Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page: https://www.socialistparty.org.uk/issue/850/20416

From The Socialist newspaper, 1 April 2015

Save our schools!

Haringey protest against academy school change, photo Paul Mattsson

Haringey protest against academy school change, photo Paul Mattsson   (Click to enlarge)

Education will be a vital question on people's minds in the general election and local elections on 7 May. But most voters will have very different priorities from the Tory-Liberal Democrat coalition government.

Students at school will be asking if they will be able to afford to go to university, where they are charged sky-high fees, with the prospect of massive debts. Students in further education no longer get the help provided by the Education Maintenance Allowance, abolished by the Con-Dems. In adult education swingeing cuts are now putting it at risk of total extinction.

Parents, students and teachers want places in good schools with well-trained and well-paid teachers. They will be demanding free, publicly run, good quality education for people of all ages.

But the main parties have different priorities. The Tories want 500 more 'Free Schools' set up in England. They all want more Academies. While neither of these is meant to directly make a profit, they are a step towards privatisation. They break schools from local authority control and import business into the running of schools.

The capitalist parties ignore issues such as lack of resources, poverty and the advantages of co-operation between schools. They want to 'open up' education to private investment. They want to downsize and restructure it, turning public education into a marketplace. They want to diminish the power of the unions and scapegoat teachers for problems in education and society.

The unnecessary and callous policies of cuts and austerity are part of this plan. The Socialist Party says there is an alternative to this capitalist catastrophe and is part of the Trade Unionist and Socialist Coalition (TUSC) which is standing hundreds of candidates in the general election and local council elections.

We proudly offer socialist solutions to the problems faced by schools, their teachers, students and parents.

■ The Trade Unionist and Socialist Coalition (TUSC) national steering committee has endorsed the Manifesto for Education produced by the largest teachers' union in England and Wales, the National Union of Teachers (NUT). Four members of the union's national executive committee will be standing as TUSC candidates in May's elections


  • TUSC 2015 election campaign website
  • TUSC website

  • Labour cannot defend education

    The Mail and Telegraph are trying to alarm Tory voters by claiming that a future Labour government would return academies (begun under Labour Prime Minister Tony Blair) to local authority control. If only! That, unfortunately, just isn't their plan at all.

    While the NUT manifesto rightly demands: "Return oversight of all state funded schools to local authorities", New Labour policy has something very different in mind as Jane Nellist (Coventry NUT) reports.


    School students and teachers protest against academies at Tile Hill Wood school in Coventry , photo Coventry Socialist Party

    School students and teachers protest against academies at Tile Hill Wood school in Coventry , photo Coventry Socialist Party   (Click to enlarge)

    The Con-Dem government is damaging children's education. Their attacks on pay, conditions and pensions demoralise school staff. Excessive testing and divisive league tables drive enjoyment out of education for staff and students alike.

    With the general election just weeks away and Labour struggling in the polls, you might think Labour would seize on teachers' demoralisation and staff, students and parents' anger and create a manifesto with clear policies. People in education hope for policies that at least begin to reverse these damaging attacks.

    But every time Labour's education spokesperson Tristram Hunt opens his mouth he antagonises teachers with statements and suggested policies that fail to address the real issues and some that will even exacerbate conditions in schools.

    At a recent conference, instead of pledging to end 'Free Schools' he suggested "parents, teachers, businesses and voluntary groups set up schools in areas of need". He wants foreign education "innovators" to open up schools.

    Well thanks Tristram for showing faith in our schools! It's as bad as handing over education to carpet sellers, car salesmen and other millionaires!

    The Labour Party website has plenty of rhetoric but very little substantial about education. If you look at Labour's 'Blunkett Review' published last year, you start to worry. He says: "Academies are here to stay and we need to build on this landscape".

    Blunkett, who was the Education Minister that planted the seeds of many of our problems today and created a teacher shortage, said that there is a "need to ensure that properly qualified teachers 'oversee' the learning process". That 'oversight' is a very different commitment to the one that parents and teachers seek.

    Labour simply hopes to somehow manage this fragmented landscape by introducing "Directors of School Standards" to oversee school provision.

    However, unlike local authorities, they would be appointed, not elected. Why not simply bring all schools under a local education authority - that actually worked in the past!

    Teachers are desperate for policies to mend our damaged education system and provide us with better working conditions. Parents would back us on this.

    But Labour gives no sign that it can do so. Shadow education secretary Tristram Hunt does not have the courage to listen to teachers. Instead he keeps treading the dangerous path of 'marketisation' of our education service. Labour is no alternative.


    Ukip's grammar slip

    Derek McMillan

    Our local UKIP candidate in Worthing is calling for "a grammar school in every town." There are problems with this. It would mean taking any power away from local authorities to decide schooling policy. You would get a grammar school whether you like it or not.

    Secondly, in neighbouring Kent parents send their children over the border to the maligned comprehensive schools of West Sussex because they didn't pass the eleven plus and so are not allowed into the glittering grammar schools.

    There is no evidence that grammar schools improve the results for pupils excluded from them; but a wealth of evidence that tests which differentiate children at 11 are not confirmed by subsequent tests and are biased towards white middle class pupils. Like the policies of all the capitalist parties, this policy is not based on any consultation with teachers.


    Fight back against academies

    Lewisham teachers striking against academisation, March 2015

    Lewisham teachers striking against academisation, March 2015   (Click to enlarge)

    Martin Powell-Davies TUSC candidate in Lewisham West and Penge and secretary of Lewisham National Union of Teachers (NUT)

    As in many other areas, Lewisham's education is at risk. Governors at three schools, Prendergast schools at Hilly Fields, Ladywell Fields and the Vale, want to turn them all into academies. If these schools convert, others could soon follow.

    This government aims to steal away public services from elected local authorities across the country and vowed to put 'rocket-boosters' under the academies programme started under Labour. In some places, this has already led to the break-up of local schooling into different academy employers. In others there is resistance. We are fighting back in Lewisham.

    The NUT, NASUWT and GMB unions locally have taken joint strike action. In just a few months, our campaign has also included marches, student protests and public meetings. Even the governors admit academies are 'unproven' but are pressing ahead with a 'consultation' to try and convert the schools quickly. Parents and local residents must act fast to make the governors think again.

    If the governors are so sure of their arguments, why won't they agree to a ballot of parents on our schools' future? Maybe they know the facts show their plans are wrong! Our campaign highlights what the facts really say about academies.

    Don't academy schools give children a better education?

    No. "Current evidence does not prove that academies raise standards overall or for disadvantaged children", said the All-Party Select Committee of MPs in January 2015.

    Won't converting to an academy improve our exam results?

    No. "The rate of improvement in GCSE results in Local Authority secondaries was twice that of converter academies," said Ofsted's Annual Report for 2013/14

    Won't schools be better-off if they convert into academies?

    No. "There is no funding advantage to being an academy" says the Prendergast governors' report on the school website.

    Aren't academies better than non-academy 'maintained' schools at supporting students from all backgrounds?

    No. "Converter Academies, on average, take far less than their fair share of disadvantaged pupils. They aren't helping increase social justice in education". Professor Gorard, quoted in the Prendergast governors' own report

    Won't becoming an academy "secure greater accountability" for staff and parents?

    No. "Parents are sidelined from all important decisions, over whether schools convert in the first place, and over how they're run once they become academies" said a parent witness to January's All-Party Select Committee Report.

    Can academies be trusted to act fairly when given control of admissions policies?

    No. "Charter School (an academy in Dulwich) has been criticised for setting its catchment area to exclude children from two council estates with the risk of skewing its intake" said a Guardian report on Schools Adjudicator, 2012.

    Can we trust giving academy governors control over school budgets?

    No. "Nearly half of academy trusts have paid millions of pounds in public money towards the private businesses of directors, trustees and relatives," said the National Audit Office, 2014

    Our campaign is determined to stop these plans but the next government must act nationally. We need all academies brought back into the hands of genuinely democratic local authorities so that parents, staff and the local community can work and plan together to ensure every child receives the education they need and deserve.

    And schools' staff, parents, governors and local communities should have direct representation on the bodies making decisions about local education provision, not just politicians.


    We pay for their dividends

    Haringey protest against academy school, photo Paul Mattsson

    Haringey protest against academy school, photo Paul Mattsson   (Click to enlarge)

    Education can be a very profitable business - for the rich. GEMS Education is a top ranking international education business. It runs private schools in Britain and has been involved in academies and bidding to run free schools.

    In a glorified advert, Investing with GEMS, they say "In 2010, the world's top ten global education companies generated over US$26 billion in revenue. Education, like the health sector, is a 'counter-cyclical' sector, performing well even in recession."

    GEMS says in their experience, "education projects should generate an IRR (internal rate of return) of 15% to 30%". Such blatant private profit seekers are pushing the educational counter-reforms of today. We suffer for their dividends.

    480 private supply teaching agencies are mostly competing in a race to the bottom to underpay teachers. A school may pay 150 to the agency while the teacher is paid perhaps 75 to 100. One of Britain's largest teaching agencies Teaching Personnel has reported 7.5 million profit on a 50 million income.


    The Socialist Party demands

    Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.


    In The Socialist 1 April 2015:


    Socialist Party news and analysis

    No cuts to welfare!

    Save our schools

    How to fight the anti-union laws

    NHS funding crisis deepens

    End punitive benefit sanctions now!

    Them & Us


    International socialist news and analysis

    South Africa: campaigning for a working class party

    Greece: negotiations continue

    US: Seattle gets a raise!

    Solidarity with Cypriot workers

    Tunisia: thousands demonstrate


    Elections 2015

    Kick out rotten MPs and councillors

    TUSC set for TV broadcast

    School crossing campaigner stands for TUSC

    Gloucester College hustings: Scrap all fees

    Defend further education

    Socialist Party general election appeal 2015


    Socialist Party workplace news

    Teachers need national action

    Unison special conference votes for new pay claim

    London bus companies forced into pay talks

    Bolton Uni: reinstate Damien and Jenny Markey!

    Leeds: Save our train guards

    Workplace news in brief


    Socialist Party youth and students

    Students occupy for free education


    Socialist Party comments and reviews

    Election 2015 Cameron and Miliband Live

    Axing Clause IV: Making Labour safe for capitalism

    Working in the NHS: Low pay, cuts and stress

    The Great Money Trick: Another World is Possible

    The new look Socialist - thumbs up from readers


     

    Home   |   The Socialist 1 April 2015   |   Join the Socialist Party

    Subscribe   |   Donate   |   PDF  |   ebook






    Related links:

    Schools:

    triangleVictory: how school strike beat 'academy' privatisers

    triangleKeith Morrell, anti-cuts councillor, re-elected

    triangleVictory against academisation

    triangleChild poverty to hit 5m by 2021 - strikes can stop the cuts

    triangleNEU conference: Teachers vote to strike over pay and workload

    Labour:

    triangleTories prepare for possible snap election

    triangleStudent leaders claim one million on the streets against Brexit - fight for a workers' exit

    triangleAntisemitism, Israel-Palestine, & the left

    triangleChesterfield May Day: march turnout great

    Academies:

    triangleSchool strike forces head to say privatisation will stop

    triangleCampaign against academies boosted by victories

    triangleFor Whom the School Bell Tolls: Our kids or the Tories?

    Education:

    triangleHow 'Prevent' training fosters racist paranoia

    triangleCollege staff caught between the devil and the deep blue sea

    Teachers:

    triangle30 years on from Section 28: the legacy of fighting LGBT+ attacks must continue

    Parents:

    triangleParents and campaigners protest Leeds disability travel cut

    School:

    triangleAvenue School strikers and parents win judicial review

    Students:

    triangleStop Trump! Build for 13 July student walkouts

    Children:

    triangleAction demanded from new council

    NUT:

    triangleNEU conference 2018: Strike to take on the Tories

    TUSC:

    triangleMay 3 elections: the TUSC results report

    Union:

    triangleFirst ever strike at TGI Fridays

    Lewisham:

    triangleYoung people trapped in private rental

    Free Schools:

    triangleSchools and teaching: A perfect storm of cuts, underfunding, excessive workloads and low pay

    Trade Unionist and Socialist Coalition:

    triangleTUSC stands against Birmingham council's cuts and attacks on workers

    News and socialist analysis

    News and socialist analysis

    23/5/18

    Rail

    Government continues to back failed private rail

    23/5/18

    Ebola

    New Ebola threat

    23/5/18

    Homelessness

    Homeless charity colluding to deport homeless!

    23/5/18

    General election

    Tories prepare for possible snap election

    23/5/18

    Ireland

    Youthful enthusiasm to break with repression of past

    23/5/18

    Housing

    Capitalism's Grenfell shame - Tories must go

    23/5/18

    Refugees

    Support refugees rights

    21/5/18

    Antisemitism

    Antisemitism, Israel-Palestine, & the left

    17/5/18

    PCS

    Threat to unity of PCS left

    16/5/18

    Super-rich

    Richest worth 724bn... as 100,000 kids fall into poverty

    16/5/18

    Monarchy

    Royal wedding opulence... during longest pay squeeze in 200 years

    16/5/18

    Brexit

    Tories' continuing EU quagmire is Corbyn's opportunity

    15/5/18

    Gaza

    Stop the Israeli state slaughter!

    15/5/18

    Middle East

    Middle East in crisis

    15/5/18

    PCS

    PCS conference 2018: building on the union's militant record

    triangleMore News and socialist analysis articles...


    Join the Socialist Party
    Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
    Donate to the Socialist Party
    Socialist Party Facebook page
    Socialist Party on Twitter
    Visit us on Youtube

    LATEST POSTS

    CONTACT US

    Phone our national office on 020 8988 8777

    Email: info@socialistparty.org.uk

    Locate your nearest Socialist Party branch Text your name and postcode to 07761 818 206

    Regional Socialist Party organisers:

    Eastern: 0798 202 1969

    East Mids: 0773 797 8057

    London: 020 8988 8786

    North East: 0784 114 4890

    North West 07769 611 320

    South East: 020 8988 8777

    South West: 07759 796 478

    Southern: 07833 681910

    Wales: 07935 391 947

    West Mids: 02476 555 620

    Yorkshire: 0114 264 6551

    ABOUT US

    ARCHIVE

    Alphabetical listing


    May 2018

    April 2018

    March 2018

    February 2018

    January 2018

    2017

    2016

    2015

    2014

    2013

    2012

    2011

    2010

    2009

    2008

    2007

    2006

    2005

    2004

    2003

    2002

    2001

    2000

    1999