Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page:

From The Socialist newspaper, 21 April 2010

National Care Service - fact or fiction?

And how will it be paid for?

MOST RESEARCH suggests that the general population is living longer. Advances in science and healthcare mean that more conditions are treatable and many people with previously life-threatening conditions can now live well into old age. Socialists welcome these advances, but we also have to explain that people living in poverty or on low incomes still live much shorter lives than their rich counterparts.

Paul Couchman, TUSC parliamentary candidate for Spelthorne

One of the results of longer life-expectancy is the need for better and more widely available social care for elderly people and disabled adults. The New Labour government has published a White Paper (discussion paper) called Building the National Care Service. On the face of it, the proposals sound progressive. The new National Care Service will apparently:

But just weeks before the general election and Labour is already backtracking and now says the new service will not come into being until 2016.

Cuts are already being made in care services in local authorities across the country and Labour, the Tories and the Lib Dems all clearly state that more cuts are on the agenda.

The government says that efficiency savings (read cuts) of around 4 billion will have to be found in social care from 2014. All the three parties agree that the level of cuts after the election will be 'even worse than under Margaret Thatcher'.

Read between the lines and it is clear that this White Paper will do nothing to enhance the lives of vulnerable adults in our communities. It is also likely that the bill will not be passed by an incoming Tory government or hung parliament.

Real independence

Eligibility criteria are now so high in many councils that only those who are at death's door or who cannot care for themselves at all are receiving services. The level of services when you do meet the criteria is a scandal in many areas - a ten minute visit from a private homecare agency to check you are still breathing, then the company charges the council for a half-hour personal care service!

Increased 'Choice and Control' has become synonymous with closing day centres and residential homes, whilst repeating the mantra that 'people should stay in their own homes'.

Direct Payments (cash for care) and Self-Directed Support (individual budgets) are just other ways of 'saving' money while hiding behind a cloak of progressive, disability-friendly policies.

The truth is that many more vulnerable adults, elderly and disabled people will become isolated and neglected over the coming months as social care budgets are cut and day and residential options closed.

It may well be nicer to remain in your own home rather than go into residential care, but if the services are not in place to support you at home then you are actually in a very dangerous place. Every week the media shows another vulnerable adult who has been abused or killed when living in their own home.

For independent living to be truly safe and to be a real choice then billions of pounds of real investment needs to go into home care, social work and outreach services.


What does the government mean when it talks about 'partnerships'? On past experience this means working with the private sector - selling off our social care services (such as home care which is now 85% privately run) and siphoning public money into the private purse.

Partnership working with families actually means asking family members (usually women) to give up their time to provide extra unpaid care to loved ones. Working in partnership can also mean passing the buck to the poorly-funded and ill-equipped voluntary sector and local charities who have already stated that they are facing a funding crisis.

The 'comprehensive' element of the new National Care Service, if it was treated in the same way as the National Health Service is meant to be, ie fully funded by government and free to all at the point of need, would be welcomed by socialists. But New Labour will not deliver this.

A socialist government would though and could pay for it by re-nationalising the gas, electricity, telecommunications, transport and water companies under workers' and users' control - providing compensation to shareholders only on the basis of proven need. The top 150 companies should also be nationalised.

The massive wealth and productive potential of these national and multinational companies could then be ploughed back into the NHS and also fully fund and provide for a truly universal care service, education and other public services.

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.

In The Socialist 21 April 2010:

Stop these savage cuts: support the socialist alternative

Youth fight for jobs

Young people facing a fight for their future

National Union of Students conference: Campaign needed against fees and cuts

Socialist Party editorial

Left candidates excluded from media

LibDem Surge

Big business as usual for Liberal Democrats

TV debate - Party leaders compete for the same policies


Volcanic eruption brings travel chaos: Planned and integrated transport system vital

Planes, trains and automobiles

Socialist Party news and analysis

Cameron turns back clock on women's rights

Banks use microloans to fleece poor

Fast news

Socialist Party election campaign

Doncaster - Jarvis's vicious sackings and workers' fightback

Portsmouth North: "An ordinary guy to represent ordinary workers"

Lewisham councillors' record

Trade Unionist and Socialist Coalition

Coventry: Standing up for public services

Colne Valley / Huddersfield: Kirklees' only fighting councillor

Spelthorne: "The trade union candidate guy"

A chance to put your questions to your local Trade Unionist and Socialist Coalition candidates.


Why the BNP offers no way forward for working class people

Anti-BNP protest

International socialist news and analysis

Progressive Workers Federation of Pakistan founded

Sri Lanka parliamentary elections: Rajapaksa's clan consolidates its rule

Socialist Party features

National Care Service - fact or fiction?

1936 - A play about the Olympics

Socialist Party workplace news

Vote to boycott SATs

Civil service dispute continues

Fighting cuts at Coventry council

Strike ballot at Manchester Metropolitan University

Unison health conference

Laundry workers fight closure

Dover trade unions against privatisation

National Shop Stewards Network 2010 conference:


Home   |   The Socialist 21 April 2010   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate  

Related links:


triangleEdmonton joins Enfield North Labour in supporting 'no cuts' fightback strategy

triangleGrenfell two years on - Still fighting for safety and justice

triangleNeglected Newham tenants demand action

triangleCorbyn must go on the offensive against the Labour right


triangleProtesters condemn Tory candidate

triangleCardiff West Socialist Party: Boot out the Tories!

trianglePCS conference: defeats for union officialdom and steps taken to rebuild a fighting left opposition

triangleTories smashed in Euros - Now get them out


triangleCuts and NHS crisis result in 'excess' elderly deaths

triangleMajor private care operator puts thousands of vulnerable people at risk

triangle'Freedom riders' lobby against violent policing


triangleStep forward for campaign to reverse mobility pass cuts in Nottingham

triangleSouth Yorkshire Freedom Riders - still battling on

Paul Couchman:

triangleFive years on - and still no justice for Zane

Reports and campaigns

Reports and campaigns



Scottish airport strikes against attack by "ideological capitalists" - fight for better pay and pensions



Southampton hospital workers win



Socialist Party members make big impact at trades council conference


National Shop Stewards Network

Fight the closures save every job!



Save Essex libraries protest



Edmonton joins Enfield North Labour in supporting 'no cuts' fightback strategy



D-Day for fighting Trump attack on NHS


South Western Railway

South Western Railway guards to strike again



Socialists in Unison hold positions in elections despite ban on campaigning



Fire tears through flats - cladding off now!



Stagecoach strike - bus workers show how it's done



Ford closure announcement must be met with united response of defiance


National Shop Stewards Network

Strike together to kick out the Tories!



Welsh train fleet workers' victory



UCU conference 2019: Preparing for struggle

triangleMore Reports and campaigns articles...

Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party
Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube



Phone our national office on 020 8988 8777


Locate your nearest Socialist Party branch Text your name and postcode to 07761 818 206

Regional Socialist Party organisers:

Eastern: 0798 202 1969

East Mids: 0773 797 8057

London: 020 8988 8786

North East: 0784 114 4890

North West 07769 611 320

South East: 020 8988 8777

South West: 07759 796 478

Southern: 07833 681910

Wales: 07935 391 947

West Mids: 02476 555 620

Yorkshire: 0114 264 6551



Alphabetical listing

June 2019

May 2019

April 2019

March 2019

February 2019

January 2019