Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page:

From The Socialist newspaper, 22 February 2006

The music industry:

Do we only hear his master's voice?

AN OUTLINE of how the modern popular music industry has developed provided the background to our discussion at last autumn's Socialism 2005: The music industry, do we only hear his master's voice?

Manny Thain

The debate was wide-ranging, including the role and portrayal of women, numerous musical trends, homophobia, the need for community access to playing and producing music, the politics of salsa and much more besides. Many of us feel passionate about music and everyone has a point of view.

The modern music industry could be said to begin with sound recording at the end of the 19th century. Ever since, it has been dominated by very few companies, though not always the same ones. Today, after the recent (troubled) merger of Sony and Bertelsmann Music Group, four companies dominate: Warner Music, Vivendi/Universal, EMI and Sony/BMG.

The industry has been pushed by technological breakthroughs. The gramophone challenged sheet music's domination and internationalised the industry. Discs made of shellac - secreted by the lac insect - replaced fragile and unwieldy tinfoil cylinders.

Magnetic tape

Electric recording (1924) improved sound quality and magnetic tape (developed in Nazi Germany) meant recording could take place practically anywhere and be edited - boosting local radio and independent record labels.

Vinyl and the development of 33 and 45 rpm records in the late 1940s further enhanced sound quality and facilitated mass production. Cassette tapes were another important development, while CDs sounded the death-knell for vinyl on the mass market.

Nonetheless, the music industry consistently stifles innovation - illustrating the regressive role that capitalism plays, holding back research and development as well as cultural advances. When shellac became widely available, old cylinders were destroyed in their thousands. The earliest blues recordings and other irreplaceable music perished in an act of wanton vandalism dictated by the short-term drive for profit.

Vinyl was first used before the second world war but, because it provided much better sound reproduction, record companies sold off existing shellac stock before introducing it. A worldwide shortage of shellac during the war (it also had military applications) helped speed up the use of vinyl.

The patent on stereo recording was filed in 1933, but the slump in the music industry during the great economic depression meant that it wasn't fully developed until the late 1950s.

Unlike most of these examples, MP3 and its use in internet file-sharing were not developed by the major record companies. Whatever the long-term effects of the internet on music and the industry - a subject worthy of further comment - the big corporations have been slow off the mark to use it.

At first they clamped down on its use with court cases against Napster, Grokster, StreamCast, and over 15,000 individuals. Belatedly, 'legitimate' business is moving in, with Apple developing iPod and iTunes, and record companies making back catalogues available to punters prepared to pay to download music.


WHEN CONSIDERING alternatives to big business, people often conjure up the periodic explosion of new musical trends -. punk, hip hop or the DIY movement rave scene of a decade ago (part of the growing anti-globalisation mood). Linked to these is the role of independent record labels.

This is not new. Early blues recordings were pioneered by small outfits - compelled to tap into niche markets because of the established labels' dominance over the mainstream. In 1920s USA, this meant the working class, and rural areas.

For black artists, in particular, it was often the only possibility of getting recorded. These markets exploded after world war two with rhythm & blues, country and rock & roll. Local radio stations and studios helped disperse the industry nationwide.

The independents became test beds for new music. Once a market was established and a genre 'crossed over' into mainstream popularity, big companies moved in to cream off the profits. Sometimes they simply took over the independents or used their mass production capability and grip over distribution to exert control.

Sun Records - the proving ground for Elvis Presley, Johnny Cash, etc - is the classic example. It could not supply the market it helped create. Presley's 'transfer fee' to Columbia Records was $35,000. It's a recurring theme, continuing with punk, rave, indie and hip hop, and on to the next big thing.


Once a genre has crossed over, the industry pushes a commodified version of the original, a pale imitation. Hip hop developed in New York as black and Latino youth self-expression. It continues still in vibrant, alternative scenes.

But the hip hop peddled by the multinationals and which dominates the world market is now part of the establishment, based on the lowest-common-denominator formula, the most reactionary themes: gangs, guns and drugs, individual greed, sexism and homophobia. It is, overwhelmingly, a stereotype of black communities marketed to an overwhelmingly white teenage audience.

Another, often inadvertent, role of the independents is in undermining pay and conditions. This has gone furthest in the US: neo-liberalism, the musical. Independent labels are increasingly sub-contractors to major labels. The main musicians' union, the American Federation of Musicians (AFM), has labour contracts with all the majors.

But musicians working for independent 'sub-contractors' are only covered by the deal if the major label owns 50% or more of the independent label. As a result, over three-quarters of AFM members are not covered by the agreement their union negotiated.

In the US, the rise of radio coincided with, and helped create, the market for popular music. This was aided by large population shifts. Over a million African-Americans migrated north in the 1940s to work in munitions factories and other war-related industry. They provided the bedrock for an emerging market for rhythm and blues - and some of the most innovative and influential musicians.

In the post-war economic boom, the spending power of the mass of the population increased. In 1952, record sales overtook sheet music revenue for the first time. The rise of TV starved national radio of advertising revenue, the influence of local radio rose and this, in turn, fed local record labels.

In 1996, a fundamental change took place. The Telecommunications Act removed restrictions on how many radio stations a company could own. Clear Channel, which owned 40 US stations in 1996, now has 1,240 - a quarter of all listeners and radio-generated revenue.

This deregulation led to thousands of lay-offs, the decimation of community programming, and limited musical choice. The use of digital pre-programming has been used to cut staff and break labour contracts.

Ultimately, we aren't forced to hear only his master's voice. There are many vibrant, alternative music scenes involving many people making and enjoying music. Nonetheless, overall, capitalist rules apply and big business rules. The four majors control around 90% of music industry revenue.

Now more than ever, the profit-driven capitalist system holds back progress and stifles initiative. Despite this, people still create wonderful works of art, music and culture. For a full flowering of musical talent, however, we must get the big business monkey off our backs.

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.

In The Socialist 22 February 2006:

Unite Save pensions, jobs and services

Fight for your future!

Campaign for a New Workers' Party conference

Gas price rise the biggest in history !

Daggers at NHS's heart

Why rural workers need socialism

Bush and Blair's total failure

Car workers fight layoffs

Trade wars and protectionism

Khrushchev: The Stalinist who denounced Stalin

Music industry: Do we only hear his master's voice?

Good Night and Good Luck

Get your May Day greeting into the socialist!

University staff vote to strike over pay


Home   |   The Socialist 22 February 2006   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate  

Related links:


triangleCarlisle: Alternative Burns night

triangleCatchy folk rock with a socialist edge

triangleCrunchy guitar and poignant dialogue in alt-rock homage to south Wales miners

triangleRussia 1917: how art helped make the revolution

triangleSave Cardiff's live music venues


triangleThe Socialist inbox

triangleClosure of Nottingham unit shows dismantling of NHS

triangleThem & Us

triangleThem & Us


triangleCorbyn's left must seize the advantage in Labour's civil war

triangle90 feared dead after migrant boat capsizes

triangleStop the war on the Kurds


triangleThe Socialist inbox

triangleYour newspaper fights with you: help fund it with May Day greetings


triangleTower Hamlets Socialist Party: Organising for socialist change

Reports and campaigns

Reports and campaigns



Lecturers strike around country in defence of pensions



German engineering strike puts shorter week on agenda - but could have won more



Cardiff Refugee Rights gig success



Nottingham hospital black alert


East Midlands

Lively discussion at East Midlands Socialist Party conference


West Midlands

Tremendous determination on show at West Midlands conference



Successful Socialist Party Wales conference sets tone for the year ahead



Bradford protests against kids' service cuts


May Day

May Day, May Day! Celebrate solidarity!



Labour councillors push through savage cuts in Kirklees budget



Save Salford nurseries!



Victory: Pontllanfraith leisure centre saved



Northants council crisis - protesters demand an end to cuts and privatisation



Leicester Uni makes Tory fee tripler David Willetts chancellor - sack Willetts!



Bosses divided - university pension strikes can win!

triangleMore Reports and campaigns articles...

Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party
Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube



Phone our national office on 020 8988 8777


Locate your nearest Socialist Party branch Text your name and postcode to 07761 818 206

Regional Socialist Party organisers:

Eastern: 0798 202 1969

East Mids: 0773 797 8057

London: 020 8988 8786

North East: 0191 421 6230

North West 07769 611 320

South East: 020 8988 8777

South West: 07759 796 478

Southern: 07833 681910

Wales: 07935 391 947

West Mids: 02476 555 620

Yorkshire: 0114 264 6551



Alphabetical listing

February 2018

January 2018