Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page:

From The Socialist newspaper, 17 September 2008

Scotland: Tactical questions for local government pay battle

On 20 August almost 200,000 Scottish local government workers across three trade unions took united strike action forcing the employers to move from a three-year offer to a one-year deal. However, a battle is still needed to win an inflation-busting deal. The following letter was sent to The Socialist following the strike report in issue 547. See for the article.

Brian Smith's article on the Scottish council workers' struggle contains a couple of misrepresentations. Unison's Scottish Local Government Conference of 5 September did discuss the next step in the campaign. The Local Government Committee (LGC) put forward a strategy of continuing joint action with the GMB and Unite for a further one day strike on 24 September and selective action throughout October. This was agreed almost unanimously.

The Glasgow emergency motion was put to the conference to be accepted onto the agenda. This failed to get the two-thirds majority required. This was a reflection of branches' intentions to vote against the motion. It was later accepted onto the agenda following a recommendation from the committee to the conference chair. The motion was debated at length but with only Glasgow speaking in support (with four speakers) and only one other branch voting in favour.

Brian fails to reflect the mood of the conference and seems to suggest that the 'leaders' were somehow dragging their heels and reluctant to take action. This could not be further from the truth. As a member of the negotiating team and one of the Scottish Socialist Party (SSP) members speaking in opposition to the Glasgow motion (on behalf of my branch, not the SSP) I regret that the comrades in the International Socialists (IS) are out of touch with the vast majority of union activists and members in Scotland. I regret even more that neither Brian nor other IS comrades attempted to have any discussion with those of us in the 'leadership' who are attempting to maintain unity in action, bringing the weakest branches with us at the same time as putting forward a bold strategy for action to win the dispute.

No credit is given to the 'leadership' for the action in August or for maintaining a joint campaign with the two other unions. Brian seems to fail to understand that the 'leadership' in this dispute are branch activists like himself who have worked very hard to build a campaign at local and national levels. While the local government unions in England have collapsed into talks and the health three-year deal was accepted, the Scottish council unions have built a successful campaign with successful action delivered, concessions made by the employers, and further action planned.

Surely it is time for the IS to come in from the ultra-left fringes and actually get serious about building campaigns alongside other trade union activists. Sometimes it is not good enough to lecture fellow workers, you have to listen to them, debate with them and try to work with them for the benefit of the union and the members.

Stephen Smellie
South Lanarkshire Unison branch secretary

Response from Brian Smith:

Stephen makes three basic accusations; the International Socialists (IS) won't work with others, are out of touch with ordinary union members and are ultra left.

I hoped that Stephen would have explicitly supported the idea of having the debate on the Glasgow motion. The Glasgow motion was with the Local Government Committee (LGC) and all the Scottish branches almost two weeks before the meeting on 5 September, unlike the LGC emergency motion which was handed out after the meeting had already begun. I don't think it is unreasonable that, five months into a dispute where there has been little movement from the employers, there should be a discussion on tactics.

The Unison members in Glasgow who have been involved in discussions in the workplaces and the Glasgow branch committee are overwhelmingly in favour of escalating the action beyond a series of monthly one-day strikes and selective action. Glasgow consulted with its members. Glasgow has listened to its members. Glasgow has put forward its members' views. Stephen cannot casually dismiss the views of the largest branch in Scotland as the views of the 'ultra-left fringes' who are out of touch with ordinary members. Unlike Stephen's assertion, on the contrary, we in the IS have listened to fellow workers, debated with them and worked with them to advance the dispute.

Stephen suggests that I or other members in the IS should have contacted the LGC. Two members of the LGC (around 18 people) come from Glasgow. One was supportive of the motion during discussions within the branch and the other made no attempt to alter the motion. The members of the Glasgow branch committee who are also in the SSP expressed their support for the motion. One even argued for no 'life and limb' cover. I am not aware of any request from the LGC to the Glasgow branch to discuss the motion in the weeks before the 5 September meeting. I am not sure who else we were supposed to consult with.

If Stephen is suggesting that the LGC cannot be challenged because they are lay members of the union then I am afraid I must disagree with him. We are all accountable to who elects us. The LGC are the 'leadership' in this dispute. The fact that the pay disputes in local government in the rest of the UK or in the NHS have been poorly led is hardly the point.

Finally, Stephen calls for the IS to get serious about building campaigns alongside other trade union activists. This call either reveals Stephen's lack of knowledge of the work of IS activists within the labour and trade union movement or is an attempt at mischief. The several episodes of industrial action in Glasgow over the last few years have arisen directly from cooperative activity between activists of various shades of political opinion, including the IS. We are heavily involved in the Scottish Shop Stewards' Network. Any blocks to work cooperatively with other activists who seek to maintain unity in action, will not come from the International Socialists.

Brian Smith (personal capacity),

Social work stewards secretary, Glasgow Unison

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.

In The Socialist 17 September 2008:

Credit crunch

It's time to fight back!

Socialist Party editorial

Capitalist crisis - Karl Marx was right


No to racism: Yes to decent jobs, homes & services!

Socialist Party campaigns

Socialist candidate gains 40% of vote, stuns Usdaw leaders

Conflict in Georgia - independent position needed

Brown's feeble fuel package

Labour Party conference protest

Protest at war and occupation

Welcome to the real Manchester

Fighting city needs a fighting party

Panicky MPs turn on Labour

Privatisation and closure

No to post office closures

Protesters tackle Metro privatisation

Socialist Party feature

Middle East: End imperialist aggression!

Socialist Party workplace news

London bus strike: "Showing them our power"

Pickets cheer in West London

Ford workers meet to defend jobs

Journalists win union recognition victory

2008 Trades Union Congress: Pressure from below begins to show

Swansea rail workers fighting for a living wage


International socialist news and analysis

Interview with Cindy Sheehan: "Some kind of populist uprising needs to happen"

Scotland: Tactical questions for local government pay battle

Socialist Party review

'Bob Marley' reviewed by Jason Toynbee


Home   |   The Socialist 17 September 2008   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate  

Related links:

Local government:

triangleUnite local government sector plans strike ballot

triangleDemand for no-cuts budget grows

triangleBack the Brum bin strikers!

triangleUnison must back Corbyn's pledge to abolish zero-hour contracts with action

triangle200,000 empty homes - 250,000 homeless - end property speculation


triangleWhere is Scotland going?

triangleSwansea Socialist Party: Is the National Question finished in Scotland & Wales?

triangleScotland - SNP loses but Labour could've won more

triangleMay and Tories must go!


triangleGlasgow jannies win famous victory against council cutters

triangleGlasgow janitors win famous victory

triangleElectric atmosphere at Corbyn rally

Reports and campaigns

Reports and campaigns


North West

Arriva North West bus drivers strike over pay


Democratic rights

Conference on state spies: who's watching who?



Striking back against sackers' charter at Leeds Uni


Royal Mail

Royal Mail bosses block strike - back postal workers



Balloting members on the pay cap



'Dazzling' Bad Art show points to socialist future



Sheffield Labour council threatens peaceful protesters with prison


South West Wales

Hundreds turn out for rally aimed at removing west Wales Tory MP



Uprising to save the NHS!



Can you donate to the Socialism 2017 appeal?


East London

No cuts - hands off King George A&E!


North London

North London hospital workers fight cuts and job losses



Nationalise to save jobs at BAE Systems



Schools "can't go any further" - stop the cuts: set deficit budgets now



Socialist Students 'welcome' Hillary Clinton to Swansea

triangleMore Reports and campaigns articles...

Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party

triangle19 Oct Arriva North West bus drivers strike over pay

triangle18 Oct Russia, October 1917: When workers took power

triangle18 Oct Tories torn - bin them now

triangle18 Oct Royal Mail bosses block strike - back postal workers

triangle18 Oct Balloting members on the pay cap

triangle13 Oct The end of the Tories?

triangle11 Oct Nasty party out the Tories

More ...

triangle21 Oct Birmingham: NSSN Solidarity Forum

triangle23 Oct Chesterfield Socialist Party: The continuing struggle for abortion rights

triangle24 Oct Liverpool Socialist Party: The October Russian Revolution 100 years ago to the day

triangle25 Oct Salford Socialist Party: The October 1917 Russian revolution

More ...

Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube



October 2017

September 2017

August 2017

July 2017

June 2017

May 2017

April 2017

March 2017

February 2017

January 2017





















Platform setting: = No platform choice