Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page: http://www.socialistparty.org.uk/issue/881/21820

From The Socialist newspaper, 2 December 2015

Editorial of the Socialist

Don't bomb Syria! War vote reveals two Labour Parties in one

For workers' unity against war, terrorism and racism

A bomb crater in Syria, photo by Wikimedia Commons (Creative Commons)

A bomb crater in Syria, photo by Wikimedia Commons (Creative Commons)   (Click to enlarge)

The civil war within the Labour party has reached fever pitch. In the last week, Blairite MPs and right-wing shadow cabinet members openly joined forces with the Tories, attempting to imprison Jeremy Corbyn and secure a parliamentary vote in favour of war in Syria.

The crisis has removed any remaining veil of 'unity' that had cloaked the reality: Labour is essentially two parties in one. There is, on the one hand, the Corbyn-supporting Labour Party. The hundreds of thousands who were enthused by the clear anti-austerity and anti-war message of his leadership campaign. The 75% of members who oppose bombing Syria. The people who delivered Jeremy his historically large mandate in September.

On the other, there are the majority of pro-austerity right-wing Labour councillors, MPs and shadow cabinet members. And between these two irreconcilably opposed political positions, peaceful co-existence is impossible.

This contradiction at the centre of the Labour Party will be made most abundantly clear when, on 2 December (after we go to press), the leader of the opposition and the shadow foreign secretary speak in the House of Commons to put forward diametrically opposed views. While Jeremy Corbyn will advance a case against bombing, Hillary Benn will back the Tories' march to war.

'Free vote' mistake

In the view of the Socialist Party, it was a serious mistake for Jeremy Corbyn to grant the concession of allowing Labour MPs a 'free' vote on the question of bombing Syria. Clearly he is hoping this move will stave off an all-out war with the Blairites - who had threatened resignations if he attempted to make them vote against war, even though a majority of Labour MPs indicated they were against the war.

But the truth is that this climbdown will embolden both the Tories and the Labour right. Had Labour taken a clear stand in opposing this latest round of imperialist intervention in the Middle East, the government could well have been forced to retreat.

Outside parliament, 1.12.15

Outside parliament, 1.12.15, photo J Beishon   (Click to enlarge)

Instead, Cameron is now pressing ahead with the vote in Parliament, feeling confident that he will get backing of enough Labour MPs to vote for bombing.

The disastrous legacy of recent British interventions - in Iraq, Libya and Afghanistan - has helped to sow the seeds of the deadly chaos that currently engulfs Syria and its people - including the horror of Isis.

This has made Cameron more anxious to have the political cover of a vote in Parliament, including the support of Labour MPs, before embarking on this latest war. Chastened by losing the vote on bombing Assad in 2013, he has been cautious to make sure the 'parliamentary sums add up' before pressing ahead.

As the Socialist Party argued in last week's issue of this paper, bombing Syria will not stop Isis. Cameron is attempting to use the grief and outrage felt by ordinary people at recent terrorist atrocities - including in Paris, Mali, Beirut, Tunisia and Ankara - to try to build public support for this war.

But his real motivation is not to make Britain's streets safer. In reality, extending British air strikes from Iraq to Syria risks increasing the chances of new terrorist attacks on our shores.

Instead, it is maintaining Britain's prestige as an imperialist power which is a main motivator for this latest push, with the government determined not to be 'left behind' as the US, France and Russia continue their bombing campaign. This instinct is shared by the Labour right.

After all, many of the MPs and shadow cabinet members currently scheming against Corbyn were among the architects and supporters of Blair's bloody wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. They are biding their time before attempting to unseat Corbyn, and will feel that they have scored a victory this week.

Anti-war mandate

By allowing himself to be 'hemmed in' on Syria, a dangerous precedent for future battles on other key issues has been set. In September, Jeremy Corbyn won an enormous mandate on the basis of a leadership campaign which put forward a clear anti-war and anti-cuts stance.

But now he finds himself perched atop an overwhelmingly hostile, right-wing parliamentary Labour party, whose aim is to remove him as soon as they feel the timing is right.

As the battle over Syria has raged, these malign intentions have been made absolutely clear. It was revealed in the papers over the weekend before the vote that some Labour back-benchers were seeking legal advice over the possibility of excluding Jeremy Corbyn from the ballot paper if a new leadership election was triggered by MPs.

Parliament Square, 1.12.15

Parliament Square, 1.12.15, photo J. Beishon   (Click to enlarge)

Meanwhile, shadow cabinet members including Tom Watson and Hilary Benn openly broke ranks by publicly declaring their support for the bombing, even before internal discussions on the question had reached a conclusion.

At the same time, a plethora of shadow cabinet members and Labour MPs - some named, but most anonymous - have lined up to attack Jeremy Corbyn in the press, detailing his various heinous crimes such as 'writing to Labour MPs stating his anti-war position'. Indeed, despite Corbyn supposedly striking a deal with deputy leader Tom Watson - whereby official 'party policy' would be to oppose the bombing while MPs would not be 'whipped' - as soon as Corbyn signalled that he was in retreat, the Blairites smelt blood.

At the subsequent shadow cabinet meeting on 30 November they forced him to step back even from this uncomfortable compromise. It is reported that shadow cabinet members refused to leave the room until Jeremy Corbyn agreed that Hilary Benn would be allowed to sum up Labour's contribution to the discussion in parliament from the despatch box - supporting the government's position.

Without a serious strategy to overcome the isolation faced by Jeremy Corbyn and his few allies in the parliamentary Labour party, he could rapidly become completely paralysed as leader and ultimately be removed. This episode has emphasised that it is now of even greater urgency that Corbyn's supporters are organised with a clear strategy and programme.

The Socialist issue 881 front page - Don't bomb Syria: for workers' unity against war, terrorism and racism

The Socialist issue 881 front page   (Click to enlarge)

Tens of thousands respond

A glimpse of what is possible was shown over the weekend before the vote. Tens of thousands of people responded to calls to write to and, in some cases, lobby Labour MPs to vote against the war.

Over 70,000 people also responded to a survey sent out to Labour party members and supporters - with three quarters declaring their opposition to the bombing. But letter writing campaigns and surveys are not enough.

An almighty struggle is required in order to defeat the Labour right. This means mobilising the hundreds of thousands of working class and young people who back Corbyn, drawing on the strength of the organised workers' movement in the trade unions and bringing in existing anti-austerity campaigns and parties.

The setting up of Momentum was a step in the right direction. But so-far, on a national level this organisation has mainly restricted itself to things like calling for voter registration campaigns and organising for people to assist with canvassing in support of the right-wing Labour candidate standing in the Oldham by-election.

Instead Momentum nationally should adopt the kind of approach taken at local level by some of its groups. A good example is Lewisham Momentum, which has taken a clear anti-cuts stand and is campaigning for Labour councillors to protect local services rather than passing on Tory austerity.

Mandatory re-selection

At an anti-austerity conference in London on 21 November Matt Wrack, general secretary of the firefighters' union FBU, and Mark Serwotka, general secretary of civil servants' union PCS, called for the setting up of a Trade Union Momentum. This could potentially play a very important role.

Parliament Square, 1.12.15

Parliament Square, 1.12.15, photo J Beishon   (Click to enlarge)

This week at a special conference, the FBU also voted to re-affiliate to Labour. The Socialist Party has cautioned against this - as affiliation means handing money to the right wing Labour machine, not Corbyn and his supporters.

But what is clear is that, whether affiliated or not, the trade unions must now use their weight to put pressure on Labour councillors and MPs to act in the interests of working class people.

This fight must not be limited to the current, undemocratic Labour Party structures. At an absolute minimum, this means opposing imperialist wars and interventions and refusing to continue to implement brutal austerity measures.

In the Socialist Party's view it was a mistake for Jeremy Corbyn to state that he opposed the mandatory re-selection of MPs. In fact, it is absolutely crucial that Labour MPs or councillors who use their positions to vote for this war - not to mention the destruction of jobs and services through cuts - should be held democratically accountable via a reselection process.

As the Blairites sharpen their knives against Corbyn, it is vital that we are organised to defend him and to fight for there to be no further retreat from the key pledges that saw him elected. The Socialist Party is helping to organise this struggle and to fight for the socialist programme that is needed in order to put an end to war and austerity.

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.


In The Socialist 2 December 2015:


What we think

Don't bomb Syria! War vote reveals two Labour Parties in one


International socialist news and analysis

Greece - general strike against austerity sees mass protests

Eyewitness to the refugee crisis: a visit to 'The Jungle'

Belgium: ruling class can't be trusted with 'security'

Socialist takes third of vote in Hong Kong election


Socialist Party women

Women: fight for equality, fight for socialism


Socialist history

How the Iron Lady was reduced to iron filings


Socialist Party news and analysis

Action needed to save our NHS

Autumn Statement u-turns: austerity can be defeated

Student nurses must pay to work

Paris climate summit falls short in world's hottest year

London ambulances in special measures due to underfunding

Them & Us


Workplace news and analysis

Junior doctors' strike suspended for talks

JCB redundancies mitigated but fight needed

Open Uni strikers prepared to go the distance

Bus drivers fight bully-boy managers

Water workers protest against pension attacks

Workplace news in brief


Socialist readers' comments and reviews

Film review - The Hunger Games: Mockingjay - Part 2

A socialist Christmas gift guide

Letters


Socialist Party reports and campaigns

Christmas 'collectathon': 8 to 17 December

Workers snap up the Socialist!

Protesters demand system change not climate change

Demonstration against the war

FBU fights the cuts in Yorkshire


 

Home   |   The Socialist 2 December 2015   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate   |   Audio  |   PDF  |   ebook






Related links:

Anti-war:

triangleAttacks ratchet-up Syrian conflict and fuel tensions between powers

triangleDebates on building the anti-Trump movement

Syria:

triangleTrump's policies hit a wall

triangleBristol South Socialist Party: What do Socialists say about Syria?

triangleThe Socialist inbox

triangleTurkey: Erdogan seeks sweeping dictatorial powers in referendum

Parties:

triangleTUSC's south Wales challenge to pro-cuts parties

triangleFrance: Groundswell of support for left candidate

trianglePerspectives for the two parties in one

Labour:

triangleBritain's election and the coming battle for Labour

triangleObituary: Rhodri Morgan 1939-2017, architect of the 'Welsh Labour' brand

The Socialist:

triangleBook launch meeting: showing the Socialist Party's active participation in events past and present

Workers:

triangleWorkplace news in brief

Terrorism:

triangleUnite against terror, racism and war

Socialist:

triangleChesterfield Socialist Party: Tories Out! Corbyn can win with a socialist, anti-austerity programme

Racism:

triangleManchester bombing: Unite against terror, war and racism

MPs:

triangleCorbyn's manifesto: An important step in the right direction

Jeremy Corbyn:

triangleCorbyn and Brexit: Why a socialist approach to the EU is needed

Austerity:

triangleBlackpool deserves better - anti-austerity rally

Labour Party:

triangleFund the fight against the Tories

Momentum:

triangleThe Socialist inbox

Iraq:

triangle'From Militant to the Socialist Party' - new book now available

Isis:

triangleHistoric demonstration in Barcelona in support of refugees

Parliament:

triangleCorbyn could re-win Scotland with a socialist approach to independence

Anti-austerity:

triangleWest London Socialist Party: Tories out! Corbyn can win with a socialist, anti-austerity programme

Tories:

triangleSocialist Students call on chicken May to debate Corbyn

Middle East:

triangleLivingstone, Labour and anti-Semitism

Anti-cuts:

triangleNational Shop Stewards Network conference

State:

triangleTrump regime faces deepening crisis

Terror:

triangleRefugee rescue

News and socialist analysis

News and socialist analysis

25/5/17

Socialist

Britain's election and the coming battle for Labour

24/5/17

Tuition Fees

Corbyn's pledge: free education - May's plan: hike fees

24/5/17

BBC

The media, May and the general election

24/5/17

Oil

Tory oil spoils v poisonous air

24/5/17

Pay

Work doesn't pay: Tory policies have meant another wages cut

24/5/17

Schools

Theresa 'Lunch Snatcher' May vs Jeremy 'free meals' Corbyn

24/5/17

Socialist

Corbyn in - Tories out

24/5/17

EU

Corbyn and Brexit: Why a socialist approach to the EU is needed

24/5/17

Labour

Obituary: Rhodri Morgan 1939-2017, architect of the 'Welsh Labour' brand

24/5/17

Ttip

Single market = TTIP

24/5/17

General election

May's 'dementia tax' wobble vs Corbyn's extra funds

23/5/17

Manchester

Manchester bombing: Unite against terror, war and racism

22/5/17

Capitalism

Capitalism condemned

17/5/17

Housing

One in three borrow for rent, Corbyn pledges housing revolution

17/5/17

General election

Corbyn's manifesto: An important step in the right direction

triangleMore News and socialist analysis articles...


Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party

triangle27 May Book launch meeting: showing the Socialist Party's active...

Socialism Today 209 cover

triangle25 May Britain's election and the coming battle for Labour

triangle25 May Human rights workers strike in support of sacked union members

triangle24 May The media, May and the general election

triangle24 May Corbyn and Brexit: Why a socialist approach to the EU is needed

triangle24 May Obituary: Rhodri Morgan 1939-2017, architect of the 'Welsh Labour'...

triangle24 May 5,000 march against plans to cut teachers

More ...

triangle27 May Southampton Socialist Party: Tories Out! Jeremy Corbyn can win with a socialist programme

triangle27 May Leicester Socialist Party: Tories Out! - How Labour's left can win

triangle30 May Birmingham South East Socialist Party: Education in crisis - the socialist answer

triangle30 May Manchester Socialist Party: Chechnya - Gay rights and the repressions

More ...

Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube

Archive

Archives:

May 2017

April 2017

March 2017

February 2017

January 2017

2016

2015

2014

2013

2012

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

Legal

SP RSS feed RSS

Platform setting: = No platform choice