Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page: https://www.socialistparty.org.uk/issue/1098/31172

From The Socialist newspaper, 19 August 2020

75 years since the publication of Animal Farm

From 'two legs bad' to 'two legs better'

The revolutionary animals face down the farmer in the 1954 Halas and Batchelor adaptation of Animal Farm

The revolutionary animals face down the farmer in the 1954 Halas and Batchelor adaptation of Animal Farm   (Click to enlarge)

James Ivens

George Orwell first conceived of "exposing" what he called "the Soviet myth" with "a story that could be easily understood by almost anyone" in 1937. He had narrowly escaped Stalinism's murderous repression of his fellow revolutionaries in the dying days of the Spanish Civil War.

The result, published on 17 August 1945, was 'Animal Farm: A Fairy Story'. Orwell had finished it in February 1944, but no publisher wanted to touch it while British capitalism was still allied with Stalinism during World War Two.

The advent of the Cold War made satires of the Soviet Union acceptable - even necessary - to the establishment. In fact, in 1950, the year Orwell died, Britain's Foreign Office adapted Animal Farm into counter-revolutionary newspaper cartoons in Burma and Brazil. He would likely have been horrified.

The 1954 animated feature was funded by the CIA. And reflecting the collapse of Stalinism, the 1999 TV film inverted Animal Farm's message entirely, ending with a restoration of capitalism under fairy-tale 'nice' farm owners. But what does Orwell's fable actually say about revolution?

Animalist revolution

The working animals of "the Manor Farm" in England suffer enormous hardship at the hands of their drunken, bullying ruler, the farmer Mr Jones. The respected elder boar, Old Major - a composite of authoritative Marxist theoreticians - explains their woes are caused by human exploitation.

Decadent human mismanagement provokes a spontaneous uprising for fodder. Patient explanation of the tenets of "Animalism" by the intelligent pigs has allowed "the Rebellion" to blossom from it - an insurrectionary seizure of the farm. Its leaders are the visionary Snowball, representing Leon Trotsky, and the brutish Napoleon - Joseph Stalin.

The animals abolish all the old inequalities and barbarities. But little by little, their revolutionary principles are diluted, then betrayed. The novella leaves the working animals, hungry and brutalised once more, looking "from pig to man, and from man to pig, and from pig to man again; but already it was impossible to say which was which."

As a satire of one of history's greatest treacheries, it still packs a punch. Each injustice is made all the more stinging by the innocent style of a children's story. The poignancy of the final betrayal of Boxer, the Rebellion's most self-sacrificing workhorse, is almost unbearable.

The excesses and absurdity of the Stalinist bureaucracy are often hilarious. And Orwell's recurrent theme of political falsification (which reaches its apex in his next novel, 'Nineteen Eighty-Four') even receives its own character, in the pigs' propagandist, Squealer.

Animal Farm is remarkable for how many parallels with real episodes and ideas it crams into its short word count. But that's not to say Orwell exercises no licence. Many key events and figures appear out of order, conflated, or without their proper context.

Some of this is inevitable and necessary in an allegory, of course. The trouble comes - as Orwell himself might have warned - when events are recast to suit ideas, rather than vice versa.

Orwell explained in a letter in December 1946: "I meant that that kind of revolution (violent conspiratorial revolution, led by unconsciously power-hungry people) can only lead to a change of masters... I think the whole process was foreseeable... from the very nature of the Bolshevik Party." It is worth considering these accusations in turn.

First, violence. Orwell himself wrote in his 1941 manifesto for revolution in Britain, 'The Lion and the Unicorn', that "revolution does not mean red flags and street fighting, it means a fundamental shift of power. Whether it happens with or without bloodshed is largely an accident of time and place."

In fact, diligent organisation and overwhelming social weight can counter the power of "accident." This is why the October 1917 Petrograd insurrection was almost bloodless.

But the workers and masses, grasping for a way out of war, poverty and oppression, did face violent opposition from the old elite both before and after. Orwell understood the need to fight back in those circumstances, having done so in Catalonia.

Second, conspiracy. The Russian revolution was a mass movement, not some palace coup. The Bolsheviks came to lead it by arguing openly for their ideas, including in the workers' councils elected from below to coordinate that mass movement - the 'soviets'.

Orwell mixes praise for workers' potential for power and democratic debate with some ambivalence about their capacity to control events. The animals do hold mass meetings to decide policy, but in practice are always subordinate to the clever pigs.

Despite their power, therefore, Animal Farm quite wrongly depicts the workers as just too dense to resist Napoleon's abuses. "Several of them would have protested if they could have found the right arguments." Orwell means this as a warning, but it's hard not to feel some pessimism behind it too.

Third, that political degeneration was "foreseeable" in the "unconsciously power-hungry... Bolshevik Party." This is Orwell's fundamental error, running throughout Animal Farm.

Stalinism's roots

It suggests that Stalinism was inherent from the start due to some 'original sin' in the psychology of Bolshevism. On the contrary, Lenin, Trotsky and thousands of worker Bolsheviks fought - to the death in many cases - against encroaching bureaucracy and for workers' democracy.

But from the off, Animal Farm's pigs lust for power and material privilege - Snowball included. Orwell's 1946 letter also states that "the turning-point of the story was supposed to be when the pigs kept the milk and apples for themselves." This was during a time of peace and plenty on the farm.

In fact, bureaucratic privileges only developed over time and under conditions of war-torn scarcity. The best revolutionaries, including Lenin and Trotsky, consistently stood for abolishing privileges of office.

So what does explain the political decay of the Russian revolution? The landlords and capitalists had proven unable to bring Russia's economy and society fully into the 20th century. They dragged things back still further with years of imperialist war and then civil war. And the defeat of revolutions in industrialised Europe left the fledgling workers' state without help.

As Trotsky explained in 'The Revolution Betrayed': "When there are enough goods in a store, the purchasers can come whenever they want to... When the lines are very long, it is necessary to appoint a policeman to keep order. Such is the starting point of the power of the Soviet bureaucracy."

Marxists analyse the material and social forces that drive epic conflicts of politics and ideas. Orwell too often reduced these conflicts to psychological defects and personality clashes, as if ideas exist independently of the outside world.

Nonetheless, he does sketch some of the fundamental differences between Trotskyism and Stalinism - albeit, unavoidably, in caricature. When Animal Farm is threatened by a new invasion, Napoleon's proposal is to "procure firearms." Snowball wants to "stir up rebellion among the animals on the other farms."

Trotsky never denied the need for armed defence. He had organised the Red Army. But what Orwell depicts here is Bolshevism's consistent internationalist outlook. Lenin and Trotsky explained that whatever the setbacks, this was the only way to complete the socialist revolution - and make it permanent.

But the demoralising defeat of the first workers' revolutions beyond Russia led to hesitant outlooks among other Bolshevik leaders, such as Stalin. This process culminated in the notorious theory of 'socialism in one country', a complete reversal of Lenin and Trotsky's politics.

At the same time, "the animals formed themselves into two factions under the slogans 'Vote for Snowball and the three-day week' and 'Vote for Napoleon and the full manger'." But why?

The Bolshevik government had its roots among industrial workers. But Russia's working class was overwhelmed in numbers by the peasantry, which sometimes had different economic needs and interests.

Trotsky's supporters saw developing industry - Animal Farm's windmill - as the way to satisfy the peasants' needs and raise the general standard of living. This was in anticipation of economic and social support from revolutions in advanced capitalist countries.

But the bureaucracy crystallising around Stalin, short-sighted and conservative, again resorted to stopgaps, placating top peasants by letting them keep more and more wealth. This short-termism led to political zigzags later.

Orwell's moral

George Orwell was an astute observer of human personalities and politics. His works, however, tend to conceive of social class simply as upper, middle, and lower, without further distinction. Nor does Animal Farm hint at more organic, conflicting social trends. Political differences seem merely the whims of rival party intellectuals.

So if Orwell contends the Bolshevik Party was the problem, what was the alternative? Only the existence of an organised leadership, ready to fight to the end, with roots in the working animals, could achieve what it did. Uprisings convulse surrounding farms after the Rebellion, but they fail. Perhaps they wanted for Animalist parties to channel outbursts of rebellious spirit into animals taking power.

But despite the capitalists' distortions, Orwell still stood for workers' revolution. The animals do experience huge benefits after chasing out their exploiters. "I meant the moral to be that revolutions only effect a radical improvement when the masses are alert and know how to chuck out their leaders as soon as the latter have done their job."

It is wrong to conclude that leaders, or parties, or revolution itself is the problem - the issue is democratic workers' control. Orwell was right then, and is right now, that an active and critical working class is the best safeguard against socialist degeneration.

Further reading

Donate to the Socialist Party

Coronavirus crisis - Finance appeal

The coronavirus crisis has laid bare the class character of society in numerous ways. It is making clear to many that it is the working class that keeps society running, not the CEOs of major corporations.

The results of austerity have been graphically demonstrated as public services strain to cope with the crisis.

The government has now ripped up its 'austerity' mantra and turned to policies that not long ago were denounced as socialist. But after the corona crisis, it will try to make the working class pay for it, by trying to claw back what has been given.

  • The Socialist Party's material is more vital than ever, so we can continue to report from workers who are fighting for better health and safety measures, against layoffs, for adequate staffing levels, etc.
  • Our 'fighting coronavirus workers' charter', outlines a programme to combat the virus and protect workers' living conditions.
  • When the health crisis subsides, we must be ready for the stormy events ahead and the need to arm workers' movements with a socialist programme - one which puts the health and needs of humanity before the profits of a few.
Inevitably, during the crisis we have not been able to sell the Socialist and raise funds in the ways we normally would.
We therefore urgently appeal to all our viewers to donate to our special coronavirus appeal.

Please donate here.

All payments are made through a secure server.

My donation

 

Your message: 

 


In The Socialist 19 August 2020:


Socialist Party news and analysis

Students 2 : 0 Tories - Protests work!

Student protests force government retreat

"As a working-class student, I already faced struggles"

Tory track and trace failure

Tory planning deregulation: a charter for building profitable slums

NHS workers demand improved pay - 15% for all now!


International socialist news and analysis

Revolutionary mood in Lebanon following horrific explosion

Mass protests and strikes rock Belarus


Leon Trotsky

80th anniversary of Leon Trotsky's assassination

Yorkshire: Celebrating the life and ideas of Leon Trotsky


Education

September school return must be safe for all workers and students


NHS pay

NHS pay: unions must take fight to U-turn Tories


Socialist history

75 years since the publication of Animal Farm: From 'two legs bad' to 'two legs better'


Workplace news and analysis

300 Covid cases at Northampton food plant - management to blame, not the workers!

PCS union: Vote Yes in DWP ballot! Reject longer opening hours

Support the Tower Hamlets council workers, vote for Hugo Pierre!


Socialist Party reports and campaigns

Black Lives Matter: this generation is willing to stand up and fight

We can't take any more cuts

Nottingham: oppose the far right and attempts to divide us

Your donations help us campaign

Leeds: Little London residents are celebrating

To push change we need to be organised - why we joined the Socialist Party

Sheffield: Support Sue

Brighton: Another luxury development

The Socialist: back to weekly soon


 

Home   |   The Socialist 19 August 2020   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate   |   Audio  |   PDF  |   ebook






Related links:

George Orwell:

triangle70 years since the publication of Nineteen Eighty-Four: "But if there was hope, it lay in the proles"

triangleBarcelona May Days 1937 - a civil war within a civil war

triangleBooks that inspired me

Revolution:

triangle80th anniversary of Leon Trotsky's assassination

triangleCuba: Covid-19 and the 60-year-old embargo

triangle100 years since the foundation of the Communist Party of Great Britain

triangleReform or revolt? How was the slave trade abolished?

Trotsky:

triangleTrotsky online rally - watched across the world

triangleBristol North Socialist Party: Revolutionary leader Trotsky murdered 80 years ago

Stalinism:

triangleBirmingham Socialist Party: The collapse of stalinism

triangleYork Socialist Party: Tito and Stalinism in the former Yugoslavia

Russian revolution:

triangleHackney & Islington Socialist Party: The Russian Revolution's 'July Days'

Reviews and comments

Reviews and comments

14/10/20

Obituary

Obituary: Raph Parkinson 1958-2020

14/10/20

Letters

The Socialist Inbox

14/10/20

Labour Party

Non-fiction: This Land - the story of a movement

14/10/20

Education

Students speak out: isolation and uncertainty reign

7/10/20

Letters

The Socialist Inbox

7/10/20

Racism

Non-fiction: 'Why I no longer talk to white people about race'

7/10/20

Film

Film: 'Sick' - 'They've got people looking in the wrong direction'

2/10/20

Southwark

TV: Council House Britain

30/9/20

Letters

The Socialist Inbox

30/9/20

Socialist Party

Why I joined the Socialist Party: Labour moved right and left me behind

23/9/20

Pay

A day in the life of a salon worker

23/9/20

Socialist Party

Why we joined the Socialist Party

23/9/20

Football

TV: The English Game - how the working class made football the people's game

23/9/20

Letters

The Socialist Inbox

16/9/20

Labour Party

Non-fiction: Left Out - the inside story of Labour under Corbyn

triangleMore Reviews and comments articles...


Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party
Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube

LATEST POSTS

CONTACT US

Phone our national office on 020 8988 8777

Email: info@socialistparty.org.uk

Locate your nearest Socialist Party branch Text your name and postcode to 07761 818 206

Regional Socialist Party organisers:

Eastern: 079 8202 1969

East Mids: 077 3797 8057

London: 075 4018 9052

North East: 078 4114 4890

North West 079 5437 6096

South West: 077 5979 6478

Southern: 078 3368 1910

Wales: 079 3539 1947

West Mids: 024 7655 5620

Yorkshire: 077 0671 0041

ABOUT US

ARCHIVE

Alphabetical listing


October 2020

September 2020

August 2020

July 2020

June 2020

May 2020

April 2020

March 2020

February 2020

January 2020

2019

2018

2017

2016

2015

2014

2013

2012

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999