Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page:

From The Socialist newspaper, 21 March 2012

Fight or privatise: A tale of two councils

Councils across the country are currently setting their budgets. Whether Tory, Lib Dem or Labour, they all dutifully carry out the government's cuts.

Socialists and anti-cuts campaigners call on them to defend the communities they represent and point to the record of the socialist-led Liverpool council in the 1980s.

Former Liverpool city councillor Tony Mulhearn answers some of the slurs thrown at the 1983-87 council's record.

Clive Heemskerk shows how privatisation of council services is the real crime.

Liverpool's fighting 47

Right-wing politicians often besmirch the achievements of the 1983-87 Liverpool councillors, the '47'. They claim that Liverpool's financial problems were caused by irresponsible borrowing which left the city in debt in 1987 and which successive administrations had to resolve.

This argument is false. Listening to these arguments, you could possibly believe that Liverpool was the only local authority that borrowed money. The practice is universal, it is the only way local authorities can function, in fact capitalism itself functions on borrowing large chunks of finance for revenue and investment purposes.

When the Liverpool 47 took office in 1983 they faced a catastrophe, inheriting a historic debt of 150 million created by the previous Liberal/Tory alliance's financial recklessness and 10 million of unallocated cuts.

This was compounded by then prime minister Thatcher's policy of savage cuts in the government's Rate Support Grant (RSG) to the council of 30 million. The RSG was conditional on staying within government spending limits, any expenditure over these limits was penalised by losing 2 for every 1 'overspend'.

The Liverpool 47's campaigning activity resulted in 60 million being clawed back from central government. With this more council houses were built than in all other local councils put together between 1983 and 1987. That was on top of the nursery classes, job creation and sports centres that were opened.

When the government cut off the cash supply in a vindictive act, Liverpool was compelled to borrow from foreign banks. Liverpool's present council leader Joe Anderson quotes a 100 million loan that cost 157 million. But all the money that Liverpool city council borrowed (for the capital programme) was at interest rates similar to those available to all councils throughout Britain.

Taking into account the 16,000 jobs created in a time of desperate unemployment and decent homes built for thousands of families (a permanent asset to the city) the case for value is irresistible.

In fact, when Thatcher's District Auditor surcharged the 47 councillors and removed them from office in 1987, the debt per head of Liverpool's population was roughly the same as all other major authorities in England and Wales.

The opponents of the Liverpool 47 never say what policies they would have suggested. The only answer which would have conformed with Thatcher's policies and pleased Kinnock and his acolytes would have been massive cuts in jobs and services, the abandonment of the house-building programme and the breaking of every election promise made by the council.

That may be the avenue favoured by the right wing and its media backers but such a move was decisively rejected by the 47 councillors.

Lewisham - relying on social enterprise

Clive Heemskerk

All councils borrow as part of their normal activity, and on much worse terms than those achieved by the Liverpool 47. While Liverpool council was fighting Thatcher's government for more resources for council house building, the 'moderate' Labour councillors in Lewisham, south London were contracting out their responsibilities.

In 1986 they made a deal with Hyde Housing Association to build and redevelop properties on the old St John's hospital site. Hyde borrowed 13.5 million, on a 50 year index-linked loan, and leased the 148 homes to Lewisham council for 20 years, with the rents collected to be used to make repayments on the loan.

Many details of the 1986 deal are still kept by the present Lewisham Labour councillors in secret 'part two' papers not available to the public. But the bottom line was that Lewisham council would be liable for St John's debts if Hyde refused to meet the loan repayments after the leases expired in December 2006.

And that's what happened. The outstanding balance on the original loan of 13.5 million in 1986 had become 28 million by 2006, even though Hyde had collected 37.8m (in 2006 prices) from Lewisham council over 20 years to meet its annual loan repayments! Lewisham's Labour executive mayor authorised council officers to borrow the money to meet the debts, without a full council vote.

As Ian Page and Chris Flood, then Socialist Party councillors in Lewisham, said when this came to light in 2006, at least it showed that councils' can borrow money when they are forced to! But our job is to force them to spend it on council services rather than their 'social enterprise' or private business friends.

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.

In The Socialist 21 March 2012:

Fighting the cuts

Tell the Con-Dem government: NO CUTS!

Prepare for future struggle - build the trade union left

Build a strategy to win on pensions

Stop the NHS sell-off - National demo now!

Stroud: Labour lets NHS down again

Socialist Party features

Capitalism isn't working: Time to fight for socialist change

Fight or privatise: A tale of two councils

Socialist Party news and analysis

Budget: far from 'all in it together'

Student walkout: Socialist Students show what could have been

No to workfare - fight for a genuine alternative

Defend the right to protest!

Youth demand future at Dundee sham summit

Them & Us

Socialist Party workplace news

MMP packaging: workers still locked out

Swindon hospital workers fight bullying

Construction workers demand better pay and conditions

Workplace news in brief

International socialist news and analysis

The 'Kony 2012' phenomena

Sri Lanka's Killing Fields: War Crimes Unpunished

Reviews and readers' comments

Smear campaign on Hillsborough?

Single and video: ill Manors by Plan B


Home   |   The Socialist 21 March 2012   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate   |   PDF  

Related links:


triangleLiverpool council: "No more cuts" - Is Joe Anderson serious?

triangleCapitalism fails NHS services in Liverpool: scrap PFI!

triangleTo win back working-class trust Labour must take the 'Liverpool road'

triangleCouncil cuts continue... So must the fightback

triangleLiverpool & District Socialist Party: Perspectives after the General Election


triangleSouth east London Socialist Party: Fight the anti-trade union laws!

triangleSouth east London Socialist Party: World in Turmoil

triangleSouth East London Socialist Students & Socialist Party: After the election - perspectives for 2020

triangleSouth East London Socialist Party: How would socialist nationalisation work?


triangleSocialist sellers

triangleStop the council cuts

triangleCouncil cuts could cost Labour another general election


triangleJohnson emits huge quantities of hot air!

triangleSinn Fein harnesses working-class anger to top poll

Tony Mulhearn:

triangleCardiff Socialist Party: Tribute to Tony Mulhearn


triangleBig Unison south east regional meeting votes for anti-cuts position

Historic events

Historic events


Berlin Wall

30 years after the fall of the Berlin Wall: How a mass revolutionary movement for genuine socialism was diverted



Obituary - Bob Lee: 1954 - 2019



How working-class tenants beat Gentrification


Wall Street Crash

The 1929 Wall Street Crash: When the capitalist system was on its knees



China after the 1949 revolution: the benefits of the planned economy stifled by bureaucracy



40 years on: Mandatory reselection more vital for Labour than ever


Northern Ireland

Northern Ireland, August '69: 'Battle of the Bogside' and British troops on the streets



The Peterloo Massacre 1819: When a fearful ruling class tried to crush working-class political aspirations



The 45th anniversary of the strike



50 years since Apollo 11 - 'One giant leap': how political conflict launched the moon landing



Stonewall riots' legacy shows need for socialist struggle to win LGBT+ liberation



35th anniversary of the Battle of Orgreave


Tiananmen Square

The Tiananmen Square massacre - 30 years on


Nuclear power

40 years after Three Mile Island disaster



Visteon: when factory occupations stayed the hands of the bosses

triangleMore Historic events articles...

Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party
Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube



Phone our national office on 020 8988 8777


Locate your nearest Socialist Party branch Text your name and postcode to 07761 818 206

Regional Socialist Party organisers:

Eastern: 079 8202 1969

East Mids: 077 3797 8057

London: 020 8988 8786

North East: 078 4114 4890

North West 079 5437 6096

South West: 077 5979 6478

Southern: 078 3368 1910

Wales: 079 3539 1947

West Mids: 024 7655 5620

Yorkshire: 077 0671 0041



Alphabetical listing

February 2020

January 2020