Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page: https://www.socialistparty.org.uk/issue/1065/29914

From The Socialist newspaper, 20 November 2019

Save the NHS: kick out the Tories

Striking junior doctors in 2016, photo Paul Mattsson

Striking junior doctors in 2016, photo Paul Mattsson   (Click to enlarge)

Although the Tories wanted to make this the 'Brexit election', the NHS remains a vital issue - in some polls it comes out as the most important issue in the election. A publicly owned, funded and controlled National Health Service meant to provide free health care for all is one of the most important gains in the last 70 years.

But the NHS is in crisis. After high alerts even during the quieter summer months, some hospitals are now declaring "black alerts" - now called 'Opel 4' - where demand for services exceeds the ability of the hospital trust to supply them. Hospital waiting lists are at an all-time high of 4.6 million, 34,000 cancer patients are waiting longer than two months for treatment.

Steve Score, Socialist Party national committee, exposes the Tories' lies, looks at Labour's approach and explains how a real socialist programme can save and develop the NHS.

Tory lies exposed

Boris Johnson claimed "we are the party of the NHS" at Tory Party conference, echoing Margaret Thatcher's "The NHS is safe in our hands", before she began a process of marketisation and privatisation that continues to this day.

Johnson claimed that they would build "40 new hospitals" in ten years. Previously the Tories claimed they will increase overall NHS spending by an extra 20.5 billion by 2024 and that spending on the NHS is "higher than ever".

But the "40 new hospitals" turned out to be a lie. It was in fact a release of capital funding for new buildings that had been held back, sometimes for years, by government-imposed austerity restrictions.

20.5 billion extra funding by 2024 is a less than average increase for the NHS over its existence and comes after years of underfunding. The average increase under the Tories has been 1.3% since 2010. But if you consider factors such as the growing and ageing population, as well as the costs of new technology, this is in fact a substantial real cut.

The Kings Fund estimates that the NHS needs long term growth of at least 4% a year and the average growth, under all governments, since its establishment in 1948 has been 3.7%.

There is a backlog of 6 billion for repairs and maintenance alone. Because of day-to-day underfunding of services and hospital trusts running huge deficits - a lot of money (Labour says 4 billion) that was meant to be spent on equipment and maintenance has gone into keeping services afloat by the transferring of funds from capital budgets.

The government claim to increase the number of GPs by 6,000 is unconvincing when the Tories made a similar claim in 2015 to increase by 5,000, and there are now 1,500 less!

There is a massive staffing crisis across the NHS, with a shortage of at least 100,000 of all staff, 40,000 of those are nursing posts. The lack of forward planning in training, the abolition of bursaries for student nurses, the high cost of tuition fees, low and frozen pay for staff, and huge levels of stress from overwork, all contribute to this crisis. NHS staff work one million hours a week in unpaid overtime.

Tory privatisation

Over their years in power the Tories have carried out, and continue to propose, reorganisations of the NHS which push in the direction of more privatisation. The NHS has been divided up. Over 200 'Clinical Commissioning Groups' (CCGs) were created, with 'providers' such as NHS hospital trusts, private companies and other organisations competing with each other to get contracts from the CCGs.

It took the competitive market approach a step further and brought increased privatisation. The unpopularity of privatisation with the public has forced the Tories to play it down, with health Secretary Matt Hancock promising "no more privatisation on my watch". It is of course another lie.

The language and focus of various plans have more recently been on "integration" of services including with social care. The latest bodies being proposed are 'Integrated Care Systems' or 'Integrated Care Providers'. It all sounds nice but, in reality, these are more bodies in the same competitive mold, with even less accountability.

Labour's record and Labour's programme

Labour has promised an increase in funding of 26 billion extra in England by 2023-24. (All these figures are for England with equivalent increases on top in Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland). This is a welcome start and better than the Labour promise in the last general election.

In addition, Labour promises to increase funding in mental health services that are in a dire position after years of drastic cuts, spend 15 billion capital spending on hospital buildings over five years, scrap prescription charges and hospital car parking charges and reinstate nursing bursaries.

Labour also promises to reverse the privatisation that has crippled the NHS for many years. This is also very welcome, especially because privatisation soared under previous Blairite Labour governments.

While Thatcher laid the groundwork by introducing the 'internal market' it was the Blair government that ramped up the 'Private Finance Initiative' schemes, continued by subsequent Tory governments, that handed over control to private companies and have cost the NHS dearly.

Blairite privatisation

Outsourcing of non-clinical services of all kinds to private companies has meant they extract profits from the NHS, and cut staffing and service quality in order to increase them. Often these companies have failed to do the job, forcing hospitals to take services back in-house. This has taken place under governments led by all three main parties.

It was under Blairite governments that, using the excuse that waiting lists couldn't be quickly reduced any other way, that some operations (the cheapest and easiest ones) were handed out to private hospitals, again at the cost of the NHS. This has led to a blossoming of those companies and a shift of staff and resources away from the NHS.

Now, after years of cuts, the number of procedures carried out by private companies is rocketing. There were 613,000 people treated in private hospitals last year, three times the number nine years earlier.

Massive cuts in the funding of social care have a huge impact on the NHS, with long delays in elderly patients being discharged from hospital for example, because the care services are not available. The excuse given by NHS management for not increasing the number of beds in line with a growing and ageing population is that more patients will be helped at home, yet nothing is done to make that possible. To solve the NHS crisis, proper provision and funding of social care is vital.

Labour has promised to provide free personal care for those with the most severe needs, which is much needed. But that will require a massive reversal of the cuts made to local council budgets over many years.

Whether the NHS is 'up for sale' has been part of the election debate. Labour has pointed to the discussions between Boris Johnson and Donald Trump about a possible trade deal with the US after leaving the EU. Trump first made comments implying the NHS would be "on the table" then later denied it.

At the moment, big US companies can bid for NHS contracts only if they have a subsidiary based inside the EU. As part of a new trade deal, access for those companies could be made easier. Although the real issue is to end privatisation full stop, whatever the country of origin of the companies. The truth is that the NHS is already 'up for sale' and has been for a long time.

What could also be a threat in a new trade deal could be regulations allowing US pharmaceutical companies to charge the NHS higher prices for its drugs. Labour says that the drugs bill for the NHS could rise from 18 billion a year currently to 45 billion.

In Britain, the NHS is able to use its monopoly position to negotiate on drug prices, advised by the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. If it was a totally 'free market', as in the US, prices would be even higher. Any deal involving an increase in costs to the NHS must be resisted.

But that drugs bill is already too high. It represents a huge draining of resources from the NHS into the profits of the big pharmaceutical companies. Patent rules allow companies a monopoly position on new drugs so that they can hugely hike their prices. Labour has proposed regulation changes and the establishment of a publicly owned manufacturer to help combat this (see Socialism Today, issue 233, November 2019).

How to defend and rebuild the NHS with a socialist programme

Piecemeal measures will not be enough to solve the crisis in the NHS. Piecemeal measures are inadequate to deal with the power of 'big pharma'. The Socialist Party proposes the nationalisation of the pharmaceutical industry to enable its integration into the NHS, improve research and development and allow the resources and profits of these companies to fully benefit patients.

On privatisation, shadow Chancellor John McDonnell has said that Labour would bring private contracts "back in-house" when they "come to an end", allowing privatisation to continue for some time. He may argue that time is needed to expand NHS services so that they can absorb the extra work. However, what is really needed is the rapid nationalisation of the bigger private companies, with compensation based only on proven need, to ensure their capacity is absorbed into the NHS.

Corbyn government

The election of a Corbyn-led Labour government would be a big step forward. But we also know that many of the Blairite Labour MPs voted in the past for cuts and privatisation. It will need a mass movement in support of the NHS to ensure their programme is carried out and that we get the improvements we need.

If there isn't a Labour government after this election, we will need that movement even more. Over the last few years there has been local strike action taken by different groups of workers in the NHS in defence of jobs and conditions as well as the NHS as a whole. We have seen national action by junior doctors as well. There have been many local campaigns established to fight particular cuts and closures. Some have successfully fought those attacks.

If a Tory or other variety of pro-big business government comes to power, we will need national action led by the trade unions in the NHS, and backed by the movement as a whole, linking up with the local campaigns through organisations like Health Campaigns Together.

The immediate task over the next few weeks is to fight for a Corbyn government. But there is no doubt that capitalism casts its greedy eye over national resources spent on the NHS. For big business, profit comes before everything.

We need a fully funded, fully publicly owned and genuinely free National Health service with democratic working-class control and management. Health is a vital human need and can only be secured by ending capitalism and replacing it with a socialist society.

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.


In The Socialist 20 November 2019:


What we think

High Court injunction: solidarity to the CWU

CWU - ground laid for an almighty struggle


Climate change

Major funding for flood risk management needed


NHS

Save the NHS: kick out the Tories

Frimley NHS Trust: Strikers remain determined to defeat privatisation


Violence against women

What policies are needed to end domestic violence and abuse?


Socialist Party news and analysis

Broadband: privatisation has failed to deliver, time for a socialist plan

Bolton university fire: government inaction puts safety at risk

Wages flatline, while shareholders profit


Workplace news and analysis

UCU pay and pension strike: university staff have had enough

West Midlands Trains: guards strike to defend safety-critical role

PCS union: elect Marion Lloyd!

Cleaners strike over low pay at Haringey secondary school

Bradford library and museum strikers enter third round of strike action

Long hours in the world of security

NEU members' sixth-form walkouts


Socialist Party reports and campaigns

Secret police infiltration of workers' movement exposed

150 protest against Leicester hospital downgrading attack

Carmarthenshire union demands no-cuts budget

Swansea: students protest against Hillary Clinton hypocrisy

Keep the National Poetry Library free

Selling the Socialist


Readers' opinion

The Socialist Inbox


International socialist news and analysis

Amazon bosses defeated in Seattle - Kshama Sawant reelected

Chile revolt continues: read eyewitness report


 

Home   |   The Socialist 20 November 2019   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate   |   Audio  |   PDF  |   ebook






Related links:

NHS:

triangleEnd profiteering from health - nationalise big pharma

triangleNews in brief

triangleWorkplace news in brief

triangleNorthern Ireland: strike action by NHS workers

triangle150 protest against Leicester hospital downgrading attack

Tories:

triangleTrump and Tories are a threat to environment

triangleTories launch 'non manifesto'

triangleSixth-form college strikes: 'Sticking two fingers up at the Tories'

triangleStevenage Socialist Party: Kick out the Tories!

Labour:

triangleSwansea: Corbyn rally attracts turnout but many can't get in

trianglePrepare now for the struggles after 12 December

trianglePlymouth Blairites side with anti-tenant landlords

Privatisation:

triangleFrimley NHS Trust: Strikers remain determined to defeat privatisation

triangleBroadband: privatisation has failed to deliver, time for a socialist plan

Health:

triangleNorthern Ireland: Health workers take action over understaffing and pay equality

Hospitals:

triangleLeicester campaigns to save our NHS

Election:

triangleClimate change election debate - Corbyn offers best green solutions but needs to go further

News and socialist analysis

News and socialist analysis

4/12/19

Pharmaceutical

End profiteering from health - nationalise big pharma

4/12/19

Labour

Prepare now for the struggles after 12 December

4/12/19

The Socialist

Keep up to date with our election coverage

4/12/19

NHS

News in brief

4/12/19

Hillsborough

Hillsborough justice eluded

30/11/19

London

Unite against terrorism, racism, war and austerity

27/11/19

Northern Ireland

Northern Ireland: strike action by NHS workers

27/11/19

University

Resist attacks against free speech on campus

27/11/19

Council

End council cuts now, to end Tory austerity!

27/11/19

Tories

Tories launch 'non manifesto'

27/11/19

Labour

Labour's manifesto: fight to transform hope into a socialist society

27/11/19

Monarchy

Prince Andrew outrage exposes establishment

27/11/19

Tory

Tory election campaign's dirty tricks and lies

20/11/19

Wages

Wages flatline, while shareholders profit

20/11/19

Internet

Broadband: privatisation has failed to deliver, time for a socialist plan

triangleMore News and socialist analysis articles...


Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party
Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube

LATEST POSTS

CONTACT US

Phone our national office on 020 8988 8777

Email: info@socialistparty.org.uk

Locate your nearest Socialist Party branch Text your name and postcode to 07761 818 206

Regional Socialist Party organisers:

Eastern: 0798 202 1969

East Mids: 0773 797 8057

London: 020 8988 8786

North East: 0784 114 4890

North West 07954 376 096

South East: 020 8988 8777

South West: 07759 796 478

Southern: 07833 681910

Wales: 07935 391 947

West Mids: 02476 555 620

Yorkshire: 0114 264 6551

ABOUT US

ARCHIVE

Alphabetical listing


December 2019

November 2019

October 2019

September 2019

August 2019

July 2019

June 2019

May 2019

April 2019

March 2019

February 2019

January 2019

2018

2017

2016

2015

2014

2013

2012

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999