Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page: http://www.socialistparty.org.uk/issue/201/8468

From The Socialist newspaper, 13 April 2001

Construction: British Industry's Killing Fields

IN THE year 1998-99 there were 66 workers' deaths in construction, 78 in 1999-2000 and this year there have been an average ten deaths per month. But the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) only prosecute in a tiny number of cases, with many of the fines imposed less than 1,000. Against this terrible background, The Socialist looks at the killing fields of Britain's construction industry.

FOUR PEOPLE died in the Hatfield train crash, paying the price for deregulation and privatisation. Building workers are dying through a similar hodge-podge of contractors and subcontractors. Big business sacrifices everything, including workers' lives, for profit.

Over the last 20 years the construction industry has changed. Large contractors now employ very few workers directly, they rely on a vast network of small sub-contractors.

In 1997, just over 136,000 building workers were employed by firms with less than 13 workers, whilst the largest firms only employed 44,500. Yet the big firms dominate the trade.

'Self-employment'

As well as a massive rise in sub-contracting, 'self-employed' workers account for about half the building workforce. Yet while the vast majority of these workers may be 'self-employed' under the tax system they are really part of the workforce without employment rights.

By this method, the contractors are able to avoid responsibility for national insurance, sick and holiday pay, redundancy pay etc.

This, in turn has had a big effect on training within the industry. Apprenticeships, for example, fell from nearly 9,000 in 1985 to 2,500 in 1994. This means there is a chronic shortage of skills, as well as direct safety training.

The confusion and communication breakdowns between the many different sub-contractors working together can mean unsafe working practices, exacerbated if incentive payments are used.

All these factors, combined with a low level of trade union organisation on many sites provide a lethal cocktail of risks for workers in the industry.

Safety reps

THE GOVERNMENT is the biggest client in the construction industry, responsible for 40% of all work. They could play a vital role in setting and insisting on safety standards, yet there are only 128 safety inspectors to cover over half a million sites in England, Scotland and Wales.

Regulations introduced by New Labour in 1999 have actually encouraged the use of 'self-employment' in the building industry.

Workers who become safety reps are routinely sacked for carrying out their duties. For example, building union UCATT is currently dealing with a case in west London where a worker was sacked for calling an ambulance after a fellow worker fell 12 feet.

One of UCATT's main demands is for roving safety reps, which the HSE is piloting at the moment. The pilot scheme in agriculture however ran into problems when the National Farmers Union adopted what amounted to a "get off my land" approach. Similarly, the Construction Confederation - representing 5,000 contractors, recently voted against the idea.

As Sean Prophet argues, at the very least any effective scheme must be backed up by laws which allow safety reps access to the sites in the first place and give them powers to stop dangerous jobs.

Similarly, charges of corporate manslaughter will only be really effective if the directors face prison for a workers' death, rather than just the site foreman.


Workers Protest As Safety Conference Is Downgraded

Deputy prime minister John Prescott called a safety conference in February this year. It was originally to be a full day event with the major players in the industry; contractors, clients, trade unions and families of victims. But it was down-graded to a three-hour session, closed to ordinary building workers and bereaved relatives.

The trade unions and other safety campaigners lobbied the event. Sean Prophet explains what happened:

"On the day of the summit, round the corner in a church which was being renovated, a wall had collapsed on a bloke and killed him. So whilst the summit was on, he was still under the ground.

"The union had a mountain of hardhats outside the summit showing how many building workers had died that year. So blokes came round from the church job and laid another hard hat on the mound.

"Also at the safety summit most of the bereaved relatives weren't allowed in. 600 people were there, mostly employers' representatives. So we got a big group of builders around the relatives because they said they wanted to go in.

"Two loads of old Bill were called - yet some of the people there were 80 years old.

"Eventually the police had to go inside and tell the Health and Safety Executive to let the relatives in. Which was about the only useful thing which came out of the day."


Getting Away With Murder

"I THINK what we have to get across is the carnage there is on sites. We have to get it across to the government and the health and safety executive...

"I think the only time that real action will come out of this is when building workers themselves decide they have had enough.

"One of the things we have been calling for is roving safety reps and greater protection for safety reps on site. I know from bitter experience that when you get safety reps on site you are usually counting in days the time they are left on site before they're dismissed, moved or harassed or whatever.

"I haven't really noticed this Labour government has been any better than the previous Tory government on health and safety.

"The Health and Safety Executive still appear to be underfunded, they don't appear to be on sites, they don't appear to be taking proactive measures on sites.

"The only way you will get across to construction companies that they have to improve health and safety is you when start to hit the people who have overall responsibility through corporate manslaughter."

Ron McKay, UCATT official for Essex and London South East Region

Killing People At Work Should Be A Criminal Offence

"IT'S GOING to build up where we have hundreds and thousands of workers saying: 'No more, we're not standing for any more deaths on sites.' That's the main thing that will change things.

"The government see that there has been a change in attitude and people expect more regarding safety. People do not expect a 60% increase in deaths and serious injuries on sites.

"So publicising deaths and injuries on sites puts the politicians on the spot and they don't like that.

"We've had to struggle with this Labour government all the way to get a ban on asbestos for example. Blair was going to do a deal with the Canadian prime minister, which is the biggest exporter of asbestos. It was a right fight. We had many demonstrations, including national demonstrations and yet we had all these promises which they haven't carried out.

"Also, they should have implemented corporate manslaughter laws by now. There's a pilot study going on about roving safety reps, which is very important. But building employers are resisting it like mad. But we have got to make a breakthrough.

"If I had two minutes with Tony Blair the most important things I would tell him to address are: make changes to say that killing people at work is a criminal offence; and I'd ask him why aren't you working as fast in stopping workers being killed at work as you are about petty thefts and other crime."

Tony O' Brien, Construction Safety Campaign.

Safety Reps Should Have The Law On Their Side

"MY WORST experience in the construction industry was when a friend of mine was killed. The company didn't even supply a pair of steps for him. One day he stepped on a transformer and fell down a hole.

"He was in hospital and his mother had to come over from Ireland to turn his life-support machine off.

"Workers are getting more organised and groups like the Joint Sites Committee (JSC) have been absolutely brilliant, there's no doubt about that. They've brought things to a head in many areas on this issue.

"Unions in the construction industry survive with the management's say-so. I think sometimes the unions rattle the sabre but I'm afraid that's all it is.

"I've never heard of any union in this industry say they are going to close a site down because of safety. All they do is talk about so-called partnerships. You need people like the JSC and the Construction Safety Campaign to really hammer the point home.

"I would like to see company bosses jailed if they neglect safety. Also I would like to see unions get off their backsides and stand up for their members and not for the bosses. I was on a job at the Royal Opera House and they sacked 30 people to get rid of me as a safety rep off the job.

"Safety reps should have the law on their side and they should be guaranteed that they can have the right to stop a job without being victimised."

Jim, an electrician and AEEU member.

The Socialist demands:


Fighting Back

The Socialist spoke to Sean Prophet, of the Joint Sites Committee (JSC). The JSC campaigns for decent pay and working conditions in the construction industry.

ROVING SAFETY reps are a great idea. The HSE is running a pilot scheme but they've had to go to the construction employers and ask them to help them run it. The employers have said: 'We're not interested'.

They've already changed the name to 'workers' safety advisers'. And to get the pilot scheme running they're going to have to find employers who are already 'union-friendly'.

So sites which are already organised will have people coming in probably forewarned, to do a quick inspection on the basis of: 'Don't upset them too much so everyone will say what a great idea it was'.

In the building game at the moment everyone has to have a safety inspection periodically anyway. Small ten-bob subbies obviously haven't got their own safety officers. So what they do is employ freelance ones to come in and have a look.

Of course there's an inevitable financial conflict of interest. If you're being paid to visit the site and you give them a really bad report, they won't employ you any more. They'll go and find someone who will tell them there's nothing wrong.

The only thing they'll ever pull anyone on is not wearing their hard hat or not having their boots on. Something which isn't going to cost them any money. As soon as there's any money implications, they won't book it.

So when the roving safety reps come in are we going to be the same as them? Go and see the employer and be polite?

There's no point inspecting a 'union-friendly' employers' site. The places where you really want to go are the rotten horrible places where they won't let the union in.

In places like Sweden and Australia they have roving safety reps who can issue notices themselves to stop the job and fix the dangerous parts of the site. The problem we have is the level of union organisation on many sites.

Fifteen years ago, people in the trade union movement calling for corporate manslaughter to be used against employers were considered to be 'mad'. The Construction Safety Campaign, Hazards and the JSC have campaigned on this and it became national union policy. Last year the TUC adopted it as policy.

In 1999, 80 people were given prison sentences for cruelty to animals but no-one was sent to prison for murdering a worker. But if anyone does get sent down, it will be someone like site foremen who are only allowed to get away with disregarding the rules because the company employs them to do that.

We want one of the managing directors in prison. But of course what Labour are introducing isn't going to be that at all. There's talk about banning them from being a director - what a big deal.

The deputy prime minister turns up at the construction safety summit with all the employers there and you expect him to lay down the law about all these deaths. But all we got was: "We need a bit more training and then we can improve".

Everyone on the cards

The main demand should be for everyone to be taken on the cards. You can have as much education as you want, roving safety reps and corporate manslaughter but it's no good as long as the entire industry is so deregulated.

20 years ago if you walked past a Balfour Beatty building site, the vast majority of people there would be working on the cards for Balfour Beatty. Nowadays a big building site might have 600-700 people working on it with Balfour Beatty on the hoarding but they will only be employing 10-15 people. They will all be the managers. Everything else will be sub-contracted out.

As soon as work is subcontracted, people work for a price, rather than being paid the daily rate. So the way work is organised is asking for people to cut corners.

The quest for profit by the speculators, major contractors and cowboy subbies has meant health and safety has gone out the window.

Workers Memorial Day 28 April.

March and rally organised by the rail union RMT, supported by the Construction Safety Campaign.
Assemble 10.30am Grant Road, Clapham Junction, London SW11.
March to rally at Clapham rail crash memorial site, Spencer Park.
Further information from the London Hazards Centre: www.lhc.org.uk

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.


In The Socialist 13 April 2001:

Dinners For Them... Dole For The Workers

Teacher shortage: Labour offers nothing

Football trial fiasco will stoke anger about racism

Knowsley Unison - Council Concedes Historic 35-Hours For All Deal

Socialists Gear Up For Election Campaign

Bush's China Syndrome

Construction: British Industry's Killing Fields


 

Home   |   The Socialist 13 April 2001   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate  




Related links:

Construction:

triangleUnite protest against blacklisting

triangleNo more excuses: fit sprinklers now!

triangleRemove cladding without delay says head of Housing Fed

triangleOne in three borrow for rent, Corbyn pledges housing revolution

Reps:

triangleRoyal Mail walkout over suspension of union reps

triangleSheffielders call for a no-cuts 'people's budget'

triangleAristocrats to hold byelection for one of their 92 reps

triangleVictory for UPS parcel workers

Health and safety:

triangleFood processing workers vote for action against miserly bosses

triangleThe Socialist inbox

triangleBin workers - fifth week of strike action

Health:

triangleGlenfield victory shows people power can save our NHS

triangleVictory: Glenfield Children's Heart Centre saved!

UCATT:

triangleLetter from blacklisted construction workers

Reports and campaigns

Reports and campaigns

7/12/17

RMT

Anti-DOO lobby of Liverpool's transport committee

7/12/17

Blacklisting

Unite protest against blacklisting

6/12/17

Donald Trump

Mobilise to stop bigoted billionaire Donald Trump's state visit to Britain

6/12/17

Transport

Arriva bus strikers stand firm

6/12/17

Pensions

BT pensions review - oppose the attacks on the pension schemes

6/12/17

PCS

Driving examiners walkout hits first day of new test

6/12/17

Newham

School staff strike against privatisation

6/12/17

Rail

Brutal rail privateer Abellio takes over Midlands rail services

6/12/17

PCS

PCS Left Unity celebrates 40th anniversary at annual conference

6/12/17

North Yorkshire

Court maintains injunction against fracking protesters

6/12/17

Waltham Forest

Waltham Forest Universal Credit protest

6/12/17

Coventry

Coventry Socialist sales hit 1,000

6/12/17

TUSC

TUSC conference to debate 2018 elections

6/12/17

Liverpool

Liverpool John Moores Uni landslide for Socialist Students

6/12/17

Kirklees

Plans to launch no-cuts campaign at Kirklees College

triangleMore Reports and campaigns articles...


Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party

triangle8 Dec Local government pay: fight for the full 5% claim

triangle6 Dec Strikers rally in Liverpool

triangle6 Dec Corbyn's Labour can defeat Tories with socialist programme

triangle5 Dec Victory at Glenfield shows people power can save our NHS

triangle5 Dec Labour council Blairites deselected

triangle30 Nov Victory: Glenfield Children's Heart Centre saved!

triangle30 Nov Dramatic retelling of Grunwick strike

More ...

triangle13 Dec Caerphilly Socialist Party: Are we heading for an era of war?

triangle14 Dec Wakefield Socialist Party: Universal Credit - the Tories' latest assault on the poor

triangle18 Dec Leeds Socialist Party: Religion and Socialism

triangle19 Dec Bristol North Socialist Party: Christmas social

More ...

Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube

Archive

Archives:

December 2017

November 2017

October 2017

September 2017

August 2017

July 2017

June 2017

May 2017

April 2017

March 2017

February 2017

January 2017

2016

2015

2014

2013

2012

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

Legal

SP RSS feed RSS

Platform setting: = No platform choice

V2