Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Socialist Case for Exit

Link to this page: https://www.socialistparty.org.uk/issue/906/23009

From The Socialist newspaper, 15 June 2016

EU: busting the myths that Remain is best for the 99%

French workers demonstrating against the proposed new labour law photo Naomi Byron

French workers demonstrating against the proposed new labour law photo Naomi Byron   (Click to enlarge)

As we approach voting day for the EU referendum, panic has set in for the establishment and 'project fear' has been stepped up. The official campaigns on both sides have bandied about arguments full of lies and misrepresentations. Many working class people don't know who to believe or feel completely turned off the debate. Here we address three of the concerns workers and young people may have about voting Leave.


Does the EU help us show international solidarity and stand against racism?

Paula Mitchell

A lot of people, young people especially, look at the official representatives of Leave and are - rightly - completely repelled. Boris Johnson, Michael Gove, Nigel Farage and the rest are repugnant right-wing millionaires, spouting nationalist and racist bile. As a statement of anti-racism, and of internationalism against 'Little Englander' isolationism, some people think they need to vote to remain in the EU.

Even some on the left promote their own 'project fear' suggesting that a vote to leave will lead to a wave of popular racism. They point to working class people's concerns about immigration and votes for Ukip, for example in the recent Welsh elections.

It is important to oppose racism. However, the majority of working class people who express concerns about immigration do not do so out of racism but out of fear that there is already not enough to go round. They see the destruction of stable, skilled, reasonably well-paid jobs (for example, currently, in the steel industry) and their replacement by low paid zero-hour contracts. They experience a stagnation in wages, a housing crisis, cuts in benefits and pensions.

This is why the Socialist Party and Trade Unionist and Socialist Coalition have argued strenuously for an independent socialist Leave campaign. A bold anti-austerity alternative that fought for jobs, council houses and rent control, 10 an hour minimum wage, and an end to cuts and privatisation, would go a long way to cut across divisions, and harness and direct anger against the bosses and the Tories.

Cameron and Osborne, who lead the campaign to remain, are no less racist and nationalist than Johnson etc. They just believe, as does the majority of big business leaders and the banks, that the pursuit of profit for British business is better served in the EU.

But is the EU itself a guard against racism and promoter of internationalism?

We are internationalists - the internationalism of the working class, not of the bosses and the bankers and the super-rich, whose internationalism is in order to maximise the exploitation of working class people across Europe to enrich themselves.

Greece

We stand shoulder to shoulder with the Greek bus workers in Athens who have just won a pay victory. We stand with the French workers engaged in a huge battle against proposed new labour laws. We stand with workers in Belgium on general strike.

None of this internationalism is aided by Britain's membership of the EU - in fact in many cases the action is against EU dictats implemented by willing big business governments. While we stand with the people of Greece, the EU is grinding them into the dirt.

Our support for European workers is no different, or easier to deliver, than our solidarity with miners in South Africa after the Marikana massacre, or in support of Palestinians under the cosh of the Israeli state, or the huge human sympathy and support shown to refugees fleeing war, terror and persecution.

The EU, on the other hand, is clearly no defender of refugees or migrants. The free movement of people within the EU is in order that big business can guarantee a cheap labour supply. For anyone else it is 'fortress Europe'. Refugees are left to drown in the Mediterranean, and rot in squalid camps. In fact barriers are going up within Europe to prevent movement of non-EU people across borders.

To combine resources, skills, technology and production across Europe would be a hugely positive step forward. However, under capitalism it is impossible to fully achieve. Although they established the EU to facilitate trade and move around capital and labour without barrier, in the end capitalists in different nations are in competition and retreat behind national borders and protections when their profits are threatened.

It also suits them to promote national and racial loyalties so they can divide working class people against each other rather than have us all come together against the bosses.

It will only be on the basis of working class action, solidarity, and a socialist fight that this divisive and unjust system can be removed and human and material resources can fully come together on a voluntary basis.


Does the EU protect workers and the economy?

As the referendum gets closer, the Remain campaign has stepped up its emphasis on the supposed benefits the EU brings to the economy (and thereby jobs, pay and services) and to workers' rights.

We've scandalously had corporate bosses on TV saying 'we are going to cut investment and jobs' in the event of a Leave vote. Who elected them to decide our fate? Those companies should be taken into democratic public ownership to secure jobs and services.

Prime Minister David Cameron said the Tories couldn't guarantee rises in the state pension if Britain wasn't in the EU. He said that NHS spending would be under threat. Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn told us a Leave vote would mean a "bonfire of workers' rights."

This despite the fact that much of the legislation that exists to protect workers was won prior to the UK joining the EU. Equal pay for men and women is often referenced. But British workers had won the right to equal pay in 1970, particularly through the strike by women workers at the Ford Dagenham plant.

In fact there are examples where UK law offers better protections than EU law. We're told to thank the EU for paid holidays, but the EU legislates four weeks while UK law legislates 5.6 weeks.

And it would be very pessimistic to think that workers would sit idly by while the few protections that have come specifically from EU legislation (which are all incorporated into UK law anyway and would need reversing) are attacked.

Working Time Directive

The Working Time Directive, for example, provides limits on the length of the working day and regular rests (although workers - generally at the 'request' of employers - can opt-out). Haven't the junior doctors shown in their magnificent strike movement that when needed and given the chance workers will fight unfair and unsafe changes to working times?

Much more significant than these few crumbs are the number of EU directives that drive down pay and conditions for workers - the Posted Workers Directive, the Temporary Agency Work Directive and the planned Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership, to name a few.

The rhetoric about potential negative impacts on the economy don't carry much weight with many workers either. One study showed that while the majority of voters think there may be negative economic consequences if Britain were to leave, only a third think it would affect their personal finances.

This is hardly surprising given that the economy is supposedly now in recovery following the world economic crisis that started in 2007-2008, but workers are still experiencing unemployment, pay freezes and cuts, and attacks on terms and conditions.

An austerity avalanche has taken place in Britain since 2010 - including on the pensions and NHS services Cameron is now so keen to protect - while the EU has observed approvingly. The same is true for the biggest 'bonfire of rights' - the (anti) Trade Union Act - being implemented by the leaders of the Remain campaign. And similar is taking place in EU member states across the continent. More than 35% of youth in Greece, Italy and Spain are unemployed.

Ultimately, Brexit on a capitalist basis will produce broadly the same results as Remain on a capitalist basis - continued austerity, attacks on wages and living standards, cuts and privatisation of public services.

The only way to resist this is for a mass, united working class fightback against austerity - whether implemented by Brussels or the governments of individual countries. Workers should support legislation but legislation can be brushed aside as needed by the capitalist class - it's militant trade union-led action that will really defend us.

Poverty

A Leave vote would open up the potential to kick out this hated, weak and divided Tory government. It would remove one of the many obstacles that exist to make it harder for workers to organise effectively and defend their rights. It would be a kick in the teeth for the same EU institutions impoverishing the working classes of southern Europe.

As Ian Hodson, president of the BFAWU bakers' union, said at the union's recent conference: "The role of the trade union is to protect workers' rights. Anyone expecting Angela Merkel or Christine Lagarde to do it will be sorely disappointed."


Does the EU keep the peace?

Judy Beishon
photo Gary Knight/Creative Commons

photo Gary Knight/Creative Commons   (Click to enlarge)

David Cameron unscrupulously referred to "rows of white headstones in lovingly tended Commonwealth war cemeteries" when arguing that the EU helps to maintain peace in Europe. This is the same Tory leader who has been promoting the bombing of Iraq and Syria, which the Ministry of Defence claims has killed nearly 1,000 fighters but inconceivably not a single civilian.

Also lacking any credibility is the idea that 70 years of peace in Europe has been due to the existence of European institutions. The truth is that it's been - and still is - in the best interests of the capitalist classes across most of Europe to compete for markets and prestige through economic and political means rather than through turning to war.

Revolution

After the second world war they were met with a revolutionary wave across western Europe - mass movements of the working class demanding welfare, jobs and housing. In Britain, the Clement Attlee-led Labour government was elected with huge pressure on it to deliver change. It nationalised failing large industries including coal, the railways and steel. It set up a welfare state - a great gain extracted by working people, which developed further during the post-war economic boom.

Another feature of that period, outlasting the boom even, was the cold war standoff between the western powers and the Stalinist eastern bloc, and the proliferation of nuclear weapons that was part of that. US imperialism underwrote the security of its western allies, including through spearheading the NATO military alliance.

So, far more overriding processes were at play regarding 'peace' than the economic cooperation treaties signed between governments in Europe. Those treaties were aimed at boosting the fortunes of European big businesses and not at maintaining peace - that wasn't then in jeopardy - between the main western powers.

There have however been wars in eastern Europe, in the Balkans as Yugoslavia broke up and more recently in Ukraine, which the existence of the European institutions hasn't prevented. As the EU is in essence a club of the top European corporations and elites, the peace-making attempts of it and its predecessors have been in their own interests and not in those of ordinary people living in the war zones.

In western Europe today though, with economies barely growing and the resulting tensions between governments, is the EU a vital force for peace and stability as Cameron would have us believe?

Certainly national antagonisms between the ruling classes are rising as a result of capitalism's inability to develop industry and services. The 28 governments that make up the EU are increasingly divided over key issues, from their response to the refugee crisis to policy on Greece's unsustainable 'debts'.

The Eurozone, originally heralded as aiding integration and prosperity, has become a strait jacket for its most struggling members, again aggravating antagonisms. None of this will be any surprise to longstanding readers of the Socialist; it has always argued that capitalist European integration will become shipwrecked on the rocks of economic crisis.

Socialism

This is no reason for doom and gloom, or for hanging onto the coattails of EU institutions, because those bodies have never operated in the fundamental interests of the majority in society.

The only way to build European institutions that would be genuinely anti-war and based on mutual wellbeing and cooperation between the working peoples of Europe, is to do so on a democratic socialist basis. Only socialist ideas can offer a war-free, poverty-free alternative to the impasse and horrors of capitalism.

Donate to the Socialist Party

Finance appeal

The coronavirus crisis has laid bare the class character of society in numerous ways. It is making clear to many that it is the working class that keeps society running, not the CEOs of major corporations.

The results of austerity have been graphically demonstrated as public services strain to cope with the crisis.

The government has now ripped up its 'austerity' mantra and turned to policies that not long ago were denounced as socialist. But after the corona crisis, it will try to make the working class pay for it, by trying to claw back what has been given.

  • The Socialist Party's material is more vital than ever, so we can continue to report from workers who are fighting for better health and safety measures, against layoffs, for adequate staffing levels, etc.
  • When the health crisis subsides, we must be ready for the stormy events ahead and the need to arm workers' movements with a socialist programme - one which puts the health and needs of humanity before the profits of a few.
Inevitably, during the crisis we have not been able to sell the Socialist and raise funds in the ways we normally would.
We therefore urgently appeal to all our viewers to donate to our Fighting Fund.

Please donate here.

All payments are made through a secure server.

My donation

 

Your message: 

 


In The Socialist 15 June 2016:


EU referendum

EU referendum: whatever the result, political turmoil is ahead

EU: busting the myths that Remain is best for the 99%

TUSC anti-EU tour touches down in Wales

BT Brexit baloney

Letters: EU referendum


International socialist news and analysis

Orlando massacre: working class unity to defeat homophobia, terrorism and racism

France: workers' revolt against labour law grows


Socialist readers' comments and reviews

Hilarious, innovative satire on state bureaucracy


Workplace news and analysis

Unison conference 2016: fighting leadership needed more than ever

GMB backs no-cuts budgets and steel nationalisation

Pennine Foods strike forces bosses back to the table

Hospital porters and domestic staff claim jobs and pay victory

Strike at Argos depot against contracting out of jobs

Buses parked three deep in Leeds strike

School support staff mobilise against slashing of pay

Uber drivers strike against unfair fares

Lorry stoppage paves the way to victory

Solidarity with victimised bakers' union rep


Housing crisis

Action to defeat the Housing Act: we won't move!

Housing Act: landlords and developers set to profit

Generation rent demands affordable housing


NHS

Re-open Chorley A&E - end the staff shortages

Hands Off HRI campaign grows from strength to strength


Socialist Party news and analysis

Systemic failures hurt kids in justice system

Them & Us

Socialist Party fundraising: punching above our weight


 

Home   |   The Socialist 15 June 2016   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate   |   PDF  |   ebook






Related links:

EU:

triangleCovid 'vaccine wars' underline failure of capitalist nation states to deal with the global pandemic

triangle2020 - a year which drove home the catastrophic failures of capitalism

triangleFood and a capitalist Brexit: No trust in Tory Deals!

triangleThe Socialist: More than a newspaper

triangleBritain's fragile Covid equilibrium is coming to an end

Economy:

triangleBiden's policies will not solve underlying US crisis

trianglePreparing for the revolts to come

triangle'Casino capitalism' - driving another potential financial Armageddon

trianglePoverty wages: When workers can't afford to self-isolate

Workers:

triangleUnited action needed to defeat fire and rehire

triangleReaders' opinion

triangleNorwich City Council workers vote for strike action over broken promises on pay and conditions

Solidarity:

triangleGoodlord strike forces talks

triangleInternational Workers' Day - struggle, solidarity, socialism

Racism:

triangleUSA: cop killings and the anti-racist movement

US:

triangleIs Biden offering a new 'New Deal'?

Europe:

triangleBristol North Socialist Party: The rise of Eastern Europe's right-wing populist movements

Working class:

triangleRight-wing Partido Popular wins Madrid elections - a warning to the working class

War:

triangleStop war on Gaza demo, London 15.5.21. Socialist Party members were at the many protests across Britain

Pay:

triangleThurrock refuse workers strike escalates

Jobs:

triangleSparks fight continues

Austerity:

triangleCan the 'Preston model' beat the cuts?

Cuts:

triangleRMT: Militant industrial and political strategy must be fought for

State:

triangleBritish state absolves itself from killings during 'the Troubles'

Strike:

triangleEaling parking wardens strike against Serco over absence policy

Trade union:

triangleColombia: Mass trade union-led protests force tax retreat

Refugees:

triangleKent: Chaotic privatised asylum process

Privatisation:

triangleHaringey: Hands off our GP practices

Poverty:

trianglePoverty increasing. Welfare state in crisis. Do we need a new Beveridge Report?

Young people:

triangleThe system is broken... youth unite and fight back

Welfare:

triangleThe Socialist Inbox

Racist:

triangleSwansea BLM protest against racist police brutality

Pensions:

triangleLessons of the 2011 pensions strike: when workers showed their power

Women:

triangleNew law ignores economic barriers to escaping domestic abuse

Steel:

triangleNationalise Liberty Steel to save jobs

NHS:

triangleNottingham NHS pay protest

Economic crisis:

triangleBooks that inspired me: The Grapes of Wrath by John Steinbeck

Housing:

triangleCladding: Tories refuse to protect leaseholders again

David Cameron:

triangleGreensill scandal, Corruption ... Build a socialist alternative

Benefits:

triangleLong Covid: Fight for jobs, benefits and services

Immigration:

triangleProtest against immigration enforcement centre in Newham

Equal pay:

triangleAsda equal pay ruling victory - now fight for equal pay for all

Nato:

triangleSyria: Is an end to the war in sight?

Jeremy Corbyn:

triangleGoodlord strikers fight fire and rehire as part of day of action

Nigel Farage:

triangleMay ends in June! Boot out the Tories!

Zero-hour contracts:

triangleCovid and precarious workers - union organisation vital

Imperialism:

triangleHackney & Islington Socialist Party: Imperialism

UKIP:

triangleTories facing electoral meltdown

Trade Unionist and Socialist Coalition:

triangleTUSC is back

Second World War:

triangleBradford Socialist Party: Trotskyism and the Second World War

Competition:

triangleNo trust in billionaire owners - kick them out and reclaim the game

Anti-austerity:

triangleDonate now to fuel our election campaigns

Anti-war:

triangleHistory: Alice Wheeldon - an anti-war socialist persecuted by the state

BFAWU:

triangleThe Trade Unionist and Socialist Coalition (TUSC) is 'up and running' for the May 2021 elections

Balkans:

triangleHow capitalist restoration led to war and 'ethnic cleansing' in the Balkans

Eurozone:

triangleEU-Canada trade deal battle points to Corbyn's Brexit opportunity

Boris Johnson:

triangleLondon: #BuhariMustGo protests are back

Eastern Europe:

triangleLiverpool Socialist Party: Eastern Europe - a revival of class struggle

News and socialist analysis

News and socialist analysis

14/5/21

Unite

Starmer moves against Unite - No to the attack on Beckett

12/5/21

Welsh Government

Welsh Labour holds on to government but new crises loom

12/5/21

Scotland

Scotland: Pro-independence majority in highly polarised election

9/5/21

Hartlepool

Hartlepool sums up Labour crisis

5/5/21

Cuts

Fight the rotten establishment

5/5/21

Women

New law ignores economic barriers to escaping domestic abuse

5/5/21

Housing

Cladding: Tories refuse to protect leaseholders again

5/5/21

Sleaze

Capitalist sleaze and cronyism

5/5/21

Local government

Can the 'Preston model' beat the cuts?

5/5/21

NHS

Hands off our NHS

5/5/21

Mental health

Covid, capitalism and mental health

29/4/21

SWP

Socialists and elections - a response to the SWP

28/4/21

Elections

What councils can do to protect the environment

28/4/21

Welfare state

Poverty increasing. Welfare state in crisis. Do we need a new Beveridge Report?

28/4/21

Post Office

39 'postmasters' cleared - now clear the rest

triangleMore News and socialist analysis articles...


Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party
Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube

LATEST POSTS

CONTACT US

Phone our national office on 020 8988 8777

Email: [email protected]

Locate your nearest Socialist Party branch Text your name and postcode to 07761 818 206

Regional Socialist Party organisers:

Eastern: 079 8202 1969

East Mids: 077 3797 8057

London: 075 4018 9052

North East: 078 4114 4890

North West 079 5437 6096

South West: 077 5979 6478

Southern: 078 3368 1910

Wales: 079 3539 1947

West Mids: 024 7655 5620

Yorkshire: 078 0983 9793

ABOUT US

ARCHIVE

Alphabetical listing


May 2021

April 2021

March 2021

February 2021

January 2021

2020

2019

2018

2017

2016

2015

2014

2013

2012

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999