Socialist Case for Exit

Link to this page: http://www.socialistparty.org.uk/issue/888/22187

From The Socialist newspaper, 10 February 2016

Cameron's EU renegotiation charade

Photo Paul Mattsson

Photo Paul Mattsson   (Click to enlarge)

Last July Socialism Today, the monthly magazine of the Socialist Party, wrote that "after some suitable renegotiation sound and fury by Cameron", his position and that of "the main forces of capitalism in Britain and internationally" would be to support Britain's continued membership of the EU.

And 'sound and fury signifying nothing' describes precisely Cameron's 'new deal for Britain in Europe'. Most of the provisions are effectively a clarification of what is already stated in the EU treaties.

One new proposal is an 'emergency brake' to deny full in-work benefits for up to four years to workers in Britain from other EU countries. But, as The Economist magazine says, it is largely "theatre".

Just 84,000 families on tax credits would have been affected by the 'brake' if it had applied for the last four years, according to the HMRC. And they count in this one in ten of these couples with one partner who is a UK national.

The 'savings' from the brake would be minimal. They pale, for example, next to the annual 1 billion EU migrants' healthcare costs incurred by Spain, where 50% of the Britons who live there are aged over 50 and are not in work.

Cameron's deal has it that the 'emergency brake' will be activated if the leaders of the other 27 EU countries in the European Council agree that Britain's 'social and economic systems are being overwhelmed'. But who are these capitalist politicians to pass judgement, having imposed austerity across the continent, including the savagery in Greece?

Austerity

Many local communities in Britain will rightly feel that public services are 'overwhelmed' when drastic cuts have been made and with another round of council cuts on the way. They need real action to defend and improve services, not Cameron's divisive play-acting.

There is palpable rage at the shortage of decent affordable housing, for example. Meanwhile the 'big nine' house-building companies hold enough land to build 600,000 new homes and sit on a 1 billion cash pile. An 'emergency brake' that really dealt with the housing crisis would mean nationalising these building monopolies and handing over their land banks to local councils to build homes.

But public ownership and other forms of state intervention are outlawed under EU treaties. Local councils, for example, have to sign off everything they do against EU state aid regulations. Cameron didn't demand that these were 'renegotiated', of course.

In that regard Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn was right in his Commons' response to Cameron to warn that the new deal's clauses on 'competitiveness' were "a fig leaf for increasing pressure to privatise our public services" and reduce workers' rights.

But he was wrong to say that to keep workers' rights "we need to remain with the EU". Doesn't what happened in Greece to the Syriza government's attempts to implement policies similar to Corbyn's prove the opposite?

The Socialist Party opposes the EU because, as Greece showed, its laws and institutions, while they ultimately could not stop a determined workers' government supported by a mass movement from carrying out socialist policies, are another hurdle to overcome. We oppose the EU, Cameron's deal included, in order to defend working class interests and take forward the fight for socialism, in Britain and Europe.

In contrast, that minority of capitalist politicians who oppose the EU eagerly participate in Cameron's renegotiation and referendum charade the better to try and divide the working class. There can be no unity with them in the trade unionist and socialist campaign that needs to be conducted for a Leave vote.

See also:

Don't give taxpayers' money to Ukip and Tory EU campaigners!

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.


In The Socialist 10 February 2016:


Socialist Party news and analysis

Fight council cuts!

Tories bankrupting NHS

Defiant mood as junior doctors demonstrate

Lawyers defeat Tories' unjust legal aid cuts

Cushy government job for Amazon boss

'Pro-rape' anti-feminist Roosh V humiliated

Liverpool fans walk out against ticket price hikes

Them & Us


Socialist Party feature

Mental health: system in crisis

Mental health: My battle for the help I needed


What we think

Cameron's EU renegotiation charade

Don't give money to Ukip and Tory EU campaigners!


Momentum, Labour and the Socialist Party

Lack of strategy and exclusions threaten Momentum

Birmingham: socialists kicked out of Momentum

Labour right wing blocks call to debate budget cuts


Socialist Party workplace news

No-cuts strategy needed to save 25,000 council jobs

Local government union backs no-cuts council budgets

Big victory at Small Heath School against academy attack

Cuts to premiums mean no 'rise' in store for Tesco workers

Leicester taxi dispute: Labour's rank hypocrisy

South London: Library workers strike to save services

Continued action in crane drivers' pay dispute

Workplace news in brief


Socialist Party reports and campaigns

Portsmouth: support for anti-austerity stand

Leeds meeting expresses Corbyn and McDonnell's contradictions

Socialist Party members inspired by conference

Torbay: "A tale of two towns"

Anger against plans to close Bradford libraries

NHS campaign gains support


International socialist news and analysis

Sanders' socialist message rattling the establishment

US elections: Clinton coins it

International news in brief


 

Facebook   Twitter

Home   |   The Socialist 10 February 2016   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate   |   Bookshop






Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Related links:

EU:

triangleGreece crisis - please vote Leave

triangleSocialist inbox

triangle'Socialist case against the EU' TUSC tour kicks off

triangleEU referendum can bring the Tories down

triangleBritain's gaping political fault-lines

David Cameron:

triangleEx-TUC chief lines up with David Cameron

triangleLondon elections: fight for an anti-austerity GLA

triangleJeremy Corbyn's EU u-turn

triangleEU: bosses pick 'safe' reactionary out voice

Britain:

triangleLeicester drives out Britain First

trianglePaul Mason's EU referendum defeatism answered by TUSC

triangleGloucestershire Socialist Party: Lessons of Britain's 1926 General Strike

Europe:

triangleThem & us

triangleHackney & Islington Socialist Party: No to the bosses' EU!

News and socialist analysis

News and socialist analysis

25/5/16

EU

EU referendum can bring the Tories down

25/5/16

What we saw

What we saw: 'I, Daniel Blake' and Hunt/'Thick of It' remix

21/5/16

EU

Britain's gaping political fault-lines

18/5/16

EU

The EU and the economy - Project Fear steps up

18/5/16

Them & Us

Them & Us

18/5/16

Cuts

Tories attack: Fight back

18/5/16

NHS

NHS staffing black hole

18/5/16

Bristol

Bristol Green backs cuts

18/5/16

Women

Stamp out sexist dress codes

18/5/16

Universities

University of Facebook

18/5/16

What we saw

What we saw

18/5/16

Tony Blair

Blair bombshell

11/5/16

Elections

Elections showed anger and fragmentation

11/5/16

BMA

Government blinks first in junior doctors' dispute

11/5/16

Tories

Tories retreat: now drive them out!

triangleMore News and socialist analysis articles...

triangle25 May Austria - Hofer defeated, but far-right threat remains

triangle25 May EU referendum can bring the Tories down

triangle25 May University lecturers strike for fair pay

triangle25 May Motion passed for no-cuts council budgets

triangle25 May Link the strikes - come to the NSSN conference

triangle25 May Tories forced back in junior doctors' dispute

triangle21 May Britain's gaping political fault-lines

More ...

triangle26 May East London Socialist Party: The EU referendum - what position should socialists take?

triangle26 May Bristol South Socialist Party: Protests in France against labour 'reforms'

triangle26 May Gloucestershire Socialist Party: Lessons of Britain's 1926 General Strike

triangle26 May Torbay & South Devon Socialist Party: The socialist case for Brexit

More ...

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube

Find us on Facebook

Archive

Categories

1-9 

1-9 


Archives:

May 2016

April 2016

March 2016

February 2016

January 2016

2015

2014

2013

2012

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

Legal

SP RSS feed RSS

Platform setting: = No platform choice