Link to this page:

From The Socialist newspaper, 11 February 2009

Carbon trading: Crisis creates bonanza for polluting firms

THE HOPE of the bureaucrats who devised a European carbon permit trading system to tackle global warming was that polluting firms would have to pay for their anti-social actions, so letting 'market forces' encourage green behaviour. However, due to the crazy market system, it is now clear that the worst environmental culprits, far from being made to pay up, are actually being paid by us to continue polluting.

Pete Dickenson

The permit trading system operates by issuing companies with a quota of permits to emit carbon dioxide, the gas that is mainly causing global warming. If firms need to emit more they must buy permits from other companies, so encouraging them in theory to invest in renewable energy.

According to Paul Newman of the brokerage Inchcape, the price of the permits must be between 35-45 to have any chance of success but it has never reached this level. In fact, governments issued so many permits for the first three years of the scheme they were virtually free, so undermining the whole claimed logic of the system.

To try to rectify this, the permit system was revamped in 2008 to push the price up, which resulted in it rising to 30 last summer, but this proved to be only temporary and it quickly collapsed to 11. This fall partly caused the nosedive in investment in green technology that coincided with the economic crisis that began last autumn.

The reason for the current low price is perverse but entirely 'rational' from a capitalist point of view. The price of permits fell because a large number of them came onto the market late last year, so forcing down the cost. This was a direct result of the fall in production due to the economic crisis. It meant greenhouse gas emissions by the main polluting industries also fell, allowing firms to sell unwanted permits (see the Global Warning column in Socialism Today, December/January 2008/09 for more background).

The fall in the price of oil, due to the economic crisis, reduced the market incentive for firms to make green investments, but perversely the price of carbon permits fell at the same time, reinforcing this effect, at a time when, according to market logic, the price needed to go up to encourage green behaviour.

The main industries that appear to be selling permits are cement and steel who are some of the biggest polluters and where output is expected to drop by 20% and 15% respectively this year.

Highly profitable

A study commissioned by the WWF environmental pressure group, found that British companies such as these could make 15 billion from selling unwanted permits, a figure that was calculated before the current downturn and so will be far higher now.

The scandal is that most firms cashing in on this did not pay for the permits in the first place, they got them for free, or virtually for free, due to government policy.

The money they will get is therefore largely clear profit, a reward for continuing to emit huge quantities of greenhouse gases, making a complete mockery of the 'make the polluter pay' market mantra.

To make matters worse, the power-generating companies are buying these unwanted permits and passing on the cost to us, their customers according to The Guardian (28 January).

It is not due to mistakes or teething problems that the permit trading system has been a fiasco.

Its failure is rooted in the structure of capitalism: a system where it is impossible to reconcile the needs of the corporations to maximise their profits and therefore to minimise what they pay for carbon permits, and the imperative to take decisive measures to stop global warming.

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.

In The Socialist 11 February 2009:

Bankers' bonuses - daylight robbery!

Vendetta continues against socialist fighter

JCB owner - still shovelling in the cash

Construction workers

Lindsey oil refinery strike: Workers score important victory

Construction workers' battle to defend jobs and conditions

Welcome to the JIB!

Motherwell Bridge bosses declare war on striking workers

Stop GSK job cuts

Socialist Party youth and students

Defend youth services

College students - keen to fight back

Save Charlotte Turner school!

Socialist Party campaigns

Tyneside Metro: Workers' action to stop privatisation

Carbon trading crisis creates bonanza for polluting firms

Exeter: Mobilising to stop the far right

Fast news

Car workers

Fight for jobs at Ford

Car industry in crisis - national meeting

Socialist Party workplace news

Wirral cuts: We need a new party

Victory for Salford Unison

Defend jobs at Salford University

Usdaw presidential election

Protest against the Unison witch-hunt

Greenwich council: An injury to one is an injury to all

International socialist news and analysis

Nationalise Waterford Crystal!

United Socialist Party members remanded on trumped-up charges

Socialist Party review

Slumdog Millionaire


Reclaim the game


Facebook   Twitter

Home   |   The Socialist 11 February 2009   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate   |   Bookshop

Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Related links:


triangleSocialist change to remedy climate change

triangleTories and Labour refuse moratorium on fracking

triangleClimate change: Socialism and global planning essential

triangleFloods: fully-funded environmental planning needed

triangleDebate on the environment


triangleChina crisis: What will this mean for the world economy?

triangleProfiteering housing firm ignores angry residents

triangleFiddling finance capital in the dock


triangleGive us the resources to defeat the Tories

triangleWorkplace news in brief


triangleArticle on China crisis

Global warming:

triangleBeyond the Pale - capitalism and the environment

Reports and campaigns

Reports and campaigns



Come to Socialism 2015


The Socialist

Subscribe to a paper by workers, for workers


Socialist Party

Give us the resources to defeat the Tories


Socialist Party

Why you should join the socialists



Kazakhstan: workers solidarity action


Fire service

Anger and protest against fire service cuts in Leicestershire



Campaign Kazakhstan protest: Kaz Minerals



Labour cuts school crossings


Waltham Forest

Tower block residents defend homes


Mental health

Notts NHS trust closing more mental health units



TUC debates action to defeat anti-trade union bill


Socialist Students

Organise the student fightback!



Workplace news in brief



Traffic wardens strike for better pay



London protesters demand affordable housing

triangleMore Reports and campaigns articles...

triangle30 Sep EU ministers squabble while refugees drown

triangle30 Sep Socialism is back!

triangle30 Sep Junior doctors fight government attacks

triangle30 Sep How can we bring down the Tories?

Protesting against school crossing cuts by Derbyshire County Council, photo E Evans

triangle29 Sep Labour cuts school crossings

triangle28 Sep TUSC: Central in the battle for a working class anti-austerity voice

triangle23 Sep Greece: Widespread abstention in election

More ...

triangle4 Oct TUC demonstration against the government's austerity agenda

triangle5 Oct Wirral Socialist Party: History of the Socialist Party

triangle5 Oct Chesterfield Socialist Party: When Liverpool council defeated a Tory government

triangle5 Oct Birmingham Central Socialist Party: Class struggle, feminism and socialism

More ...

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube

Find us on Facebook






October 2015

September 2015

August 2015

July 2015

June 2015

May 2015

April 2015

March 2015

February 2015

January 2015



















Platform setting: = No platform choice