Link to this page: http://www.socialistparty.org.uk/issue/356/5877

From The Socialist newspaper, 17 July 2004

Review

Why Fahrenheit 9/11 Makes Bush Fume

IT'S NOT surprising that Michael Moore's documentary Fahrenheit 9/11 is storming the US. The film's release coincides with Americans' growing anger at George Bush and his right-wing regime.

Dave Carr

In particular, Bush's lies and deceptions over the war and occupation of Iraq are creating a political backlash. In one scene from the film an elderly resident of Moore's hometown of Flint, Michigan, fumes about the Haliburton corporation (formerly run by Vice-President Dick Cheney) securing another profitable contract from the Iraq 'reconstruction' budget, and about the failure to find the 'weapons of mass destruction'. "We've all been duped!", she says in disgust.

The film shows how Bush cheated Al Gore to take the presidency in 2000, with the Democrats meekly accepting this electoral fraud. Installed in office, the film hilariously portrays a dysfunctional president responding to his falling popularity by spending more and more time on vacation.

Then, the twin towers are felled by passenger aircraft hijacked by suicidal al-Qa'ida operatives. Moore's film here retreads much of the ground covered in his book Dude, where's my country? He shows a president politically paralysed when told of the attack. (Bush ignored prior intelligence predicting such an event.)

Immediately after 9/11, when all commercial aircraft were supposedly grounded, high-ranking Saudi Arabians (the nationality of most of the hijackers) - including Osama bin Laden's extended family - jetted out the country. Moore suggests that Bush was keen to get them out of the way in case intimate financial connections between the Bush family, the bin Laden's, and the Saudi ruling dictatorship were revealed.

'War on terror'

But every cloud has a silver lining and for Bush and his neo-conservative White House buddies, the 9/11 outrage let them unleash their full political agenda on a stunned America under the guise of fighting a 'war on terror'.

This included the anti-democratic Patriot Act and its 'homeland security' provisions, passed unanimously by Congress. Moore asks a Democrat representative why they passed the act without reading its contents. The Congressman replies that bills aren't read beforehand - such scrutiny would paralyse government!

Assisted by the right-wing media, Bush concocted a spurious connection between al-Qa'ida and Saddam Hussein, and claimed the regime in Iraq was threatening the West with weapons of mass destruction.

Turning to the bloody war in Iraq we're shown interviews with gung-ho US soldiers and their top brass. But later, as the insurgency against the US-led occupation grows and the casualties mount, the soldiers interviewed are mostly scared and simply want out. Several are contemptuous of their political masters' lack of understanding about the occupation. One openly calls for defence secretary Donald Rumsfeld's resignation.

Economic conscription

The film shows how the most oppressed sections of the US population - economic conscripts desperate to escape from their poverty and lack of opportunities - end up in the armed forces. These people do the fighting and the dying, for the ruling class.

In one scene Moore follows two US marine sergeants as they tour the poorest districts of Flint, enticing the unemployed to sign up for a spurious 'better life'.

But perhaps Fahrenheit 9/11's most poignant scenes are the interviews with Lila Lipscombe, the mother of a serving Black Hawk helicopter crewman. She's the archetypal 'middle American' - a practising Christian who proudly raises the stars and stripes each day. But her patriotism is shattered by her son's subsequent death in Iraq.

At a family gathering she tearfully reads out his last letter, which accuses Bush of lies and deception and questions why he's in Iraq. I defy anyone to be unmoved by this scene.

Moore delivers his coup de grace by contrasting the losers in this war on terror with the winners. Cameras pan around a trade conference, where corporate fat cats are salivating over the huge profits to be made from exploiting Iraq's oil reserves and from the multi-billion dollar budget for Iraq's 'reconstruction'. One even says, without embarrassment, that "war is good for business".

Moore shows the US ruling class waging wars in order to maintain the established social order. No wonder the right-wing on both sides of the Atlantic are fuming at this film.

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.


In The Socialist 17 July 2004:

Strike Against Jobs Carnage

Brown's Jobs Cull - Unions Must Strike Back

An Attack On The Whole Public Sector

Public spending review: Robbing Penny To Pay Paula


International socialist news

Lies, Lies, Lies

Iraq War: The Guilty Men

Why Fahrenheit 9/11 Makes Bush Fume


Socialist Party campaigns

Fight Blair's Privatised Academies

Tolpuddle: Fight The Anti-Trade Union Laws

Heading For A Split

The Socialist Party And The United Left

"Low Pay No Way, Council Workers Here To Stay"


International socialist news and analysis

'Offensief Against Racism' Success

Sri Lankan Socialists' Elections Boost


 

Facebook   Twitter



Home   |   The Socialist 17 July 2004   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate   |   Bookshop






Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter



Related links:

Iraq:

triangleGulf War 'unfinished business' remains today

triangleHuman tragedy of Calais crisis

triangleTurkey: only workers' unity can end terrorism, division and war

triangleMigrants flee horrors created by capitalism

triangleTen years since the London 7/7 bombings

War:

triangleHiroshima - 70 years on

triangle2005: Jean Charles de Menezes shooting

triangleTerrorist attacks: working class people pay the price

triangle1945 - when Britain said no to Churchill

US:

triangleSubscribe to the Socialist!

triangleThem & Us

triangleUS: Kshama Sawant leads Seattle primary elections count on 50%

Occupation:

triangle9,000 tuition fees legacy - debt and slave labour

triangleStudent occupation of Birmingham library

Michael Moore:

triangleKshama Sawant's response to Obama speech

International

International

28/8/15

Syriza

Greece: New Left force launched following Syriza's betrayal

25/8/15

China

Article on China crisis

19/8/15

US

US: Kshama Sawant leads Seattle primary elections count on 50%

19/8/15

Ireland

Ireland: drop the prosecutions, scrap the water charges

19/8/15

Greece

Greece: Building a new left alternative after Syriza capitulation

5/8/15

China

China at a turning point

5/8/15

Seattle

Kshama gets 49.9% in Seattle primary vote

29/7/15

Europe

Turmoil in Greece will be repeated across Europe

29/7/15

Turkey

Turkey: only workers' unity can end terrorism, division and war

15/7/15

Greece

EU revenge against Greek workers

15/7/15

CWI

International news in brief

15/7/15

South Africa

The Marikana report - a whitewash

11/7/15

Greece

Greece: Tsipras crosses the Rubicon

7/7/15

Greece

Greece: Mighty class-based 'NO' shakes bosses' EU

1/7/15

Terrorism

Terrorist attacks: working class people pay the price

triangleMore International articles...

triangle1 Sep Strike action gets results!

triangle1 Sep Indesit strikers determined to press on for acceptable deal

triangle1 Sep Aspire Housing workers striking to defend pay and conditions

triangle30 Aug Rail and PCS strikers rally together

triangle28 Aug Greece: New Left force launched following Syriza's betrayal

triangle28 Aug Socialist councillor aids anti-gas storage campaign

triangle28 Aug 'Unapologetic attack on austerity' at Corbyn rally

More ...

triangle1 Sep Bristol Socialist Party: Fighting the anti-trade union laws

triangle2 Sep Salford Socialist Party: How did early humans live?

triangle2 Sep Hackney & Islington Socialist Party: Art and revolution

triangle3 Sep York Socialist Party: Attracting youth to socialist ideas

More ...

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube

Find us on Facebook

Archive

Categories

1-9 

1-9 


Archives:

September 2015

August 2015

July 2015

June 2015

May 2015

April 2015

March 2015

February 2015

January 2015

2014

2013

2012

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

Legal

SP RSS feed RSS

Platform setting: = No platform choice