Reports and Campaigns

spotAbout the Socialist Party




spotElection campaigns



spotSocialist women


spotYouth and Students

All keywords

Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube

Youth keywords:

Apathy (2)

Apprenticeships (24)

ASBOs (7)

Black youth (11)

Campaign to Defeat Fees (40)

Childrens homes (1)

Croxteth Comprehensive School (1)

Educational Maintenance Allowance (4)

EMA (65)

Freshers fairs (10)

Gangs (4)

Grants (26)

Policing (35)

Sick Of Your Boss (17)

Students (1072)

Teenage obesity (1)

Workfare (43)

Workfare protests (6)

YFJ (97)

Young people (541)

Young workers (64)

Youth (556)

Youth Fight for Education (12)

Youth Fight for Jobs (362)

Reports and campaigns:

Anti-capitalism (1248)

Anti-fascist (562)

Anti-racism (705)

Anti-war (1498)

Asylum (213)

Black and Asian (395)

Children (385)

CNWP (108)

Corporate crime (2)

Disability (202)

Education (3950)

Election campaigns (2466)

Environment (610)

EU (452)

Finance (101)

Food (270)

Health and safety (35)

Health and welfare (317)

Housing (1049)

Human Rights (383)

LGBT Pride (143)

Local government (2195)

Local services (3677)

Low pay (513)

Migration (57)

Nationalisation (147)

New workers party (470)

NHS (1854)

Pensions (704)

Post Office (222)

Poverty (579)

Privatisation (1025)

Public Services (1143)

Socialism (878)

Socialist (43)

Sport (197)

Stop the slaughter of Tamils (92)

Students (1843)

The state (1373)

Transport (557)

TUSC (999)

Welfare rights (720)

Women (769)

Workplace and TU campaigns (8307)

Youth (1978)

Related websites

Youth Fight For Jobs

Trade Unionist and Socialist Coalition

National Shop Stewards Network

Tamil Solidarity

Highlight keywords  |Print this articlePrint this article
From: The Socialist issue 848, 18 March 2015: Fight for 10 an hour!

Search site for keywords: Liberties - Working class - War - Human rights - ASBOs - Terrorism - Aid - Legal aid

How can civil liberties be protected?

Paul Heron reviews 'On Liberty' by Shami Chakrabati (Allen Lane)

Shami Chakrabati joined Liberty on 10 September 2001, the day before the 9/11 attack changed world relations. 'On Liberty' is her account of authoritarian anti-terrorism measures introduced by Blair's Labour government, and other governments worldwide.

She also criticises proposals for ID cards, anti-social behaviour orders (ASBOs), cuts to legal aid, and the creeping acceptance of torture. These, she explains, were introduced without fully considering human rights norms, democracy or the rule of law.

Liberty's work, and Chakrabati's role within it after 9/11 and 7/7, showed her taking on the warmongers. On Question Time she was often a clear, reasoned voice for human rights while some people, whipped up into a war frenzy, shouted her down.

The book comes to life when Chakrabati addresses a group of working class mums who supported anti-social behaviour orders (ASBOs) on estates. She explains that the anti-social behaviour in question is in fact serious criminal activity, and that ASBOs are often aimed at young people who have nothing to do because services have been decimated.

Sadly, this is one of few instances where Chakrabati shows how civil liberties and human rights touch working class peoples' lives, and she fails to link the breakdown of 'social order' to the wider effects of austerity.

Dealing with the potential effects of more security and less civil liberty she quotes Lord Hoffman on the Blair government's proposals after 9/11: "The real threat to the life of the nation... comes not from terrorism but from laws such as these. That is the true measure of what terrorism may achieve. It is for parliament to decide whether to give the terrorists such a victory".

These words were particularly principled given that the state forces were preying on people's fears to drive through counter-reforms. However, Chakrabati puts too much faith in the judges' role.


Use of 'the law' can only be part of the struggle. Belief in the inherent fairness in the legal system is delusional. Socialist lawyers must use the law to fight for the interests of the working class and democratic rights. But even where judges - such as Lord Hoffman - uphold civil liberties we cannot simply rely on legal judgements as the sole saviour.

There is a class basis of law, and judges do not act in the working class' interest. Yes, we can secure victories in the courts, but this can often rely on the strength of class struggle at any given time.

The book ascribes a passive role to the working class, and relies on the great and the good to save us through legal processes.

Chakrabati does not put the 'war on terror' and legal aid reforms in their social and political context. Neoliberalism demands both a free market and a strong authoritarian state, and attacks on human rights and civil liberties are linked to the pursuit of those aims.

The capitalist class understands that in order to smash the post-war consensus, it needs to deal with any backlash from the working class. That is the drive behind attacks on civil liberties.

A real passion comes across in 'On Liberty' and Chakrabati makes effective arguments against the 'war on terror', ASBOs and the cuts in legal aid. But at 17.99 for 146 pages it's hardly a bargain. My advice: wait for the paperback.

Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Related links:


triangleTories 'Prevent' civil liberties

triangleBlock Osborne's Billionaire Budget

triangleFight the snoopers' charter!

triangleInitial Statement on Boston Marathon Tragedy from Socialist Alternative

triangleDanger: New secret courts in Britain

Working class:

triangleWidening wealth gap, increase in poverty...make the fat cats pay

triangle2018: more upheavals loom

triangleA world in crisis, ripe for revolution

triangleLabour 'purge' furore really just democracy


triangleOpinion: British imperialism can take no credit in fight against Isis

triangleCardiff East Socialist Party: Do Trump's antics make nuclear war more likely?

triangleSalford Socialist Party: A socialist look at the Vietnam War

Human rights:

triangleSweden: School strike against deportations

triangleInterview: Refugee Rights Campaign


triangleThem & Us


triangleSalford Socialist Party: Why Marxism opposes terrorism


triangleStop the cuts - save our vital services

Legal aid:

triangleCourts and tribunal services face huge cuts