Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page:

From The Socialist newspaper, 14 April 2005

Pope John Paul II

Pope John Paul II died on Saturday 2 April - the first ever Polish pope and first non-Italian since 1523. Millions of people who identify with Catholicism will mourn for Karol Jozef Wojtyla.

Karl Debbaut

His public popularity can be explained by his use of modern technology allowing him to speak to more people - an estimated 17.8 million people attended masses led by him - than any other pope or indeed any other human being, before him.

However, even the unprecedented media frenzy around his death could not drown out dissenting voices. John Paul II was the representative of the most conservative currents of Catholicism.

His doctrines on wide-ranging issues from liberation theology, over the ordaining of women to the use of condoms were reactionary. His modus operandi was "there is no such thing as loyal opposition" as he set about rolling back the achievements of the second Vatican council in modernising the church.

The tributes paid to him by Catholic dignitaries, political leaders, pop stars and commentators make the death of John Paul II a very political event and will, have an effect, at least in the short term, on how he will be viewed in history.


The American president George Bush said "The world has lost a champion of peace and freedom", opportunistically forgetting how John Paul II had been a critic of the Iraq war and occupation.

Many commentators, however, concentrate on the role played by the Catholic hierarchy in general, and John Paul II in particular, in the events around Solidarity in the early 1980’s in Poland and the fall of Stalinist regimes in Eastern Europe between 1989 and 1991.

Commentator Timothy Garton Ash (Guardian April 4 2005) goes overboard, making it sound as if the Pope single-handedly brought down the iron curtain: "without the Polish Pope, no Solidarity revolution in Poland in 1980, without Solidarity no dramatic change in Soviet policy towards Eastern Europe under Gorbachev, without that change, no velvet revolutions in 1989".

The reality is different. While the Polish Catholic establishment, together with the Pope, played an important role in steering the Polish uprising against the Stalinist bureaucracy in early 1980’s towards the restoration of capitalism they did not lay the basis for it. Indeed, for most of its post-war history, the Polish bishops had sought and found an accommodation, albeit an uneasy one, with the Stalinist bureaucracy.


Even when the then Polish Prime Minister Gen. Wojciech Jaruzelski declared Martial Law in Poland on the morning of 13 December 1981, the Solidarity leaders, together with the leaders of the Catholic Church, tried to seek an accommodation with the ‘liberal’ wing of the Stalinist bureaucracy, declaring a 90-day truce on strikes.

This approach of attempted conciliation in reality prolonged the rule of the Stalinist bureaucracy.

John Paul II’s demise is being used to rewrite the history of the collapse of the Stalinist regimes in Eastern and Central Europe. Workers’ risings in Poland and Hungary in 1956, in Czechoslovakia in 1968 or in Poland in 1970-1971 are completely ignored.

These political revolutions were a reaction to the mismanagement of the planned economy combined with police-state like repression by the Stalinist bureaucracy. Workers implicitly adopted the demand for genuine workers’ democracy.

The Szczecin shipyard workers in 1971 carried slogans like "Stalin for the bureaucrats, Lenin for the workers" or "Russia 1905 – Hungary and Poland 1956, Russia 1917 – Poland and the world 1971?"

Those like Timothy Garton Ash who only see politics as an exchange between powerful individuals, without understanding the crucial role played by social processes and the masses, fail to understand these political revolutions. They turn their back on the driving forces of history and are doomed to be mere parrots repeating the elitist view of history.


How would they explain the enormous contradiction in today’s Poland between the mass perception of John Paul II and Lech Walesa, leader of the Solidarity trade union and Polish president from 1990 until 1995?

These two figures are both most closely associated with the restoration of capitalism and still John Paul II is regarded as a saint while Lech Walesa is reviled as little better as the devil. When standing for the presidential election in 2000 Walesa received less than 1% of the vote; he received the blame for introducing rampant capitalism, aggravating poverty amongst the mass of the population whilst amassing personal wealth in the process.

The public perception of John Paul II is very contradictory. The mass media made him a household name across the world, including many countries in the neo-colonial world, which never had been reached by the leader of the Catholic Church before.

The extreme and desperate conditions, created by capitalism, that many people live in and the lack of an alternative means millions are extremely receptive to the Catholic teachings of compassion and the hope of a better life after death. The papal politics of John Paul II were, however, reactionary.


He became the representative of the most conservative currents of Catholicism and purged the leadership of the Latin American churches who supported the liberationists – a ‘radical’ theology combining Christianity with some elements of Marxism and Socialism.

John Paul II condemned the use of condoms as a "culture of death" though they might have saved millions of people in the neo-colonial world from an early death as a result of HIV/Aids infection.

He first ignored and then partly covered up the child sex abuse scandal in the Catholic Church in the United States. The Pope’s opposition to all contraception means that Catholic women have no rights over their own bodies and many, even within the Catholic hierarchy for example in Latin America, choose to turn a blind eye to the Church’s doctrine. He was vehemently opposed to the ordaining of women and forbade Catholics from discussing it further.

During his 26-year rule Pope John Paul II succeeded in strengthening the church apparatus, centralising decision-making in the corridors of the Vatican and controlling opposing currents inside the Catholic community.

It is ironic that the Pope whom many claim ‘won the cold war’ leaves the followers of the Catholic faith with a hierarchy that is closed, dogmatic, censorious and hierarchical, awash with myth and personality cults; much like the former Stalinist regimes in Eastern Europe and Russia.

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.

In The Socialist 14 April 2005:

MG Rover: The Ugly Face of Capitalism

Nationalise Rover now

No more asset-stripping, renationalise, don't subsidise

British economy - not really that healthy

Tesco - every two billion helps

Socialists' city-wide challenge

Anti-social behaviour orders (ASBOs) A socialist approach

New Labour's education failure

Liberal Democrats: Phoney radicals - no different to the rest

Socialist Students fight for a campaigning NUS

Three months after the tsunami, government inaction fuels the flame of protest

Pope John Paul II

Young members create new opportunities in Huddersfield


Home   |   The Socialist 14 April 2005   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate  

Related links:


triangleThe Socialist inbox

triangleLeeds Socialist Party: Political turmoil in Poland

triangleThe Socialist Inbox

triangleSlave labour at Sports Direct

triangleSocialist Party national women's meeting


triangleThe fight against racial discrimination is tied to fighting against capitalist austerity

triangleLiverpool Socialist Party: Solidarity with Catalonia

triangleSolidarity with Catalonia - the people have the right to decide


triangleLessons from the Russian revolution for LGBT+ struggle today

triangleBlairite warmonger misses chance to fight on Corbyn's popular policies


triangleTower Hamlets Socialist Party: "You can't have capitalism without racism" (Malcolm X)





Catalonia: Workers can finish what Puigdemont won't



Solidarity with Catalonia - the people have the right to decide



Eyewitness: Irish socialist MP participates in events



Exemplary resistance by the people of Catalonia



Germany: Election results in political earthquake



Strike against Madrid's 'state of emergency'!



German elections: rise of the far right and right-wing government will provoke resistance



French Labour reform protests



Catalonia: Student strike called



Brutal repression of Rohingya people sparks massive humanitarian crisis



Solidarity with Catalonia in the Spanish state



Berlin hospital strike



Korean peninsula: is nuclear war likely?



Interview with leader of students' union in the Spanish state: "When we fight, we win!"



Hurricane Harvey: A tragedy made far worse by capitalism

triangleMore International articles...

Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party

triangle13 Oct The end of the Tories?

triangle11 Oct Nasty party out the Tories

triangle11 Oct CWU fights court attempt to stop national strike

triangle11 Oct The fight against racial discrimination is tied to fighting against...

triangle11 Oct Catalonia: Workers can finish what Puigdemont won't

triangle6 Oct Boeing bust-up threatens thousands of skilled jobs

triangle4 Oct The nasty party turns on itself... but the Tories must be driven out

More ...

triangle16 Oct Teesside Socialist Party: After the party conferences

triangle17 Oct London: TUC lobby & rally; and London march

triangle18 Oct Warrington & St Helens Socialist Party: 1917-2017; the October Russian Revolution

triangle18 Oct Hackney Socialist Party: 100 years ago - the Bolshevik-led revolution

More ...

Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube



October 2017

September 2017

August 2017

July 2017

June 2017

May 2017

April 2017

March 2017

February 2017

January 2017





















Platform setting: = No platform choice