World Social Forum 2004, Mumbai
NGOs Provide No Solutions For The Exploited
OVER 120,000 people attended the World Social Forum (WSF)
in Mumbai, India. The majority came in their tens of thousands from the most
poverty stricken areas of India as well as other countries in Asia such as
Pakistan, South Korea, Tibet and the Philippines.
Kevin Simpson (CWI), Mumbai
Also present were hundreds of trade unionists who
explained the horrific conditions they face as a result of the exploitation
of the multinational companies and also local capitalists (interviews in
next week’s the socialist).
However, they would not have found a programme from the
WSF organisers and most speakers on how to fight back against mass
unemployment, poverty, and discrimination.
NGOs’ failings
THE ATTENDANCE at the WSF is dominated by members of the
Non-Governmental Organisations (NGOs). While many sincere people work for
the NGOs, their leaders have played a negative role in the workers’ movement
in Asia. With Western aid, they have diverted a whole layer of potential
activists from class struggle with the promise of jobs and a personal
solution for the problems they face.
While the NGOs produce much factual material explaining
the horrific conditions faced by workers and poor farmers in the region,
they, in reality, oppose a determined struggle to change the conditions of
the masses in this part of the world.
NGO leaders who in the past have been good trade union
and community activists are now in control of huge budgets that have had a
corrupting influence on their politics. It is also the case that some NGOs
have made millions of Rupees at this event by winning contracts to provide
goods and services.
The WSF has a programme of meetings which numbers over
200 pages with literally thousands of meetings at the six-day event.
However, even at meetings scheduled to have over 20,000 delegates present
they attracted only a few hundred. This is because most of the meetings
provide no solutions to the problems that they face.
At the bigger meetings dominated by political activists,
the leaders of NGOs address the meetings in terms which simply are not
understood by the workers, peasants and youth who are there.
As the President of the United Labour Federation, V.
Prakash told CWI members: "The panel meetings simply exchange
grievances of various different sectors facing exploitation. When those
attending the meetings ask ‘how are we going to change things’, the panel
speakers simply say: ‘we have to rush to the next panel’."
At a meeting of the main left parties, including
Bertinotti of the PRC (Communist Refoundation, Italy) and representatives
from the Communist Party of India and Communist Party of India (Marxist),
not one speaker mentioned what kind of society should be fought for. The
words "socialism" and "communism" never passed their
lips.
Socialist alternative
DESPITE THIS, many genuine activists, workers and youth
have attempted to find their own solutions through thousands of informal
discussions, exchanging experiences and attempting to formulate strategies
to fight back against the conditions they face.
The Committee for a Workers International (CWI – the
socialist international organisation to which the Socialist Party is
affiliated) has members from Australia, Austria, Britain, CIS, India, Sri
Lanka and Sweden attending the event. We distributed over 40,000 leaflets
(in English, Tamil and Hindi) explaining the case for socialism.
We were the only political group who produced material
like this for the event. 121 copies of the CWI’s Indian Paper (Dudiyorohaata
– Workers’ Struggle) were sold at just one session to mainly poor farmers
from the Karnataka region of India. Many workers and youth have eagerly
snatched this material from our hands and become involved in animated
discussions. The betrayals of the Communist Parties in India mean that there
is a layer of young people looking for anti-capitalist and socialist ideas
in the form of a new party.
At a CWI meeting on Sri Lanka (with speakers from the
CWI’s party in Sri Lanka) two workers from Tamil Nadu in southern India
joined the New Socialist Alternative, the CWI’s section here.
It is workers and young people like these that the CWI
is seeking to provide answers to through our political explanation and our
record of campaigning against oppression and exploitation across the globe.
The CWI fights in countries throughout the world for a programme for the workers, poor and oppressed of the world which includes policies such as:
