Socialist Party
| Print

21 February 2018

Outrageous sentence for TUSC agent in 'misleading electors' court case

Chris Fernandez, the local election agent for eight Trade Unionist and Socialist Coalition (TUSC) candidates at the 2016 council elections in Derby, was sentenced on 13 February to 15 months' imprisonment for 'electoral fraud'.

After a two-and-a-half-week trial in December, Chris had been found guilty on 12 out of 14 counts of 'misleading voters' into signing the TUSC candidates' nomination papers.

The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) argued many electors signed believing they were backing a petition against the closure of Derby's Moorways swimming pool, and not a local election nomination form.

TUSC's national election agent, Clive Heemskerk, present at the sentencing, said:

While recognising the jury's verdict, it is important to understand that in this case there was no question of actual votes being fraudulently cast, of ballot papers being interfered with, of people's right to vote how they wish being denied, of impersonation of voters, or postal ballot irregularities.

Nor was public money misspent, or any financial or other material gain achieved, by Chris's acts. It was purely a question of the formal process by which candidates are enabled to appear on ballot papers in local elections.

That is why the comments at the sentencing hearing by the trial judge, Peter Cooke, that this case "strikes at the heart of our democracy," were frankly ludicrous.

Candidates for election to the Scottish parliament, the Welsh assembly, and Greater London Authority regional list seats, for example, unlike local council candidates, can all self-nominate, without going through the process of collecting signatures before they can appear on the ballot paper.

Do these elections too 'strike at the heart of our democracy'?

In reality a 15-month prison sentence is totally disproportionate, even if the offences had been proven beyond reasonable doubt.

But what is most disturbing about this case is that there was, in fact, plenty of doubt.

I attended throughout the trial in December and submitted a 22-page account to the TUSC national steering committee, raising serious questions about the CPS's case - which, unfortunately, were not addressed in the trial. These include:

As Chris begins his prison sentence, it is impossible not to draw the contrast between the Crown's approach to this case and that of the Conservative Party's 'Battle Bus' 2015 general election expenses scandal.

The Tories' extra spending then on the 20 or so marginal seats involved may well have made the difference in their winning the election, and everything that has followed from that.

Yet in the Battle Bus case, while the CPS accepted that Tory candidates' election returns "may have been inaccurate" and therefore breaking election law, they decided it was "not in the public interest to charge anyone referred to us."

Who said what on the doorstep during a municipal election in Derbyshire was obviously of greater concern!

In reality the CPS wanted a prosecution on the extremely unusual 'false pretences' charge to satisfy the demand from the Tory government to clamp down on so-called 'sham nominations'.

This is part of the Tories' moves against democratic rights, including electoral rights, as a response to the accumulating rage at their never-ending austerity agenda.

However, this was one case, with specific circumstances, tried in one court. It does not establish case law which could be applicable to other possible instances in the future.

The vindictive political prosecution of Chris Fernandez should not cow trade unionists, socialists and working class community activists - or stop them from taking their battle against austerity, and for a new society, to the ballot box.

Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party
Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube


triangle23 Mar For a fighting, democratic Labour Party

triangle23 Mar Social media - the potential and the limits

triangle22 Mar NHS pay: Reject the Tories' divide and rule offer

Homes for All - Not billionaire profit!  GLA Square protest, photo Sarah Wrack

triangle22 Mar Homes for All - Not billionaire profit!

triangle22 Mar School strikes against academy management

triangle21 Mar Passing the council cuts test

triangle21 Mar Walkout from undercover policing inquiry

More ...


triangle24 Mar North West Socialist Party regional conference

triangle26 Mar Birmingham Central Socialist Party: Japan - Stagnation and Military Tensions

triangle28 Mar York Socialist Party: Situation of struggle in Ireland

triangle28 Mar Salford Socialist Party: The modern day slave trade


Phone our national office on 020 8988 8777


Locate your nearest Socialist Party branch Text your name and postcode to 07761 818 206

Regional Socialist Party organisers:

Eastern: 0798 202 1969

East Mids: 0773 797 8057

London: 020 8988 8786

North East: 0191 421 6230

North West 07769 611 320

South East: 020 8988 8777

South West: 07759 796 478

Southern: 07833 681910

Wales: 07935 391 947

West Mids: 02476 555 620

Yorkshire: 0114 264 6551


What we Stand For

About the Socialist Party

Our 2015 election manifesto

Joining the Socialist Party - what will it mean for you


Alphabetical listing

March 2018

February 2018

January 2018