangerous' activities (which potentially could include occupational risks) or have health problems.

The scandal over PIP breast implants has wide implications and affects a staggering 300,000-400,000 women in 65 countries. The Con-Dem government has shown callous disregard towards the 40,000 British women who have PIP breast implants (Poly Implant Prothese).

Last week, some of them, carrying placards reading "Health Before Wealth" and "Toxic Time Bombs", protested outside the Harley Medical Group (HMG). HMG, like other clinics, refuses to pay for the routine removal of PIP implants.

Women were told to approach their clinics but many calls were unanswered. Some clinics declared bankruptcy (opening later under another name). HMG's chair, Mel Braham, who advised the Labour government on industry regulation and standards, even thinks the whole thing is a conspiracy engineered by competitors.

The four biggest clinics, including HMG and Transform (turnover last year of 36.2m) are implicated in the majority of the 40,000 operations using PIP implants. Scandalously, HMG claims its clinics do not have the resources or time to cope with the 'panic' of its patients. It wants the NHS to do the ops, while HMG would pay for new implants - but demands a government loan to do so.

UK health secretary Lansley, after issuing several conflicting statements, agrees with the clinics that routine removal of implants is not medically indicated, but now says the NHS would pay to remove, but not replace, implants (although the Welsh Government has promised to do so in Wales). Replacing implants is not a cosmetic exercise: there are health implications and this policy will cause further distress and expense to the NHS.

But it is not all bad news for business: Now PIP is bankrupt, no-win, no-fee lawyers are eagerly touting for clients online. MyBreast, MyFace, MyBody has identified an opportunity, stating it has never used the French implants, will offer free consultation and can help women with PIP implants.

The case for fighting Lansley's NHS reforms and the need for public ownership and control of all areas of medical practice, including the pharmaceutical and medical device industries, has surely never been stronger.

PIP scandal

How could PIP get away with selling implants made from industrial grade silicone used in mattresses and computers? The company already had a bad name - its products were banned by US authorities (the FDA) in 2000. UK patients sued successfully after the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency (MHRA) identified inadequacies in the biological safety of its production of hydrogel implants (although the insurance companies have not paid up).

Warnings about PIP silicone implants began circulating in France and Britain three years ago. PIP implants were the cheapest available: they had no protective coating and the silicone used was ten times cheaper than medical grade silicone.

This is not the first scandal involving private practice and the next "toxic time bomb" - artificial face implants - is already ticking. With over 60,000 people receiving cosmetic surgery in Britain every year, cosmetic surgery is big business.

But cosmetic surgery is not just about vanity: its development as a major branch of medicine began with pioneering treatment of horrific and debilitating injuries sustained by soldiers and airmen during the two world wars.

Reconstructive surgery is vital to cancer patients, burns and trauma victims, but this work is mainly confined to the NHS.

The proliferation of private practice reflects a media-driven obsession with body image. Massive industry expansion did not lead to more stringent licensing and control - quite the opposite. Clinics do not even have adequate insurance. As increasing numbers of teenagers opt for cosmetic surgery, some clinics are offering underage clients payment plans. It is unlikely they will they be as eager to help when the estimated 20% of their clients need corrective surgery.

The whole story reveals some ugly aspects of private medicine and the medical devices industry. With worldwide sales exceeding $300 billion in 2011, competition in the medical devices industry is fierce. There are 18,000 companies in Europe alone, hence the massive pressure to 'cut costs'.

Last year, artificial hip joints sold by Johnson & Johnson were withdrawn because metal, rather than plastic and metal had been used in their manufacture. Patients experienced severe pain and toxic metal deposits in the blood - many thousands will have to undergo corrective surgery. In 1983 one US study found that 20% of pacemakers implanted were medically unnecessary. One patient endured six ops and paid $60,000 only to be told her heart was healthy. This is what marketisation of health care means.

Medical devices such as breast implants, artificial hip joints, facial fillers and pacemakers are not subject to the same stringent controls as apply to drugs.

Manufacturers do not have to prove safety on the basis of clinical trials. GPs and surgeons are required to report problems, but the lack of a national register of implants makes it difficult to track problems. Ruptures are often due to accidents which might not be linked to product quality and leaking implants do not always cause immediate symptoms. UK clinics were not obliged to divulge information on sourcing and many still refuse to do so.

None of this explains why no action was taken. Back in 2010 the Hospital Group and Healthcare UK were offering free consultations to concerned patients with PIP implants. Even after PIP products were banned, they were sold in Holland under a different name. Private practice makes a mockery of the physician's oath "to do no harm" and replaces it with "greed is good".

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.


In The Socialist 18 January 2012:


Anti-cuts campaign

Stand up to Tory bullies

Pensions attacks can still be defeated

Labour leadership approves the Con-Dem cuts

Cameron's attack on Scottish independence referendum backfires

Welfare Reform Bill:- Lords compromise is no victory

Ofsted: "requires improvement"

John Lewis economy: another fantasy from Corporal Clegg

Them & Us


Socialist Party NHS campaign

Keep private vultures out of our NHS!


Youth fight for jobs

End the slave labour culture of workfare


Socialist Party workplace news

Electricians' national meeting plans next steps in battle against pay cut

Unilever workers say hands off our pensions

South Yorkshire Stagecoach bus drivers take eighth day of strike action

Jobs massacre at La Senza

Doctors support call for action


Obituary

Rob Windsor: socialist fighter and Coventry Socialist Party councillor 1964-2012


Socialist Party feature

1972 Derry - "this was murder"


Socialist Party campaigns

EDL intimidation fails in Barking

Save community schools - no to academies

Protect women's rights - oppose the abstinence bill


International socialist news and analysis

Greece: Non-payment movement against new housing tax

Irish 'poll tax' battle has begun

Nigeria: Fuel strike suspended


 

Home   |   The Socialist 18 January 2012   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate  




Related links:

Healthcare:

triangleClosure of Nottingham unit shows dismantling of NHS

triangleTory prescription for mental illness: stress and bureaucracy

triangleSouth London health bosses' cover-up

triangleSave our NHS

triangleKids wait 18 months for mental healthcare

NHS:

triangleLobby pushes Liverpool council to oppose privatisation

triangleNHS crisis: under pressure from all angles - end cuts and sell-offs!

triangleDemonstration: NHS in crisis - fix it now!

triangleSustained mass movement needed to stop Tories wrecking our NHS

Medical:

triangleThem and us

triangleStriking back against sackers' charter at Leeds Uni

Health:

triangleNHS in winter crisis as Branson creams off 1bn

Women:

triangleSocialist Party women's meeting brings together members to share experiences

Government:

triangleTunisia: explosion of protests against government austerity

Cosmetic surgery:

triangleThe beauty industry: out of control?

News and socialist analysis

News and socialist analysis

17/1/18

Labour

Corbyn's Labour needs 100% anti-cuts strategy and fight for democracy

17/1/18

Trump

Victory! Trump's UK visit cancelled by fear of protests

17/1/18

NHS

NHS crisis: under pressure from all angles - end cuts and sell-offs!

15/1/18

Carillion

Carillion crisis: demand action to save jobs and services

10/1/18

Tories

Cabinet chaos as shambolic reshuffle underlines Theresa May's impotence

10/1/18

NHS

Sustained mass movement needed to stop Tories wrecking our NHS

10/1/18

Education

Bigot Toby Young quits - now scrap the new uni regulator driving privatisation

10/1/18

Them & Us

Them & Us

10/1/18

Teachers

Teacher recruitment falls by a third - cut workload, not funding

3/1/18

Fire service

Fire service victory

3/1/18

Fares

Rail: fares up, bosses' pay up - delays and cancellations up

3/1/18

Higher Education

Mobilise against rip-off executive pay

3/1/18

Virgin

NHS in winter crisis as Branson creams off 1bn

3/1/18

Homes

Thousands live in tents and sheds - seize empty homes

3/1/18

Fat cats

Widening wealth gap, increase in poverty...make the fat cats pay

triangleMore News and socialist analysis articles...


Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party

triangle17 Jan Corbyn's Labour needs 100% anti-cuts strategy and fight for democracy

triangle17 Jan NHS crisis: under pressure from all angles - end cuts and sell-offs!

triangle17 Jan We must fight all council cuts!

triangle16 Jan Home care workers to strike

triangle15 Jan Carillion crisis: Demand action to save jobs and services

triangle12 Jan Outrage against 'monster block' plan

triangle12 Jan Mini-strike wave continues and intensifies

More ...

triangle23 Jan Bristol North Socialist Party: 'You can't have capitalism without racism' - was Malcolm X correct?

triangle23 Jan Cardiff West Socialist Party: How the Poll Tax was beaten

triangle24 Jan Caerphilly Socialist Party: The Carillion scandal

triangle24 Jan Cardiff Central Socialist Party: Carillion collapse - Watershed moment for public services

More ...

Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube

Archive

Archives:

January 2018

2017

2016

2015

2014

2013

2012

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

Legal

SP RSS feed RSS

Platform setting: = No platform choice

V2