Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page:

From The Socialist newspaper, 1 April 2009

Indian software industry

Now that the profits are drying up...

A JOURNALIST friend recently asked me how recession is affecting India's software professionals. He wanted to write a story on how recession has adversely affected the lifestyle of software professionals, who are compelled to cut their expenses on eating out, watching movies in multiplexes and shopping in plush malls.

An Indian socialist

While the worldwide economic implosion threatens many people's livelihoods in the developing countries, India's mainstream media sheds tears at the deteriorating lifestyle of software engineers.

The blue-eyed boy of India's 'success story' of economic liberalisation, the IT industry has posted successive annualised growth of around 33% for many years. At times, the top IT companies (TCS, Infosys, Wipro, Satyam) consistently reported annualised 50% increases in profits every quarter. The industry is highly export-oriented; exports amount to two-thirds of its revenue.

India's specialisation in software was driven by two sorts of wage advantage that reinforced each other. Lower wages for Indian software developers relative to those of their US and European counterparts make Indian software cheaper in global markets. Meanwhile, the higher wages earned by software professionals in India relative to those in other industrial sectors ensured a steady supply of software professionals.

However, these higher wages isolated software workers (who see themselves as 'knowledge professionals') from India's wider masses on the social, political and economic fronts. Living in their virtual enclave, they considered themselves forerunners of the 'era of prosperity' that was supposedly dawning in India.

Most of India's population, including 90% of her workforce that are employed in the unorganised sector, lacks even basic necessities like safe drinking water and primary health care facilities, but her capitalist class and media shamelessly tout the idea of India becoming a superpower.

Youth in the software industry, moulded by propaganda and blinded by new prosperity, became votaries of the neoliberal market cult. The market, too, was quick to milk this new breed of 'high-profile customers' who are in their 20s or early 30s.

Multiplying multiplex theatres, sprawling shopping malls, the array of investment and insurance products - all the tentacles of the consumer economy grasped them. However such market orientation towards the induced needs of highly-paid 'professionals' had catastrophic effects on the rest of the working class, especially in housing, education and health services.

This is most evident in housing where the needs of a migrating IT workforce were quickly transformed into attractive investment opportunities. Interest rates on home loans were lowered and the government offered substantial income tax benefits on them.

Builders, politicians and land hoarders seized the opportunity, leading to an unprecedented surge in real estate prices in cities reputed as 'software hubs', where property prices soon rose by as much as 400%.

This brutally ended the home-owning dreams of fellow workers in other industries 'not paid so well'. The large number of people migrating from rural areas into cities, looking for cheap jobs, are left with no option but to settle in already cramped slums. This further exacerbates the ghettoisation seen in Indian cities.

The social composition of the IT workforce helps explain its distance from the rest of the working class. It also exposes the myth that the industry offers opportunities for social and economic mobility irrespective of caste, religion and regional background. On the contrary, if anything it helped to widen this disparity.

Most of its workforce (in some cases as high as three-quarters) is drawn from urban, upper/middle caste and landowning agriculture communities. A study of IT employees in Bangalore shows that brahmins (upper-caste priest community) constituted 48% of the workforce. The brahmins' predominance is not surprising, given their historical monopoly over higher education and employment in the formal sector, especially in south India.

Inequalities and exclusive mechanisms in India's higher education system are further compounded by IT recruitment processes which look for workers who can be moulded into 'global' professionals. Another study describes the IT companies' criteria: good communication and social skills, confidence, and the 'right kind of personality', as nothing but elements of cultural capital.

And in India such capital is so far monopolised by the urban middle classes and upper castes. So IT recruitment processes tend to 'weed out' any lower caste/rural candidates that may have otherwise qualified.

Global crisis

Apologists of neo-liberalism often claim that India's IT industry has flourished mainly because of the absence of state control or intervention. But the industry has all along received substantial state support, directly through subsidies, tax holidays, provision of land and infrastructure, etc. and indirectly through the large pool of "knowledge workers" produced by decades of state investments in higher education.

These apologists cheered the IT industry bosses' entrepreneurial zeal and global vision for leading India towards becoming 'knowledge capital of the world'. Captured by this, many young minds, including IT workers revered their bosses. However, with recession now deepening its grip, their gods are falling!

Being predominantly export-oriented, the software industry is prone to problems in the global economy, especially with its particular reliance on the US and UK. Statistics for the finance year 2007 show that the US and UK markets accounted for 61% and 18% of total Indian software exports respectively.

To add to the problem, banking, financial services and insurance, the industry domain worst hit by the global economic crisis, is the single largest growth source for software exports, contributing a whopping 40.4%. Faced with such a daunting situation, Indian IT companies and their promoters - the former 'entrepreneur heroes of emerging India' - are showing their true colours.

The IT workforce is already stripped of many facilities like free transport, pensions, and subsidised food in company hours that workers in other organised sectors benefit from. The situation is even worse in the business process outsourcing industry where workers have to keep long and irregular work hours, do night shifts, take short lunch breaks and do dull, mundane work.

Obsessed with higher growth rates, IT companies are shedding their workforces, refusing salary rises, replacing higher paid engineers with lower-paid trainees and doing everything possible to make sure their profits and share values don't fall. As a finance manager in an IT industry bluntly put it - the software industry is in the business of nothing but selling man-hours.

This is a crude demonstration of the Marxist theory of surplus value. Charging the clients for (minimum) 8 hours (at a rate of around US $80 an hour), companies pay workers for barely 1.5 to 2 hours; the rest (almost 70%) becomes surplus value appropriated by the most senior managers and by the shareholders.

Workers get peanuts and are supposed to be content with it. But with the wind changing direction; unceremonious job cuts, negative annual increments and harsher company policies, may scratch the surface of their expectations. It will lead them to realise that they are nothing but cheap labour for the West and for their bosses, who are solely accountable to their shareholders.

Common interests

Recently, Ramling Raju (founder of Satyam Computers, India's fourth largest IT company) resigned, admitting fraud to the tune of around 1 billion. The company's account books were grossly manipulated with 94% of the cash being fictitious.

Such frauds are motivated by pressure to maintain the high pace of growth, to please investors and shareholders and to justify inflated share prices-to-earnings ratios during a six-year bull run on the Indian stock market.

While the media lauds institutional investors for their role, the spectre of losing jobs threatens more than 50,000 employees of Satyam in particular and IT workers in general. Some IT recruiters shamelessly await such catastrophe, hoping to cherry-pick employees.

While Raju may be prosecuted, all other complicit elements including the auditors (PriceWaterhouseCoopers), board of directors, domestic institutional investors and foreign institutional investors (that held 48% of the shares) would walk away, leaving workers alone to bear the brunt of the crisis they did not cause.

Such hostile circumstances may provoke workers to question the prevalent market system which thrives on exploitation of their labour and in return offers them only crumbs even in the best of periods. Their castist interests may conflict in their own eyes now, but a further deterioration in material conditions and the presence of a clear socialist alternative may help them identify a common interest with the working class of the rest of society.

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.

In The Socialist 1 April 2009:

The G20 leaders have no solution to the crisis...

Fight for a future!

Youth Fight for Jobs conference

Why I'm marching

The grim reality of job-hunting

G20 protests

G20 Summit: Capitalism facing 'make or break'

Free market system killing our planet

UEL clampdown

Bail out workers, not Wall Street!

Socialist Party workplace news

Visteon workers occupy Belfast factory

Construction workers' protests continue

Socialist stands in Aslef leadership elections

College teachers strike in Eastbourne

Unison needs a fighting leadership: Leeds City Council

Whipps Cross Hospital

Unison elections

Socialist Party Marxist analysis

Economic crisis turning into political action

Socialist Party election campaign

No2EU - Yes to Democracy

Dave Nellist on the Politics Show

Socialist Party campaigns

Poor hit by price rises

No to privatised polyclinics

Gordon Brown meets the bankers

Sack the bankers not the workers!

Fast News

International socialist news and analysis

Now that the profits are drying up in the Indian software industry

Sweden: Socialist councillor viciously assaulted by Nazis


Home   |   The Socialist 1 April 2009   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate  

Related links:


triangleLeicester Kashmir protest rejects religious smokescreen

triangleBradford demo: Self-determination for Kashmir

triangleAnger continues to mount over imposition of direct rule

triangleKashmir crisis: Stop the attack on democratic rights

triangleThe 45th anniversary of the strike




South Africa

Violence against women in South Africa: how should organised workers respond?



West Papuans demand self-determination in London


South Africa

South Africa: Xenophobic violence - a product of failed capitalist policies


Far right

Far right makes gains in Germany


Hong Kong

Hong Kong protests: No let-up in trial of strength



Italy: Governing coalition fractures as Salvini looks to capitalise on crisis


Hong Kong

Pro-democracy protests continue to rage



Kashmir crisis: Stop the attack on democratic rights


Puerto Rico

Mass movement topples governor of Puerto Rico


Hong Kong

Hong Kong: the struggle for democratic rights escalates



Greece elections: Syriza ousted amid voter disillusionment



Interview: protests over killing in Israel



Sudan masses mobilise against state repression



Irish health workers' anger boils over into strike action



New opportunity to build working-class fightback after voters punish Erdogan

triangleMore International articles...

Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party
Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube



Phone our national office on 020 8988 8777


Locate your nearest Socialist Party branch Text your name and postcode to 07761 818 206

Regional Socialist Party organisers:

Eastern: 0798 202 1969

East Mids: 0773 797 8057

London: 020 8988 8786

North East: 0784 114 4890

North West 07954 376 096

South East: 020 8988 8777

South West: 07759 796 478

Southern: 07833 681910

Wales: 07935 391 947

West Mids: 02476 555 620

Yorkshire: 0114 264 6551



Alphabetical listing

September 2019

August 2019

July 2019

June 2019

May 2019

April 2019

March 2019

February 2019

January 2019