Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page:

From The Socialist newspaper, 2 July 2008

Fight Labour's welfare privatisation

JAMES PURNELL, secretary of state for the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP), has announced that he intends to let private sector companies cherry pick whatever DWP services they wanted to provide. Contractors, who already eat up half the budget of Job Centre Plus (JCP), will no longer have to wait for the government to decide which services are put out to tender.

Dave Reid

Under new government proposals they can knock on the government's door and bid for any services they want. Obviously they will bid for the easier services that can make them the most money and leave more challenging services to what is left of the civil service.

Shortly after Purnell's announcement, about 70 trade unionists, civil servants, academics and voluntary sector representatives met at Cardiff university to hear presentations on the government's welfare reform proposals, including one by Stephen Timms, minister for employment and welfare.

Every contributor bar one questioned or condemned these government 'reforms' and their likely effects. Unfortunately the exception was Stephen Timms who intends to implement them regardless of evidence that they will not work.

Timms repeated New Labour mantras about private sector "flexibility", "specialisation" and "competitiveness". He claimed that JCP staff cannot innovate or be flexible enough to tailor different solutions to different parts of the country. Actually no-one is better than the hard-working Job Centre staff at doing the things the government says it wants to achieve.

What is inflexible and unwilling to change is the government and JCP management. In the debate, Timms extolled the virtues of Pathways, a private provider in Newport, because their flexibility allegedly helped a claimant who said that, unlike the JCP, their first question was "would you like a cup of coffee?"

"That is the kind of transformation we want the welfare system to bring" Timms said. But John Walters, a PCS rep from Port Talbot, pointed out that JCP staff were forbidden by DWP management from allowing hot drinks on their desk!

PCS union general secretary Mark Serwotka said the experience of private sector involvement in welfare provision over six to eight years had already uncovered fraud, corruption and falsification of records. Some private contractors had walked away from their contracts or gone bankrupt.

Many claimants felt they were forced into any old job to get them off benefits so the private contractor would be paid rather than providing long term work for the claimant.

The government is doing this not because the private and voluntary sectors are more efficient but to try to reduce the public sector. Already 30,000 jobs have been lost in the DWP. Some DWP workers were told their jobs were surplus to requirement three weeks after winning a public servants of the year award.

With all its queues and faults, Mark said, when a person went into a Job Centre in the past the Job Centre staff's job was to help them to access a whole range of services and benefits regardless of what they came in for. Now one of DWP management's main aims at Job Centre Plus (JCP) is to reduce "footfall" - to get rid of people and tell them to go or phone somewhere else.

Steve Davies, senior research fellow at Cardiff university, said there is no evidence that private sector provision of DWP services has been more efficient than by the public sector. In fact the whole private-sector process is inefficient. Markets have to be created in welfare provision and the market has to be "incentivised", i.e. made worthwhile for private providers to enter the market. Already private contractors provide about a third of welfare provision.

The "third sector", the voluntary sector, is used as a Trojan horse by the private sector to open up opportunities for privatisation. The director of public services at bosses' association the CBI said the voluntary sector was its "weapon of choice for those engaged in the continuing battle over public sector reform". Charities and voluntary organisations will be transformed into private companies by having to compete against private companies for public sector contracts.

A government-commissioned study concluded that the cost effectiveness of private providers and JCP was the same. In the Action Teams for Jobs, the private sector providers met 78% of their job entry targets while the JCP teams met 140% of their targets. Yet the government wants to expand private sector provision. A campaign is needed to stop them.

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.

In The Socialist 2 July 2008:

Hands off our NHS!

Feature: 60 years of the NHS

Socialist Party campaigns

Local government strike action: Workers say: 'enough is enough!'

Fight Labour's welfare privatisation

91% of pay deals are below inflation

Workers united against pay freeze

Socialist Party news and analysis

Education - class segregation grows

Boris Johnson reveals his real policies

Royals down to their last crown?

Union support for demo to stop BNP 'festival'

National Shop Stewards Network

National Shop Stewards Network: Rebuilding trade union strength

Campaign for a New Workers Party

Campaign for a New Workers' Party


Obituary: Terry Fields

Socialist Party LGBT

LGBT London Pride: No to homophobia

International socialist news and analysis

Mugabe clique tightens its grip on Zimbabwe

Big oil returns to Iraq

Poland: Thousands join 'hands off the Labour Code' demo

Socialist Party workplace news

PCS shows action gets results

Visteon workers win 5%

For a fighting, democratic Usdaw

Tube cleaners in pay strike

Victory for Belfast Airport shop stewards

East London street cleaners fight privatised employer


Home   |   The Socialist 2 July 2008   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate  

Related links:


triangleChesterfield Socialist Party: The fight for the welfare state

triangleChild poverty set to hit 5.2m - unions and Corbyn must act now

triangleUniversal Credit chaos: Tories punish the poor

triangleYoung people being strangled by debts

triangleMajor attacks 'Universal Credit', half a million more face poverty


triangleLeeds TUSC: How can we stop NHS cuts & privatisation?

triangleLeeds TUSC: How can we stop NHS cuts & privatisation?

triangleLeeds TUSC: How can we stop NHS cuts & privatisation?

triangleMay elections: a chance to fight attacks on health and social care


triangleBristol South Socialist Party: How can councils protect public services?

triangleLocal paper reveals Labour candidate 'tried to defect to the Tories'

triangleLabour councillors could stop unsafe 'driver-only operation' tomorrow


triangleDWP to outsource more work to Capita

triangleSheffield Eastern Ave Job Centre strike ends

Public sector:

triangleGender pay gap figures show need for trade union action

Mark Serwotka:

triangleBritish Museum: Carillion workers demand to be brought back in-house

Reports and campaigns

Reports and campaigns



College protest against job losses



Bromley library workers win strike campaign



UCU members vote to end pensions dispute



Usdaw conference 2018: time for new era of fighting trade unionism



Victorious Fearnville Fields campaigners thank the Socialist



Hull says no to war, no to austerity


The Socialist

The Socialist - a fighting, campaigning, workers' paper


Socialist Party

Building fund: 150,000 milestone smashed!


Fighting Fund

Give us your change (and more) to fight for system change!



Workers' victory over anti-union Scottish council



Avenue School strikers and parents win judicial review



Vote for a left, fighting PCS leadership



PCS rejects Acas offer - further strikes announced



Bromley libraries - indefinite strike action continues



Butterfields tenants join TUSC campaign

triangleMore Reports and campaigns articles...

Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party
Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube



Phone our national office on 020 8988 8777


Locate your nearest Socialist Party branch Text your name and postcode to 07761 818 206

Regional Socialist Party organisers:

Eastern: 0798 202 1969

East Mids: 0773 797 8057

London: 020 8988 8786

North East: 0784 114 4890

North West 07769 611 320

South East: 020 8988 8777

South West: 07759 796 478

Southern: 07833 681910

Wales: 07935 391 947

West Mids: 02476 555 620

Yorkshire: 0114 264 6551



Alphabetical listing

April 2018

March 2018

February 2018

January 2018