Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page:

From The Socialist newspaper, 20 October 2010

Lawful Industrial Action (Minor Errors) Bill 2010

Fighting the anti-union laws

Trade Unionists lobbying parliament - trying to persuade at least 100 MPs to turn up at John McDonnell's Lawful Industrial Action bill's second reading, to prevent the Tories crushing it, photo Suzanne Beishon

Trade Unionists lobbying parliament - trying to persuade at least 100 MPs to turn up at John McDonnell's Lawful Industrial Action bill's second reading, to prevent the Tories crushing it, photo Suzanne Beishon   (Click to enlarge)

On 22 October, two days after the government announces its savage public spending cuts, left Labour MP John McDonnell's Lawful Industrial Action (Minor Errors) Bill has its second reading. The Bill aims to change the law to prevent the courts granting employers injunctions against strike action because of minor technical errors in industrial action ballots.

Jim Horton

If allowed to fall, the government's axe to public spending will result in a devastation of public services. Tens of thousands of public sector workers will lose their jobs. Private sector workers will not be immune from the jobs cull. Those remaining in work face a management offensive against their terms and conditions.

Decisive in stopping the Con-Dem assault will be industrial action by public sector unions. Yet in their arsenal the bosses have a raft of anti-union laws introduced by Thatcher, which New Labour refused to repeal when they were in power.

In the past year several unions, including Unite and the RMT, have had strike action thwarted by the courts' application of a strict interpretation of the onerous balloting and notification procedures of the Trade Union and Labour Relations (Consolidation) Act 1992 (TULRCA). This is despite huge majorities in ballots.

Most notoriously on two occasions Unite members working for British Airways fell foul of the court's pro-big business bias. In December 2009 cabin crew voted for strike action by a margin of 92.5% on a ballot turnout of 80% of 12,000 workers. Scandalously the courts granted BA an injunction because a handful of members who voted had already accepted redundancy. And again in May this year BA initially successfully used the High Court to frustrate a strike of BA cabin staff, 80% of whom had voted for action. This was on the flimsy grounds that Unite had failed to comprehensively communicate that out of 9,282 ballots cast, eleven (0.1%) were spoiled. Unite had put the full result, including spoilt ballot papers, on its website and union notice boards. In both instances the claimed minor flaws made absolutely no difference to the ballot result. Although Unite's appeal against the ruling was upheld, this was not a harbinger of changed legal bias in favour of the unions.

Trade Unionists lobbying parliament - trying to persuade at least 100 MPs to turn up at John McDonnell's Lawful Industrial Action bill's second reading, to prevent the Tories crushing it, photo by Suzanne Beishon

Trade Unionists lobbying parliament, photo by Suzanne Beishon   (Click to enlarge)

Last year the Court of Appeal ruled in favour of Metrobus against Unite's 90% vote in favour of strike action, claiming that the 20 hours it took the union to notify the employers of the result did not comply with the legal requirement to notify 'as soon as reasonably practicable'. Furthermore, the union had failed to explain that the number of members to be balloted had been taken from its central computer. Again these 'defects' did not affect the overwhelming support for action.

Also last year EDF won a High Court injunction against the RMT on the grounds that the union's notice to EDF which described 65 members as engineers/technicians did not give their precise job description.

Section 232b of the TULRCA states that 'accidental' errors made 'on a scale unlikely to affect the result of the ballot' should be disregarded. However, as recent decisions have revealed, the courts have given an unfavourable interpretation of 'accidental' and declared that notices to employers are not included in the protection.

John McDonnell's Bill should be supported by all trade unionists. Its provisions state that all small accidental failures in ballots and notices, and minor errors in the information about the ballot result, will be disregarded; and the burden of proof will shift so that the evidence required will be that of 'substantial compliance'. At the same time the unions' sponsored MPs should put down a motion in parliament calling for the abolition of all the anti-trade union laws.

There is no right to strike under British law. Every industrial action is a breach of the employment contract leaving the union exposed to being sued for damages by the employer. Since 1906 there has been statutory protection from common law where industrial action was in contemplation of or furtherance to an industrial dispute. In the 1980s Thatcher limited the scope of this protection and enacted the additional hurdles of the complex balloting and notification procedures.

In the unlikely event that McDonnell's Bill reaches the statute books, the vast bulk of the anti-union laws will remain in place. The whole history of industrial relations law also shows that the courts are more than willing to interpret any law in the bosses' favour.

In fact workers now face further legal restrictions on their rights. Citing increased labour tensions, the employers' organisation the CBI is pushing for a tightening of the ballot rules so that a strike can only go ahead if a minimum of 40% of the balloted workforce supports it (in addition to a simple majority of those voting). In the past the Tories have proposed the removal of immunity for industrial action that has a disproportionate or excessive effect, which potentially could apply to all strike action.

Some unions are looking towards the European Court of Human Rights to provide a bit of legal protection, but recent decisions of the European Court of Justice have placed the economic interests of the bosses ahead of the 'disproportionate' effect of workers asserting their rights.

No trade unionist would lightly risk sequestration of a union's funds by recklessly ignoring the law. But in the months and years ahead big industrial battles loom. Where the bosses' anti-union laws are used to frustrate majority support for strike action, or where its provisions act as a shackle on workers taking unavoidable spontaneous or solidarity action, then in such circumstances the unions will have no choice but to support the 'unlawful' but justified action of their members.

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.

In The Socialist 20 October 2010:

Anti-cuts campaign

Fight all cuts in jobs and services

Build coordinated action to stop cuts

Workers under attack

Socialist Party news and analysis

NHS: Not safe in Con-Dem hands

Coventry jobs slaughter - unions must fight back

Government slams door shut on social housing

Osborne mugs poor to pay for rich

Cambridge Uni to go private?

Socialist Students

Mass action needed to defeat fees and cuts

Warwick university - students condemn escalation of fees

Leeds university - protest following Browne review

Socialist Party workplace news

Huge demo against passport office closure in Newport

RMT executive election: Support Lewis Peacock

Fighting the anti-union laws

Police try to stifle Trade Unionist and Socialist Coalition protest

Strike forces concessions at Tyneside Safety Glass

Workplace news in brief

International socialist news and analysis

Protest, strike, fightback! French workers and youth challenge cuts

World economy heading for 'double-dip' recession

Socialism 2010

Socialism 2010: ideas to fight the cuts

Socialist Party reviews

Days of Hope by Jim Allen, reviewed by Leigh Cartwright

Enter Shikari - Common Dreads (album 2009)


Liverpool FC: "They don't care about fans!"


Home   |   The Socialist 20 October 2010   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate  

Related links:

Anti-union laws:

triangleRoyal Mail bosses block strike - back postal workers

triangleTories weak: time for the TUC to act

triangleConference opens debate on Labour and pledges to fight anti-union laws

triangleKick out the Tories: For a Corbyn-led government

triangleJeremy Corbyn's workers' charter


triangleSchool strikes against academy management

triangleUCU strike: staff and students unite to continue pensions fight after magnificent 14 days of action

triangleWest Virginia teachers' strike victory

triangleSpain: millions on streets against sexism and capitalist oppression


triangleHinkley workers win back unpaid wages after sit-in protest

triangleWorkplace news in brief

triangleWoolwich ferry workers win automation campaign


triangleNHS pay: Reject the Tories' divide and rule offer

triangleLeaked pay deal: fight for a genuine pay rise

John McDonnell:

triangleMcDonnell says Labour would put services 'irreversibly' in workers' hands

Reports and campaigns

Reports and campaigns



Homes for All - Not billionaire profit!



School strikes against academy management



Hands Off HRI campaign granted judicial review



Refugee Rights to be launched in Manchester



Over 1,000 on Newcastle NHS march


Socialist Party

Why I joined: 'The Socialist Party is at the forefront of defending Corbyn's anti-austerity leadership'


Socialist Party

Past fund-raising campaigns show dedication to the fight for socialism


May Day

Ideas matter: help us fight to win with May Day greetings



Refugees march against racism and to demand rights



Unions condemn 'culture of bullying' at Merseyside hospital



Hull college workers ballot for action against mass redundancies



Strikers and parents rally again in Newham against academies



Hinkley workers win back unpaid wages after sit-in protest



UCU strike: staff and students unite to continue pensions fight after magnificent 14 days of action



Walkout from undercover policing inquiry

triangleMore Reports and campaigns articles...

Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party
Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube



Phone our national office on 020 8988 8777


Locate your nearest Socialist Party branch Text your name and postcode to 07761 818 206

Regional Socialist Party organisers:

Eastern: 0798 202 1969

East Mids: 0773 797 8057

London: 020 8988 8786

North East: 0191 421 6230

North West 07769 611 320

South East: 020 8988 8777

South West: 07759 796 478

Southern: 07833 681910

Wales: 07935 391 947

West Mids: 02476 555 620

Yorkshire: 0114 264 6551



Alphabetical listing

March 2018

February 2018

January 2018