Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page:

From The Socialist newspaper, 9 December 2009

Scotland: The national question and the general election

THE SCOTTISH National Party (SNP) government in Scotland marked St Andrew's day - 30 November - by presenting a 'white paper' which sets out its case for a fully independent Scotland. This is to be followed in early 2010 by a parliamentary bill allowing for a referendum on Scotland's constitutional future, which will include a question on independence.

Philip Stott, International Socialists, CWI Scotland

However, the majority of MSPs (members of the Scottish parliament), at this stage, are opposed to a referendum on independence and there is little chance of a referendum bill being passed by the Scottish parliament before the next Scottish elections in 2011.

The SNP have therefore made it clear that they are not opposed to a third question in a referendum that gives the option of extending the powers of the parliament - but which falls short of full independence. This option has majority public support according to all opinion polls at the moment.

Meanwhile, Gordon Brown's Westminster government have accepted most of the recommendations of the Calman commission that proposed extending the powers of the Scottish parliament. The centre piece of this is making the Scottish parliament responsible for the setting of income tax in Scotland beyond the first 10p in the pound that will be set at a UK level, as well as some other limited powers.

The Tories have responded by agreeing that if they win the general election they will bring forward their own proposals for strengthening the devolutionary powers of the parliament.

What is clear is that the "first phase" of devolution in Scotland and Wales has come to an end. All the main capitalist parties now favour, to one degree or another, a change to the 1999 devolutionary arrangements that were established, of which the union forms an important part.

Resurgent nationalism?

With a Westminster general election a few months away, this flurry of activity from the political establishment reflects partly a manoeuvring for maximum political advantage.

But it is also a realisation that the current devolutionary arrangements have lost support, largely because the various pro-capitalist governments have failed to solve the problems of working class communities.

This is reflected in growing public support for more widespread powers for the Scottish parliament. Added to this is a growing fear by the pro big business political elite that a resurgence of nationalist feelings will follow the next general election.

If Tory leader David Cameron were to win an outright majority next year it is likely to lead to a powerful resurgence of nationalism in Scotland. It would be seen as a return to the 'dark days' of the 1980s and 1990s, when the Tories were left with a rump in Scotland, but a Tory government held power across Britain as a whole.

There is an increasingly powerful mood to stop the Tories coming to power. The memory of Thatcherism, with the economic and social carnage that came in its wake, is still strong, particularly among the older generation.

Many working class people in Scotland will vote at all costs to try and stop the return of a Tory government. Even if that means holding their noses and voting Labour. However, this does not reflect any enthusiasm for the big business friendly policies of the Brown government.

Under these conditions, a Tory government, while attempting to implement an all-out war on public spending and the working class generally, could themselves have to make concessions on the national question and offer talks over extending the powers of the parliament.


The capitalist crisis is deva-stating all sectors of the economy in Scotland. Growth rates are due to shrink by 5% this year, an even bigger decline than during the worst period of the Thatcher era in 1980-81.

All the capitalist parties, including the SNP, are committed to policies of the slashing of public services, jobs and working conditions.

The International Socialists support a parliament in Scotland with full economic powers to tackle the economic crisis.

That means the power to nationalise the banks and other industries threatening job cuts and closures, the power to increase the minimum wage, pensions and benefits, end privatisation and get rid of Trident nuclear weapons.

We also need to build a mass working class party committed to socialist policies to fight for the interests of the working class and champion the building of a socialist Scotland that would take its place as part of a voluntary socialist confederation alongside England, Wales and Ireland as a step to a socialist Europe.

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.

In The Socialist 9 December 2009:

Corus steel closure: 'Bail out our jobs, not greedy bankers'

Corus closure

Nationalise Corus Steel

Youth Fight for Jobs campaigners speak out on Corus closure

Socialist Party editorial

Socialist nationalisation - the only way to save manufacturing jobs and end the bank bonus scandal

Teesside steel: No trust in big business 'solutions'

War and occupation

End the war in Afghanistan

Global Warming

Climate change summit: Coming up short in Copenhagen

Socialist Party news and analysis

Free the Tamil boat people

Fight the political witch-hunt in Unison

Fast news

Youth fight for jobs

Youth Fight for Jobs organises demo in Barking

Socialist Party workplace news

New Labour gift wraps Tyne and Wear Metro

Stoke Axiom workers escalate the action

Save jobs at Borders

Twinings workers fight job losses

Management bullying? Surely not...

Socialist Students

Uniting to stop cuts at Sussex

Starting Socialist Students at a Coventry sixth form

No to student civic service

Northampton protest against student loan delays

Socialist Party feature

The legacy of Charles Darwin

International socialist news and analysis

Solidarity with striking South African miners

Scotland: The national question and the general election


English Defence League show themselves up

Socialist Party appeal

Christmas 2009 donation appeal

A present that can last all year - a subscription to The Socialist


Home   |   The Socialist 9 December 2009   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate  

Related links:


triangleUndercover policing legal challenge

triangleWhat does the left victory in Scottish Labour mean?

triangleScotland: BiFab workers' occupation and march secures jobs and pay guarantee

triangleCardiff East Socialist Party: Catalonia, Scotland and Wales

triangleSE London Socialist Students & Socialist Party: Catalonia & Scotland


triangleAmy Murphy for Usdaw president - vote for a fighting and democratic union

triangleCabinet chaos as shambolic reshuffle underlines Theresa May's impotence

triangleThe Socialist's 2017 quiz

triangleBlairite horror and Labour's divisions graphically exposed


triangleTories on the brink - kick them out!

triangleWestminster sexual harassment scandal

triangleWestminster sexual harassment scandal: symptom of a rotten system

Working class:

triangleWidening wealth gap, increase in poverty...make the fat cats pay

triangle2018: more upheavals loom


triangleSocialist sales highest in years as mistrust in capitalist media hits record levels


triangleWhere is Scotland going?




Hong Kong

Stop repression in Hong Kong and China



Tunisia: explosion of protests against government austerity



Movement challenges Iranian regime



Appeal from Iranian independent unions



Sweden: School strike against deportations



Catalan elections: PP humiliated



Trump's incendiary Jerusalem statement reignites Israeli-Palestinian conflict



A world in crisis, ripe for revolution



Trump's tax plan: Robin Hood in reverse



Irish capitalist state: rotten to the core



Fighting sexism, violence and capitalism - an international struggle



Trump's tax attacks



Australia: massive yes vote for marriage equality



Zimbabwe: Mugabe gone - but his regime remains in power



USA: Historic vote for Ginger Jentzen campaign in Minneapolis

triangleMore International articles...

Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party

triangle17 Jan Corbyn's Labour needs 100% anti-cuts strategy and fight for democracy

triangle17 Jan NHS crisis: under pressure from all angles - end cuts and sell-offs!

triangle17 Jan We must fight all council cuts!

triangle16 Jan Home care workers to strike

triangle15 Jan Carillion crisis: Demand action to save jobs and services

triangle12 Jan Outrage against 'monster block' plan

triangle12 Jan Mini-strike wave continues and intensifies

More ...

triangle23 Jan Bristol North Socialist Party: 'You can't have capitalism without racism' - was Malcolm X correct?

triangle23 Jan Cardiff West Socialist Party: How the Poll Tax was beaten

triangle24 Jan Caerphilly Socialist Party: The Carillion scandal

triangle24 Jan Cardiff Central Socialist Party: Carillion collapse - Watershed moment for public services

More ...

Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube



January 2018






















Platform setting: = No platform choice