Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page: https://www.socialistparty.org.uk/issue/1143/32859

From The Socialist newspaper, 28 July 2021

TV Review: Stateless blames mismanagement rather than system

Australia has long been held up as a particularly repressive immigration system, and has served as an inspiration for both Labour and Conservative governments in Britain. As the UK government considers following the 'Australian model' yet again, we carry a review of the 2020 Netflix drama Stateless which takes place within the Australian immigration system.

A still from Netflix's Stateless

A still from Netflix's Stateless   (Click to enlarge)

Ben Robinson, Waltham Forest Socialist Party

Stateless is a dramatisation of the 2004-05 case of Cornelia Rau, an Australian citizen who was falsely detained by the Australian immigration services for ten months. In the midst of a mental health crisis, and fleeing an abusive cult, Rau played up her German roots in an attempt to be deported.

In the six-part Netflix series, Rau is the inspiration for the character Sofie Werner. Her struggles take centre stage throughout.

While her individual story is an interesting extreme of the impact of mental health on a person's life, often the sharpest writing is found in other scenes which cover the life of others in the detention centre. However, this is the backdrop rather than the focus, and ultimately the show feels compromised as a result.

Tragi-comic episodes are scattered throughout. Protesting Tamils on the detention centre roof are sent a Sinhala translator, visiting nuns smuggle mobile phones in via roast dinners, and an exchange about cancelled camp activities is reminiscent of Catch-22.

As the drama progresses, these notes are replaced by darker overtones, such as the immigration case worker uncovering a plaintive 'help' scratched into her desk underneath stacks of incomplete paperwork, and a violent camp guard ends up promoted to running the entire facility, alongside the struggles of Sofie's family to track her down.

The show's secondary characters represent different facets of the system. Afghan refugee Ameer faces tragic consequences of his boat journey, and dealings with careless people-smugglers.

Case worker Claire is confronted head-on by the choices policies she co-developed force those claiming asylum into. New detention centre guard Cam struggles to acclimatise to the culture of the other guards.

However, this is aimed at the bureaucracy and mismanagement within the system, rather than the system itself. This is compounded by the central narrative of a white Australian citizen who clearly should not be detained by Australian immigration services.

The show's liberal message chimes with the protagonists' struggles with her mental health. The idea is that everything Sofie undergoes is an aberration, rather than the norm under capitalism for wealthy countries such as Australia.

Stateless co-producer and actor Cate Blanchett works with the UN High Commission for Refugees, and there is a through line of highlighting the appalling extremes of the refugee experience, while being silent on the more 'mundane' realities of the system. This is reminiscent of those outraged at Trump's detention facilities, but quiet about their continuation under Biden.

The show's wider limitations are ultimately a reminder and a reflection of the racism in capitalist society, and the immigration system in particular. Refugees flee war, poverty and state persecution, facing brutal conditions along the way, before very few can even face up to the challenge of building a new life in a new country. Those stories are at best haltingly told here.

Donate to the Socialist Party

Finance appeal

The coronavirus crisis has laid bare the class character of society in numerous ways. It is making clear to many that it is the working class that keeps society running, not the CEOs of major corporations.

The results of austerity have been graphically demonstrated as public services strain to cope with the crisis.

  • The Socialist Party's material is more vital than ever, so we can continue to report from workers who are fighting for better health and safety measures, against layoffs, for adequate staffing levels, etc.
  • We must be ready for the stormy events ahead and the need to arm workers' movements with a socialist programme - one which puts the health and needs of humanity before the profits of a few.
Inevitably, during the crisis we have not been able to sell the Socialist and raise funds in the ways we normally would.
We therefore urgently appeal to all our viewers to donate to our Fighting Fund.

Please donate here.

All payments are made through a secure server.

My donation

 

Your message: 

 


In The Socialist 28 July 2021:


News

Labour expulsions confirm need for new mass workers' party

'Pingdemic' exemptions

Tories and Labour fail on child poverty

Nationality and borders bill

London floods: Privatisation and heavy rain are a dangerous mix

Jobs and homes for all


International

Cuban protests - what do they represent?

Flood devastation in Europe

Israel: Hospital ancillary workers' strike suspended

In brief: News, reports & analysis from the CWI


Public sector pay

Public sector pay - Prepare for action!

Unite to fight Tory pay insults

New left NEC meets - Organise the fight back now

Government departments move to impose pay cuts

Further education set for industrial action over pay


Trade union

Sheffield Uni UCU fights archaeological dept closure

Bexley bin workers strike for better pay

Fight Freeports to stop bonfire of workers' rights


Campaigns

Thousands march to Reclaim Pride

Tower Hamlets Labour backs Tory cuts

East London resident fighting eviction again

Barnsley 'Big Green Space' protest

Youth Fight for Jobs is officially relaunched

Selling the Socialist

Scottish socialist breaks running record


Readers' Opinion

TV Review: Stateless blames mismanagement rather than system


 

Home   |   The Socialist 28 July 2021   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate   |   Audio  |   PDF  |   ebook






Related links:

Review:

triangleTV Review - Help: Heart-wrenching portrayal of Covid care home crisis

triangleTV review - Grenfell: The Untold Story

triangleVigil: A nuclear sub murder mystery

triangleTV review: Revolutionary Love

triangleFilm Review: Martin Eden

TV:

triangleTV - Statue wars: one summer in Bristol

triangleTV Review: GB News

triangleTV review: Mrs Thatcher vs the miners

triangleTV review: Three Families is excellent. But protest movement is missing

Immigration:

triangleAre Biden's immigration policies a break with Trump's?

triangleGlasgow mass action defeats Home Office deportation attempt

triangleProtest against immigration enforcement centre in Newham

Detention:

triangleCovid outbreak at Kent asylum detention centre: Napier is not fit for purpose

triangleTears and anger over the treatment of the Windrush generation

Health:

triangleLife expectancy falls - a condemnation of capitalism

Australia:

trianglePost-Brexit trade deals: Workers' mobilisation needed to stop corporate extortion

Refugees:

triangleAfghanistan disaster - Unite to fight for funding for refugees and local communities

Reviews and comments

Reviews and comments

22/9/21

Covid

TV Review - Help: Heart-wrenching portrayal of Covid care home crisis

22/9/21

Miners

Gleision mine deaths: Still fighting for justice ten years on

22/9/21

Labour

Corbyn had a social care plan

15/9/21

Cuba

Nuclear Folly: A New History of the Cuban Missile Crisis

8/9/21

Obituary

Obituary: Roger Henshaw, comrade and class fighter

8/9/21

Gloucester

The street I live on

8/9/21

Climate change

Socialist change, not climate change

8/9/21

Review

Vigil: A nuclear sub murder mystery

8/9/21

Socialist Party

Why I joined the Socialist Party

25/8/21

Film

Film Review: Martin Eden

25/8/21

Review

TV review: Revolutionary Love

28/7/21

Review

TV Review: Stateless blames mismanagement rather than system

14/7/21

Football

England football team

14/7/21

Covid

Readers' comments

7/7/21

Socialist Party

Book: The struggle for world socialism

triangleMore Reviews and comments articles...


Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party
Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube

LATEST POSTS

CONTACT US

Phone our national office on 020 8988 8777

Email: [email protected]

Locate your nearest Socialist Party branch Text your name and postcode to 07761 818 206

Regional Socialist Party organisers:

Eastern: 079 8202 1969

East Mids: 077 3797 8057

London: 075 4018 9052

North East: 078 4114 4890

North West 079 5437 6096

South West: 077 5979 6478

Southern: 078 3368 1910

Wales: 077 7221 5281

West Mids: 024 7655 5620

Yorkshire: 078 0983 9793

ABOUT US

ARCHIVE

Alphabetical listing


September 2021

August 2021

July 2021

June 2021

May 2021

April 2021

March 2021

February 2021

January 2021

2020

2019

2018

2017

2016

2015

2014

2013

2012

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999