Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page:

From The Socialist newspaper, 19 May 2010


The Tragedy of the Chinese Revolution by Harold Isaacs

Tragedy of the Chinese Revolution by Harold Isaacs

Tragedy of the Chinese Revolution by Harold Isaacs

The Chinese revolution of 1925-27 represented one of the most gigantic and splendid movements in human history. Kept at the level of pack animals, the multi-millioned Chinese masses - led by the magnificent Chinese working class - gathered in the urban areas of Shanghai, Guangdong, Wuhan, etc and battered at the foundations of Chinese and imperialist landlordism and capitalism in their quest for liberation and a new society. With a more favourable position than existed even in Russia in October 1917, a successful revolution was entirely possible.

Peter Taaffe, Socialist Party general secretary

However, a major obstacle standing in the way of the success of the revolution lay in the false policies recommended by Stalin and his circle at the head of the Communist International at the time. They stood for an alliance of the working class and the exploited peasantry with the so-called 'national capitalists' in a 'bloc of four classes' in China.

This was the failed policy of the Mensheviks in Russia, transferred to Chinese soil. Isaacs' book demonstrates brilliantly that this was the 'tragedy' of the revolution. This has been disputed endlessly by the apologists for Stalin and Stalinism since. But Isaacs answers them with an abundance of facts and descriptions of the march of the masses which completely undermines their arguments and reinforces those of himself and Trotsky.

But this book is also much more than this, as it evokes with great literary brush strokes the magnificent panorama of the heroism, self-sacrifice and determination to change the world of the terribly exploited Chinese workers and peasants.

This edition has the added advantage as it appears as it was in the original version, which contains the illuminating introduction by Leon Trotsky, which was excised from the 'abridged' edition. As Isaacs moved towards the right, following Trotsky's death, he only allowed this 'abridged' version of his book to be published. This was still useful and, despite the author's change of mind, vindicated Trotsky's analysis of the revolution.

But it was not as effective as this restored full version. Trotsky himself remarked: "Isaacs' book represents a scientific work from beginning to end. It is based on a conscientious study of a vast number of original sources and supplementary material."

It must be added that Trotsky discussed with the young Isaacs, who was 28 when he wrote this book, and went over it line by line before its publication. Despite Isaacs' later recanting of his Trotskyist and Marxist past, and the ideas of Trotsky himself, the book is nevertheless a brilliant demonstration of Trotsky's ideas, particularly on the key question of the permanent revolution as applied to China.

This theory holds that the capitalist bourgeois-democratic revolution in what is now the neo-colonial world, which involves thoroughgoing land reform and the purging of society of all feudal and semi-feudal land relations, the solution of the national question, democracy, election of parliament, etc., is only possible if the working class becomes the leading force in such a revolution. It, in turn, is only capable of leading the revolution to a victorious conclusion if it leads the peasantry - particularly its lower layers - in the struggle.

Uneven development

The opening chapter - 'Seeds of Revolt' - is a minor literary masterpiece as it describes, through the lives of the Chinese masses, the law of 'combined and uneven development' the essence of which is an integral point of Trotsky's theory of the permanent revolution. It begins:

"On the fringes of big Chinese cities the shadows of lofty factory chimneys fall across fields still tilled with wooden ploughs. On the wharves of seaports modern liners unload goods carried away on the backs of men or shipped inland on primitive barges.

"In the streets great trucks and jangling trams roar past carts drawn by men harnessed like animals to their loads. Sleek automobiles toot angrily at man-drawn rickshaws and barrows which thread their way through the lanes of traffic. Streets, lined with shops where men and women still fashion their wares with bare hands and simple tools, lead to huge mills run by humming dynamos. Aeroplanes and railways cut across vast regions linked otherwise only by footpaths and canals a thousand years old. Modern steamers ply the coasts and rivers, churning past junks of ancient design.

"Throughout the towns and villages, and on the tired land of the vast river valleys that stretch from the sea to the heart of Asia, these contradictions and contrasts multiply. They embody the struggle of nearly half a billion people for existence and survival."

It is regrettable that the author retreated from his Marxist-Trotskyist position later. His son, Arnold Isaacs, in his new introduction, tries to explain his reasons. He concedes his father was at one ideologically with Trotsky when he wrote the book but then goes on to state: "His [Harold Isaacs] position on Trotsky's underlying beliefs is a different matter."

Yet Isaacs' son concedes that the book was written by the young Isaacs as a 'revolutionist', as Trotsky approvingly noted in his foreword but "those views fairly quickly changed". Thirteen years later, however, in a new abridged edition - which did not give the full scope of this present book - "he [Harold Isaacs] no longer agreed with the fundamental Leninist principles that Trotsky held until his death in 1940" [foreword by Arnold R. Isaacs].

The change of heart by Isaacs is explained by the fact that he disagreed with "the principle that a proletarian dictatorship led by a single revolutionary party must exercise sole power in a revolutionary state". This is a quite false conclusion attributed to Trotskyists and also to Marxists today.

A single party state in Russia, exercising the 'proletarian dictatorship' (which had a quite different meaning then than it does today, in the sense that it really represented workers' democracy) did not arise from Trotsky's ideas but the exigencies, the difficulties of the Russian revolution.

As Trotsky and we have explained many times, only one party was originally banned by the Bolsheviks, the reactionary Black Hundreds. All other parties - Mensheviks, Social Revolutionaries, anarchists, etc. - were allowed to continue as long as they exercised political opposition to the Bolsheviks in a peaceful, democratic manner. Only after many had resorted to armed insurrection against the Bolsheviks - as did the Social Revolutionaries in 1918 - with the Mensheviks and others supporting different tsarist or White generals, were they suppressed.

Later, some members of these parties did adhere to the October 1917 victory but their parties as a whole were originally on the other side of the barricades. Isaacs, as his son explains in the introduction, later sought to argue that the "soviet experience taught us that the contradiction between authoritarianism and democratic socialism is complete. The one-party monopoly of political life developing into bureaucratic oligarchy, an outcome that clearly arose out of some of the basic premises of bolshevism."

This is the familiar tale which argues that Stalinism, 'authoritarianism', originated in the Bolsheviks and their methods. In reality, Stalinism had to consolidate itself by destroying all elements of Bolshevism.


Lenin's Bolshevik party was the most democratic mass party in history. Stalinism had to annihilate this party in a river of blood in the terrible purges of the 1930s. The one-party regime flowed from the isolation of the Russian revolution and not the original aims of Bolshevism.

The hope was that after the civil war that soviet democracy would be restored. Instead the isolation of the revolution led to the crystallisation of a bureaucratic caste which succeeded 73 years after the revolution in returning Russia to capitalism.

These issues, in any case, are not central to this book, dealing as it does with the mighty Chinese revolution of 1925-27. The mainsprings of this mighty movement were rooted - as in the Russian revolution itself, which inspired the Chinese masses - in the incapacity of capitalism to take society forward.

We would urge all those who are able to buy this book or at least buy it in combination with others to do so. Reading it will allow the younger generation in particular to understand the full character of the revolution of 1925-27.

It will also allow them to see that the forces involved in the revolution of 1944-49, led by the Red Army and Mao Ze-Dong, were entirely different to those present in 1925-27, which was a classic working-class revolution that led the mass of the Chinese nation in the struggle to change society.

This book also has a contemporary relevance because the problems of the incomplete capitalist-democratic revolution - which the Chinese workers and peasants confronted - are still colossal barriers to real liberation in those parts of the world which comprise two thirds of humankind. We therefore urge readers to buy it and discuss it, hopefully as a means of understanding what will take place in the neo-colonial world.

Note: the book is online on the website here

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.

In The Socialist 19 May 2010:

Action needed to save our services

Workplace news

Vote Roger Bannister in the Unison general secretary election

British Airways: Another intolerable court judgment

Youth fight for jobs

Youth need job creation, not job slaughter

Socialist Party election analysis

Time for the fight of our lives

Socialist Party news and analysis

Building Coventry Socialist Party after the election

Support for socialists Ian Page and Chris Flood

Packed out London meeting looks to fight against cuts

Fast news

International socialist news and analysis

Initiative for a week of European-wide protests

Italy: ControCorrente socialists support CWI

Thailand's government orders bloody crackdown on protesters

Kazakhstan: "Thanks comrades for support"

USA: Putting forward a Socialist Alternative in Seattle

Marxist analysis: history

The Tragedy of the Chinese Revolution by Harold Isaacs


Peter Hadden - an inspiring life for socialism

Socialist Party workplace news

Communication Workers Union conference: Hands off Royal Mail!

Defending the postal service

Bus workers gear up for action

RMT ballots Tube Lines workers

National Shop Stewards Network conference: International rally planned


Home   |   The Socialist 19 May 2010   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate  

Related links:


triangleA world in crisis, ripe for revolution

triangleCampaign against political repression in Hong Kong

triangleKorean peninsula: is nuclear war likely?

triangleHong Kong: mass demonstration against repression

triangleChina: debt crisis, state repression and the prospects for workers' struggle


triangle110 years ago: massacre at Santa Maria school in Chile - commemorate 21 December 1907

triangleCaerphilly Socialist Party: Women and Revolution

triangleMass rally to commemorate 1917 Russian Revolution

triangleSpain: Madrid rally celebrates October revolution


triangleSheffield South Socialist Party: Trotsky's theory of permanent revolution

triangleOctober 1917 reviews: 'More bright than any heaven'

triangleRussia, October 1917: When workers took power


triangleWest London Socialist Party: Why we need a party

triangleWest London Socialist Party: 100 years since the October revolution in Russia


triangleWell-deserved ridicule of Stalinism is impressive, funny but flawed


triangleRussia 1917: how art helped make the revolution

Peter Taaffe:

triangleHow to help the struggle to change the Labour Party

Reviews and comments

Reviews and comments


The Socialist

The Socialist's 2017 quiz



The Socialist Inbox



Comment: Socialism and truth about Zane


Labour Party

Blairite horror and Labour's divisions graphically exposed



Dramatic retelling of Grunwick strike


Working class

Left comic's take on politics will have you in tears



The Socialist inbox


The Socialist

The Socialist Inbox



TV review: Abortion on Trial - hard-hitting look at impact of 1967 act


Vietnam war

Comprehensive account of bloody conflict



The Socialist inbox



Obituary: Paul Randall, 1959-2017



Welsh update of Chekhov an engrossing tale of 1980s class conflict



The Socialist inbox



The Socialist inbox

triangleMore Reviews and comments articles...

Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party

triangle14 Dec Stop the rotten redevelopment plan, demand residents

triangle13 Dec Six months on - still no justice for Grenfell

triangle13 Dec Movement growing against fracking giant Ineos

triangle13 Dec Totnes MP uses coffin controversy to distract from brutal NHS cuts

triangle13 Dec Trump's incendiary Jerusalem statement reignites Israeli-Palestinian...

triangle13 Dec Labour 'purge' furore really just democracy

EU parliament, Strasbourg

triangle13 Dec Brexit deal no solution to Tory rifts

More ...

triangle14 Dec Wakefield Socialist Party: Universal Credit - the Tories' latest assault on the poor

triangle18 Dec Leeds Socialist Party: Religion and Socialism

triangle19 Dec Bristol North Socialist Party: Christmas social

triangle21 Dec Wakefield Socialist Party: Socialists and the National Question

More ...

Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube



December 2017

November 2017

October 2017

September 2017

August 2017

July 2017

June 2017

May 2017

April 2017

March 2017

February 2017

January 2017





















Platform setting: = No platform choice