Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page:

Posted on 8 December 2010 at 21:21 GMT

Education White Paper a 'poisonous amalgam of twisted logic and dangerous threats'

The Con-Dem government is not only attacking higher education. They recently brought out a new Education White Paper, 'The Importance of Teaching'.
Martin Powell-Davies says that this is a poisonous amalgam of twisted logic and dangerous threats to teachers and the future of education in schools.
Martin Powell-Davies, NUT, addresses 2,500 uniformed firefighters who marched with Fire Brigades Union (FBU) flags and placards to protest outside the London Fire Authority (LFA), photo Suzanne Beishon

Martin Powell-Davies, NUT, addresses 2,500 protesting firefighters, photo Suzanne Beishon   (Click to enlarge)

CLEGG AND Cameron's foreword sets the tone of the White Paper with its deceiving distortions.

They quite rightly say that we have to learn from other countries like Finland - but their educational and economic policies are in total contradiction to the relative social equality that Finland's success has been based upon.

The Con-Dems want more Academies and 'Free Schools'.

But more children succeed in Finland precisely because they have resisted such privatisation measures and maintained a broadly comprehensive system.

Finland doesn't have a witch-hunting Ofsted-style inspection regime nor does it publish the divisive school league tables that stigmatise schools in the most disadvantaged communities.

But the Con-Dems want to force schools into becoming Academies if they don't reach their heightened 'floor targets' of 35% A*-C GCSE's (including English and Maths) or 60% achieving Level 4 in Year six.

The White Paper claims that it is reducing 'prescription' but, while promising a review of testing, states clearly in advance that the Con-Dems will maintain the national testing that forces fearful schools to adopt 'teaching-to-the-test'.

Far from granting freedom to primary teachers, the White Paper insists that 'synthetic phonics' is the best way to teach reading, when, in reality, it is just one of a range of techniques that children can benefit from.

Instead of abolishing league tables, the White Paper proposes extending them, moving closer to Obama's divisive strategy of producing not just school-by-school but teacher-by-teacher comparisons.


Both governments have the same agenda of scapegoating teachers when it is their own failings to tackle poverty, poor housing and unemployment that are really to blame.

Gove will abolish the 'value-added' league tables which, for all their faults, went some way to recognising that, however well a school tries to meet pupil needs, home background remains the main influence on exam outcomes.

Gove simply declares that "we do not expect pupils eligible for free school meals to make less progress".

But his government's vicious attacks on jobs, services and benefits will only accentuate those very real factors that discriminate against working-class children.

43% of Finnish 20-29 year-olds have had a university education.

But the Con-Dems' plans to abolish EMA and charge 9,000 tuition fees will steal that opportunity away from so many young people.

In Finland, class sizes are below average, teachers have shorter teaching hours - meaning more time to prepare lessons.

But in Britain, class sizes will rise and workloads worsen as budgets are cut.

The 'Pupil Premium' will not add new money to budgets.

On the contrary, it has been estimated that 60% of primary students and 87% of secondary students will see their school's real funding fall when allocations are finally calculated.


The White Paper also proposes cuts to school sixth form funding.

Included in the White Paper's various claims about reducing 'bureaucracy' are comments about loosening lesson planning requirements - along with other proposals such as speeding up the time it takes to investigate allegations against teachers - that could sound attractive to staff.

However, the regulations that Gove will be keenest to remove will be those protecting our pay and conditions.

Gove's abolition of the School Support Staff Negotiating Body and his letter to the School Teachers Review Body calling on them "to reduce the rigidity of the existing pay and conditions framework" shows that he expects schools to balance their budgets at the expense of staff.

Those limited workload protections that survive in national legislation such as the right to time out of class for 'PPA' (planning, preparation and assessment), could soon be under attack.

Gove will be looking to give schools even greater powers to set teacher against teacher through performance-related pay.

Staff will be told to knuckle down and do as management tells them - or face a continual pay freeze.

What's certain is that the White Paper will mark a further sharpening of the bullying management regime that has already taken grip of so many of our schools.

For example, it proposes removing the existing annual limit of three hours of management observations of a teacher's lessons as well as 'shortening' capability procedures to make it easier for teachers to be bullied out of their jobs.

The White Paper pretends to acknowledge how important it is to have high-quality teaching.

Over-worked schools

But it proposes handing over much of teacher training from universities to over-worked schools.

Many new teachers will just be thrown in schools to 'sink or swim' without any chance for a broader study of pedagogy.

The idea that a 'Troops to Teachers' programme can restore 'authority in the classroom' is Tory nonsense.

'Hands up children' could certainly take on a new meaning!

Some of the proposals may indeed be laughable, but the White Paper is a very serious attack on what remains of democratically accountable comprehensive Local Authority education.

Shamefully, New Labour promoted the marketisation of public services, following the mantra that 'competition works'.

In reality, the market creates both winners and losers, as each school looks after its own interest rather than the needs of every child in the community.

Resources are stolen from local communities and handed over to education businesses.

The Con-Dems are taking Labour's Academy programme to its logical conclusion.

The White Paper even quotes approvingly from Blair's autobiography about how Academies are 'freed from the ... interference from state'.

Jump ship

Having already encouraged 'outstanding' schools to jump ship from local authorities, Gove now wants to force supposedly 'failing' or even 'satisfactory' schools into Academies.

His model of 'collaboration through Academy chains and multi-school trusts' is a clear plan to replace public local authorities with private conglomerates.

The White Paper makes clear that the Con-Dems have already lined up their big business friends as sponsors "who are keen to extend their reach".

Gove wants to go beyond Academies with his privatised Free Schools - based on the anti-union US Charter Schools being peddled in the film "Waiting for Superman".

Free Schools will be allowed to expand at the expense of community schools.

The White Paper makes clear that "where there is a need for a new school, the first choice will be an Academy or Free School".

This is a major threat in areas like London where a rising school population will require an urgent expansion of school places.

Of course, another 'bureaucracy' that privatised schools will really want to have removed is any restriction on their ability to select the pupils they teach.

Gove's promise to consult on a "simplified and less prescriptive Admissions Code" could be a further step towards open selection.

Teaching and education is indeed of vital importance to our communities and our youth.

But this White Paper is a blueprint for dismantling comprehensive education - along with the pay and conditions of school staff.

Alongside defending pensions, school staff need to be ready to respond to any attack on our national pay and conditions with strike action.

Together with our communities we must organise to defeat the Con-Dems' drive to privatise and dismantle local authority schooling.

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.

Related links:


triangleInternational Women's Day

triangleCaerphilly & RCT Socialist Party: A socialist plan for education

triangleKingston Socialist Party & Socialist Students: Who should benefit from education?

triangleNational lecturers' pension strike continues

triangleLecturers strike around country in defence of pensions

Martin Powell-Davies:

triangleNewham academy strikes spread to Cumberland school

triangleShould you be furious about 'furious cycling'?

triangleStrike together to kick out the Tories!

triangleUniting to defeat John Roan academy plans


triangleStrikers and parents rally again in Newham against academies

triangleThem & us

triangleWorkplace news in brief


triangleWest Virginia teachers' strike victory


triangleUS school shootings: student walkouts challenge establishment


triangleHated Blairite mayor ousted: now fight for a no-cuts Newham!

Reports and campaigns

Reports and campaigns



Hands Off HRI campaign granted judicial review



Refugee Rights to be launched in Manchester



Over 1,000 on Newcastle NHS march


Socialist Party

Why I joined: 'The Socialist Party is at the forefront of defending Corbyn's anti-austerity leadership'


Socialist Party

Past fund-raising campaigns show dedication to the fight for socialism


May Day

Ideas matter: help us fight to win with May Day greetings



Refugees march against racism and to demand rights



Unions condemn 'culture of bullying' at Merseyside hospital



Hull college workers ballot for action against mass redundancies



Strikers and parents rally again in Newham against academies



Hinkley workers win back unpaid wages after sit-in protest



UCU strike: staff and students unite to continue pensions fight after magnificent 14 days of action



Walkout from undercover policing inquiry



Hated Blairite mayor ousted: now fight for a no-cuts Newham!



NSSN conference moves

triangleMore Reports and campaigns articles...

Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party
Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube



Phone our national office on 020 8988 8777


Locate your nearest Socialist Party branch Text your name and postcode to 07761 818 206

Regional Socialist Party organisers:

Eastern: 0798 202 1969

East Mids: 0773 797 8057

London: 020 8988 8786

North East: 0191 421 6230

North West 07769 611 320

South East: 020 8988 8777

South West: 07759 796 478

Southern: 07833 681910

Wales: 07935 391 947

West Mids: 02476 555 620

Yorkshire: 0114 264 6551



Alphabetical listing

March 2018

February 2018

January 2018