Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page: http://www.socialistparty.org.uk/issue/929/24107

From The Socialist newspaper, 14 December 2016

What kind of education?

Primary school teacher, photo US Department of Education (Creative Commons)

Primary school teacher, photo US Department of Education (Creative Commons)   (Click to enlarge)

What kind of education should we be fighting for? Teacher and Socialist Party member James Kerr asks how we might change schooling from a chore to a truly vibrant, nurturing part of life.

Teacher trade unionists have been engaged in a bitter struggle to defend education. The next few years will see further battles over school funding and teacher workload, among other things.

As socialists, though, we don't simply see our role as a defensive one, but to offer a way out of the chaos: a socialist education programme. "Education for the masses," as the popular demonstration slogan goes. This requires examining the current education system under capitalism.

"Why are we doing this?" A familiar question we hear as teachers when students embark on a task in school. Sometimes there is no easy answer, or we know that the reply is probably "because the exam board demands we do."

Teachers use every trick in their repertoire to make the subject matter engaging and meaningful, but the reality is that what is demanded of students can often be viewed as abstract and irrelevant.

Counter-reforms

This has been exacerbated by recent education counter-reforms. For example, under Michael Gove, the teaching of history in primary schools moved to a linear model.

Previously, students had started their learning of history 'closest to them', studying World War Two. This enabled some to discuss with grandparents and other adults who had lived through it, understanding their family history and placing their own lives in the context of world history.

They developed an understanding of the 'concept' of history as well as the content. It wasn't without flaws, but was more meaningful than beginning with the Neolithic period and working forward like they do now.

Is it a surprise that this is one of the characteristics of the school system under capitalism?

Karl Marx explained that workers can experience a feeling of estrangement from their own humanity, 'alienation', as a result of their mechanical role in production. This alienation is of course present within the school system too, as students complete abstract tasks, preparing them for a life in work.

The class system in capitalism is reflected in the education system. The vast majority of judges, politicians, military officers, journalists, executives and so on come from the tiny number of elite private schools and universities.

This suits capitalism well. The bosses benefit from an education system which can produce an able next generation of workers, but also avoids encouraging challenges to the inequality of class-based society.

However, this is a fine balance for them to strike. It prompted Friedrich Engels, Marx's collaborator, to state that "the capitalist class has little to hope, and much to fear, from the education of the working class."

In fighting for socialism we cannot simply see our role as tinkering with the capitalists' system. We should fight to revolutionise the education system, to meet the needs of the 21st century.

Despite many 'innovations' over the years, has the education system really been transformed? The blackboards may be gone, but is the PowerPoint projector not just a jazzed-up version? Opportunities to create more active learning opportunities have often not been developed, and will be further sidelined with the impact of school funding cuts.

We are left in many cases with what pioneering educator Paulo Freire described as 'banking education'. Knowledge from an all-knowing 'expert' is deposited into the student, rather than learning coming from dialogue, debate and criticism.

The freedom for teachers and students to explore their interests and follow tangents is restricted by a rigid curriculum. In some schools now there is an expectation that teachers should be at the same stage of the same lesson simultaneously, regardless of the class in the room or what discussion might throw up.

In 2017 we celebrate the hundredth anniversary of the Russian revolution, where many of these same questions confronted the Bolsheviks as they fought to build a new society. The old 'book school' of the Tsar was to be replaced; innovation and experimentation was to be encouraged.

Polytechnical

One area where much attention was directed was around the introduction of 'polytechnical education', an approach long-discussed within the Marxist movement. Put simply, polytechnical education foregrounded the importance of human labour and production in the learning process.

Vladimir Lenin, one of the leaders of the Russian revolution, gives the example of the study of electricity involving regular visits and lessons within a power station. This enables students to see electricity not as an abstract concept, but an integral part of the modern society they live in.

There are numerous opportunities in society for learning to be approached in this way and not confined to a set time period within the school building. The school could become the organiser of a student's learning, rather than its only provider.

Finland plans to replace rigidly defined subjects in the next few years with more thematic learning. This will provide interesting opportunities for study and discussion. Finnish students will take courses like 'Working in an English café' in order to learn a range of skills and concepts within a 'real life' situation.

It is important here to not confuse the arguments for a rich and varied learning experience with those for a purely 'vocational education'.

There can be a tendency for often well-meaning arguments to be made for alternative provision for students who are deemed not to be 'academic'. This effectively means preparing young people for a set employment path as a specialist in a particular area.

We should argue for young people to be introduced to a variety of practical skills and to experience real work situations, but not be deprived of learning in other areas. People should have the opportunity to develop as rounded human beings and the education system should support that. This is an important facet of the fight against the Tories' proposed expansion of grammar schools, and also campaigns to defend and extend adult education.

Learning should be open to all, throughout life, and not just as a crash course prior to employment.

Play

These debates rage around the education of some of our youngest students too. Any good early-years teacher will tell you that much of students' early learning comes through play - through playing roles and experimenting with ideas as part of a social interaction with others.

Even in early years, that approach is under threat from standardised testing - a similar theme running through education - but it should form the basis of all learning. Students' creativity and curiosity should be given a forum to be explored throughout life.

Some of these ideas are present within the independent sector, like the Montessori Schools. They should be trialled and introduced within state education, under democratic working class control and management.

For these ideas to bear fruit, a fundamental change in the running of education would be required.

Schools would need greater autonomy to experiment and embed teaching methods which worked, and this would require genuine democracy. The day-to-day running of schools would need the input of elected teachers, students and representatives from the local community to ensure schools served the whole community.

A massive injection of funding would be required to train the number of teachers necessary to bring down class sizes, and allow for the teaching approaches previously discussed. With proper funding, schools could become hubs of their community; open to all, to provide wide-ranging, high-quality education, plus clubs, trips and other community functions.

While fighting to defend past gains, we will continue to look ahead to a future where no one's left counting the days until the school holidays.

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.


In The Socialist 14 December 2016:


Socialist Party news and analysis

NHS crisis: we're fighting back!

End the Tories' war on the working poor

Amazon workers living in tents

Pfizer drug extortion - nationalise big pharma!

Trust in politicians reaches all-time low

No to home seizures for care bills

Them & Us


What we think

Establishment EU crisis deepens - fight for a socialist Brexit


A socialist programme for education

What kind of education?

Education for all - not exam factories


International socialist news and analysis

CWI: opportunities for substantial growth


Workplace news and analysis

Glasgow Labour leaders deluged with protests

Victory for UPS parcel workers

Nationalise Tata Steel to save jobs and pensions

Bin workers strike against draconian management

Derby TAs to strike against pay cut

Southern: back the strike, nationalise the railways!


Socialist Party reports and campaigns

Birmingham Labour: Corbyn supporters need not apply

The Socialist Party and fighting women's oppression

Doncaster: cuts give rise to 'tent city'

Scrooge Tory council confronted over treatment of homeless


Comment and review

It's the bumper Socialist 2016 quiz!

2016 sounds for your stocking

The Socialist Inbox


 

Home   |   The Socialist 14 December 2016   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate   |   Audio  |   PDF  |   ebook






Related links:

Schools:

triangle5,000 march against plans to cut teachers

triangleTheresa 'Lunch Snatcher' May vs Jeremy 'free meals' Corbyn

triangleTories out! Corbyn can win with socialist policies

triangleCorbyn pledges council powers to take over academies

triangleCorbyn pledges end to uni fees and school cuts

Education:

triangleBirmingham South East Socialist Party: Education in crisis - the socialist answer

triangleCorbyn's pledge: free education - May's plan: hike fees

triangleSouth-East London Socialist Party: The General Election; fighting for free education and votes at 16

triangleCorbyn's alternative for young people

Students:

triangleSocialist Students call on chicken May to debate Corbyn

triangleSocialist ideas are energising young people

triangleSocialists tell free marketeers "the pitchforks are coming" in Durham debate

School:

triangleHull workers who fought in the Spanish Civil War

triangleHuddersfield Socialist Party: A Socialist education policy

Teachers:

triangleOne Housing tenants force housing association back

Capitalism:

triangleCapitalist journal's warning to the bosses: Marx was right, watch out!

Student:

triangleKCL housing 'wall of shame'

Young people:

triangleSocialist Party Congress 2017 reports

Socialist:

triangleObituary: Rhodri Morgan 1939-2017, architect of the 'Welsh Labour' brand

Revolution:

triangleBarcelona May Days 1937 - a civil war within a civil war

Reports and campaigns

Reports and campaigns

24/5/17

National Shop Stewards Network

National Shop Stewards Network conference

24/5/17

Strike

Workplace news in brief

24/5/17

PCS

PCS DWP conference 2017

24/5/17

RMT

Third strike against driver-only operated trains suspended but dispute continues

24/5/17

Devon

Window workers walk out after seeing through contract changes

24/5/17

London

Human rights workers strike in support of sacked union members

24/5/17

Newcastle

Newcastle: fresh faces and the fight in Labour

24/5/17

Salford

Labour council's threat to children's care centre

24/5/17

Walthamstow

Blairite warmonger misses chance to fight on Corbyn's popular policies

24/5/17

Socialist Students

Socialist Students call on chicken May to debate Corbyn

24/5/17

Wirral

Things are changing: 20,000 sing for Corbyn at Wirral rock festival!

24/5/17

Hull

Wave after wave: 5,000 at 'rock festival' Corbyn rally in Hull

24/5/17

Bristol

5,000 march against plans to cut teachers

19/5/17

Argos

Argos: aggressive bosses met by determined strike

17/5/17

Manchester

Manchester: housing maintenance workers plan strikes every week

triangleMore Reports and campaigns articles...


Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party

triangle24 May The media, May and the general election

triangle24 May Obituary: Rhodri Morgan 1939-2017, architect of the 'Welsh Labour'...

triangle24 May 5,000 march against plans to cut teachers

triangle24 May Corbyn and Brexit: Why a socialist approach to the EU is the only way...

triangle23 May Manchester bombing: Unite against terror, war and racism

triangle22 May Capitalism condemned

triangle19 May Aggressive bosses met by determined strike

More ...

triangle25 May London Socialist Party: Tories Out - Corbyn can win with a socialist, anti-austerity programme

triangle25 May Swansea Socialist Party: The general election - will socialist policies win?

triangle25 May Huddersfield Socialist Party: A socialist health policy

triangle25 May Bristol South Socialist Party: What does the Russian revolution mean today?

More ...

Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube

Archive

Archives:

May 2017

April 2017

March 2017

February 2017

January 2017

2016

2015

2014

2013

2012

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

Legal

SP RSS feed RSS

Platform setting: = No platform choice