Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page: http://www.socialistparty.org.uk/issue/748/15994

From The Socialist newspaper, 16 January 2013

Northern Ireland: Flag issue turmoil illustrates failure of the 'peace process'

Trade unions must offer a clear cross-community, anti-sectarian class alternative

Ciaran Mulholland , CWI Northern Ireland

Turmoil over the issue of the flying of the union flag has now continued across Northern Ireland for six weeks.

The protests, involving the blocking of roads, petrol bombs and frequent rioting, began on 3 December when Belfast City Council voted to fly the flag over City Hall on 17 "designated days" rather than 365 days a year.

On some nights as many as 80 roads have been blocked. The police have used water cannon and fired potentially lethal plastic bullets and over 100 protesters have been arrested.

The worst violence has occurred in East Belfast where the local Ulster Volunteer Force (UVF) appears to be acting independently of the central UVF leadership.

Democratic Unionist Party (DUP - the largest unionist party) leader, and First Minister, Peter Robinson has stated that the protesters now only represent a "thin layer of unionism".

Robinson's party played an important role in kicking off the trouble when it and the second largest unionist party, the Ulster Unionist Party (UUP), together circulated 40,000 leaflets on the flag issue in the run-up to the City council vote.

This was despite the DUP and UUP on Lisburn City council quietly agreeing to the same arrangement for flying the union flag.

Now the leaders of the main unionist parties are trying to regain control of the situation. They are desperate to simultaneously play the card of sectarian division in order to maintain their vote, but also wish to play the role of responsible bourgeois politicians seeking to provide stability and social peace.

While the total numbers involved are relatively small there is no doubt that the issue has acted as a lightning rod for widespread dissatisfaction with the peace process which has built up over time in the Protestant community.

There is a sense that "everything is going in one direction", that is, Protestants are losing out to Catholics.

Progressive Unionist Party (the PUP is linked to the UVF) leader Billy Hutchinson has argued "Sinn Féin [the largest nationalist party] are acting outside the spirit of the Good Friday Agreement".

This is the reason that the PUP have given for reversing their previous conciliatory approach on the flags issue.

Extreme right winger Jim Allister of the Traditional Unionist Voice (TUV) has condemned Sinn Féin's "aggressive cultural war".

Allister's party is small but this assertion rings true for many more Protestants than those who are prepared to directly support him.

At the same time many Catholics continue to believe that they are subject to sectarian discrimination.

They hold that they are dealt with more harshly by the police. They know that they are more likely to be poor and unemployed than Protestants.

The real problem is that the peace process, established by the 1998 Good Friday Agreement, has failed to deliver for working class or young people whatever their background.

Under the structures established by the Good Friday Agreement it is assumed that everyone belongs to one or other of two mutually exclusive communities.

While all sections of the Protestant community have been affected by the flag issue it finds its sharpest expression in the most deprived working class areas.

The rioting and the road blocks are in part a distorted form of class anger directed at the unionist political establishment represented in the Assembly and on the Executive.

Under capitalism, all that is possible is a sharing out of political power and a sharing out of poverty and unemployment.

Unionist parties

While the protests have been mainly organised through social media, a leadership has emerged over the past weeks and is attempting to assert itself.

On 3 January the "Ulster Peoples Forum" (UPF) was launched to represent this new layer. Willie Frazer was elected as its spokesman.

The UPF has adopted two key demands: "A return to direct rule because of the failing of our political representatives" and "the Union Flag to be flown from every council building across Northern Ireland".

Such strident demands are designed to put pressure on the mainstream unionist parties (the DUP and UUP) and to carve out a base for Frazer and his allies.

The UPF has counter-posed itself to the "Unionist Forum" convened by the DUP and UUP and which also involves the PUP and the Ulster Defence Association (UDA)-linked Ulster Political Research Group (UPRG).

The Unionist Forum is a transparent attempt by the DUP and UUP to gain control of what is a confused and fluid situation.

Many unionist politicians have argued that the mobilisation of sufficient numbers of Protestant voters will reverse the flag decision.

Some have taken this argument further and raised the question of unionist unity or a single unionist party. Such unity may amount to little more than the DUP swallowing the UUP almost whole.

The UVF-linked PUP has had a very high profile throughout the protests and could gain electorally as a result. It has reported an influx of new members.

The PUP is strident on sectarian issues and is shortly to announce a programme of "cultural counter-attack" and "re-Britification".

Simultaneously it constantly raises issues of class, pointing out that all working class people are suffering.

The Alliance party, the target of loyalist wrath after it used its casting vote in Belfast council to limit the flying of the union flag, had made marginal gains in recent elections.

However its victory in the East Belfast Westminster seat at the last general election was in large part accidental.

Thousands of Protestant working class voters lined up behind the Alliance Party in order to deliver a bloody nose to Peter Robinson who was mired in a corruption scandal at the time.

Demographic change

While most of the rioting has involved Protestant youths battling with the police there has been a number of clashes between Catholics and Protestants especially at the Short Strand/Lower Newtownards Road interface area.

Dissident republican paramilitaries have consciously intervened to stoke the fires of sectarian division "offering" to "defend" the Short Strand.

The SDLP and Sinn Féin encourage Catholics to view this issue as a simple one of "democracy", often employing strident and sectarian language.

In their view Belfast is now a majority Catholic or nationalist city and consequently the union flag should come down.

This reflects the argument that demographic change is inexorably moving in one direction. At a certain time a tipping point will be reached and the majority of the population of Northern Ireland will be Catholic. Sinn Féin essentially holds that Protestants should "accept reality" and "move on".

This line of argument displays a profound amnesia. For three generations Catholics in Northern Ireland refused to recognise the "democracy" of Northern Ireland.

In their view they had been coerced into an artificial statelet and they would not bow down and accept this situation.

They were perfectly justified in this stance. Why now do nationalist and republican politicians assume that Protestants must accept the formal democracy of losing their majority position in the North, despite their fears of what a capitalist united Ireland would mean for them?

Political alternative

The picture is in many ways bleak but this can change, and change quickly. The trade unions are best placed to bring together workers in the workplaces and communities to discuss contentious issues, as well as burning class questions, and where possible initiate cross community, anti-sectarian committees that can counter sectarianism, including sectarian attacks on either community, and offer a class alternative.

Against the current background of conflict sectarian politicians continue to impose cuts on all workers. Northern Ireland will be hit harder than anywhere else by cuts in welfare payments.

The abolition of the public sector body which is responsible for housing, the Housing Executive, was announced by DUP minister Nelson McCausland, on 9 January.

The Assembly continues its deliberations over the future of the Educational Maintenance Allowance (EMA) but clearly intends to make sharp cuts in this vital student allowance.

Large-scale working class opposition to the cuts has already been expressed on the streets and in the workplaces in 2010 and 2011. But since 30 November 2011 there has been a lull in the class struggle.

There is no doubt that the vast majority of workers and young people are opposed to the violence. There is a widespread sense of unease that Northern Ireland is being dragged back to its more violent past.

In each community there are many who are consciously anti-sectarian and who see clearly the role of the sectarian politicians.

The majority of both Catholics and Protestants however are divided on the issue of the union flag.

So far there has not been an opportunity for the working class as a whole to give voice to its opposition to the violence.

There has been two "peace" demonstrations in Belfast city centre each drawing crowds of about 1,000. The organisers have insisted that the protests are non-political.

Such an approach will not succeed in mobilising working class people from either community. The issues are very much political.

Twenty years ago the Socialist Party pioneered an approach on the issue of contentious parades which focused on recognising the rights of each community, but also on the over-arching right of the working class as a whole not to be dragged into conflict. A similar approach should be taken now.

However, if a political alternative is not built, then reactionary, sectarian groups can develop further and gain support.

A new mass party of the working class, which actively combats sectarianism, is urgently needed.

See socialistworld.net for the full, in depth, version of this article

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.


In The Socialist 16 January 2013:


Fighting the cuts

Mass action to save our NHS

PCS fighting the austerity agenda - 'Action gets results'

Teachers: fight for strike action is on

Beware: latest pensions changes

Sussex County hospital cleaning and catering: The brutal reality of privatisation

Brixton Hill: Opposing Labour's 'cuts cooperative'

Two TUSC candidates standing against cuts on the Wirral


Socialist Party news and analysis

We need an alternative to blind-alley capitalism... socialism!

Northern Ireland: Flag issue turmoil illustrates failure of the 'peace process'

Prison closures = more privatisation

Them & Us

News In brief


Socialist Party feature

Renationalise the railways now!


Socialist Party reports and campaigns

Tory minister lies about 'lategate'...

Sheffield fight back, or we'll have nothing left!

Swindon: 1,100 Honda job losses

Indian embassy protest: raging against rape


Reviews and readers' comments

Capitalism - Forever blowing bubbles

Review of the film 'McCullin'

A day in the life... Young, low-paid, bullied and angry

Reject the wedge between generations


 

Home   |   The Socialist 16 January 2013   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate   |   PDF  




Related links:

Northern Ireland:

triangleBoeing bust-up threatens thousands of skilled jobs

triangleWeakened Tories forced into Northern Ireland abortion u-turn

triangleCardiff East Socialist Party: The DUP, Northern Ireland, and socialism vs sectarianism

triangleWirral Socialist Party: The DUP, Northern Ireland, and socialism vs sectarianism

triangleNorthern Ireland: DUP propping up the Tories

Trade unions:

triangleStrikers rally in Liverpool

triangleSocialism 2017: ideas to change the world

triangleAslef members must reject poor Southern Rail offer

Working class:

triangleFighting sexism, violence and capitalism - an international struggle

triangleLeft comic's take on politics will have you in tears

triangleWaltham Forest Socialist Party: Environmental crisis - a working class issue

Catholic:

triangleScotland 'indyref2' for socialist independence not the capitalist EU

News and socialist analysis

News and socialist analysis

8/12/17

Government

Local government pay: fight for the 5% claim, fully funded

6/12/17

Labour

Corbyn's Labour can defeat Tories with socialist programme

6/12/17

NHS

Branson sues NHS: kick out the profiteers

6/12/17

Immigration

Royal wedding exposes them-and-us visa system

6/12/17

Banks

RBS to sack 1,000: nationalise the banks

6/12/17

Homelessness

Rough sleeping crisis: make homes, not arrests

6/12/17

Poverty

End Tory war on poor

6/12/17

Rail

Nationalise rail now

29/11/17

Them & Us

Them & us

29/11/17

Homes

Tory housing policy: build zilch, hike prices

29/11/17

Wages

Make the Tories history

29/11/17

Birmingham

Birmingham bin workers win!

29/11/17

British economy

Amber warning lights flash on British economy

23/11/17

Pay

After the budget - unions must launch pay fight

22/11/17

Climate change

Carbon dioxide hits 800,000-year high: end profit-driven pollution

triangleMore News and socialist analysis articles...


Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party

triangle8 Dec Local government pay: fight for the full 5% claim

triangle6 Dec Strikers rally in Liverpool

triangle6 Dec Corbyn's Labour can defeat Tories with socialist programme

triangle5 Dec Victory at Glenfield shows people power can save our NHS

triangle5 Dec Labour council Blairites deselected

triangle30 Nov Victory: Glenfield Children's Heart Centre saved!

triangle30 Nov Dramatic retelling of Grunwick strike

More ...

triangle12 Dec Birmingham South East Socialist Party: Can the Labour Party be changed?

triangle12 Dec Liverpool Socialist Party: Fighting council cuts

triangle13 Dec Caerphilly Socialist Party: Are we heading for an era of war?

triangle14 Dec Wakefield Socialist Party: Universal Credit - the Tories' latest assault on the poor

More ...

Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube

Archive

Archives:

December 2017

November 2017

October 2017

September 2017

August 2017

July 2017

June 2017

May 2017

April 2017

March 2017

February 2017

January 2017

2016

2015

2014

2013

2012

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

Legal

SP RSS feed RSS

Platform setting: = No platform choice

V2