Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page:

From The Socialist newspaper, 6 July 2011

Dilnot report: A disservice to disabled and older people

A disabled activist

The 'independent' report, Fairer Care Funding, by the Dilnot commission has predictably failed to address the primary cause of the current crisis in social care - the underfunding of local authority social services by successive Tory and New Labour governments.

It has also brought forward the day when people will have to use private insurance to pay for their care and personal assistance needs.

According to economist Andrew Dilnot, and his colleagues Dame Jo Williams, chair of the Care Quality Commission, and former Labour health minister Lord Warner, the "current adult social care funding system in England is not fit for purpose and needs urgent and lasting reform."

They argue: "The current system is confusing, unfair and unsustainable. People are unable to plan ahead to meet their future care needs. Assessment processes are complex and opaque. Eligibility varies depending on where you live and there is no portability if you move between local authorities. Provision of information and advice is poor, and services often fail to join up. All this means that in many cases people do not have good experiences."

While there is some truth to these assertions, they do not arise from inherent fault lines within social care or its interaction with health services. Rather the current crisis is rooted in the failure to fully fund and implement section 2 of the Chronically Sick and Disabled Persons Act 1970 which places a duty on councils to provide services to disabled people in order to meet their needs.

Lifetime costs

Many newspaper headlines have focused on the Dilnot commission's proposals to 'cap' the lifetime costs of either home or residential care to 35,000 and raise the means test threshold for residential care to 100,000. But this is very thin icing on what is a very poisonous report if its recommendations are accepted by the Con-Dem government.

The commission supports the continuation of means-tested support for those with 'lower means', but contradictorily calls for free state support for young disabled people entering adulthood. It also suggests that people in residential care should pay between 7,000 and 10,000 a year for their 'board and lodgings'. If the latter idea becomes policy, how long would it be before it is applied to hospital-based care?

For social care, the commission believes minimum eligibility should be set at 'substantial' - an incredibly high threshold that would effectively mean the majority of disabled people and family carers of all ages being permanently excluded from social services. Laughably they would then be expected to turn towards the underfunded community sector and volunteers for vital help and support.

While the commission supports the continuation of universal benefits, it does not criticise the replacement of disability living allowance with personal independence payments - a policy designed to reduce the number of claimants by 20%.

The commission says between 1.3 billion and 2.2 billion is needed to implement its 'reforms'. But 1 billion has already been cut from social care this year alone, and the 350 million Independent Living Fund for those with the most complex needs is to close.

But the most dangerous part of this report lies in its support for the idea that there needs to be a 'partnership' between the individual and the state, ie people will be expected to save through their working life to pay for the first 35,000 or so of care costs in later life.

This will necessitate the development of financial products such as private insurance or savings schemes.

How will young people today with the high cost of pensions, mortgages or rent, and student loans and tuition fees to payback, be able to save the amount the Dilnot commission is proposing before the state steps in?

Dilnot, Williams and Warner have performed a disservice to disabled and older people, family carers and the working class, and should be condemned for this. The anti-cuts movement must take up this issue and demand that decent care be a right for all who need it.

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.

In The Socialist 6 July 2011:

30th June strike and after

What next to defeat the cuts?

Next time - strike together...

24-hour public sector general strike as next step to beat the Con-Dems

Standing up to a weak government

Labour - condemned for condemning strike

Solidarity from POA

We can win together

Walkout at Wormwood Scrubs prison

30 June pension strike reports

Socialist Party news and analysis

Leaked memo shows government lied over its homeless policies

Dilnot report: A disservice to disabled and older people

Durham Miners' Gala: Miliband pulls out

Stop the racist and divisive EDL

Time to defend abortion rights... again

News in brief

Socialist Party workplace news

Southampton council workers strike on same day as teachers, lecturers and civil servants

Birmingham - the fightback begins

Leeds Unison members decisively reject the council's final offer

Fawley refinery construction engineers summarily sacked

Fighting pension cuts and the anti-union laws

Workplace news in brief

Successful NSSN meeting in Coventry

International socialist news and analysis

East Belfast riots: Only united working class action can prevent further attacks

Kazakhstan: Striking oil workers attempt to break news blockade

Sabotage on ship to Gaza

Socialist Party reports and campaigns

All workers: unite to fight for decent jobs

High street job cuts: Jane Norman worker speaks out

Socialist Students meeting prepares for new term

Youth Fight for Jobs: campaign moving forward

Day-Mer festival support for 30 June pensions strike

Pride London

Socialist Party reviews

Review: A Common Treasury

Endgame by Rise Against

Socialist Party

Building the socialist alternative on 30 June

Socialist Party youth meeting: Successful and insightful


Home   |   The Socialist 6 July 2011   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate  

Related links:


triangleTory prescription for mental illness: stress and bureaucracy

triangleDisability cuts outrage: my story

triangleThe Socialist Inbox

triangleUN slams Tories for disabled rights ruin


triangleWaltham Forest Universal Credit protest

triangleChatsworth ward campaign replies to Tory MP's intervention

triangle'Freedom riders' lobby against violent policing


triangleZero new homes 'affordable' in Blairite Manchester

triangleSainsbury's raise really a cut: fight for 10 with no strings!

triangleProfits up Wages down


triangleOpinion: foster care is work - carers deserve workers' rights

triangleEnd poverty pay for sleep-in care workers

News and socialist analysis

News and socialist analysis



Russia, spies and nerve agents



Zero new homes 'affordable' in Blairite Manchester



Spring Statement 2018: Tory austerity staggers on despite economic and political weakness


What we saw

What we saw



Sainsbury's raise really a cut: fight for 10 with no strings!



Profits up Wages down



Determined UCU strikers: We're out to win!



Capitalism oppresses women - fight for socialism!


Them & Us

Them & Us



Women's oppression: the struggle goes on



Snow chaos showed the bosses' coldness - but also workers' grit



May's EU speech kicks the can down the road



Toys R Us, Maplin: worsening retail crisis claims more jobs



Corbyn's customs union dividing line: now stand firm for pro-worker Brexit



Corbynism shows 'Clause IV' still relevant a hundred years on

triangleMore News and socialist analysis articles...

Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party
Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube



Phone our national office on 020 8988 8777


Locate your nearest Socialist Party branch Text your name and postcode to 07761 818 206

Regional Socialist Party organisers:

Eastern: 0798 202 1969

East Mids: 0773 797 8057

London: 020 8988 8786

North East: 0191 421 6230

North West 07769 611 320

South East: 020 8988 8777

South West: 07759 796 478

Southern: 07833 681910

Wales: 07935 391 947

West Mids: 02476 555 620

Yorkshire: 0114 264 6551



Alphabetical listing

March 2018

February 2018

January 2018