Link to this page: http://www.socialistparty.org.uk/issue/501/3121
From The Socialist newspaper, 13 September 2007
DNA database
Keeping tabs on the millions?
A SENIOR appeal judge, Sir Stephen Sedley, has called for the genetic details of all the 60 million people who live in Britain and the 30 million who visit every year to be added to the national DNA database.
Bob Severn
Already over four million DNA samples are kept on the database, which is more than in any other country.
The Home Office says that 5.2% of Britain's population are on the database, compared to 0.5% in the US.
What is more, 30,000 profiles are already added to the database each month. A third of the people recorded on the database have never been found guilty of a crime.
The information commissioner, Richard Thomas, warned that a universal database would be "highly intrusive" with "the greater risk of false matches and other mistakes. The potential for technical and human error leading to serious consequences cannot be under-estimated."
Even though Sedley has said that DNA details should be recorded "for the absolutely rigorously restricted purpose of crime detection and prevention", privacy experts have said there would be immense pressure to use the database for a far wider range of purposes, most obviously for such civil court actions as paternity suits. But who would control the information and decide on how it can be used?
The DNA database was created in 1995 and now has profiles of 884,000 people under 18 and over 100 records of children under ten years old.
Last year, Tony Blair said that he saw no reason for not having everyone's DNA on record.
Gordon Brown's spokesperson has said there are no government plans for a compulsory database, raising civil liberty, logistical and bureaucratic problems.
But Home Office minister Tony McNulty said that he was sympathetic to the judge's reasoning.
Currently the Home Office are reviewing the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 that sets out powers for taking and retaining biometric data.
Lord Justice Sedley's argument was that a disproportionate numbers of DNA entries on the database are of people from ethnic minorities.
Perhaps a better solution to this injustice would be to attack the main cause of crime - social deprivation - instead of passing anti-terror laws that mean people get stopped for 'travelling whilst Asian'.
And also by action against the real criminals, in particular the billionaire bosses and their war-mongering puppets in government.
Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.
In The Socialist 13 September 2007:
Fighting Unions Need a New party
Postal workers: "We have the power!"
TUC conference: Standing up to Brown's attacks
Needed: a combative trade union movement
War and terrorism
Workplace news and events
Tube workers' strike scores victory
Socialist Party NHS campaign
Manchester cuts maternity services
Leeds - no more deficits and cuts
APEC summit
APEC summit: Thousands defy police crackdown
Socialist Party news and analysis
Overcrowded prisons, overworked staff
Socialist Party feature
Tory party struggles to recapture territory taken by New Labour
International news and analysis
Socialist Party review
Robert Blincoe - a life that illuminates an age
Home | The Socialist 13 September 2007 | Join the Socialist Party
Join us today!
Printable version
email to friend
