Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page: http://www.socialistparty.org.uk/issue/159/7821

From The Socialist newspaper, 26 May 2000

Review

Lenin's lasting legacy

Lenin: A biography by Robert Service. Published by Macmillan, and reviewed by MARK WAINWRIGHT

I HALF expected this new biography about Lenin to be in the new tradition, such as in the critical and unbiased manner of Francis Wheen's superb work on Karl Marx. Well everyone makes a mistake occasionally!

What is good about the book is that Service uses access to newly released documents in Moscow to confirm Lenin's last campaign fought from his deathbed was for the removal of Stalin as the general secretary of the Party. As a consequence Service admits that the Bolsheviks led by Lenin had not set out to establish a dictatorship, which later followed under Stalin.

Service also asks: "Is Lenin really done for?... [because] when surveys of Russian public opinion are undertaken he measures among the most popular rulers in history".

You could safely say the book lacks balance. It is full of quotes like "he (Lenin) displayed a virtual lust for violence" or "he was a cheerful repressor", or "his indifference to the scale of common suffering was colossal".

The very last paragraph concludes: "Lenin was unexpected. At the very least his extraordinary life proves the need for everyone to be vigilant. Not many historical personages have achieved this effect. Let thanks be given".

His lack of balance is illustrated in a number of respects. As the example below show this undermines his claim to an 'objective' historian's approach. Or could it be he shows a certain inclination to believe things without actually checking it? I lean to the second explanation.

For example he says: "(Lenin) would not even condone the formation of famine relief bodies in order to use them for the spreading of revolutionary propaganda".

Yet if you read the collection of writings, Lenin on Britain, at the beginning you will find two letters to the then Labour leader Ramsay Macdonald from Lenin thanking him for the donations to the Famine Relief Committee!

Another example was over the military offensive by Kerensky's provisional government in June 1917, during the First World War. Service writes: "After initial success the Russian forces were held up by a spirited defence".

That's it. What he omits is that 58,000 Russian troops killed were during this offensive and that the mass armed uprisings in Russia known as the July Days developed as a result. Neither does he mention that the Bolsheviks led by Lenin - a party Service implies was purely determined on seizure of power -actually held these movements back. The Bolsheviks waited until they had won a majority of the working class and poorest peasants before assuming power in October 1917.

More seriously, Service claims that Trotsky personally supervised the suppression of the Kronstadt rebellion in 1920. Trotsky certainly was in favour of ending the revolt but he didn't supervise it at all; he was not there.

Service says that people "tend to overlook the fragility of the regime, chaos and confusion was the norm". He makes the nearly comical point that Lenin's car was stopped on at least three occasions by armed youth in Moscow in 1918/1919; in fact he was nearly killed by Red Guards who refused to believe it was him.

The distinction is important because you need to be reminded that the regime was holding on for dear life. In the very harsh conditions of civil war and no political reinforcements from successful revolution abroad, the regime survived and consolidated itself, albeit on a grotesquely deformed basis, that lasted for almost three-quarters of a century.

Maybe what irritates Robert Service most is that despite the crimes and repression of the Stalinist bureaucracy, that went on to rule in Lenin's name but which violated every Marxist principle Lenin had stood for, he still cannot explain the long-standing and inspirational effect of Lenin and his ideas.

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.


In The Socialist 26 May 2000:

Students occupy to stop expulsions: Fight the fees

The Battle against Right wing bigotry

Is this the nuclear industry's dying days?

Lenin's lasting legacy

Movement grows of workers and students in Brazil


 

Home   |   The Socialist 26 May 2000   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate  




Related links:

Lenin:

triangleWell-deserved ridicule of Stalinism is impressive, funny but flawed

triangleOctober 1917 reviews: 'More bright than any heaven'

triangleRussia, October 1917: When workers took power

triangleMarx's Capital at 150: an unequalled analysis and critique of capitalism

triangleRussia 1917: how art helped make the revolution

Russian:

triangleSpain: Madrid rally celebrates October revolution

triangleBrum meeting celebrates centenary of 1917

triangleBirmingham Socialist Party: Commemorating the 1917 Russian Revolution

triangleGoldsmiths Socialist Students Society: Russian 1917 - When workers took power

Bolsheviks:

triangleCan you donate to the Socialism 2017 appeal?

triangleTrotsky's "insightful and frank examination" of revolution out soon

triangleChesterfield Socialist Party: The Bolsheviks take power

Relief:

triangleYoung people being strangled by debts

triangleHurricane Harvey: A tragedy made far worse by capitalism

Reviews and comments

Reviews and comments

13/12/17

The Socialist

The Socialist's 2017 quiz

6/12/17

Fire

The Socialist Inbox

6/12/17

Surrey

Comment: Socialism and truth about Zane

6/12/17

Labour Party

Blairite horror and Labour's divisions graphically exposed

30/11/17

Theatre

Dramatic retelling of Grunwick strike

22/11/17

Working class

Left comic's take on politics will have you in tears

22/11/17

Letters

The Socialist inbox

15/11/17

The Socialist

The Socialist Inbox

15/11/17

Abortion

TV review: Abortion on Trial - hard-hitting look at impact of 1967 act

15/11/17

Vietnam war

Comprehensive account of bloody conflict

8/11/17

Letters

The Socialist inbox

8/11/17

Obituary

Obituary: Paul Randall, 1959-2017

8/11/17

Theatre

Welsh update of Chekhov an engrossing tale of 1980s class conflict

1/11/17

Letters

The Socialist inbox

25/10/17

Letters

The Socialist inbox

triangleMore Reviews and comments articles...


Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party

triangle13 Dec Support the Crossrail Woolwich walkout

triangle8 Dec Local government pay: fight for the 5% claim, fully funded

triangle6 Dec Strikers rally in Liverpool

triangle6 Dec Corbyn's Labour can defeat Tories with socialist programme

triangle5 Dec Victory at Glenfield shows people power can save our NHS

triangle5 Dec Labour council Blairites deselected

triangle30 Nov Victory: Glenfield Children's Heart Centre saved!

More ...

triangle13 Dec Caerphilly Socialist Party: Are we heading for an era of war?

triangle14 Dec Wakefield Socialist Party: Universal Credit - the Tories' latest assault on the poor

triangle18 Dec Leeds Socialist Party: Religion and Socialism

triangle19 Dec Bristol North Socialist Party: Christmas social

More ...

Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube

Archive

Archives:

December 2017

November 2017

October 2017

September 2017

August 2017

July 2017

June 2017

May 2017

April 2017

March 2017

February 2017

January 2017

2016

2015

2014

2013

2012

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

Legal

SP RSS feed RSS

Platform setting: = No platform choice

V2