All International subcategories:
EU-Canada trade deal battle points to Corbyn's Brexit opportunity
Clive Heemskerk, Socialist Party executive committee
The saga of the on-off-and-on again trade agreement between Canada and the European Union (EU) holds important lessons for how Jeremy Corbyn and his supporters could use the Brexit negotiations to build a European-wide workers' opposition to the EU bosses' club.
The Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement (CETA) between Canada and the EU has now been signed, at a hastily re-arranged ceremony for the Canadian premier, Justin Trudeau. But this was only possible after the federal government of Belgium, the only EU member state yet to approve CETA, was forced to agree a last-minute four-page 'interpretation' of the treaty with the country's regional parliaments.
Opposition to CETA had come in particular from the self-governing parliament of Wallonia, with a government coalition led by the Socialist Party (PS), one of Labour's sister parties in the European parliament.
Belatedly reflecting workers' concerns, the PS Wallonia premier Paul Magnette criticised the CETA 'Investor-State Dispute Settlement' plan which will allow corporations to sue states for losses if their business interests were 'infringed' by government action.
Like the proposed EU Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP) with the US, CETA threatens consumer safety, environmental protections and workers' rights, and generally enhances the power of big business over democratically-elected governments.
In the event the Walloon government backed down for what are minor concessions, with Belgium now able to seek a European Court of Justice ruling on whether the new investor courts system is compatible with EU law. But the fact that negotiations inaugurated in 2004 came so close to being derailed is very significant for the Brexit debate.
The first lesson is that the capitalist politicians of the different EU member states are not united, reflecting the character of the EU as, at bottom, a series of agreements between the competing national capitalist classes of Europe.
The EU Commission is approaching the coming Brexit negotiations with the intention of 'punishing Britain', as 'an example to others'. In reality, however, there will be no such thing as 'an EU position' but the different positions of 27 capitalist nation states - and the working class in each of those states.
In times of economic growth it has been possible to achieve unity among the 'capitalist thieves'. But smoothing over the problems caused when one or another section of the capitalist class in a particular country have not had their interests met in treaty negotiations, is more difficult in an era of stagnation.
The Wallonia government especially objected to the impact of CETA on Belgian farmers. Such disputes will be as nothing compared to the inter-capitalist divisions that will emerge in the Brexit negotiations.
More important, however, is how the saga shows that the capitalist politicians are also subject to the pressure of the working class, with their interests against austerity, privatisation and the neoliberal policies of the EU.
The Wallonia PS had to at least appear to make a 'left' stand against CETA because, as the Guardian noted (29 October), it was "under pressure" from the left-wing Workers' Party of Belgium (PTB/PvdA), "which is making inroads into Wallonia, a region of above-average unemployment".
The PTB broke through into the Walloon parliament in May 2014, but it only has two seats out of 75. Imagine then the impact Labour under Jeremy Corbyn could have on EU debates!
It is the working class, with no permanent interest in capitalism, which has the greatest possibility of reaching a common position - on socialist terms for trade arrangements with Canada or on Brexit - if a bold lead is given.
A Labour Party thoroughly transformed into a socialist, anti-austerity workers' party, committed to democratic public ownership of the economy and defiance of the pro-market, anti-worker and austerity-driving EU institutions, could play a pivotal role in building such unity.
After the recent EU summit Jeremy Corbyn was reported to be "inviting left-wing leaders from across Europe to an alternative meeting on Brexit in London" (Guardian, 21 October).
A bold stand by Corbyn against the anti-working class treaties and policies of the EU would electrify the debate across Europe.
CETA has only been signed into force on a temporary basis, subject to final approval by 38 national and regional assemblies.
Why not propose its scrapping as a negotiation 'red line' for a new relationship with the EU? And the abandonment of TTIP talks with the US, the end of the austerity-driving European Fiscal Compact, the write-off of the Eurozone debts, etc?
But who could Jeremy appeal to in order to fight for such a programme? The Belgian PS, which ultimately went along with CETA, or the PTB? The Irish Anti Austerity Alliance-Socialist Party TDs (members of the Irish parliament) being persecuted for opposing water charges, or their persecutors, the Irish Labour Party, who faithfully implemented the EU's austerity dictates?
The battle over CETA shows how the Brexit negotiations could be used to build a fighting socialist alliance on a continental scale, a vital preparation for creating a new, socialist, Europe. The opportunity must be seized.
- 'Were socialists right to say no to the EU?' - one of the sessions at Socialism 2016
26 Feb Austerity kills
Phone our national office on 020 8988 8777
Locate your nearest Socialist Party branch Text your name and postcode to 07761 818 206
Regional Socialist Party organisers:
Eastern: 079 8202 1969
East Mids: 077 3797 8057
London: 020 8988 8786
North East: 078 4114 4890
North West 079 5437 6096
South West: 077 5979 6478
Southern: 078 3368 1910
Wales: 079 3539 1947
West Mids: 024 7655 5620
Yorkshire: 077 0671 0041