Link to this page: http://www.socialistparty.org.uk/issue/682/12555

From The Socialist newspaper, 16 August 2011

Riots: rioters and police in Tottenham during August 2011 disturbances, photo Paul Mattsson

Click for gallery. Riot in Tottenham during August 2011 disturbances, photos by Paul Mattsson   (Click to enlarge)

Con-Dems to blame for anger of youth - mass, trade union-led workers' response needed

Judy Beishon

The four days of riots that followed the shooting dead of Mark Duggan by the police in Tottenham sent a massive shock wave across the country. However, tumultuous events of this nature were predictable - and were predicted in a number of Socialist Party documents and articles in recent months and years.

For instance in February 2011 the Socialist carried an article by Peter Taaffe on the 1932 Birkenhead struggles, in which a comment was made about today: "The explosion of anger in the so-called 'Tesco riot' in Bristol indicates the gathering force of opposition from below... such inchoate revolts, only on a bigger scale, will take place elsewhere as the widespread uprisings of the 1980s under Thatcherism showed".

During the four days, five people tragically died, over 100 people lost their homes and over 48,000 shops, pubs, clubs and restaurants were affected in 28 town centres.

"Over the last few days the state has lost control of England's streets" was the panic ridden comment of the Financial Times.

Sporting and leisure events were cancelled and virtual curfews operated in many areas - from Hackney in London to Toxteth in Liverpool. In the areas where the eruptions broke out, almost no one felt completely safe, for themselves, their families and their homes.

In places not directly affected, people feared what could come.

Riots: rioters and police in Hackney during August 2011 disturbances, photo Paul Mattsson

Click for gallery. Riots in Hackney, photos by Paul Mattsson   (Click to enlarge)

Prime minister David Cameron dismissed the street eruptions as "criminality pure and simple" and branded "pockets" of UK society as "sick". However the sickest pocket of all in society is him and his fellow multi-millionaires in the British ruling class, who have lifestyles that are a million light years away from those of the desperate young people whose anger exploded on the streets, and also those of ordinary working people across the country.

The ruling class was greatly shaken by the scale of the events and its international standing has been damaged just a year before the London Olympics.

Initially the government struggled to gain control of the situation, hastily convening meetings of Cobra, the emergency civil contingency committee.

But once the eruption was over, it turned to use the fear and insecurity that had developed, to spew out right-wing reactionary propaganda on 'criminality' and law and order, promoting legal revenge on those involved in rioting in order to cover up the terrible social conditions that lay behind it.

All young people can suffer from this propaganda offensive, with a whole generation potentially being demonised and labelled as troublemakers.

Con-Dems responsible

The government tries to deny that the riots are linked to cuts, but Lib Dem leader, Nick Clegg, blurted out prior to the general election:

"Imagine the Conservatives go home and get an absolute majority, on 25% of the eligible vote, they then turn around in the next week or two and say we're going to chuck up VAT to 20%, we're going to start cutting teachers, cutting police and the wage bill in the public sector. I think if you're not careful in that situation... you'd get Greek style unrest".

The Socialist Party does not support rioting as a method of protest, but we place the blame for what has taken place firmly on the Con-Dem government and say that it must be removed.

This government, on top of previous governments, has worsened and presided over a nightmare situation for young people. Even youth with the greatest determination to 'succeed' are in despair over the lack of jobs on decent pay and affordable accommodation.

A million young people are unemployed, youth services have been savagely cut, the Education Maintenance Allowance (EMA) axed, and university tuition fees are to be trebled.

Fires in Hackney, August 2011, photo Paul Mattsson

Fires in Hackney, August 2011, photo Paul Mattsson   (Click to enlarge)

It's no surprise that some young people have become so marginalised through lack of opportunity that they have become involved in gangs and many have developed - out of bitter experience - an overriding hatred of the police, mainstream politicians and other representatives of capitalist authority.

An onlooker to the riots in Hackney was quoted in the Times as noting: "Unfortunately this is about as empowered as many of these lads have ever felt in their lives and ever will feel".

How sickening has been the moralising by the media and politicians about 'teaching young people respect', 'the difference between right and wrong', and 'moral collapse'.

The young people who were involved in the eruption cannot fail to see or instinctively feel how 'wrong' the greed, corruption and amassing of vast wealth at the top of society is, with the resulting huge inequality.

And what 'respect' and morals did MPs show when they stuffed their pockets with expenses, or did top police and politicians show when they tried to protect Murdoch's phone hackers? What an irony that the London Met police were trying to quell this wave of violence without having their chief commissioner's post filled because the ex-chief had resigned under a cloud of corruption.

Not so 'mindless'

Plenty of riot participants who have been dismissed as non-political 'mindless criminals' have made political comments to the media against the rich, MPs and definitely the police, whose shooting of Mark Duggan triggered the start of the rioting.

The strong anger at that shooting was justified, especially as it has since been officially confirmed that the initial police version of what happened was false.

Black people in particular have been treated almost universally as potential criminals by the police; they are 26 times more likely than white people to be 'stopped and searched' under the provisions of the 1994 Criminal Justice and Public Order Act.

But the wave of chaotic and violent revolt encompassed all sections of youth, it was very mixed in composition. In some areas - such as Enfield - the participants were predominately white.

Riot police with dogs, Hackney, August 2011, photo Paul Mattsson

Riot police with dogs, Hackney, August 2011, photo Paul Mattsson   (Click to enlarge)

The court cases are showing that the looting involved low-paid workers as well as the unemployed - a reflection of the scale of anger and alienation that also exists in this layer.

But much of the media has deliberately played up the participation of young people who have jobs in order to downplay the plight of the unemployed. In reality, those appearing in court are overwhelmingly young and unemployed - youth facing some of the worst conditions and greatest deprivation.

In the reams of rubbish written in the media about the causes of the eruption, there is little mention of the word 'class' - that there is no homogenous community from bottom to top, but a gaping class divide, with inequality worsening year by year.

The eruption took a different form in each area. For instance in the London districts of Tottenham and Hackney it took place in the midst of working class communities and was a relatively indiscriminate lashing out.

In Manchester, small independent shops were among those looted, but a particular target was the major chain shops and luxury goods. But whatever form it took and whatever momentary release was gained through the outburst of anger, the unorganised, chaotic manner of the revolt has led to a number of unfortunate and in some cases tragic consequences for the participants, for the communities that suffered the direct effects, and for working people in general.

Heavy sentencing

Over 2,700 people have been arrested and around 1,200 charged so far. Offences vary from the minor to the very serious, but magistrates have been imposing prison sentences in rushed court hearings for even the most trivial cases.

Many young people charged have no previous convictions and momentarily succumbed to temptation to steal goods that were no longer locked away - and are now facing draconian, disproportionate sentences.

Those charged include a student who has been jailed for six months for stealing a £3.50 case of bottled water, a young worker given six months for taking chewing gum and a recent university graduate who took a TV and quickly handed it back in after the riots, saying she didn't know why she had taken it.

Tottenham riots, August 2011  , photo Paul Mattsson

Tottenham riots, August 2011 , photo Paul Mattsson   (Click to enlarge)

The Guardian reported that 3.5% of all cases heard in magistrates' courts last year resulted in remand in jail, but for the cases heard so far following the riots, it is over 60%.

Cameron recently said that he had given Coulson, the disgraced former News of the World editor, a "second chance", but he is offering no such thing to these young people and many others.

Those judging them are part and parcel of a judicial system that prioritises the defence of the private property of the rich, and are clearly pursuing a reactionary political agenda in these cases to try to deter further outbreaks of protest and anger.

The Socialist calls for the setting up of a democratically run inquiry into the riots involving elected representatives of trade unions and community organisations, that could also set the parameters on how the offences are dealt with, with the right to review sentences already imposed.

More repressive powers

It is not just the participants in the riots who will suffer the strong arm of the state forces, but trade unionists, anti-cuts campaigners, environment campaigners and others will now be faced with increased police powers and crowd control equipment in future struggles if the government's threats are carried out.

Cameron has said water cannon will be available at 24 hours notice. But a feature of the eruptions was 'flash riots' - spreading fast through use of Blackberry Messenger and other social networking.

Water cannon are useless in this type of situation as they can't be everywhere at once. But they can be used against more static crowds and pre-organised march routes - usual in demonstrations of the labour movement.

When parliament - for the second time in a month - was reconvened on 11 August, other possible repressive powers were outlined, including using army intervention; extra dispersal and curfew powers; increased powers to order the removal of face coverings; the spraying of semi-permanent dye; restricting the movement of 'gangs'; and blocking access to social networking media during times of 'social unrest'.

Disgracefully, the eviction of families from council homes is also being encouraged where a family member has been convicted of an offence; and benefits may be attacked too.

The future use of plastic bullets (baton rounds) has been discussed, though these lethal weapons may not be employed at this stage as some senior police representatives would prefer them to be held back for now.

These include Hugh Orde, president of the Association of Chief Police Officers, who authorised water cannon and baton rounds in Northern Ireland in the past, but bluntly said during the riots:

"Baton rounds are very serious bits of equipment. I would only deploy them in life-threatening situations.

"What is happening in London is not an insurgency that is going to topple the country".

However, a major campaign needs to be launched against the increased powers that are being proposed, which will reduce the democratic rights of everyone and can be used to try to prevent workers' anti-cuts demonstrations, to curtail or cancel events like the Notting Hill Carnival, and so on.

No increase in repressive measures will remove the discontent that lay behind the riots - they will only increase it, especially when considered together with the scale of the spending cuts that are still to be carried out and the extremely weak state of the world and British economies.

Riot police in Hackney, August 2011, photo Paul Mattsson

Riot police in Hackney, August 2011, photo Paul Mattsson   (Click to enlarge)

Danger of disunity

A potential danger in the present situation is of racial and ethnic division developing in some areas, for instance in Birmingham, where many believe that racism played a part in the terrible mowing down by a car driver of three young Asian men.

The far right British National Party and the English Defence League have both declared that they will organise to 'defend' communities, which means that they will spread racism and division as much as they can.

In contradistinction to this, local shopkeepers and communities quickly mobilised across ethnic and racial lines to defend business premises and homes in a number of areas during the rioting.

Had the riots continued, these initiatives could have been developed into democratically organised, mass, united defence of communities, with elected organising committees, as the Socialist Party would have called for.

It was also the case that after the riots, in many areas a mass of people turned out onto the streets to help clear up the mess and restore things to normal and donations poured in to help those who had lost homes and small businesses.

Mass, organised protest needed

The campaign 'Youth Fight for Jobs', which is supported by six trade unions, now has an even more crucial role to play.

But the trade union leaders have a responsibility to take their own national initiatives to cut across potential division and to attract young people and the unemployed into organised action for a massive programme of job creation, investment in social house building, defence of public services, and other measures to improve people's lives and basic conditions.

In particular, the four million strong public sector of the trade union movement needs to exert a massive show of strength this autumn to tell the government, through a united day of strike action, that it will not accept pension and other spending cuts.

The lobby of the TUC organised by the National Shop Stewards Network on 11 September is very important in building pressure on the TUC leaders for this action.

Police helicopters over Hackney riots, August 2011, photo Paul Mattsson

Police helicopters over Hackney riots, August 2011, photo Paul Mattsson   (Click to enlarge)

The government will not gain significant support from its propaganda offensive if the trade union movement puts forward an alternative to the Con-Dems' stance and cuts agenda, and builds for well prepared, well stewarded, mass industrial action.

It is shameful that TUC general secretary Brendan Barber and other TUC and labour leaders have not launched even a propaganda counter-offensive in defence of working class people and youth against the government's orgy of right-wing attacks and moralising.

This is despite the fact that the events have exacerbated divisions within the government and between ministers and the police chiefs, including over policing of the riots, the planned 20% cut in the police force budget and Cameron calling on a former New York police boss to help out.

The Labour Party leaders offer no alternative, they have mainly just timidly echoed Tory policies and condemnations of violence. A few Labour politicians, such as Harriet Harman, have tentatively drawn a link between the riots and the government's spending cuts, but without of course mentioning that Labour supports most of those cuts and that it helped to lay the basis for the present conditions and events during its 13 years in power until May 2010.

So this raises even more forcefully the burning need for urgent steps to be taken towards the creation of a new mass workers' party - one that can put forward a programme in the interests of ordinary working people across the country.

Following the widespread and profound shock at the riots, there will be many people questioning the nature of the system we live in and drawing the conclusion that it is deeply flawed and needs to be fundamentally changed.

The outburst of unorganised groups and individuals acting in a chaotic, disorganised way, caused the forces of the state to be temporarily overstretched.

Imagine what a mass movement of workers, acting in a highly organised, disciplined and democratically controlled way could do, to advance the interests of the overwhelming majority of people in society.

Armed with a socialist programme, of public ownership of the major companies and a planned economy, such a movement would be invincible, and could bring in a socialist government capable of offering youth a future that would provide them with decent living standards, and use and develop their talents and energies productively.


The above article - printed in issue 682 of the Socialist - is an updated and slightly shortened version of the original article under the same title posted on this website on 12.8.11.

NB: The original version included criticism of "the applauding of looting in the Socialist Worker newspaper this week". An article by Gary McFarlane incredibly said:

"Karl Marx was exactly right when he talked about expropriating the expropriators, taking back what they have taken from us. That's what looting by poor working class people represents and in that sense it is a deeply political act".

The article even tried to excuse arsonists who placed people in danger of burning to death, by saying:

"No one set out to try and kill or injure those living above [business] premises."

What a travesty to suggest that Marx would have supported the looting of goods from small businesses or arsonists setting alight to people's homes, rather than the mass, organised working class action that he actually stood for, against the capitalist class.


The Socialist Party calls for:

Socialism

Action

We stand for building a working class struggle for a socialist world

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.


In The Socialist 16 August 2011:


The street eruptions and aftermath

Con-Dems to blame for anger of youth - mass, trade union-led workers' response needed

Workers & youth unite!

After the riots... A mass workers’ movement is needed

Tell the TUC - call a 24-hour public sector general strike!

Birmingham peace rally shows need for jobs and services, not cuts

North London Unity demo - 'Workers and youth, unite and fight'

Defend council tenants from eviction!

Build strike action to defeat Con-Dems

Vital services "dying" because of cuts

Extracts from a statement from the Fire Brigades Union (FBU):

Youth workers' warnings ignored across the country

Trade union branch model resolution


Socialist Party news and analysis

World economy: Capitalists unable to stop the turmoil

News in brief


Socialist Party reports and campaigns

Stop the far-right EDL thugs

EDL try to act as vigilantes in Leicester

Reports: Pride gets political

Winston Silcott - framed by the police and justice system


Socialist Party youth and students

Doors continuously shutting on young people's futures

Youth march in Wales to demand jobs


Socialist history

The Great Unrest 1911

Liverpool 1911 - Jack's story


Socialist Party workplace news

Massive vote to continue action against Southampton cuts

Angry construction workers meet to plan strike action

Reinstate Paddy Brennan at Honda


Comments and reviews

Racist Starkey attacks rap


 

Facebook   Twitter



Home   |   The Socialist 16 August 2011   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate   |   Bookshop






Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter



Related links:

Riots:

triangleStop cuts and police repression in Tottenham!

triangleHuge anger at inquest verdict on killing of Mark Duggan

triangleCarol Duggan to speak at TUSC event in London

triangleHackney and Islington TUSC film showing: Riot from Wrong

triangleRiots Reframed - starting the debate

Youth:

triangleMosquito audio 'weapon' must be removed

triangleLiverpool Socialist Party youth: Socialism and the environment

triangleUnemployment kills

triangleJunk jobs - we're fightin' it!

Union:

triangleWorkplace news in brief

triangleNapo election: militant strategy can defeat privatisation

triangleTyneside Safety Glass strikers' stunning victory

Trade union:

triangleNew Tory attacks on trade union strikes

triangleAfter 10 July - build workers' movement

Police:

triangleCherry Groce - Met apologises 29 years later

Young people:

triangleKent TUSC stands up for Freedom Passes

Socialist:

triangleLancaster public meeting: a century of war

Unemployed:

triangleBlame the profit system not its victims!

Working class:

triangleSuper-rich flash cash at Tory bash

TUC:

triangleTrades council conference: workers won't wait for TUC

Hackney:

triangleEve-of-strike success for Look Ahead Unite members

Tottenham:

triangleTottenham: Stop fascist attacks

Democratic rights:

triangleCon-Dems and Labour fast-track 'snoopers charter'

News and socialist analysis

News and socialist analysis

16/7/14

Public sector

J10 strike success: Now build movement to end low pay

16/7/14

Scotland

Scotland: Threat of a Yes majority forces concessions

16/7/14

Child abuse

Abuse scandals reveal abusive system

16/7/14

Austerity

Them & Us

16/7/14

Democratic rights

Con-Dems and Labour fast-track 'snoopers charter'

16/7/14

Racism

Cherry Groce - Met apologises 29 years later

16/7/14

Minimum wage

Raise the minimum wage: £10 NOW

10/7/14

Public sector

Reports from 10 July pickets and demonstrations

9/7/14

General strike

After 10 July - build workers' movement

9/7/14

Super-rich

Super-rich flash cash at Tory bash

9/7/14

Andy Coulson

Coulson faces prosecution over Tommy Sheridan

9/7/14

Pay

Them & Us

9/7/14

Trade union

New Tory attacks on trade union strikes

9/7/14

EU

Junk Juncker, Cameron and the anti-worker EU

8/7/14

National Shop Stewards Network

NSSN - Organising the resistance

triangleMore News and socialist analysis articles...

Channel 4 reported that “it took them over 30 minutes to pass Nelson's column.”

triangle20 Jul London: huge show of solidarity

Tyneside Safety Glass workers celebrate pay dispute victory, July 2014, photo Elaine Brunskill

triangle16 Jul Tyneside Safety Glass strikers' stunning victory

Picketing Hackney Town Hall on 10 July 2014, photo Paul Mattsson

triangle16 Jul J10 strike success: Now build movement to end low pay

Leicester councillors Wayne Naylor and Barbara Potter, photo Leicester TUSC

triangle16 Jul Leicester anti-cuts councillors join up with TUSC

triangle16 Jul Eve-of-strike success for Look Ahead Unite members

triangle16 Jul Abuse scandals reveal abusive system

Protesting outside the Israeli embassy in London, 11.7.14, photo Paula Mitchell

triangle15 Jul No more onslaught on Gaza!

More ...

triangle23 Jul Hackney & Islington Socialist Party: Origins of the Middle East and Gaza today

triangle23 Jul Peterborough & Huntingdon TUSC meeting

triangle23 Jul West London Socialist Party: Stop the war in Gaza!

More ...

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube

Find us on Facebook

Archive

Categories

1-9 

1-9 


Archives:

July 2014

June 2014

May 2014

April 2014

March 2014

February 2014

January 2014

2013

2012

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2001

2000

1999

Legal

SP RSS feed RSS

Platform setting: = No platform choice