Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page:

From The Socialist newspaper, 8 December 2005

Domestic violence: Change in sentencing guidelines a step forward

The government has finally issued new guidelines to judges and courts on sentencing for manslaughter. The guidelines should lead to better and more consistent judgements of when murder can be commuted to manslaughter and remove the worst anomalies in the previous system.

Eleanor Donne, National chair, Campaign Against Domestic Violence (CADV)

This follows the Law Commission's review of Defences to Murder, which made particular reference to domestic violence. This was both in terms of the large numbers of women killed by their partners (two per week on average) and how the law treats women who have killed their partners, having suffered in many cases years of abuse from them.

The new guidelines don't change the law (1957 Homicide Act) but effectively define what courts should (and shouldn't) take into account to reduce a charge from murder to manslaughter and to decide the length of sentence for manslaughter.

For the first time, previous experience of abuse and/or domestic violence is outlined specifically as a mitigating factor and the guidelines make it clear that evidence of infidelity should not be seen as a high provocation.

Traditionally, sentences for (mostly) men who kill out of jealous rage have been light, but under new sentencing guidelines the experience of violence or fear of violence is more of a defence than anger or sexual jealousy alone. This is to be welcomed but it remains to be seen how well the rules are implemented by judges. Funding should be made available to train judges, barristers and all court staff on issues relating to domestic violence.

The Campaign Against Domestic Violence (CADV), formed by Socialist Party members (then known as Militant Labour) in 1991, has long called for changes in the law on manslaughter/defences to murder and welcomes these guidelines as a step forward.

Unequal treatment

The catalyst for our wider campaign on domestic violence was the unequal treatment of two people who had killed their partners. One, Joseph McGrail, walked free from court, having successfully used the defence that his wife had 'nagged' him and he had 'snapped'. The other, Sarah Thornton, suffered violence and abuse throughout her marriage but lost her appeal against a life sentence for murder. She was eventually released after a widespread campaign, proving that even judges are not immune from changing social attitudes.

It is rare for a woman to kill her partner, but of the small numbers that do, the majority have suffered longstanding and often extreme violence at the hands of that partner. Yet, the laws on self-defence and provocation (to reduce a charge from murder to manslaughter) have been woefully inadequate for women in this position. They are based historically on men's general behaviour and conditioning, requiring you to show sudden anger, temporary loss of control and the use of 'reasonable force'.

This has made it very difficult for even the most well-meaning lawyers to build a case for a woman who may have acted after the 'heat of the moment' because she was physically smaller, not conditioned to fight back or terrified rather than angry. Women often had to rely on a plea of 'diminished responsibility', placing all the emphasis on their personality and mental state.

We would hope that the new guidelines make it easier for a woman to argue that she acted in self-defence or under provocation, which implies some acceptance from society for her actions.

Little protection

In spite of campaigning and lobbying by ourselves and by other groups, as well as many in the legal profession, the government have been very reluctant to address these archaic laws. Sadly, although some women have been released after appeal or re-trial many more will have been given life sentences in the time it has taken for the Home Office to issue these new guidelines. We are calling on the government to carry out a thorough review of all murder cases where domestic violence has been a factor.

Killing your violent partner is obviously a desperate act and one which a very small number of women take if they feel there is absolutely no alternative. Statistically a woman will be hit around 35 times before she goes to the police and is even more at risk of violence and being killed after she has left her partner. Many feel justifiably that the police and the courts do not offer them proper protection.

Changing laws is important but it is just as vital to campaign to ensure that practical and legal solutions are not just there on paper but in reality. Resources are necessary, such as outreach advice centres, more refuges and safe houses, training for police and the courts, affordable housing and decent wages and benefits so that women do not face a 'choice' of living in fear of violence or poverty and social exclusion.

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.

In The Socialist 8 December 2005:

Save our NHS!

Strike back at Labour's attacks

Is there a pensions crisis?

Sign up to the campaign

Brown's low growth, low wage budget

Domestic violence: Change in sentencing guidelines a step forward

George Best

Tories elect 'Blair-lite' leader

Now working class and poor must build real socialism

Brazil: Growing crisis over Lula government's corruption scandal

Solidarity with Irish Ferries workers

Victory for Andy Beadle as he wins his job back

Sixth week of caretakers' strike

PCS Left Unity conference backs union leadership on pensions


Home   |   The Socialist 8 December 2005   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate  

Related links:

Domestic violence:

triangleNottingham 'Reclaim the Night' march highlights cuts

triangleLeeds Socialist Students marks 'International Safe Abortion Day'

triangleCampaigners fight second Yorkshire Women's Aid closure in two years

triangleVital women's services under threat

triangleDerby Socialist Party: Domestic violence - What are the causes?


triangleFighting sexism, violence and capitalism - an international struggle

triangleSocialist Party national women's meeting

triangleCaerphilly Socialist Party: Women and Revolution

triangleTV review: Abortion on Trial - hard-hitting look at impact of 1967 act


triangleIrish capitalist state: rotten to the core

triangleOrgreave campaigners' Halloween 'Death of Justice' march

triangleThe "club no-one wants to be part of" - march by families of those killed in police custody


triangleTwo in five 'right to buy' homes now for let

triangleWaltham Forest Universal Credit protest

Reports and campaigns

Reports and campaigns


Waltham Forest

Stop the rotten redevelopment plan, demand residents



Six months on - still no justice for Grenfell



Movement growing against fracking giant Ineos



Totnes MP uses coffin controversy to distract from brutal NHS cuts



Tory plan to hold dinner at coal mining museum defeated



Bradford campaign to save children's services launched


South London

South London health bosses' cover-up



Unite day of action against blacklisting



Brighton victory



Newham anti-academies strikes


Tamil Solidarity

Tamil Solidarity and Refugee Rights activists meeting



Support the Crossrail Woolwich walkout



Unite protest against blacklisting



Anti-DOO lobby of Liverpool's transport committee


Donald Trump

Mobilise to stop bigoted billionaire Donald Trump's state visit to Britain

triangleMore Reports and campaigns articles...

Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party

triangle14 Dec Stop the rotten redevelopment plan, demand residents

triangle13 Dec Six months on - still no justice for Grenfell

triangle13 Dec Movement growing against fracking giant Ineos

triangle13 Dec Totnes MP uses coffin controversy to distract from brutal NHS cuts

triangle13 Dec Trump's incendiary Jerusalem statement reignites Israeli-Palestinian...

triangle13 Dec Labour 'purge' furore really just democracy

EU parliament, Strasbourg

triangle13 Dec Brexit deal no solution to Tory rifts

More ...

triangle18 Dec Leeds Socialist Party: Religion and Socialism

triangle19 Dec Bristol North Socialist Party: Christmas social

triangle21 Dec Wakefield Socialist Party: Socialists and the National Question

triangle6 Jan Socialist Party national women's meeting

More ...

Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube



December 2017

November 2017

October 2017

September 2017

August 2017

July 2017

June 2017

May 2017

April 2017

March 2017

February 2017

January 2017





















Platform setting: = No platform choice