Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page: http://www.socialistparty.org.uk/articles/19330

Posted on 2 October 2014 at 15:50 GMT

Ebola crisis: Consequence of profit before health

The news that the United States is to send 3,000 troops to Liberia to build isolation hospitals, while Sierra Leone has implemented a national lock-down to try to contain the Ebola virus underlines how serious the epidemic in West Africa has become.
Thousands are now infected, with new cases spreading ahead of the ability to treat or isolate patients. With no actual cure, survival seems to be a function of the quality of medical and nursing care of the symptoms, mainly fluid and electrolyte replacement. New Scientist of 9 August quoted the mortality rates as 74% in Guinea, 54% in Liberia and 42% in Sierra Leone.

Support West African health workers

A huge problem is that without rigorous precautions, it is precisely those providing the care who are most at risk of infection. This only goes to show the heroism of the health workers of the West African nations, and some western volunteers, who are to be seen in protective gowns, masks and goggles, trying their level best to contain the virus. Reuters described a nurse in Sierra Leone working for hours at a stretch in full protective gear in tropical heat, as she and others worked to raise the odds in favour of her patients' survival. Sadly, she had to give a false name, such is the fear generated by the virus. There have been reports from Liberia of landlords refusing to rent to nurses, and in Guinea health workers have been attacked and even killed, wrongly suspected of helping spread the virus. Yet without the efforts of these workers, and of the charity Medecins Sans Frontieres, the virus would already have spread far and wide.

In September nurses at John F Kennedy hospital in Monrovia, Liberia, took strike action to demand better pay and equipment to protect them from the Ebola virus. Previously, in July, 20,000 health workers in Liberia went on strike to demand an increase in the $150 a month pay they were getting. Some had not been paid for three months. Trade unionists in this country should stand in solidarity with those workers taking action.

Both the London and North-West regional NHS Committees of Unite the union have passed the following motion:

"This Committee salutes the health workers of Sierra Leone and other West African countries who are on the frontline in the struggle to contain the current outbreak of Ebola virus. At great personal risk to themselves these health workers are treating patients in often imperfect facilities in full protective clothing in tropical heat for very modest salaries.

"Despite all possible precautions a high number of these heroic workers have become infected and subsequently died.

"We therefore request the Unite Head of Health to contact the relevant trade unions in Sierra Leone to offer financial help and assistance for the welfare of health workers working with Ebola patients and also to include financial help to the families of those who have succumbed to the virus. This help to be supported by a fund to be established for donations from Unite branches particularly in health but also other sectors and from individual members."

Andy Ford, Unite health sector

World Bank's 'Structural Adjustment Programmes'

Tim Sandle and Andy Ford

Even capitalist commentators have admitted that economic conditions have a crucial role in the spread and response to the virus. Business Monitor suggests that efforts to contain the outbreak have been hampered by "weak state capacity, lack of public funding and poor health infrastructure".

The state of health systems of West African states is also covered in a second report issued by the medical charity, Wellcome Trust, who argue that because of under investment in medical research the affected countries do not have a viable scientific research community capable of developing home-grown potential drug treatments or tests for Ebola or other diseases.

The terrible health systems and weak scientific base are not just a consequence of the colonial legacy and a post-colonial failure of development; the reality is that what little had been built was deliberately dismantled by the IMF and World Bank.

In Guinea, for example, the Bamako Initiative of 1987 led to a shift towards a fee-paying healthcare system leading to many treatments being beyond the reach of ordinary citizens. The Bamako Initiative was drawn up in collaboration with the World Bank and led to the decentralisation of healthcare across Benin, Guinea and Nigeria. The decentralised system has stymied the ability to formulate an effective national plan against Ebola. In Sierra Leone free healthcare only extends to pregnant and breast-feeding women and children under five. And these countries pay more in interest on debts to the World Bank and International Monetary Fund (IMF) than they spend on healthcare, education, or infrastructure.

Other health statistics indicate why the West African states have struggled to contain Ebola. Guinea spends only $62 per person on health each year, compared with $3,364 in the UK, and Guinea has the lowest number of hospital beds per capita in the world. Sierra Leone has just two doctors per 100,000 people, compared with 245 in the US. Even nominally wealthy Nigeria too has a lack of medical personnel. It is estimated that as many Nigerian doctors are practising in the US alone as there are working in the whole Nigerian public service.

Economic impact

The economic impact of Ebola on the affected states is considerable. Within the internal economy, a combination of the cases of infection and a fear of the virus appear to have had an equivalent impact to that of an environmental disaster. Crops rot in the fields, mines are abandoned and goods cannot get to market. In quarantined zones in Sierra Leone and Liberia, key cash crops such as cocoa and coffee have been left rotting in the fields as farmers fear to stray far from home. Agricultural problems are not only confined to exports. In township markets, supplies of staple commodities such as rice are already dwindling, with only the bravest traders willing to venture far afield to buy stocks.

Rather than address the fall-out, several of the actions of the African governments have been directed to appeasing international capital management. This is the basis of a charge made by Amadou Soumah, a trade union official in Guinea. It was only during mid-August that Guinea declared Ebola to be a national emergency. This is despite the country being at the epicentre of the outbreak, with the first cases reported in March 2014. Soumah argues that the government played down the crisis "to stop investors fleeing".

Resources needed

Galvanised by the realisation that a mass Ebola outbreak in West Africa has the capacity to spread, the UN, US, Britain and France have begun to commit resources to the fight against Ebola. Although the epidemic may have stabilised in Guinea, the number of cases in Liberia and Sierra Leone continues to accelerate. Britain and France are to build a field hospital in each of their former colonies, and the US has said it will build far more in Liberia.

New treatments are in the process of being licensed and a vaccine is currently under trial in Britain, and may be available to health workers in West Africa by November.

New Scientist has commented: "Is it too little, too late?"

Socialists should insist that the resources necessary to contain Ebola are found. Instead of paying billions of dollars on bombing the Middle East, a fraction of that money should have been sent to West Africa. The health workers of West Africa must be respected and supported not feared and taken for granted. The UK health unions must find a way to get money to their West African colleagues to ensure they are looked after and have full trade union rights.

The Ebola outbreak shows that the IMF and World Bank pushing the mass of the population in these countries into dire and abject poverty can affect the advanced capitalist nations too. The virus respects no borders and we live in the same world as the workers and farmers of Guinea, Liberia and Sierra Leone.

Only a socialist transformation of West Africa, including the involvement of the mighty Nigerian working class, can ensure that these nations have the infrastructure, finances and scientific resources to combat Ebola and all the other tropical diseases which afflict the populations there.

The failure of free market Pharma

It is noticeable that none of the prospective treatments for Ebola have been developed by the 'free market', despite the virus being known since 1976.

The 'miracle cure', Z-Mapp, used to treat infected US personnel and British nurse, Will Pooley, was funded by the US Department of Defence out of considerations of bio-terrorism.

Now a drug that interferes with Ebola's reproduction, Tekmira's TKM, is being rushed into production, having shown some promise in early trials. It also has been funded by the US Department of Defence.

This is the case even though, as the Financial Times commented: "Ebola is no invincible superbug". The FT reported that:

"The most striking aspect is how many experimental candidates there are; at least 15 Ebola drugs and a dozen vaccines have been developed as far as pre-clinical (animal) testing. Scientifically, Ebola is an easier target than viruses such as HIV and flu because it does not mutate so rapidly. Unfortunately, however, none of the candidates has been put through the far more expensive process of clinical trials to assess safety and efficacy against Ebola" (15th August 2014).

But there is little profit for big pharmaceutical corporations in a drug to treat intermittent virus outbreaks, especially in the world's poorest countries. There is a lot more money in drugs like Statins, that people will take for decades for less serious conditions in the richer countries of the world.


See also an article on the website of Democratic Socialist Movement in Nigeria:

EBOLA OUTBREAK: A CRISIS OF CAPITALISM


This version of this article was first posted on the Socialist Party website on 2 October 2014 and may vary slightly from the version subsequently printed in The Socialist.

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.






Related links:

Ebola:

triangleCourageous Ebola nurse Salomé Karwah dies

triangleWorld health crises show: Capitalism kills!

triangleEbola virus crisis - no profit, no vaccine

triangleEbola outbreak: one face of austerity

triangleLondon Socialist Party: Ebola and Racism

Health:

triangleThem & Us

triangleWhat kind of movement is needed to save our NHS?

triangleStop press - NHS workers' snap walkout - full victory confirmed

triangleCarlisle NHS privateers leave patients at risk

Profit:

triangleSchool cuts can be beaten

triangle1987 Zeebrugge disaster

Guinea:

triangleGreater Manchester: patients are people not guinea pigs!

triangleLetters

US:

triangleTrump escalates geopolitical tensions on Korean peninsula

Africa:

triangleSouth Africa: Unity against poverty, crime and xenophobia

Reports and campaigns

Reports and campaigns

19/4/17

London

Picturehouse cinema strike spreads

19/4/17

Education

Mood for a fightback at education conferences

19/4/17

Pensions

Weapons workers continue pension strike

19/4/17

PCS

PCS ballot papers out: vote Democracy Alliance

19/4/17

Woolwich

Workers sailing to victory on Woolwich ferry

19/4/17

CWU

CWU conference: fight Royal Mail pension attack

19/4/17

National Shop Stewards Network

National Shop Stewards Network conference 2017

12/4/17

Health

Stop press - NHS workers' snap walkout - full victory confirmed

12/4/17

TUSC

Cardiff: Labour right rattled by anti-cuts TUSC

12/4/17

Carlisle

Hundreds march to save the NHS

12/4/17

Socialist Party

Excellent Socialist Party trade union meeting

12/4/17

Rail

Solid strike across the rail network against unsafe driver-only operation

12/4/17

Arts

Arts unions agree joint campaign work

12/4/17

Derby

Derby teaching assistants accept offer to end pay dispute

12/4/17

TUSC

Doncaster: Socialist Steve's growing support

triangleMore Reports and campaigns articles...


Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party

triangle21 Apr Len McCluskey re-election - a defeat for the right

triangle19 Apr Protest is not a crime

triangle19 Apr Fightback against Royal Mail pension attack needed

triangle19 Apr Picturehouse cinema strike spreads

triangle19 Apr What kind of movement is needed to save our NHS?

triangle19 Apr Turkey: constitutional referendum result a pyrrhic victory for Erdogan

triangle19 Apr French presidential election: Mélenchon campaign gains momentum

More ...

triangle25 Apr Birmingham Socialist Party: Jobstown Not Guilty

triangle25 Apr Derby Socialist Party: A question and answer discussion

triangle26 Apr Salford Socialist Party: Russian Revolution 1917 - the April Theses

triangle26 Apr Hackney & Islington Socialist Party: Defend the right to protest

More ...

Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube

Archive

Archives:

April 2017

March 2017

February 2017

January 2017

2016

2015

2014

2013

2012

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

Legal

SP RSS feed RSS

Platform setting: = No platform choice