The Socialist 22 July 2020 |
Join the Socialist
| Audio | PDF | ebook
The Socialist inbox
Do you have something to say?
Send us your news, views and criticism, in not more than 150 words, to firstname.lastname@example.org - or if you're not online, PO Box 1398, Enfield EN1 9GT.
We reserve the right to shorten letters. For legal reasons, we need your full name, address and phone number - but confidentiality will be respected if requested.
The statue of Black Lives Matter protester Jen Reid before it was removed by Bristol's Labour council, photo Andrew Richards/CC (Click to enlarge)
Is anybody else perplexed by the behaviour of Bristol's Labour mayor, Marvin Rees? For four years he took no action about the statue of slave trader Colston. But as soon as a statue of a black protester is put up, it's removed within hours.
Rees is an elected mayor, so has a lot of power. Even if it was a council decision to keep Colston's statue up, he took no proposals there.
Roger Bannister, Liverpool
Marvin Rees confirmed it was his decision to remove the statue, on the grounds that no official application was made to erect it. He said that the whole issue was distracting from the 'great' regeneration (gentrification) projects.
He claims to be a supporter of the new Black Lives Matter statue, but in practice never did anything to remove the slave owner from his plinth. He's an opportunist imposing massive cuts.
Domenico Hill, Bristol
Alison Hill's article on the 1975 Australia coup (see 'Palace letters show the monarchy is a weapon for capitalism' at socialistparty.org.uk) provided a very good political argument for socialists to use when calling for the abolition of the monarchy.
Alison is correct regarding the ruling class being worried about the power of a mobilised labour movement. There was another incident which also undermined the activities of imperialism.
The CIA operated a listening station in the outback on land leased from the Australian government. Then prime minister Gough Whitlam threatened not to renew the lease, which held out the prospect of the station having to close, disrupting surveillance in the entire Asian Pacific region, including China.
That magnified his danger to imperialism, and pushed the intricate veneer of governmental stalemate used to justify this constitutional coup.
Clive Walder, Birmingham
Unsafe and legal
Fire doors used in Grenfell are still the main doors used in many council high rises. The excuse? They met regulations when they were installed and so are still legal.
Councils are not prepared to spend the money to make council properties safe - and that's backed up by the law. It just shows that the law is no measure of what is safe or right, and in creating a new society that meets the needs of all, many unjust laws will have to be broken.
Amy Cousens, Bradford
Football is fans not owners
What's happened at Hull City is the reality of football under capitalism - millionaire owners with no check on their arrogance and wants. Clubs become about the egos of those running them.
It's mad to think that City have gone from the Premier League and Europe to this sorry state of affairs. Clubs are not their owners, they're a community asset, they're the focal point for thousands of people, and to see the heart ripped out of City is difficult to watch.
Solidarity to all Hull City fans. #AllamOut
Matt Whale, Hull
Lockdown nuclear Armageddon
"I can't abandon that tool [lockdown] any more than I would abandon a nuclear deterrent. But it is like a nuclear deterrent, I certainly don't want to use it. And nor do I think we will be in that position again," wrote Prime Minister Boris Johnson.
Has Johnson thought through this analogy? A nuclear deterrent is presumably meant to dissuade foreign powers not to attack Britain. Having a lockdown in reserve is not going to deter a virus.
Back in March, during the pandemic, Boris did, eventually, deploy the 'nuclear option' in order to prevent hundreds of thousands of deaths. Unfortunately for the PM, that pesky coronavirus hasn't gone away and, now that the lockdown has been lifted, is making a comeback.
And this resurgence is not being contained by Johnson's 'world beating' track and trace weapon. Yet without an effective test, trace and isolation system, the Academy of Medical Sciences speculates that a second wave of the pandemic this winter could result in 120,000 excess deaths in hospitals alone.
So despite the hopes of the PM that the country won't experience a pandemic again, the likelihood, given this government's lamentable record, is that Johnson is going to have to press the nuclear button.
Simon Carter, Newham, London