Link to this page: http://www.socialistparty.org.uk/issue/556/6600

From The Socialist newspaper, 12 November 2008

Why Labour won the Glenrothes by-election

THE GLENROTHES by-election on 6 November produced a shock result - Labour won! After a series of by-election defeats for Gordon Brown's deeply unpopular government, including Crewe and Nantwich and Glasgow East, the surprise was that they held the seat, never mind with an almost 7,000 majority.

Philip Stott, CWI Scotland

The Scottish Nationalists (SNP) achieved a 23% swing in winning the Glasgow East election in July - the more modest 15% swing needed to win Glenrothes should have been well within the grasp of an SNP who were still apparently enjoying an 18-month long honeymoon as a minority Scottish government.

Add to this the banking crisis that threatens thousands of jobs in Scotland, the economy pitching into deep recession, rising unemployment, house repossessions and New Labour's public-sector pay cuts and it was no wonder the bookies had the SNP as hot favourites to win.

Alex Salmond confidently, and for many arrogantly, predicted victory. He even tried to bask in the glory of Barak Obama's victory by using Obama's 'yes we can' slogan and declaring; "yes we can" win the election. In the end the SNP could only manage a 5% swing from Labour.

Labour's vote actually went up compared to the 2005 general election - the first time a party of government increased their vote in a by-election in Scotland since 1978. Some commentators put it down to the "Brown bounce," a product of Brown and chancellor Alistair Darling's "economic competence," the pinnacle, or nadir, of which was the handing over of 500 billion in public money to bail out and part nationalise the banking system.

But, there was little positive enthusiasm in Glenrothes for either the bailout of the rich bankers or for New Labour's response to an economic crisis that was rooted in the neo-liberal capitalist policies championed by Gordon Brown as both chancellor and now prime minister. The continued opposition to New Labour policies was partially reflected in the SNP's 13,209 votes, a 37% share.

Two decisive factors decided this election's outcome - firstly, the actions of the SNP who run Fife council in coalition with the Lib Dems. The SNP, whose council leader was their candidate in the Glenrothes election, imposed draconian charges on the elderly and disabled in Fife.

Homecare charges that had been a flat rate of 4 a week or free to those people on benefits - rose to a means-tested 11 an hour. Other charges were levied including for Community Alarms. New Labour's campaign was almost a single-issue onslaught on the SNP, accusing them of carrying out a vendetta against the sick, disabled and the most vulnerable. Effectively, they called for a referendum on the SNP's attacks on the elderly and disabled. This had a significant impact.

In election week, the SNP government gave the green light to billionaire tycoon Donald Trump to build a billion pound golf complex in Scotland, overruling the decision of the local planning committee. This contrast between attacking the poor and dancing to the tune of a billionaire did not go unnoticed. The local SNP MSP commented that she saw people voting Labour who had not voted for 20 years.

Iain MacWhirter commented in the Sunday Herald: "In Glenrothes, for the first time, the Labour Party managed to portray the SNP as something different: as the inheritors of Thatcherism, callous cutters and tartan Tories who care more about their small-business friends than about protecting the vulnerable."

Economic crisis

THE SECOND factor was the impact of the economic crisis that raises serious questions in workers' minds about whether an independent Scotland could be viable on a capitalist basis.

Moreover the SNP's much talked about economic model of Ireland, Iceland, Norway and an independent Scotland, the so-called "arc of prosperity" has crumbled to dust. Iceland is in the grip of national bankruptcy while Ireland was the first European country to enter a recession.

There were increasing doubts about whether, against the backdrop of the biggest economic crisis since the 1930s, a dramatic fall in the price of oil and a severe contraction in the banking and financial sector, an independent Scotland could offer a way out. These doubts are likely to remain a big complication for the SNP as the recession worsens.

Alex Salmond and the SNP have supported Brown and Darling's state bailouts of the banks and have also joined New Labour in attacking the pay of public sector workers in Scotland.

For many workers, even those sympathetic to independence, the SNP's inability to provide any answers to the deepening economic crisis will tend to undermine support for independence, as suggested in a recent poll that found 37% of people now supported the idea of independence, down from 41% in April, with 45% opposed.

These factors together allowed Labour to hold onto the seat with a reduced majority. The Glenrothes election's polarisation was even more pronounced than in Glasgow East. 92% of those who voted chose either the SNP or Labour. Both the Tories and the Lib Dems lost their deposits and the votes of the smaller parties, including the socialist Solidarity movement, were squeezed badly.

However, what the result underlines is the need for a party to be built that puts forward a socialist and working-class alternative to the economic crisis and to capitalism. As recession deepens, New Labour will see their support further undermined.

The SNP, at all levels of government, are increasingly prepared to wield the axe against working-class communities and workers in struggle and present no alternative.

It is an urgent task to strengthen the forces of Solidarity as a step to building a powerful force that can act as a pole of attraction in the months ahead.

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.


In The Socialist 12 November 2008:


Socialist Party campaigns

Defend workers' jobs and pay

PCS union: Strike threat wins talks

Confined to one room

Fast news


Socialism 2008

Socialism 2008 - an inspiring weekend


War and occupation

Iraq, Afghanistan... End the occupations!


Socialist Party Marxist analysis

A political awakening propels Obama to victory

Why Labour won the Glenrothes by-election


Socialist Students

'Students in the Red' day of action

East Anglia region demands free education


Education

NUT leadership fails to call strike

Scotland: Victory for the Vale of Leven Four

The workload of a teacher


Socialist Party review

Prescott: the class system and me


 

Facebook   Twitter



Home   |   The Socialist 12 November 2008   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate   |   Bookshop






Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter



Related links:

Election:

triangleClacton Tory MP defects to Ukip

trianglePre-election Britain - crisis brewing on all fronts

triangleGovernment's economic mirage as election approaches

triangleJess Spear election success

triangleCapitalist crisis continues

Labour:

triangle1.6 million vote Yes in a working class revolt against austerity

triangleSocialist Party campaigning news

triangleKeep hospital services in the NHS

SNP:

triangle"Britain will never be the same again"

triangleScottish referendum: A mass revolt against austerity

Scotland:

triangleScotland Poll: Electric mood among YES supporters

Reports and campaigns

Reports and campaigns

18/9/14

Glasgow

Scotland Poll: Electric mood among YES supporters

17/9/14

Socialist Party

Socialist Party campaigning news

17/9/14

The Socialist

The Socialist: a tool for workplace organisers

17/9/14

Rail

Fighting for fair fares

17/9/14

Trade unions

TUC congress: Reject Carney's 'equality of sacrifice'

17/9/14

Brixton

Ritzy cinema workers win 26% pay rise

17/9/14

UCU

Lambeth College

17/9/14

Scotland

Campaigning for a YES vote

16/9/14

Tommy Sheridan

Tommy Sheridan on BBC's Sunday Politics

11/9/14

London

London bus drivers march for decent pay

11/9/14

FBU

FBU Ring of Fire tour

10/9/14

Teachers

NUT members angry at lack of October strike action

10/9/14

Tamil Solidarity

Solidarity Day: a great success

10/9/14

Napo

Probation officers protest against privatisation

10/9/14

Leicester

TUSC councillors back taxi struggle

triangleMore Reports and campaigns articles...

Scotland

triangle19 Sep 1.6 million vote Yes in a working class revolt against austerity

triangle18 Sep Scotland Poll: Electric mood among YES supporters

triangle18 Sep The struggle for decent social care - a personal account

Fast Food Rights campaigners in Leeds on 28 August 2014, photo Erika Sykes

triangle17 Sep 10 NOW!

Students protesting at Sussex university, photo Suzanne Beishon

triangle17 Sep Students: fight to end austerity and capitalism

triangle17 Sep Climate change: 'We're running out of time'

The Socialist (Scotland)

triangle16 Sep Scottish referendum: 'Britain will never be the same again'

More ...

triangle22 Sep Socialist Party Scotland Public meeting after the referendum: Glasgow

triangle22 Sep Birmingham Central Socialist Party: Socialism and Nationalism

triangle22 Sep Teesside Socialist Party: Could an independent Scotland meet the aspirations of the Scottish people?

triangle23 Sep Birmingham South East Socialist Party: Question and Answer - Find out what we stand for

More ...

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube

Find us on Facebook

Archive

Categories

1-9 

1-9 


Archives:

September 2014

August 2014

July 2014

June 2014

May 2014

April 2014

March 2014

February 2014

January 2014

2013

2012

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2001

2000

1999

Legal

SP RSS feed RSS

Platform setting: = No platform choice