Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page:

From The Socialist newspaper, 31 August 2011

Book review

Why Marx was right

Niall Mullholland

"Marxism may be all right in theory ...but in practice the result is terror" ... "determinism" ... "a Utopia" ... "a theory obsessed with class ... advocates violent political action ... and believes in an all powerful state..."

Terry Eagleton rebuts these arguments and other prejudices and myths against Marxism in his new book, Why Marx was right.

Starting with today's global economic crisis, Eagleton comments: "You can tell the capitalist system is in trouble when people start taking about capitalism. It indicates that the system has ceased to be as natural as the air we breathe, and can be seen instead as the historically rather recent phenomenon that it is."

Socialists everywhere will be familiar with the accusations that Marxism is a crude form of "historical determinism", reducing everything to the economic, that it goes against human nature etc.

Eagleton, a professor of English literature and cultural theory, answers these arguments with vigour and wit, often alluding to philosophy and literature. His book is sure to reach a readership well beyond academia.

While condemning Stalinism and its legacy, Eagleton also indicts the record of capitalist rule: "Modern capitalist nations are the fruit of a history of slavery, genocide, violence and exploitation every bit as abhorrent as Mao's China or Stalin's Soviet Union..."

Under today's rule of "free market dogma", during the last two decades of the 20th century, the number living on less than two dollars a day increased by one hundred million.

For seasoned Marxist readers, Eagleton's book can act as a 'refresher course' and for those new to the subject it is a useful introduction. It is not without its faults and limits, however. For example, his analysis of the state - under capitalism and the different phenomena of a 'workers' state' - is somewhat unclear.

In his discussions on a future socialist society and its possibilities, Eagleton correctly rejects Stalinist-style 'blueprints' but is also at pains to avoid appearing utopian himself. He misleadingly asserts that Trotsky, among other Marxists, advocated a "utopian extreme, foreseeing ... a future stocked by heroes and geniuses".

While Eagleton says that "over long periods of time, changes of institution do indeed have profound effects on human attitudes," he weakens and confuses his argument by using the Northern Ireland 'peace process' as a positive example.

He asserts that "changes in sectarian consciousness are likely to be geologically slow..." but "in one sense this is not all that important. What was important was securing a political agreement which could be carefully policed and skilfully evolved, in the context of a general public weariness with thirty years of violence."

The Northern Ireland Assembly does not represent a genuine "political agreement" between working people, let alone a solution. It is a top-down arrangement that institutionalises sectarianism, yet which can agree 40 billion worth of social cuts, exacerbating poverty and sectarian divisions.

A real peace process would see the working class, Catholic and Protestant, coming together in a mass struggle against cuts, sectarianism and the capitalist system, and in the process of overthrowing capitalism, democratically deciding their future in a socialist society.

Eagleton's scope is largely limited to Marx's basic ideas, vitally important as that is. He does not give enough space to discussing Marx's analysis of capitalism and the reasons for capitalist booms and slumps, which is especially apt today.

He describes the objective conditions for socialism - including how the global working class is far larger than it was in Marx's day - but does not set out ideas about how to get there.

The role of Karl Marx, the tireless revolutionary, who along with Frederick Engels laboured to build a mighty workers' International, is not given thorough treatment.

While sympathetic to the historical record of the Bolsheviks and Lenin and Trotsky, Eagleton does not comment on the validity or otherwise of a revolutionary socialist party today and how to go about changing society.

For a discussion on what policies and programme of action are needed to bring about the overthrow of capitalism and for socialist change - on the basis of the international workers' movement's experiences of over the last 150 years - readers need to look elsewhere.

Not least, in the pages of the Socialist (eg. 'What Alternative?' Peter Taaffe, The Socialist 26 June 2011) and to Socialist Party publications (eg 'Socialism in the 21st Century' by Hannah Sell).

Why Marx was right by Terry Eagleton, Yale University Press, 16.99

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.

In The Socialist 31 August 2011:

Fighting public sector cuts

Mass action can stop the cuts

Con-Dems out to destroy NHS

Housing crisis wrecks people's lives

A warning from the FE sector - hands off our education!

Socialist Party editorial

The riots and the aftermath

Socialist Party news and analysis

Gaddafi regime crumbles

'Murdochgate' places Cameron under spotlight

'Broken Britain'...

Fast News

Socialist Party youth and students

We won't be a lost generation - fight for jobs and education

Socialist Party workplace news

Plymouth Unison - Battle to reverse de-recognition - Solidarity needed!

31st August - further day of protest by construction workers

Tyne and Wear: Churchill Metro workers begin fightback

South Yorkshire Newspapers strike now in seventh week

Youth workers strike across Oxfordshire

Part time workers and the great job con

Socialist Party reports and campaigns

Keep EDL out!

6,500 Swansea children in poverty

Socialist Party summer camp

Newcastle-under-Lyme Socialist Party is now up and running!

Socialist Party review

Why Marx was right


Home   |   The Socialist 31 August 2011   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate  

Related links:


triangle200 years of Marxism meeting

triangleTower Hamlets Socialist Party: 120 years since the death of Eleanor Marx

triangleTheatre: 'Young Marx' shows growth in great platform for his ideas

triangle2018: more upheavals loom

triangleCentral London: Walk along the steps of Karl Marx


triangleYork Socialist Party: Building and financing a revolutionary party

triangleHackney Socialist Party: The Left Opposition's fight against the rise of Stalinism in Russia

triangleHackney Socialist Party: Refugee rights

triangleMembers dig deep into their pockets to support the party


triangleItalian elections create huge political shake-up

triangle15 years since the invasion of Iraq: what we said

triangleSocialist Party congress 2018


triangleWhat we saw

triangleJapan - toxic legacy of the Fukushima disaster


triangleManchester Socialist Students: 200 years of Marxism

Reviews and comments

Reviews and comments



Gripping spy thriller exposes hypocrisy of Falklands/Malvinas war


The Socialist

International Women's Day


Sexual harassment

Fighting sexual harassment in entertainment



The Socialist inbox



The Socialist inbox: International Women's Day



Socialist anti-war exhibition opens in Kingston



The Socialist inbox



What's behind the surge in eating disorders?



The Socialist inbox



In Windsor none of us want to see homeless people on the street



I'm now a 'manager' and I can barely manage!



The Socialist inbox



Darkest Hour: Not the usual flattery of brutal Tory Churchill



Bernie's book shows need for workers' party



GCSE grading game stresses out students - even more than before!

triangleMore Reviews and comments articles...

Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party
Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube



Phone our national office on 020 8988 8777


Locate your nearest Socialist Party branch Text your name and postcode to 07761 818 206

Regional Socialist Party organisers:

Eastern: 0798 202 1969

East Mids: 0773 797 8057

London: 020 8988 8786

North East: 0191 421 6230

North West 07769 611 320

South East: 020 8988 8777

South West: 07759 796 478

Southern: 07833 681910

Wales: 07935 391 947

West Mids: 02476 555 620

Yorkshire: 0114 264 6551



Alphabetical listing

March 2018

February 2018

January 2018