Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page:

From The Socialist newspaper, 5 June 2009

A Question Time carve up

The producers of BBC programme Question Time on 28 May, on the European elections, had decided not to include RMT union leader Bob Crow as a panel speaker from 'No2EU - Yes to Democracy', on the grounds that it was not an important enough party. However, three Socialist Party members were in the studio audience. Clive Heemskerk reports on their experience.

The programme started with a 'warm-up' question, not transmitted, on whether London Underground workers should be allowed to strike. Amazingly, the UK Independence Party spokesperson, Nigel Farage MEP, suggested that the strike is an RMT 'stunt' to "get publicity for the RMT's general secretary Bob Crow, who is standing in the elections for No2EU - Yes to Democracy"!

Three million Londoners depend on the underground every day, someone else said, and the RMT shouldn't be allowed to 'hold them hostage'. So perhaps 'Bob the hostage-taker' isn't so unimportant after all! Both Sarah Sachs-Eldridge and myself spoke, as did other audience members, to defend the RMT and its right to strike and to challenge No2EU's exclusion from the panel.

Then the programme proper started, and soon moved on to MEPs and MPs' expenses. Sarah was called into the audience discussion after the entrepreneur panelist PY Gerbeau had criticised MEPs' allowances but then attacked the EU as 'socialistic', and 'curbing enterprise'. Sarah made the point that in fact EU directives call for the privatisation of public services like Royal Mail and that's why she would be voting for No2EU. This was kept in the transmitted version. But her immediate next point, linked to the expenses issue under discussion, was that No2EU includes candidates like Dave Nellist, the Coventry South East Labour MP from 1983 to 1992, who had only taken an average workers' wage as an MP. This was censored out.

So how did Sarah's first point mentioning No2EU slip past the censors' knife? Because, fortunately, the Green MEP panellist, Caroline Lucas, trying to claim the mantle of opposition to the EU's pro-market policies, explicitly attacked No2EU - Yes to Democracy! It would have looked odd, even to the most zealous BBC editor, to have kept that in without Sarah's comment.

The discussion moved on, to the question of whether MPs who are going to 'retire' at the next general election as a result of the expenses scandal should resign now, with by-elections called. Points were made about the right of recall and then I was called into the discussion.

I started by supporting the right of recall, proportional representation, and MPs receiving only the average wage, "like Dave Nellist did when he was a Labour MP in the 1980s...". "We've already heard that", interrupted David Dimbleby. "So why didn't the panel respond?", I replied. "If it was good enough for Dave Nellist, why not for them?" This was all edited out.

I then continued, saying that the right of recall is important, but there needs to be an alternative to vote for, or it would be like California, where the Democrat Gray Davies was recalled in a referendum in 2003, only to be replaced by Arnold Schwarzenegger - hardly a step forward! "None of the mainstream parties represent working people, just the bankers and the rich".

This was kept in. But my next immediate line wasn't: "That's why it is so significant that people like Bob Crow and Dave Nellist are standing in this election for No2EU".

I can't claim total recall of everything that was said but I am confident that nobody's contributions were cut like ours. For example, comments from the audience by the ex-Tory multi-millionaire Sir Paul Judge, the registered leader of the 'Jury Team' party, were kept in full.

The BBC has moved on from the 'mission statement' of its first director-general, Lord Reith, who during the 1926 general strike said: "The BBC must be for the government". But our experience confirmed that it hasn't moved that far!

It now graciously cedes the right to criticise the government, but allowing a fair representation to an alternative to the whole capitalist establishment is another question.

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.

In The Socialist 5 June 2009:

Action to defend union rights

Visteon pensioners battle on

Vauxhall jobs threat - unions must organise a fightback

Workplace news and analysis

Royal Mail sell-off - Time for action!

Fast news

Tube workers vote to strike

Bristol refuse workers strike

Battling against the blacklist

Glasgow care workers' success

Socialist Party election campaign

Prepare now for next election challenge

European elections: Putting forward a workers' alternative

A Question Time carve up

Challenge these disgraced MPs

A Parliament of celebrities and a speaker of integrity


Aston University socialists fight for student democracy

Sussex University: Save Linguistics campaign

Socialist youth conference and protest

Youth Fight for Jobs: Fortnight of action 27 June to 10 July

Socialist Party feature

NATO anniversary: 60 years of aggression and terror

Socialist Party review

The Frock-Coated Communist: the revolutionary life of Friedrich Engels

Marxist analysis: history

Tiananmen Square 1989: Counter-revolution crushes China's democracy movement


Home   |   The Socialist 5 June 2009   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate  

Related links:


triangleOctober 1917 reviews: 'More bright than any heaven'

triangleThe Socialist Inbox

triangleBBC yawning pay gaps revealed

triangleLondon: Cuts Cost Lives #ToriesOut national demonstration

Socialist Party:

triangleWalkout from undercover policing inquiry

trianglePast fund-raising campaigns show dedication to the fight for socialism

triangleWhy I joined: 'The Socialist Party is at the forefront of defending Corbyn's anti-austerity leadership'


triangleItalian elections create huge political shake-up

triangleSalford Socialist Party: Five Star Movement and the Italian elections

triangleWhole lotta shakin' goin' on in DOO dispute


triangleLeicester: Blairites block Labour Party democracy

trianglePCS: Re-elect the left and fight for decent pay


triangleJeremy Corbyn and Brexit


triangleWe feel that we will win - a striker speaks

Bob Crow:

triangle15 years since the invasion of Iraq: what we said


triangleObituary: John Pickett - 1954-2017

Dave Nellist:

triangleWho's watching who?: The fight for justice, trade union and democratic rights

Reports and campaigns

Reports and campaigns



School strikes against academy management



Hands Off HRI campaign granted judicial review



Refugee Rights to be launched in Manchester



Over 1,000 on Newcastle NHS march


Socialist Party

Why I joined: 'The Socialist Party is at the forefront of defending Corbyn's anti-austerity leadership'


Socialist Party

Past fund-raising campaigns show dedication to the fight for socialism


May Day

Ideas matter: help us fight to win with May Day greetings



Refugees march against racism and to demand rights



Unions condemn 'culture of bullying' at Merseyside hospital



Hull college workers ballot for action against mass redundancies



Strikers and parents rally again in Newham against academies



Hinkley workers win back unpaid wages after sit-in protest



UCU strike: staff and students unite to continue pensions fight after magnificent 14 days of action



Walkout from undercover policing inquiry



Hated Blairite mayor ousted: now fight for a no-cuts Newham!

triangleMore Reports and campaigns articles...

Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party
Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube



Phone our national office on 020 8988 8777


Locate your nearest Socialist Party branch Text your name and postcode to 07761 818 206

Regional Socialist Party organisers:

Eastern: 0798 202 1969

East Mids: 0773 797 8057

London: 020 8988 8786

North East: 0191 421 6230

North West 07769 611 320

South East: 020 8988 8777

South West: 07759 796 478

Southern: 07833 681910

Wales: 07935 391 947

West Mids: 02476 555 620

Yorkshire: 0114 264 6551



Alphabetical listing

March 2018

February 2018

January 2018