Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page:

From The Socialist newspaper, 21 July 2010

Con-Dems propose denationalisation of the NHS

Marching to defend the NHS

Marching to defend the NHS   (Click to enlarge)

Using the cover of 'saving' money by reducing 'bureaucracy', the Con-Dem government is effectively proposing the wholesale privatisation of the National Health Service. In doing so David Cameron and Nick Clegg aim to finish what Margaret Thatcher started in the 1980s and Labour enthusiastically continued.
Andrew Lansley, the new Tory health minister has set out his government's plans to reduce the NHS to dust.
Far from the stated aim of cutting bureaucracy and saving money, these plans are predicted to cost 1.7 billion to implement. Seumas Milne, writing in the Guardian, summed up the proposals:
"From a major public service with a million employees, [the NHS] will have become a central fund with a minimal workforce, commissioning services from a string of private companies in a fully-fledged health care market."
Here a south London mental health worker gives her response to what this White Paper would mean if the government is not stopped.

On the 'Save the NHS' march, 3 November 2007 , photo Paul Mattsson

On the 'Save the NHS' march, 3 November 2007 , photo Paul Mattsson

The NHS is due to be turned completely on its head and there is no doubt that chaos will follow. If Andrew Lansley succeeds in getting his legislation passed the NHS logo will be all that remains to be misused by a multitude of new health care providers.

Private companies that specialise in 'out-sourcing' of public services, such as Capita, Serco and many others, are lining up to take advantage of the huge profits they can make by the 'denationalisation' of the NHS. Richard Marchant, one of the heads at Capita, openly stated that the 'problems' in the public sector represent a 'significant opportunity' for his company.

The White Paper

Can it be managed by the third sector? Can it be cut? Can it be privatised? These are the three questions the new Con-Dem government is asking about the NHS.

The White Paper calls for more and more NHS services (including those which directly provide patient care) to be tendered out to 'any willing provider'. Private companies will be lining up for their golden opportunity to take their pick of the most lucrative NHS services.

Profit maximisation in the NHS will have a profoundly damaging impact on a service which was designed to have the needs of the patient at the heart of its core philosophy. Lansley is explicit about his desire to "create the largest social enterprise sector in the world".

The idea of the 'internal market' was first introduced into the NHS by Thatcher in the 1980s and it was carried on with zeal by Tony Blair's Labour administration. One aspect of the market policy is that various NHS services get 'split off' into separate components and they are then tendered out to companies like Serco.

This process has happened wholesale in all NHS cleaning and catering services and it is happening increasingly with phlebotomy (blood taking) services. We have all borne witness to the damage inflicted on the NHS via PFI (private finance initiatives) which basically gave construction companies carte blanche to lock NHS trusts into long term, hugely expensive contracts for building new hospitals. NHS trusts ended up in massive amounts of debt as public funds were effectively diverted into the pockets of company shareholders.

The GMB union has identified around 640 current PFIs and more than 100 new projects in the pipeline (across all public services, although many may now be cut). The total cost was estimated at 250 billion over 25-30 years, four times the value of the assets built (64 billion). This is equivalent to 8,400 per taxpayer.

Duplication of existing services will also be encouraged under the pretext of 'offering choice' and this production of excess capacity will lead to unnecessary waste.

Extended role of the GP

Nurses demonstrate on the 3 March 2007, photo Paul Mattsson

Nurses demonstrate on the 3 March 2007, photo Paul Mattsson

Primary Care Trusts (PCTs) and Strategic Health Authorities (SHAs) are to be completely abolished by 2013. This will fundamentally change the structure of the NHS and radically alter the existing funding and commissioning of health care. These changes will be costly and complicated to implement.

Groups of GP surgeries (consortia) will be handed responsibility for up to 80% of the 100 billion health budget. GPs will increasingly have their eyes on budgets rather than on providing and accessing care for their patient population.

When money is a factor in a GP's decision-making this will make purchasing the cheapest, possibly less effective health care option more attractive, regardless of a patient's clinical need. GPs will end up avoiding referring patients on for specialist investigations and services that are deemed to be 'too expensive' or are not deemed to provide 'value for money'.

35,000 doctors could form up to 500 consortia, which will then 'buy care' from local hospitals or other providers, including private organisations. They will hire staff to manage these processes. While some have welcomed this proposal, Unison reports that around half of GPs are opposed.

GPs are not trained for their new commissioning responsibilities and will need to employ existing commissioners to help them. Capita, for example, is already offering to 'help' GPs with billing and human resources etc. It is acknowledged in the White Paper that GPs will not fully understand all of the complex areas of the specialist services, eg mental health services, that they will be commissioning.

According to Rethink, a mental health charity, two-thirds of GPs say they lack the expertise to commission mental health services. Ignorance of the value of a particular service will rapidly lead to 'disinvestment' which is the current NHS buzz term for cutting a service.

There are some GPs who wisely realise that they are going to be handed a 'poisoned chalice' and will end up implementing the government's hidden agenda of carrying out cuts to patient services.

'Efficiency savings', ie cuts of 20 billion, are expected over the next few years and if GP consortia are deemed to 'fail', ie overspend on their allocated budgets, the government is being explicit about the fact that there will be no 'bailouts'. Any failure will pave the way for other groups with vested interests to take away the health care commissioning role from a GP consortium.

Effects on existing NHS staff

NHS demonstration, photo Paul Mattsson

NHS demonstration, photo Paul Mattsson

The abolition of the PCTs and SHAs will lead to masses of job losses as all of the existing staff cannot be absorbed into the new structure. Admin workers and other ancillary staff will be hit the hardest. In the meantime Andrew Lansley is already busying himself finding cushy, lucrative roles for the old bosses of the quangos.

Dame Barbara Hakin, chief executive of NHS East Midlands, has already secured a role for herself as one of the directors of the new NHS commissioning board. She will be paid 200,000 a year in the midst of 'the very challenging financial position' to which Lansley alludes.

In the meantime the accelerated privatisation of the remainder of the NHS will mean that the contracts of NHS staff will change and our pay and conditions will most likely be driven down in the process. Staff will find that who they work for, what they work for and the way in which they work will change fundamentally.

Lansley is signing the death warrant for national pay bargaining and agreements: "Pay decisions should be led by health care employers rather than imposed by the government. In future, all individual employers will have the right, as foundation trusts have now, to determine pay for their own staff." NHS workers' pensions are also under threat.

The White Paper also proposes changes in the provision of staff training which will be outsourced to the cheapest bidder. There is a real risk that the content and the quality of training will evolve over time to incorporate more of a 'business ethos' with reduced emphasis on the needs of the patient being at the heart of operational philosophy.

Staff who entered the service because they care about patients will end up feeling completely demoralised as they are pressurised to ensure that 'the company is successful'.

The cost of caring

The Socialist Party's 'Grim Reaper' joins the Keep Our NHS Public 'Defend our health service' protest outside the Department of Health on the 60th anniversary of the founding of the health service, photo Paul Mattsson

The Socialist Party's 'Grim Reaper' joins the Keep Our NHS Public 'Defend our health service' protest outside the Department of Health on the 60th anniversary of the founding of the health service, photo Paul Mattsson

The drive towards 'payment by results' and introducing 'currencies' for units of care will be pushed forward and standardised. This is to ensure that service providers can be compared with each other and to increase competition between an ever-growing number of health care providers.

Prices for service provision will inevitably rise as new technologies, medicines and treatments are refined and developed. An organisation called 'Monitor' will be involved in price regulation, but only for publicly provided NHS services.

Competition rather than cooperation will become the order of the day. Disputes between providers could become a reality and the resolution of these disputes via the courts could put further strain on the public purse.

Health and social services will be integrated further and their budgets will be pooled. This integration has already been started and staff are finding that they have to take on additional roles and responsibilities for which they are not trained. This has a negative impact on the quality of care a patient receives.

Integration of services also leads to services being centralised in one building and patients then have to travel miles out of their local area to access the service they need.

Funding arrangements for social care are being scrutinised by the government and they are openly admitting that they are considering voluntary health insurance as one of the payment options. Of course this option will not be open to everyone, particularly the unemployed and could directly lead to those most in need of services being excluded.

Patient information

The White Paper proposes radical changes to the way in which patients communicate with health care professionals. Patients and professionals will be encouraged to communicate about a patient's health status online. This is a time-saving exercise and there is no evidence that patients have requested this style of communication or will value this 'arm's length', and essentially dehumanising, approach.

There will be implications for patients as their confidential health information will be shared with a multitude of newer, profit-driven, health and social care providers and the government has yet to clarify the legal situation around this.

In reality it will be very difficult for GP consortia and the new NHS commissioning board to ensure that these many and varied health care providers are held accountable to the public.

A patient's confidential information could end up being misused in a variety of ways and there will be more opportunities for confidentiality to be breached and privacy eroded.

These plans must be stopped

These proposed changes will make a mockery of the founding principles of the NHS constitution. Legislation still needs to get through parliament in order to effect the changes so urgent, nationwide action is needed right now to send a clear message to Andrew Lansley and the big business vultures that we, the NHS staff and service users will not tolerate the massacre of our NHS.

During the general election campaign Labour candidates liked to dress in the cloak of saviours of the NHS. This was and is pure hypocrisy. Labour's 13-year reign saw the massive expansion of the internal market in the NHS while Private Finance Initiatives sucked up enormous amounts of public money, depositing them in the pockets of private, profiteering contractors. Lansley's plan is but the next logical step.

While all three main parties agree wholeheartedly on the 'need' for private companies in the NHS the majority of public opinion wants the NHS to remain a publicly owned and run service. An overwhelming 89% of the public agree that "public services should be run by the government or local authorities, rather than by private companies", according to a 2005 YouGov poll. A mass workers' party that represents that majority view is desperately needed as part of the struggle to save the NHS.

We cannot sit back and allow this government to sell off the NHS. The Socialist Party calls for the formation of a broad coalition of NHS staff (nurses, ancillary and medical staff), trade unions, patients, carers, community and health campaigners to coordinate a nationwide campaign to save what remains of the NHS and rebuild it before it's too late.

We urgently need a national trade union-led demonstration against all cuts in jobs and services. The slogans for this demonstration must include opposition to the destruction of the NHS and for kicking out the profiteers, as well as defence of health jobs and services.

Health cuts in Yorkshire

Wakefield, Pontefract and Dewsbury hospitals, which serve more than half a million people in Yorkshire, have announced savage cuts totalling 55 million.

Plans to cut costs by 15% will mean slashing the pay bill of Mid Yorkshire Hospital NHS Trust's 7,000-strong workforce by 20 million by the end of March - equivalent to 39 million in a full year - with further pay savings of 12 million next year.

6 million has been earmarked to cover the costs of "workforce change", including redundancies.

Cuts in the time patients spend in hospital are proposed as well as plans to treat more people in the community and at home. Capital investment also faces the axe.

The report in the Yorkshire Post points out that: "The cuts are exacerbated by the opening of new 300 million-PFI hospitals in Pontefract and Wakefield which have 100 fewer beds".

The article also quotes Mick Griffiths, Unison secretary at the Trust, who said: "We are not prepared to pay the price of financial mismanagement due to the exorbitant costs of the private finance deal.

"It's pay, conditions and staff numbers that will bear the brunt of that. There is no financial justification for what is planned and we will be fighting for no redundancies and no pay cuts."

Unison at the trust will be campaigning on these demands:

A Wiltshire NHS worker says:

"With the abolition of NHS PCTs tens of thousands of staff risk losing their jobs or being taken over by these new private 'social enterprises' or health companies.

"Alongside these measures, despite public announcements by the government that funding for the NHS is 'ring-fenced', in reality the health service faces its biggest economic crisis since 1948. For instance, in Wiltshire where I am a union rep, the PCT has announced that the health service needs to make cuts of 40 million this year, and every year.

"Already, before the cuts even start, services are under pressure and staff are expected to do more care with less resources. If the government is able to get away with implementing these proposals no one should be in any doubt that it marks the end of the NHS and a comprehensive healthcare service.

"We face a battle to defend the existence of the NHS - one of the greatest reforms won by the working class in the twentieth century. If the NHS is abolished we will see a return to the 1930s when health care was the preserve of the wealthy."

The lie of patient choice

Private companies have and will, in large numbers, buy up the larger GP centres that provide primary care, refer to clinics and hospitals and hold the budget for these services. They can and will also buy up the clinics and hospitals. Some polyclinics are already run by private companies.

Therefore you have a cartel, whereby the profit making companies own and manage the care pathways in their entirety and can cream off profits at every stage.

The stated aim of the New Labour and former Tory government 'reforms' was to create 'competition' for the benefit of patients. The framework proposed by the Con Dem government in creating the landscape for such anti-competitive cartel arrangements exposes the real agenda, privatisation of the NHS, as the ideology behind these moves.

North London health worker

The Socialist Party calls for:

Do you work in the NHS? Are you a patient? The Socialist Party website welcomes your contributions.Email with your contribution.

Donate to the Socialist Party

Coronavirus crisis - Finance appeal

The coronavirus crisis has laid bare the class character of society in numerous ways. It is making clear to many that it is the working class that keeps society running, not the CEOs of major corporations.

The results of austerity have been graphically demonstrated as public services strain to cope with the crisis.

The government has now ripped up its 'austerity' mantra and turned to policies that not long ago were denounced as socialist. But after the corona crisis, it will try to make the working class pay for it, by trying to claw back what has been given.

  • The Socialist Party's material is more vital than ever, so we can continue to report from workers who are fighting for better health and safety measures, against layoffs, for adequate staffing levels, etc.
  • Our 'fighting coronavirus workers' charter', outlines a programme to combat the virus and protect workers' living conditions.
  • When the health crisis subsides, we must be ready for the stormy events ahead and the need to arm workers' movements with a socialist programme - one which puts the health and needs of humanity before the profits of a few.
Inevitably, during the crisis we have not been able to sell the Socialist and raise funds in the ways we normally would.
We therefore urgently appeal to all our viewers to donate to our special coronavirus appeal.

Please donate here.

All payments are made through a secure server.

My donation


Your message: 


In The Socialist 21 July 2010:

Warning: NHS under attack

Socialist Party youth and students

Youth and students: organise to fight for a future

Socialist Party Marxist analysis

Class struggles on the rise

Anti-cuts campaign

Stand united, fight the cuts!

Lessons of the cuts

Education workers must teach Tories a lesson

Fast news

Socialist Party workplace news

Union recommends BT pay deal

Stop the courts closures

Wales: No to fire service cuts

Strike action wins at Tube Lines

Swansea Linamar

Cuts blogger!

Socialist Party workplace analysis

PCS: a strategy to stop the cuts

TUC refuses national demo

Unite the struggle to defend pensions

Socialist Party NHS campaign

Con-Dems propose denationalisation of the NHS

Socialist Party

The Socialist Party needs you!

More join the Socialist Party in Yorkshire

Funding the socialist fightback

International socialist news and analysis

Building new workers' parties and the tasks of socialists

Egypt: Thousands protest over brutal police killing


Harder work, longer hours... All part and parcel?

A testing 'pudding' for councillors

Keep probation services public


Home   |   The Socialist 21 July 2010   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate  

Related links:


triangleCampaign stalls on jobs, pay, NHS and racism

triangleSocialist Party placards at a protest of healthcare workers in London demanding a pay rise, photo by Isai

triangleSick pay victory at Homerton hospital!

triangleFrom first wave to second? Capitalism's Covid failures

triangleNHS pay: 15% for all now


triangleUnite union branch pledges to support socialist candidates who oppose cuts

triangleCaerphilly & RCT Socialist Party: How to fight the cuts

triangleFighting for over 250 jobs that are under threat at the Wales Millennium Centre in Cardiff. Photo M Kamish

triangleOnline rally: Fight the London transport funding cuts!


triangleCapitalism's 'vaccine war' shows need for socialist cooperation

triangleCardiff West Socialist Party: Capitalism and mental health

triangleFight for the NHS


triangleChina after the 1949 revolution: the benefits of the planned economy stifled by bureaucracy

triangleTV Review: Chernobyl - Workers' heroism vs sclerotic Stalinism

Mental health:

triangleCardiff East Socialist Party: Capitalism is bad for mental health


triangleHugo Pierre for Unison general secretary


triangleSocialist planning is the alternative

Nick Clegg:

triangleThem & Us


triangleNorth London: Socialist Party speaks at BLM protest

David Cameron:

triangleThe Cameron Tory legacy


triangleLabour payouts: unions must discuss political representation

Margaret Thatcher:

triangleCouldn't pay, wouldn't pay, didn't pay: the battle to defeat the poll tax


triangleWhat would socialist universities look like?

Reports and campaigns

Reports and campaigns


Young Socialists

Young Socialist day of action


Socialist Party

Campaign stalls on jobs, pay, NHS and racism


Black Lives Matter

North London: Socialist Party speaks at BLM protest



Engage for Change Hull - trade union youth festival goes online


Socialist Party

Why I joined - Covid changed my outlook


Socialist Party

Socialist Party meetings: Online and in-person


Young Socialists

A-level results day 2020: Fight for our future!



GE Aviation workers march to save jobs



80 years since the murder of Leon Trotsky rally



Fighting to end racism and capitalism



Doncaster: Vigil for murdered women


The Socialist

The Socialist summer schedule



Unite union branch pledges to support socialist candidates who oppose cuts



Oppose BT site closures - national strike ballot needed



Sick pay victory at Homerton hospital!

triangleMore Reports and campaigns articles...

Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party
Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube



Phone our national office on 020 8988 8777


Locate your nearest Socialist Party branch Text your name and postcode to 07761 818 206

Regional Socialist Party organisers:

Eastern: 079 8202 1969

East Mids: 077 3797 8057

London: 075 4018 9052

North East: 078 4114 4890

North West 079 5437 6096

South West: 077 5979 6478

Southern: 078 3368 1910

Wales: 079 3539 1947

West Mids: 024 7655 5620

Yorkshire: 077 0671 0041



Alphabetical listing

August 2020

July 2020

June 2020

May 2020

April 2020

March 2020

February 2020

January 2020