Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page: http://www.socialistparty.org.uk/articles/8426

Posted on 27 November 2009 at 18:15 GMT

British Marxist debates Stalin and Trotsky

CWI represented in Moscow debate

Rob Jones, CWI, Russia

It's certainly the first time that the first speaker at a meeting in which the CWI participated was a Russian orthodox priest in full robe speaking through video link from St Petersburg. It's also the first time for eighty years that a leading Trotskyist has spoken on such an important platform in Moscow.

The occasion was a debate organised by the Russian state news agency RIA Novosti 's English language paper "Moscow News" to discuss "Stalin's legacy for Russia". Apart from "Archpriest" Georgy Mitrofanov, the conservative political commentator Yegor Kholmogorov, and Nikita Petrov, from the human rights organisation "Memorial" and Peter Taaffe, General Secretary of the Socialist Party of England and Wales (CWI), spoke. Another speaker, a leading spin doctor from the ruling party "United Russia" pulled out.

Archpriest Georgy is supposed to be on the "liberal" wing of the Russian church. He lost no time, however, in disputing the title of the debate. He said we should be discussing the crimes of "communism". Crudely lumping together all those who died from famine, hunger and war, he claimed that the revolution had cost the lives of millions. Ignoring the millions who had been slaughtered in the First World War, whose end was speeded up by the Russian Revolution, he painted a picture of an idyllic Russia that supposedly existed under the autocracy of Tzarism, a system in which, of course the church played a central role.

As two of the other speakers commented, it is a distortion of history to talk of twenty seven million being killed by Stalinism. Nevertheless, two to three million lost their lives in Stalin's horrific purges. Slave labour for camp inmates was introduced to help push forward the accelerated industrialisation of the 1930s. But apart from Peter Taaffe, none of the speakers gave a coherent explanation of why Stalinism arose. However, the apologists for Stalin in the discussion said nothing about the benefits of the planned economy or socialism, merely defending the dictator as a strong leader, defender of Russian interests and war leader.

After defending the rights, even of archpriests, to comment, Peter explained how the legacy of Stalinism has been used against those who argue for democratic socialism, to frighten the people of Britain, Europe and the world against socialism. Defending the gains of the October revolution, he talked of how the planned economy took Russia from being the India of Europe to the second industrial superpower in the world, but when the Stalinist bureaucracy developed, it became a barrier to the further development of the plan. "And as Trotsky predicted," Peter said, "the Soviet Union faced a choice with Stalinism, either a regeneration through the return to democracy as advocated by Marx, Engels, Lenin and Trotsky, or Russia would collapse because of the fall of productive forces, and that would lead to a return of capitalism".

He pointed out that the return to capitalism had been a disaster with a drop of nearly 50% in GDP in the 1990s. Now countries like Latvia are suffering from the world crisis, with half of its hospitals closing. "What we need today is to have a planned economy, not Stalinism but a democracy, a workers' democracy, with workers' control, the cut of the working day so the masses can be involved in the control of society" Peter continued.

A lively discussion followed among the youthful audience. Significantly a number of American exchange students were in the audience, having been radicalised by the current world crisis. One person's absence however was barely noticed. Professor Bob Service had turned down the invitation to participate for no other reason than he was afraid to debate with a representative of the CWI, even in Moscow.

We hope to post a video of Peter's speech in the next days

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.






Related links:

CWI:

triangleA world in crisis, ripe for revolution

triangleCaerphilly & RCT Socialist Party: The work of CWI members around the world

triangleZimbabwe: Mugabe gone - but his regime remains in power

triangleSweden: 'Revolution2017' success

triangleEditorial of the Socialist, issue 968

Trotsky:

triangleSheffield South Socialist Party: Trotsky's theory of permanent revolution

triangleOctober 1917 reviews: 'More bright than any heaven'

triangleRussia, October 1917: When workers took power

triangleChe Guevara 50 years on - revolutionary socialist and fighter

Stalin:

triangleWell-deserved ridicule of Stalinism is impressive, funny but flawed

triangleRussia 1917: how art helped make the revolution

triangleLessons from the Russian revolution for LGBT+ struggle today

Russia:

triangleWest London Socialist Party: Why we need a party

triangleWest London Socialist Party: 100 years since the October revolution in Russia

Stalinism:

triangleThe Socialist Inbox

Russian:

triangleSpain: Madrid rally celebrates October revolution

Marxist:

triangleCardiff West Socialist Party: How do Marxists analyse the world?

News and socialist analysis

News and socialist analysis

13/12/17

Labour

Labour 'purge' furore really just democracy

13/12/17

Brexit

Brexit deal no solution to Tory rifts

13/12/17

Housing

Two in five 'right to buy' homes now for let

13/12/17

NHS

Save our NHS

13/12/17

Them & Us

Them & Us

13/12/17

Fees

Uni market 'failure', two-year degrees - end cuts, scrap fees!

13/12/17

Retail

Retail sector crunch: nationalise to save jobs

8/12/17

Government

Local government pay: fight for the 5% claim, fully funded

6/12/17

Labour

Corbyn's Labour can defeat Tories with socialist programme

6/12/17

NHS

Branson sues NHS: kick out the profiteers

6/12/17

Immigration

Royal wedding exposes them-and-us visa system

6/12/17

Banks

RBS to sack 1,000: nationalise the banks

6/12/17

Homelessness

Rough sleeping crisis: make homes, not arrests

6/12/17

Poverty

End Tory war on poor

6/12/17

Rail

Nationalise rail now

triangleMore News and socialist analysis articles...


Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party

triangle14 Dec Stop the rotten redevelopment plan, demand residents

triangle13 Dec Six months on - still no justice for Grenfell

triangle13 Dec Movement growing against fracking giant Ineos

triangle13 Dec Totnes MP uses coffin controversy to distract from brutal NHS cuts

triangle13 Dec Trump's incendiary Jerusalem statement reignites Israeli-Palestinian...

triangle13 Dec Labour 'purge' furore really just democracy

EU parliament, Strasbourg

triangle13 Dec Brexit deal no solution to Tory rifts

More ...

triangle18 Dec Leeds Socialist Party: Religion and Socialism

triangle19 Dec Bristol North Socialist Party: Christmas social

triangle21 Dec Wakefield Socialist Party: Socialists and the National Question

triangle6 Jan Socialist Party national women's meeting

More ...

Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube

Archive

Archives:

December 2017

November 2017

October 2017

September 2017

August 2017

July 2017

June 2017

May 2017

April 2017

March 2017

February 2017

January 2017

2016

2015

2014

2013

2012

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

Legal

SP RSS feed RSS

Platform setting: = No platform choice

V2