Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page:

From The Socialist newspaper, 7 December 2016

Italy: Establishment routed - workers alternative needed

From the editorial of Resistenze by Contro Corrente, CWI Italy
Outgoing Italian prime minister Matteo Renzi, photo by (Creative Commons)

Outgoing Italian prime minister Matteo Renzi, photo by (Creative Commons)   (Click to enlarge)

In January 2014, on the day that Matteo Renzi took office, we wrote that this was the beginning of the end for the leader of the Democratic Party (PD), who at that time seemed to be on an unstoppable path to glory.

The result of the constitutional referendum, in which Renzi was defeated by almost 60% to 40%, shows not so much our foresight but the lack of foresight of the Italian ruling class, which relied on a leader who turned out to be a car without brakes.


In fact, on 4 December Italians sent a clear and strong message not only to the government and the prime minister but also to the entire political class, including those who were on the 'No' side.

As the Sole24Ore (newspaper of the industrialists and financiers) wrote on the day after the vote, those who voted 'Yes' were mainly pensioners and in the upper and middle layers of society. While those low-paid workers and youth, precisely those who the government had addressed its rhetoric to for three years, dealt them a solemn blow.

81% of those aged 18 to 35 voted 'No'. The idea that it would be possible to ride the wave of social anger by promising a few euros to the poorer sections of society, proved to be a complete illusion.

As was predicting an 'apocalypse' if 'No' won, while trying to chase after Grillo (leader of the Five Star Movement) and Salvini (leader of the Lega Nord) on their anti-'political caste' and anti-Europe terrain. The same is true for those who pose as defenders of the constitution, including Grillo.

Workers, youth and impoverished middle-class people didn't vote 'No' to defend 'the best constitution in the world', but to reject those who, instead of 'demolishing the old politics' (as everyone says they want to do), continued to demolish working people.

Laughably the establishment talked about a country that doesn't exist - where the economy is improving, companies are taking on hundreds of thousands of young people on permanent contracts, and taxes are decreasing.

Renzi's massive defeat, his resignation, and the deepening crisis of the PD (the real pro-big business wing of recent years) represent a positive development and an opportunity for workers and youth who want to fight for a better future.

But for an opportunity to become a step forward it must be grasped with a realistic analysis of the political and social situation. There isn't a single political force in the 'No' camp which could be a reference point for those who really want to change Italian society.

Fill the streets

The enthusiasm for the 'No' vote could be used to begin a serious discussion about a political alternative capable of filling the streets rather than the voting stations.

Alternatively, it could be used to sow the illusion that now that Renzi has been kicked out our problems are solved, that a new 'centre-left' can be reborn or that a victory for the Five Star Movement at the next general election could produce what hasn't been so far produced in any of the municipalities controlled by Grillo's movement.

Obviously we are for the first option.

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.

In The Socialist 7 December 2016:

What we think

No more concessions to Labour right!

Socialist Party news and analysis

Fight for a socialist Brexit

Conservatives humiliated in Richmond

Newham council to sack up to 1,300

Slump in unfair dismissal cases - scrap tribunal fees!

Workers can fight Uber-style care

Compensation disabled

Them & Us

Food banks feature

Food banks and the real Daniel Blakes

NHS crisis and fightback

NHS: Stop the Tory vandals

Hundreds protest the decimation of Devon NHS

Massive support in Stoke for action to save the NHS

Health campaigners in Yorkshire protest "slash and trash plans"

International socialist news and analysis

Victory at Standing Rock: US authorities agree to re-route oil pipeline

Spain: Government forced back by Student Union mobilisations

Italy: Establishment routed - workers alternative needed

Portugal: No to witch-hunts - fight the capitalists not socialists

Austria: Far right temporarily halted

Sudan: General strike in defiance of regime

Socialist Party workplace news

Durham TAs force Labour to suspend pay cuts

Protest against Glasgow Labour's scab workforce plan to defeat Unison strike

Crossrail action in defence of victimised union rep

Unison members barely earning the living wage in some universities

Sacked bakers' union rep Kumaran Bose calls for living wage 'protection'

Workplace news in brief

Socialist Party reports and campaigns

Bolton council gives 300k to solicitors while making swingeing cuts

Reading TUSC writes to Labour councillors to demand cuts fight

John Sharpe: 1953-2016

Obituary: John Sharpe: 1953-2016


Home   |   The Socialist 7 December 2016   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate   |   Bookshop

Related links:


triangleFight for a socialist Brexit

triangleEurope and the workers' movement after Brexit

triangleItaly: Prime Minister Renzi's party routed

triangleHiroshima - 70 years on

triangleMigrants flee horrors created by capitalism


triangleEast London Socialist Party: Stop Newham council tearing up workers' contracts

triangleThe Socialist: read it, write it, sell it

triangleThe Socialist inbox

triangleBillions in profit for Tesco, cuts and job losses for workers


triangleFootball abuse scandal: Reclaim the game for justice and accountability

triangleYoung workers in Leeds socialise and mobilise at Unison young workers gig

triangleUSA: mass protests break out to #ResistTrump


triangleNorthern Ireland calls snap election: back Labour Alternative

triangleMexico: Mass movement against "gasolinazo"


triangleLeeds Socialist Party: New technology & the gig economy


triangleHackney & Islington Socialist Party: Opposing caste and race based politics


triangleLessons of the 'N30' 2011 pension strike


triangleTories torn in two on single market

Big business:

triangleInaugurate the resistance


triangleCWI website to mark 1917 Russian Revolution

General election:

triangleAustria: Far right temporarily halted




Kshama Sawant

Kshama Sawant responds to Trump's speech


Donald Trump

We can stop Trump's sexist agenda in its tracks


Donald Trump

Inaugurate the resistance


Donald Trump

Resist Trump



USA: Seattle activists win housebuilding programme



Palestine/Israel: Everyday life under occupation


Northern Ireland

Northern Ireland: 'Cash for ash' scam shows need for non-sectarian, socialist politics



CWI: opportunities for substantial growth



Italy: Establishment routed - workers alternative needed



Sudan: General strike in defiance of regime



Austria: Far right temporarily halted



Portugal: No to witch-hunts - fight the capitalists not socialists



Spain: Government forced back by Student Union mobilisations



Victory at Standing Rock: US authorities agree to re-route oil pipeline



Spain: militant struggle by Students Union succeeds

triangleMore International articles...

Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party

triangle23 Jan Marches against Trump

triangle23 Jan NHS SOS: Save the Women's Hospital

triangle23 Jan Bernard Roome

triangle20 Jan Labour needs to replace Tristram Hunt with an anti-austerity candidate

triangle19 Jan Build a wall of resistance against Trumpism

triangle18 Jan Tories torn in two on single market

triangle18 Jan Labour's civil war continues - build a mass workers' party

More ...

triangle24 Jan Liverpool Socialist Party: Refugee rights

triangle24 Jan Kingston Socialist Party and Socialist Students: Trump's right wing populism

triangle25 Jan Hackney & Islington Socialist Party: Right wing populism and Fake News

triangle25 Jan Salford Socialist Party: After the inauguration - how can Trump be stopped?

More ...

Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube






January 2017





















Platform setting: = No platform choice