Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page:

From The Socialist newspaper, 16 October 2013

Immigration Bill: Whipping up racism to cut our services

Naomi Byron

Home Secretary Theresa May says the new Immigration Bill will stop 'health tourism', which is a major "drain" on the National Health Service.

The argument that unentitled people are benefiting from the NHS seems compelling. However, when questioned on Radio 4, May couldn't put a figure on the cost to the NHS.

In fact, the Royal College of GPs reckons health tourism amounts to a minuscule 0.01% of the NHS budget.

Even if the government did introduce the proposed 200 charge on temporary migrants (including non-EU students) for use of the NHS, it wouldn't save any money.

For a start the NHS already charges foreign nationals for using its services. In 2011-12 the NHS spent 33 million on treating foreign nationals, of which 21 million was recovered.

Clare Gerarda, chair of the Royal College of GPs, estimates that staff costs alone to administer the charge would cost 500 million - more than 40 times what is spent on healthcare for foreign nationals now!

Unsurprisingly, the Tories have the wrong target. The real drain on the NHS is the profiteering of private companies, who are bleeding the NHS dry.

Private Finance Initiative (PFI) contracts - where the NHS signs contracts with private companies to provide services or build hospitals, and which are then leased back to the NHS at massively inflated costs - are one of the biggest causes of deficits and cuts in NHS trusts.

Cancel PFI 'debts'

In 2011 the public 'owed' 121.4 billion to pay for infrastructure only valued at 52.9 billion. Repayment costs are rising sharply.

Between 2009/10 and 2011/12 they increased by almost 200 million. In London, where repayments rose by over 70% over the last three years, NHS trusts spent 143.9 million on PFI repayments last year.

The Tories' plans make no financial sense, until you see that once they set up an administrative system to introduce charges it is only a matter of time before charges are introduced for the rest of us.

This is the real aim of these new NHS charges for foreign nationals - to scrap the principle of NHS treatment being free at the point of delivery.

The Tories' plans put public health at risk in other ways too. The presence of a public NHS has meant the virtual elimination of many deadly and debilitating but curable diseases, If poor people cannot access treatment, infectious diseases such as TB will again rear their ugly heads.

To actually stop the NHS being drained dry the first step should be cancellation of PFI contracts and privatisation, with compensation only on the basis of proven need.

The next should be to cancel all planned cuts, taking immediate action to bring staffing levels up to the minimum required for safe practice.

Health workers in Mid Yorkshire Trust, who organised a successful strike earlier this year against plans to slash their wages and terms and conditions, have led the way.

Health unions need to organise coordinated action to prevent cuts and stop the planned pay freeze.

It is doubly ironic that the Tories are talking tough on immigration, as the coalition has tried to slash jobs in the immigration service.

In 2011 the government announced plans to reduce Home Office staff by a third, including 5,000 job cuts in the UK Borders Agency with 1,000 job cuts in the border force.

Only the threat of major strike action by PCS members in the Borders Agency on the eve of the 2012 Olympics forced the government to agree to take on more staff.

Like this year's Health and Social Care Act, which effectively privatised GP surgeries, these proposed charges for NHS treatment are privatisation by the back door, aimed at selling off profitable services to the Con-Dems' big business friends.

Virgin Care, owned by Richard Branson, has contracts worth 500 million to run community healthcare on behalf of the NHS in Surrey.

The Bill also includes plans to fine landlords and estate agents up to 3,000 if they fail to check tenants' immigration status.

Lawyers warn this is unworkable, discriminatory, and a step towards identity checks for everyone.

The Residential Landlords Association estimates that there are potentially 404 types of European identity documents they would have to be able to check.

Faced with expensive and complicated immigration checks for people, many landlords are likely to refuse accommodation to migrants as the simplest way to avoid fines.

This Bill is not aimed at protecting public services. The Tories hope that whipping up racism and division will weaken our ability to defend them.

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.

In The Socialist 16 October 2013:

Socialist Party news and analysis

Tories' rags and riches Britain; Join the socialist fightback!

Teachers, firefighters, workers fighting back: Unite the strikes!

TUSC: 2014 local elections campaign launched

Immigration Bill: Whipping up racism to cut our services

Council tax benefit cuts hit hard

SSE: So Sodding Expensive!

Fight Tory plans to scrap lifeline for young

Jobcentre staff struggling to cope

'Help to Buy' no solution to housing crisis

Them & Us


Robinson drops EDL but not his bigotry

Trade union-led anti-racist demo in Liverpool

Bradford anti-EDL protest

Education feature

Why are our schools in crisis?

International socialist news and analysis

Workers and youth re-assert their political voice in South Africa

Sri Lanka - 'No to Chogm' campaign

Refugees perish in Mediterranean "cemetery"

Socialist Party reports and campaigns

Join the party for the millions - not the millionaires

Socialism 2013 appeal

Save Kent's children's centres

Socialist Party workplace news

Probation officers to take on 'failing Grayling'

Time for national action on education

Fight the Royal Mail sell-off

Blacklisting victory - now build union strength

Workplace news In Brief


Home   |   The Socialist 16 October 2013   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate   |   PDF  |   ebook

Related links:


triangleNew Zealand mosque terror atrocity

triangleJavid's migrant 'emergency'

triangleThousands march against racism - now Corbyn and unions must take lead

triangleJoin the fight for refugee rights

triangleLambeth Socialist Party: Immigration - a socialist perspective from Italy


triangleUnite against terrorism, racism, war and austerity

triangleObituary - Bob Lee: 1954 - 2019

triangleBlack Liberation... Only possible through socialist struggle

triangleHackney Socialist Party: How socialists & trade unionists can fight racism


triangleCapitalism fails NHS services in Liverpool: scrap PFI!

triangleCardiff East Socialist Party: NHS in crisis

triangleBuild for strikes to save NHS


triangleThe Socialist inbox

triangleNorthern Ireland: Thousands of nurses continue to strike for better pay


triangleUnite regional committee votes to support anti-cuts Enfield councillor


triangleMassive Scottish independence demo marks new stage in struggle

News and socialist analysis

News and socialist analysis



Council cuts continue... So must the fightback



To win back working-class trust Labour must take the 'Liverpool road'


Them & Us

Them & Us



End climate change, end inequality, end capitalism!



Protesting is not terrorism



Reverse Unison's undemocratic nomination of Blairite Starmer



Build for strikes to save NHS


Labour leadership

Labour Party leadership contest: Fight for a mass anti-austerity, workers' party with a socialist programme



No free ride for the airline bosses - nationalise Flybe now!


Them & Us

Them & Us


Minimum wage

Low Pay, Long Hours. Bosses rip us off. Organise the fightback now!



Ignore the hype - austerity goes on: organise to resist



Capitalism must go - fight for socialism


Minimum wage

Tory minimum wage hike not enough


Labour leadership

Labour leadership election

triangleMore News and socialist analysis articles...

Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party
Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube



Phone our national office on 020 8988 8777


Locate your nearest Socialist Party branch Text your name and postcode to 07761 818 206

Regional Socialist Party organisers:

Eastern: 079 8202 1969

East Mids: 077 3797 8057

London: 020 8988 8786

North East: 078 4114 4890

North West 079 5437 6096

South West: 077 5979 6478

Southern: 078 3368 1910

Wales: 079 3539 1947

West Mids: 024 7655 5620

Yorkshire: 077 0671 0041



Alphabetical listing

January 2020