Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page:

From The Socialist newspaper, 22 January 2014

Bedroom tax loophole: Can legal tactics be effective?

Steve Score, East Midlands Socialist Party secretary

As reported in last week's Socialist, the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) has confirmed that tenants who have been continuously entitled to housing benefit since at least 1 January 1996, and who have occupied the same home since that date, are exempt from the bedroom tax. This is because of a flaw in the drafting of legislation.

It means that possibly 40,000 tenants and their families have suffered who didn't need to, many may have been forced to move or have even been evicted.

As the Socialist pointed out last week, Stephanie Bottrill who committed suicide because of the bedroom tax, would not have been liable if this loophole had been known about.

Tenants now need to appeal to recover the money they have had illegally docked from their housing benefit. Campaigners need to put pressure on councils to identify affected tenants, because otherwise tenants may be left unaware

Fair play to the people who discovered the loophole and every person affected now needs to be compensated.

But of course the bedroom tax should be scrapped completely and all of those affected by it should be compensated for what they have lost.

But the campaigning needs to be kept up because the DWP, referring to the loophole, threatens it "will however be taking steps to remedy this shortly."

Legal tactics are a useful and important part of any mass campaign. They were used for example in the successful campaign against Margaret Thatcher's poll tax.

Part of the strategy was to clog up the courts system with people who refused, or were unable to pay their poll tax (a single-rate tax on every adult). Millions of cases were held up.

"Mackenzie Friends"

The anti-poll tax campaigns went to court to provide assistance, and used a legal precedent to go into the courtroom with defendants to assist even when they were not trained lawyers.

Early in the campaign, a court in Leicester refused to recognise these "Mackenzie Friends". The decision was appealed, and as a result anyone who asked for a Mackenzie Friend had their cases adjourned for long periods while the appeal went through the system.

Sometimes legal loopholes can even be used by governments to extricate themselves from mass pressure.

In 1972, striking dockers were jailed because of the anti-union laws introduced by the then Tory Prime Minister, Ted Heath.

In response, preparations for a general strike started to build from below, pressurising the TUC to threaten one officially.

A legal loophole was then used as a means for the government to climb down without openly admitting the reason for their defeat: mass action.

The dockers were released after the intervention of an interesting and previously little-known figure called the "official solicitor" and a decision by the Law Lords to overturn the jailings on a legal technicality.

Successful legal tactics can be the by-product of mass campaigns. In fact the right to a Mackenzie Friend is still accepted in cases today, going far beyond the use of it in poll tax cases.

However, there is no substitute for building struggle with maximum involvement of working class people.

Various different tactics can and should be used at the same time, but ultimately it is the power of working class people that can defeat bad laws and governments.

This was the case with the poll tax, the organised refusal to pay was what defeated it and brought down Margaret Thatcher.

The bedroom tax campaigns will still need to be built to defend those threatened with eviction, and the struggle against the bedroom tax needs to be linked up to the wider struggles against this government and the system of capitalism that all the main parties defend.

The Trade Unionist and Socialist Coalition, which is standing candidates in May's local elections, says that councils should refuse to implement the bedroom tax. "Councils should write off all bedroom tax-related arrears, withdraw all court proceedings and eviction orders where the bedroom tax has been a factor, and call on housing associations to do the same."

If you agree, why not stand as a TUSC candidate?


Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.

In The Socialist 22 January 2014:

Socialist Party news and analysis

Real living wage now

Capitalism is a system in crisis

Pay me - I'm a banker!

What exactly is the point of Labour?

Stop the NHS sell-off

Bedroom tax loophole: Can legal tactics be effective?

Fracking - profiting from environmental destruction

Them & Us

International socialist news and analysis

Egypt referendum: no enthusiasm for new constitution

"Ireland is a success story" rhetoric is based on spin


Stop the student debt spiral - day of action 6 February

Youth Fight for Jobs campaign in Croydon

An open letter to Tristram Hunt

Socialist Party workplace news

Transport workers have power to defeat cuts

Teachers need a date for national action

Teachers strike against threatened redundancies

NUT strikes against management "observations"

More action needed to defend Probation Service

Publicity alone can't save sacked union branch official

Workplace news in brief

Socialist Party reports and campaigns

Lincoln marches against racism and fascism

Protest against Atos 'assessments' on 19 February

Salford workers and environmentalists challenge council

Stop cuts in Kent

Carlisle petition

Readers' comments and reviews

Benefits Street: A caricature of poverty

Leeds' forgotten dispute: The 1913-14 Corporation Strike

Robert Burns, insurrectionary poet


Home   |   The Socialist 22 January 2014   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate   |   PDF  |   ebook

Related links:

Bedroom tax:

triangleThem & us

triangleHundreds turn out for rally aimed at removing west Wales Tory MP

triangleTories out! Corbyn can win with socialist policies

triangleWhy I joined: "I am a Labour Party member and I recently decided to join the Socialist Party"

triangleCourt win against bedroom tax not enough


triangleBristol South Socialist Party: The battle that defeated the Poll Tax

triangleCaerphilly & RCT Socialist Party: The fight against the poll tax

triangleCardiff East Socialist Party: How we beat the Poll Tax

triangleTurn Carillion crisis into movement against privatisation and capitalism


triangleButterfields tenants join TUSC campaign

triangleGrenfell: survivors not rehoused, inquiry not independent, blocks not safe

triangleLeeds Socialist Party: Organising tenants in the private rented sector

Poll tax:

triangleCardiff Central Socialist Party: Carillion collapse - Watershed moment for public services

triangleCardiff West Socialist Party: How the Poll Tax was beaten

News and socialist analysis

News and socialist analysis



Enoch Powell's racist 'Rivers of Blood' rant 50 years on


Them & Us

Them & Us



Billions for the bosses, benefit cuts for us



1,400 beds empty as patients lay in corridors: health unions must act now



Young people need homes



For a fighting, democratic Labour Party



A socialist approach to Corbyn and a customs union


Child poverty

Child poverty to hit 5m by 2021 - strikes can stop the cuts


Equal pay

Gender pay gap figures show need for trade union action


Young people

Alienation and austerity behind London deaths - fight for socialism



Fight the Tory enemy


Northern Ireland

Northern Ireland: peace process on the brink



Right-wing Vote Leave campaign may have broken spending laws



Retail crunch: even giants not immune as 21,000 jobs disappear



End the housing crisis! We can't wait till 2022!

triangleMore News and socialist analysis articles...

Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party
Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube



Phone our national office on 020 8988 8777


Locate your nearest Socialist Party branch Text your name and postcode to 07761 818 206

Regional Socialist Party organisers:

Eastern: 0798 202 1969

East Mids: 0773 797 8057

London: 020 8988 8786

North East: 0784 114 4890

North West 07769 611 320

South East: 020 8988 8777

South West: 07759 796 478

Southern: 07833 681910

Wales: 07935 391 947

West Mids: 02476 555 620

Yorkshire: 0114 264 6551



Alphabetical listing

April 2018

March 2018

February 2018

January 2018