Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page:

From The Socialist newspaper, 18 November 2009

Service with a snarl: Academic refuses to answer questions

HISTORIAN ROBERT Service recently wrote a well-publicised and widely distributed book Trotsky - a biography. In The Socialist issue 597, Peter Taaffe, Socialist Party general secretary, reviewed this book, criticising its falsehoods, distortions and attempted character assassination of Leon Trotsky.
When the Socialist Party invited Service to debate his ideas at Socialism 2009 and when the RIA Novosti news agency organised a meeting on Marxism and the relevance of Trotsky in Moscow that included Peter Taaffe and others, Service refused both offers.
Recently Professor Service spoke at a public meeting in south London. PAULA MITCHELL and other Socialist Party members went to the meeting. Paula explains what happened. ROBERT SERVICE obviously likes an audience that likes him. At Southbank Centre on 11 November he got that, when around 100 fans gathered to hear him and Tristram Hunt, author of Engels: the frock-coated communist, discuss their work.

Untroubled by working class people and - he hoped - socialists, Service and the audience settled in for a good chortle at the expense of people with the temerity to dedicate their lives to fighting for a better world.

Tristram Hunt's work on Engels is fairly sympathetic and though he is not a socialist, he gave a warm, honest account. Robert Service, and the event's chair however, were set on diminishing, mocking and downright attacking Trotsky and Trotskyists from the start.

Service was introduced as having written biographies previously on Lenin and Stalin. The chair's first question, spoken with relish, was, "Robert Service, you seem to specialise in biographing bastards. Was Trotsky therefore a natural choice?"

Service replied, 'A lot of people thought that Soviet Russia would have been different if Trotsky was in charge. I expected he would overlap with Stalin but I didn't expect him to be so unappealing as a human being. He was an unexpected bastard... I wanted to bring down the edifice... His ideas and practices in power were an anachrony to decent values.'

'Some worthy qualities'

So instantly, Lenin, Trotsky and Stalin were lumped together in the typical method of capitalist ideologues. No matter that Trotsky spent nearly twenty years fighting Stalinism and that Stalin wiped out Trotsky and his supporters in an orgy of suppression, falsification and blood, trying to blot out their ideas and methods from history.

Service repeated some of his book's false assertions. For example, before 1914 Trotsky was apparently "at best a war reporter"! What about being the chair of the Petrograd Soviet in the 1905 revolution?

He conceded that Trotsky had some worthy qualities. He was a fantastic writer, a wonderful public speaker and crucial in that regard to the revolution. But 'he was a lousy tactician and had no sensible instincts about how he could achieve power... The only politics he could get on with were the politics of telling people what to do... He didn't win power because he hadn't a clue how to go about it... Trotsky couldn't handle a bag of oranges.'

These assertions made the audience titter, but bear no relation to reality. This is one of the more disappointing aspects of Service's talk - he is a professor of history, yet appears to have little grasp of real processes, or material and social circumstances. It was all unsubstantiated assertion about personal qualities, as if history is just made by individual personalities.

The fact that the Russian revolution took place in an economically underdeveloped country wracked by World War One and was followed by a three-year civil war when 21 armies from imperialist countries invaded to try to overthrow the revolution, and was then left isolated by the failure of the other revolutionary movements which swept across Europe - these facts, which created the circumstances where a bureaucracy could arise, were all absent from this discussion.

For Trotsky it was not a question of having to "take power" after the 1917 revolution, but of waging a battle first to put in place measures that would restrict the development of a bureaucracy, and then a battle of living forces, against the bureaucracy in the interests of the working class.

Service did say that one thing he admired about Trotsky was that he was always honest. But Service obviously doesn't mind a few untruths himself. At one point he declared, "People who call themselves Trotskyists call themselves democrats - but Trotsky wasn't a democrat, he supported the dictatorship of the proletariat, he wrote a pamphlet called 'terrorism and communism'."

He failed to mention (though several people in the audience reminded him) that the 'terrorism and communism' pamphlet was written against terrorism. Service must know that since he claims to have read it.

He must also know that 'dictatorship of the proletariat' means rule of the majority in society as opposed to rule of an exploiting minority. Because this term can be misunderstood, socialists today prefer to use the term 'workers' state' to mean the same thing.

In fact, the period of the 'dictatorship of the proletariat' in Russia was the most democratic society there has ever been, with committees at all levels of society, with votes for working class men and women for the first time in the world, with rights for national minorities and so on. This man is a professor of Russian history, he must know the facts, he just prefers to ignore them.


When the floor was opened up for questions, the first question was: "Have there been any Marxist reviews of your books?" Service instantly, gleefully, launched an attack on the Socialist Party.

"There has been a review by an organisation that used to be known as the Militant - do you remember it? ... Peter Taaffe ....they even invited me to debate at one of their conferences [whoops of hilarity from the audience - what a ridiculous idea! - PM] but you can't give these people oxygen."

Unfortunately for Service, a couple of "these people" were in the audience. Tom Baldwin got up to explain that he was the person who had invited Mr Service to debate ("Oh you are a real person then?") and asked why he was not prepared to debate - not just at our event, but with any Trotskyist anywhere.

Before Tom could finish his question he met a tirade from Service about how 'there's no point, I've done it before, these people don't want the drip, drip of reality, they say they want to debate but give you ten minutes and then start booing, it's really just a stitch-up.'


I said he had just read a bit from his book about how Stalin had hunted down Trotsky to wipe out him and his ideas, and yet he himself had just said that Trotskyists shouldn't be given oxygen - isn't that the same thing? If he doesn't want to debate in a socialist event, OK, but why has he refused to debate in Moscow, in front of an open audience, alongside other academics and even a priest?

But neither most of the audience nor Service himself would have heard this question, because as soon as I opened my mouth both he and the chair talked over me. The chair loudly repeated: "Just a question, what's your question, do you have a question". When I said yes and tried to repeat it I was told: "That's the wrong question!"

And they call us undemocratic! If Service had come to debate at Socialism 09, he would have been given at least 20 minutes to put his case. Anyone in the audience, including opponents of ours, would have been given five minutes each to speak, and then he would have had time to reply to any points made. This apparently would have been a stitch-up.

But depriving Trotskyists of oxygen, not allowing one sentence to be spoken without interruption, shouting over people, then telling them they're asking the wrong question - that's presumably the stuff of rational academic debate!

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.

In The Socialist 18 November 2009:

Fighting for a future

Youth march for jobs

Global Warming

More evidence of climate change: Socialist planning needed

Socialist Party news and analysis

British Airways merger plan poses new threat to workers

Tamil refugees in desperate situation

Labour pushes nuclear plants

Fast news

Socialist Party workplace news

Third week of Superdrug strike

Brighton bin workers score quick victory

Leeds council delays talks to end bin dispute

Sheffield First bus drivers beat back bullying management

Socialist Party feature

Interview with Mark Serwotka, PCS general secretary

Marxist analysis: history

USSR 1989 - the collapse of Stalinism

Socialist Party election analysis

Glasgow North East by-election: Mass abstentions in Labour's 'surprise win'

Far right SDL driven out of Glasgow city centre

Socialist Party Marxist analysis

Service with a snarl: Robert Service refuses to answer questions

Workplace news and analysis

Working life in a car factory

Ericsson closure condemned by Coventry socialist councillor

Save Ashford further education

London trade unionists meet to build workers' solidarity


Home   |   The Socialist 18 November 2009   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate  

Related links:


triangleSheffield South Socialist Party: Trotsky's theory of permanent revolution

triangleOctober 1917 reviews: 'More bright than any heaven'

triangleRussia, October 1917: When workers took power

triangleChe Guevara 50 years on - revolutionary socialist and fighter

triangleLessons of October new edition out now!


triangleBirmingham Central Socialist Party: The rise of Militant - lessons from our history

triangle110 years ago: massacre at Santa Maria school in Chile - commemorate 21 December 1907

triangleThe Socialist's 2017 quiz

triangleTwo in five 'right to buy' homes now for let

Socialist Party:

triangleStop the rotten redevelopment plan, demand residents

triangleUnite day of action against blacklisting

triangleLabour 'purge' furore really just democracy

Peter Taaffe:

triangleMass rally to commemorate 1917 Russian Revolution

triangleHow to help the struggle to change the Labour Party

The Socialist:

triangleCoventry Socialist sales hit 1,000

Socialism 2009:

triangleAbout Socialism


triangleA world in crisis, ripe for revolution


triangleCardiff East Socialist Party: Catalonia, Scotland and Wales


triangleCaerphilly Socialist Party: Women and Revolution


triangleWell-deserved ridicule of Stalinism is impressive, funny but flawed





Fighting the great tax robbery: taxes and regulation or socialist nationalisation?



Lenin's revolutionary legacy


Economic crisis

The Causes of Capitalist Crisis; Reply to Andrew Kliman



Book review: Karl Marx - How to change the world



1983: A political voice for the working class



Marx was right!



Leon Trotsky: A revolutionary's life



Lenin's April Theses, 1917



What's wrong with capitalism?



What has socialism got to do with fighting the cuts?


General strike

The general strike: Important tool of the working class



The legacy of Leon Trotsky



In defence of Leon Trotsky



Service with a snarl: Robert Service refuses to answer questions



Stalin's Nemesis: The Exile and Murder of Leon Trotsky

triangleMore Marxism articles...

Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party

triangle16 Dec Blairite council 'all ears' to rich property developers

triangle16 Dec Arriva bus drivers' action wins pay rise

triangle14 Dec Stop the rotten redevelopment plan, demand residents

triangle13 Dec Six months on - still no justice for Grenfell

triangle13 Dec Movement growing against fracking giant Ineos

triangle13 Dec Totnes MP uses coffin controversy to distract from brutal NHS cuts

triangle13 Dec Trump's incendiary Jerusalem statement reignites Israeli-Palestinian...

More ...

triangle18 Dec Leeds Socialist Party: Religion and Socialism

triangle19 Dec Bristol North Socialist Party: Christmas social

triangle21 Dec Wakefield Socialist Party: Socialists and the National Question

triangle6 Jan Socialist Party national women's meeting

More ...

Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube



December 2017

November 2017

October 2017

September 2017

August 2017

July 2017

June 2017

May 2017

April 2017

March 2017

February 2017

January 2017





















Platform setting: = No platform choice