Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page:

From The Socialist newspaper, 18 September 2004

The Prostitution Debate

THE CONTROVERSIAL Tolerance Zones (Scotland) Bill and the British government's consultation document on prostitution, Paying the Price, have sparked a real debate about how to deal with the issue of prostitution.
 The following is an edited version of an article by Sinead Daly which first appeared in International Socialist, the paper of CWI members in Scotland.

ALTHOUGH THE Tolerance Zones Bill was defeated in 2003, MSP Margo McDonald is presenting a similar bill which is due to be heard by the end of this year. The Bill, if passed, would see tolerance zones designated by the local council in consultation with the police, health boards and the local community. The council would then have a duty of care to provide CCTV, adequate lighting and access to support workers.

There is real division among support agencies that work with prostitutes about whether to support the Bill. Routes out of prostitution, based in Glasgow, where there are no tolerance zones, oppose the bill. While the Scottish Prostitution Education Project (Scotpep) based in Edinburgh - where until 2001 they had a designated tolerance zone - support it.

Tolerance zones

Scotpep claims that there has been a massive increase in recorded attacks in Edinburgh - 111 in 2003 compared with 11 in 2001. Previously they found it easy to locate and support prostitutes, now they are dispersed all over the city.

Prostitutes themselves have reported feeling less safe; one woman said: "I carry a knife with me now and I have never, ever done that before". Another said: "since the zone has gone we have had to put up with more violence than ever before, from the residents and drug dealers pushing their kit and more girls than ever on drugs."

Before the ending of tolerance zones, less than a third of prostitutes were heroin addicts in Edinburgh compared to 97% in Glasgow and 90% in Aberdeen. There is also less incidence of sexually transmitted disease.

The reality of working on the streets is horrific, women tell of being raped, severely beaten and being driven by strangers to locations they may not know or feel safe in - if they are attacked who do they tell?

One study found that 66% of women involved in street-based prostitution in the UK experienced client violence, including being slapped, kicked or punched - 28% reported rape or attempted rape.


THE SITUATION facing the estimated 700 women per year smuggled into the UK to work as prostitutes, mostly unknowingly and unwillingly, is worse. They face not just the brutality of their abusers who buy sex but also from their 'pimps' who have enslaved them.

Who can they turn to if they get the chance to escape - the police? If they report to the police they will most likely be deported. The reality is these women are being criminalised both as prostitutes but also as illegal immigrants.

The legalisation of prostitution, pimping and brothels has facilitated an increase in the trafficking of women. According to Michael Platzer, Head of UN Centre for International Crime Prevention, "the laws help the gangsters. Prostitution is semi-legal in many places and that makes enforcement tricky. In most cases the punishment is very light."


Rode Draad (Red Thread) a prostitutes union in the Netherlands claims that the legalisation of brothels has meant that prostitutes working conditions have improved. Many are now entitled to holiday, maternity and sick pay, as well as improved pay and conditions.

However, this is not the case for many. The other side of the coin is that prostitution is now regarded as a legitimate profession - so much so that two women have had their benefit stopped because they refused to take a job as a prostitute!

Big business and the governments who back up their system are now beginning to recognise that there is a lot of money to be made, which is why we are seeing the beginnings of the legalisation of brothels. One of the proposals under consideration by the British government is legalisation/licensing of brothels and prostitutes.

The 1998 report from the UN's International Labour Organisation blatantly legitimated sexual exploitation as an appropriate, key component of gross national product and called upon governments of poorer countries to take economic advantage of "The Sex Sector" - regulated, expanded and taxed!


We should be in favour of removing the existing legislation that criminalises prostitution. [This is not the same as legalising it]. We would not want to condone or legitimise any aspect of the sex industry, which is based, not on sexual 'freedom' and openness, but on the commercial exploitation of sex, and promotes stereotypical and damaging images of sex and sexuality.

However, the legal system should not be making criminals of prostitutes who are generally amongst the most vulnerable and most exploited people in society. Statistics released by the British Home Office consultation document state that 70% of prostitutes have been in local authority care as children, 45% have been victims of child sexual abuse and 42% have been raped.

We should back harm reduction measures that will ensure that prostitutes can work more safely, ie well-lit tolerance zones, safe off-the-street venues where support workers and health workers have regular contact.

There is also a need for women to access safe houses, a place where they can go to escape from their pimp/abuser. Women should also be assured that they will be given a legal right to remain should they manage to escape.

At the same time it is essential to fight for policies to end poverty like a decent minimum wage and free education.

We live in a society which is based on inequalities of power and wealth and breeds poverty, exploitation and abuse. Sexism, including the sexual exploitation of women, is rooted in its very structures. As long as this system remains women will continue to be forced into the 'sex industry'. A socialist society will provide the only lasting solution.

The socialist would welcome readers' views on this issue.

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.

In The Socialist 18 September 2004:

Turn Anger Into Action

TUC Delegates Give Thumbs Down To Blair

Pay Us A Living Wage

Behind New Labour's Power Struggle

International socialist news and analysis

Bush Sinks Deeper In Iraq Quagmire

How The US Went To War

Nigerian Workers Must Fight Anti-Union Law

Anger, Bitterness And Increasing Opposition in Germany

Socialist Party campaigns

Big Macs Can Seriously Damage Your Health

The Prostitution Debate

Asleft: Rebuilding The Union

Swansea IT Workers Determined To Win


Home   |   The Socialist 18 September 2004   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate  

Related links:


triangleLessons of Russia 1917 for women's struggle today

triangleBradford murders and prostitution


triangleFighting sexism: Positive discrimination - yea or neigh?

triangleUnison national women's conference

triangle100 years since women won the vote


triangle1967 Abortion Act reflected social changes

triangleRacist smears won't stop child sex abuse


triangleUndercover policing legal challenge

Reports and campaigns

Reports and campaigns



No fudge with the right wing



TUSC statement on sentencing of Derby TUSC agent



Haringey protests HDV - but Labour fails to kill it off completely



Uni strike: coordinate public sector fightback



Enjoyable and successful Cardiff Refugee Rights gig



Carlisle debate - socialism or social democracy?



Staines fire services saved



Threat of action defeats pay cut at Surrey council



Woolwich Crossrail walkouts to demand promised bonuses



Sadiq Khan's bus drivers' London licence doesn't go far enough



Stop press: victory - campaign saves NHS rehab ward



Teachers strike again as anti-academy pressure mounts



Unison national women's conference


Royal Mail

Royal Mail forced back under threat of action



'Occupy to save the town square'

triangleMore Reports and campaigns articles...

Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party
Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube



Phone our national office on 020 8988 8777


Locate your nearest Socialist Party branch Text your name and postcode to 07761 818 206

Regional Socialist Party organisers:

Eastern: 0798 202 1969

East Mids: 0773 797 8057

London: 020 8988 8786

North East: 0191 421 6230

North West 07769 611 320

South East: 020 8988 8777

South West: 07759 796 478

Southern: 07833 681910

Wales: 07935 391 947

West Mids: 02476 555 620

Yorkshire: 0114 264 6551



Alphabetical listing

February 2018

January 2018