Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page: http://www.socialistparty.org.uk/issue/754/16237

From The Socialist newspaper, 27 February 2013

Should socialists support GM foods?

The first genetically modified (GM) plant was grown in 1983. Thirty years later, should socialists agree with Con-Dem environment minister Owen Paterson that GM foods could be beneficial for society?

Yes - but demand science for social need, not profit

Ben Norman

Debate over the genetic modification of crops raises questions for socialists and environmentalists as to the role of GM, as well as the wider issue of science under capitalism.

Last year, protesters threatened to destroy GM crops at Rothamsted Research in Hertfordshire. In response, scientists launched a YouTube appeal in defence of their research, which seeks to modify wheat crops by making them resistant to aphids.

Socialists should not oppose GM research in principle. As with all scientific advancements, the question for socialists is never simply 'right or wrong?' Rather we ask which class controls it and in whose interest will it be used?

Often the debate centres on moralistic ideas of 'playing god', or as one of the protest banners put it, 'nature does it best'.

Yet, from eradicating deadly diseases to establishing agriculture and developing flight, human history has relied on consistently challenging nature and natural laws.

To declare everything which occurs naturally to be unalterable is to turn our backs on thousands of years of progress.

However, scientific research exists within the constraints of capitalism. From applying for research grants to publishing findings, big business plays a crucial role in deciding which research exists, the direction it takes and who reads it.

Education budgets

As education budgets are cut and universities are turned into free market competitors, scientists are not able to carry out research simply for the sake of science. They have to find a funder and increasingly this is the private sector.

This is just as true for research into renewable energy being controlled by oil giants such as BP, as it is in the field of medicine, where the pharmaceutical giants' competition for profit comes before sharing vital scientific breakthroughs.

For GM crops, the Rothamsted research was carried out on spring type wheat, which is more commonly used in the US than Europe.

The US presents a more profitable market for selling the research. This shows that while GM could be a weapon in the fight against the global food crisis, the primary aim of such research under capitalism is the profits of US agriculture.

The crisis in global food production is itself a savage indictment of the failings of capitalism. The only long-term solution remains a democratically planned economic system, which can only be brought to existence through socialism.

As unavoidable as this truth is, GM research still represents a potential transitional solution to alleviating global hunger.

The research should focus on crops which could be used in sub-Saharan Africa and similar crisis areas.

The research should be publicly funded and democratically accountable, with findings published openly so the results can be read and shared for global benefit.


No - potential damage from GM is enormous

Jenny Brooks

Ben rightly points out that agribusiness capitalists control the type and direction of agricultural research and that they do so in their own interests.

Much of the research done - with the profit as the main aim - is of questionable social and human benefit, while some is undeniably worthwhile.

But genetic modification research and use in agriculture is in a category of its own, because whatever the potential benefits are, the possible damage to the environment and our health could be enormous.

We certainly should not "declare everything which occurs naturally to be unalterable," but this doesn't mean that all alterations are desirable and progressive.

The accumulation of greenhouse gases causing climate change is one example of potentially disastrous consequences of 'alteration'.

Genetic modification is not simply an extension of the relatively harmless plant and animal breeding that has long been practised.

That type of change didn't involve the imprecise transfer of genes between very diverse species as is taking place in genetic engineering today.

It is impossible to confine the modified genes in a crop - test sample or otherwise - to a patch of land and stop them from affecting the environment further afield.

There hasn't been anywhere near enough research done on the potential effects of such spread, but some of the studies carried out indicate unpredictable and harmful consequences, including more weed and insect tolerance to herbicides and insecticides and a decline in biodiversity.

Unknown consequences

Despite the unknown consequences, 160 million hectares of land globally were producing GM crops by 2011.

Some studies have indicated possible alarming effects on the health of the millions of people eating foods containing genetic modification; more research on this is urgently needed.

The European Union is presently discussing whether to allow GM crops (beyond trials) to be grown in Europe, many of them modified to give resistance to certain herbicides.

Growing them is predicted to lead to a large increase in herbicide usage (due to an increase in herbicide resistant weeds), polluting the environment unnecessarily and probably leaving greater toxic residues in the food we eat.

The global 'food crisis' doesn't need GM foods to solve it. Enough non-GM food can be produced to feed everyone on the planet simply by planting non-GM seed instead of GM; it is poverty that is mainly responsible for starvation.

In fact GM foods are tending to worsen poverty and hunger, as farmers are forced into dependency on the expensive GM seed and herbicides of the agribusiness multinationals.

In a socialist society, it may be feasible to genetically modify crops in a safe and beneficial way, as it will be possible to carry out the necessary safety precautions and investigations and thoroughly assess - by democratic discussion and decisions - what is done.

Today however, in capitalist society, socialists should say a firm no to GM use in agriculture. There is little evidence of its benefit - except to the mega profits of multinationals like Monsanto, Syngenta and Bayer - while at the same time evidence of the risks has been growing.

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.


In The Socialist 27 February 2013:


Socialist Party news and analysis

Austerity... Anger... Action!

Resist all attacks on trade union facility time

The Work Programme isn't working

Will the Tories play the benefits card?

Foodbank figures reveal reality of austerity

Them & Us


International socialist news and analysis

South Africa: Big response for Workers' and Socialist Party

Italian election - Results resolve nothing


Socialist Party workplace news

Oil tanker drivers show their industrial strength

Socialists strengthened on NUT executive

London workers lobby GLA about cuts and conditions

Housing support - workers and service users under attack

Workplace news in brief


Socialist Party reports and campaigns

Southampton: Councillors must fight attacks on council services

Trade Unionist and Socialist Coalition: building an anti-cuts electoral voice

Hull: build an unstoppable force

Campaigning against the cuts

East Midlands Ambulance Service

Marching against cuts in Coventry

Socialist Party 2013 congress

Socialist Party Scotland conference


Socialist history

45 years since the Ford Dagenham strike: women workers still fighting for decent pay


Readers' comments

Should socialists support GM foods?

A busy day in the life of a 'shirker'


 

Home   |   The Socialist 27 February 2013   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate   |   PDF  |   ebook






Related links:

GM:

triangleGenetic Modification: A contribution to the debate

triangleGenetic modification: A means of making profit

triangleIs UK car building back in Top Gear?

triangleGeneral Motors - no to 'divide and rule' in Germany

Global:

triangleCarbon dioxide hits 800,000-year high: end profit-driven pollution

triangleSE London Socialist Students & Socialist Party: Global warming - A global threat

triangleExtreme weather events and global warming

Food:

triangleWe're freezing: reverse cuts to boiler replacement schemes!

triangleThe Socialist inbox

triangleObesity epidemic: end food market anarchy

Environment:

triangleOpposition to new academy school being built on Leeds playing fields

triangleHackney Socialist Party: How can the environment be saved?

Agribusiness:

triangleWhat would a socialist food industry look like?

Reviews and comments

Reviews and comments

6/12/17

Fire

The Socialist Inbox

6/12/17

Surrey

Comment: Socialism and truth about Zane

6/12/17

Labour Party

Blairite horror and Labour's divisions graphically exposed

30/11/17

Theatre

Dramatic retelling of Grunwick strike

22/11/17

Working class

Left comic's take on politics will have you in tears

22/11/17

Letters

The Socialist inbox

15/11/17

The Socialist

The Socialist Inbox

15/11/17

Abortion

TV review: Abortion on Trial - hard-hitting look at impact of 1967 act

15/11/17

Vietnam war

Comprehensive account of bloody conflict

8/11/17

Letters

The Socialist inbox

8/11/17

Obituary

Obituary: Paul Randall, 1959-2017

8/11/17

Theatre

Welsh update of Chekhov an engrossing tale of 1980s class conflict

1/11/17

Letters

The Socialist inbox

25/10/17

Letters

The Socialist inbox

25/10/17

Fidel Castro

New musical on life of Castro

triangleMore Reviews and comments articles...


Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party

triangle8 Dec Local government pay: fight for the full 5% claim

triangle6 Dec Strikers rally in Liverpool

triangle6 Dec Corbyn's Labour can defeat Tories with socialist programme

triangle5 Dec Victory at Glenfield shows people power can save our NHS

triangle5 Dec Labour council Blairites deselected

triangle30 Nov Victory: Glenfield Children's Heart Centre saved!

triangle30 Nov Dramatic retelling of Grunwick strike

More ...

triangle13 Dec Caerphilly Socialist Party: Are we heading for an era of war?

triangle14 Dec Wakefield Socialist Party: Universal Credit - the Tories' latest assault on the poor

triangle18 Dec Leeds Socialist Party: Religion and Socialism

triangle19 Dec Bristol North Socialist Party: Christmas social

More ...

Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube

Archive

Archives:

December 2017

November 2017

October 2017

September 2017

August 2017

July 2017

June 2017

May 2017

April 2017

March 2017

February 2017

January 2017

2016

2015

2014

2013

2012

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

Legal

SP RSS feed RSS

Platform setting: = No platform choice

V2