Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page:

Posted on 22 February 2012 at 17:50 GMT

The Unison witch-hunted 'four', photo B. Severn

The Unison witch-hunted 'four', photo B. Severn   (Click to enlarge)

Unison leadership found guilty of "unjustifiable discipline" against four Socialist Party activists

Victory for the Unison four!

Once again, the Unison leadership has been found guilty of "unjustifiable" disciplinary action against four activists for producing a leaflet protesting about the exclusion of resolutions from the 2007 Unison conference.

Today an Employment Appeal Tribunal (Judge Michael Supperstone QC) upheld the unanimous judgment of an earlier Employment Tribunal (Employment Judge Ms H Grewal, 27 January 2011).

That ET judgment last year rejected false allegations of racism against the four and found that the real reason for disciplinary action was that they had issued a leaflet criticising the Standing Orders Committee and the union leadership for preventing discussion on the issue of union democracy.

Today's EAT rejects all five grounds on which the Unison leadership appealed against last year's ET judgment.

The four activists who were disciplined by Unison were banned from holding any union office for up to three years.

The four are Glenn Kelly (formerly Bromley branch secretary and NEC member), Onay Kasab (formerly Greenwich branch secretary), Brian Debus (formerly Hackney branch chairperson), and Suzanne Muna (formerly Housing Corporation branch secretary).

The judgments of the ET and the EAT completely vindicate the four's struggle to defend union democracy.

The unjustified sanctions against the four are part of a wider witch-hunt being carried out by the Unison leadership against activists fighting for union democracy and effective action to defend public services, jobs, pay and conditions.

There is now a rising tide of discontent within the union at the ineffective policies of the leadership when faced with a tsunami of attacks on the public sector.

The Unison leadership unscrupulously tried to bolster their disciplinary charges with allegations of racism.

This related to a cartoon on the leaflet protesting about the Standing Orders Committee's suppression of over 50 resolutions that used the well-known image of three wise monkeys who see no evil, hear no evil, and speak no evil.

The ET judgment forcefully rejected the allegation of racism: "All four Claimants are committed anti-racists and have fought against racism.

"They quite reasonably assumed that anyone who saw the leaflet would understand the cartoon to be saying that the SOC was out of touch in closing its minds to and ignoring issues that concern the membership."

"Looking at the context in which the cartoon was used (i.e. to depict the attitude of the SOC towards controversial motions) it cannot be said that any reasonable person would or should have realised that it would cause racial offence, and that not doing so was somehow 'careless'.

That is reinforced by the fact that [it] never occurred to many people who saw the cartoon before its publication. These individuals included an Equalities and Diversity officer and black members."

Incredibly, during the case, it was discovered that Unison's own lawyers had used a cartoon of the three wise monkeys.

The tribunal found that the main reason for disciplinary action against the four was that they produced a leaflet criticising the SOC for rejecting a large number of branch resolutions.

It is estimated that the Unison leadership must have spent at least £100,000 on the disciplinary hearings and tribunal cases.

At a time when the focus should have been on fighting public-sector cuts, the four have been dragged through four years of tortuous, money-wasting investigations and hearings.

Glenn Kelly, one of the four, is demanding that the witch-hunts must stop, and the four branches be taken out of regional administration so that the members can run their branches.

Also that the bans on the four should be rescinded and the latest charge against Glenn should be withdrawn.

Glenn urges UNISON to fight the Con-Dem government instead of hardworking union activists.

For more info phone: 07595 352 795

A Defend the Four press release

This version of this article was first posted on the Socialist Party website on 22 February 2012 and may vary slightly from the version subsequently printed in The Socialist.

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.

Related links:


triangleUnison higher education seminar points no way forward over pay

triangleSupport the 'Kinsley 3' cleaners in pay fight

triangleBristol: Millions of pounds of "horrifically unpalatable" cuts

triangleDurham teaching assistants ballot for strike

triangleUnison Broad Left meeting

Socialist Party:

triangleReadmit expelled socialists

triangleSocialist inbox

triangleBook review: Fighting racism in football

triangleIreland: Jobstown protester found guilty


triangleNewsquest strike: Bosses realise 'contraints' of scab labour

triangleSheffield bin striker slams privatised refuse bosses

triangleThe Socialist inbox


triangleCorbynism and the rise of left populism

triangleNo backtracks, no compromises: we must fight for real democracy in Labour


triangleThe Socialist inbox

News and socialist analysis

News and socialist analysis


Labour Party

Readmit expelled socialists


Welsh Government

Welsh Labour government makes Tory cuts



Protest and strike to save our NHS



'Jungle' camp destruction is no solution



Homeless sleeping rough: councils must build housing



Battle in Leeds council over care home closure


Labour Party

Wallasey whitewash must be condemned



Four in five self-employed workers living in poverty



Academies mired in debt and corruption



Corbynism and the rise of left populism



TUSC discusses new tasks after Corbyn victory


Labour Party

No backtracks, no compromises: we must fight for real democracy in Labour



Where next for the BMA junior doctors' dispute



Tories whip up division over Brexit



Tories’ £5bn for housing not enough

triangleMore News and socialist analysis articles...

Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party
Dave Nellist and Jeremy Corbyn at the Burston school rally, 4.9.16, photo by Teresa Mackay

triangle26 Oct Readmit expelled socialists

triangle26 Oct Health campaigners announce national NHS demo

triangle26 Oct Ireland: Jobstown protester found guilty

triangle26 Oct Welsh Labour government makes Tory cuts

triangle26 Oct Protest and strike to save our NHS

triangle26 Oct 'Jungle' camp destruction is no solution

triangle26 Oct Hundreds march to defend South Tyneside hospital

More ...

triangle26 Oct Salford TUSC: Campaign for a socialist metro mayor

triangle26 Oct Hackney & Islington Socialist Party: The struggle is international

triangle27 Oct Leicester Socialist Party: 'Prevent' - Does the state really have children's best interests at heart?

triangle27 Oct Waltham Forest Socialist Party: Solidarity with refugees!

More ...

Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube






October 2016

September 2016

August 2016

July 2016

June 2016

May 2016

April 2016

March 2016

February 2016

January 2016




















Platform setting: = No platform choice